Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Has anyone ever offered 400k on a 500k house?

201 replies

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

OP posts:
MrEdwardElizabethHitler · 16/11/2026 14:40

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 14:16

Demand is also way down in many areas though, you can have a good price and no demand now it seems.

If the price is low enough, that will create some demand.

PocketSand · 16/11/2026 14:47

It just looks like an attempt at justification. ‘I used to be able to afford a £500k property at 1% but now rates are 6% I can only afford £400k. What if I offer £400k for a £500k property based on my assumption that it is over valued/survey/buyers market?’

Surely part of the problem is that buyers have become used to viewing advertisements for properties with a value they could afford at much lower mortgage interest rates because they could afford the monthly repayments?

Instead of thinking ‘I can afford a property valued at x amount (on a 1% rate)’ they need to readjust to the new reality that they can now only afford a property valued a y amount (on a 6% rate).

At the moment there are still those on old fixed low rates but this is a time limited issue. It is far more likely that property prices will remain stagnant with inflation reducing gain than some sellers will take a double whammy of an additional fall in property values.

We seem to be in a transitional phase where those requiring a mortgage are thinking practically about how much they can afford in terms of monthly mortgage payments but then expecting sellers (who are also likely to be borrowers on onward purchase) to reduce the value of their house to keep one unrealistic buyer in the chain immune from the increased rate of borrowing.

There will always be those in a market with some advantage (first time buyers, renters and cash buyers who are chain free) and some disadvantage (probate and/or project, or forced to move - divorce/repossession etc) but the rest of the market either sells around valuation or all properties across the board lose similar percentage of valuation.

M0nst3r · 16/11/2026 14:57

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 14:31

When the valuation comes in much lower they will just find some other excuse, they sound like they are in denial.

I think people get a bit carried away with listing prices. If you need a mortgage on a property, the banks valuation (RICS red book valuation) is materially more important than any bollocks an agent trots out. If you are a cash buyer, you can decide what you will pay, same for anyone willing to burn their equity. The times of renovation = return are gone. Buyers and vendors are having to adjust to this.

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 15:25

PocketSand · 16/11/2026 14:47

It just looks like an attempt at justification. ‘I used to be able to afford a £500k property at 1% but now rates are 6% I can only afford £400k. What if I offer £400k for a £500k property based on my assumption that it is over valued/survey/buyers market?’

Surely part of the problem is that buyers have become used to viewing advertisements for properties with a value they could afford at much lower mortgage interest rates because they could afford the monthly repayments?

Instead of thinking ‘I can afford a property valued at x amount (on a 1% rate)’ they need to readjust to the new reality that they can now only afford a property valued a y amount (on a 6% rate).

At the moment there are still those on old fixed low rates but this is a time limited issue. It is far more likely that property prices will remain stagnant with inflation reducing gain than some sellers will take a double whammy of an additional fall in property values.

We seem to be in a transitional phase where those requiring a mortgage are thinking practically about how much they can afford in terms of monthly mortgage payments but then expecting sellers (who are also likely to be borrowers on onward purchase) to reduce the value of their house to keep one unrealistic buyer in the chain immune from the increased rate of borrowing.

There will always be those in a market with some advantage (first time buyers, renters and cash buyers who are chain free) and some disadvantage (probate and/or project, or forced to move - divorce/repossession etc) but the rest of the market either sells around valuation or all properties across the board lose similar percentage of valuation.

Or more likely, all the "500k houses" are no longer "500k houses" because there are no buyers.

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 15:58

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 15:25

Or more likely, all the "500k houses" are no longer "500k houses" because there are no buyers.

Not what I am reading on countless MN treads. More like buyer thinks/believe updating or renovation or repair according to their opinion = money off. Which it doesn’t, properties are valued and marketed as per their condition at the time.

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 16:06

Fairiesarereal345 · 16/11/2026 13:19

This is correct, I am not the other poster! The property is not listed. It just needs a lot of work doing to it to modernise it.

Would people think 450k is a more acceptable offer?

Edited

I asked a few days ago what was so “unique” and what needed to be”updating”. You haven’t answered. This is all relevant to an offer, you need to justify why you are offering so low, with a reasoned argument. It hasn’t been for sale long so that’s not relevant.

PocketSand · 16/11/2026 16:18

The buyers are a constant - those who can no longer afford a £600k house are the new cohort. If you don’t find a buyer and you don’t need to sell you just don’t do so.

The idea that the value of property is set by interest rates and COL and that the seller is not subject to the same is naive. These determine what you can afford to buy not the cost of things you want to buy.

The cost of food, utilities, clothes, cars etc is not based on what you can afford given low wages and high living costs. There is no bartering - you have to cut your cloth.

But you think the housing market is different? Why? If a buyer is not needed they have no power.

Properties are removed from the market increasing competition for the few available and maintaining valuation because there will always be people who need to buy.

Buzzfoam · 16/11/2026 17:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Buzzfoam · 16/11/2026 17:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 17:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I agree. @Fairiesarereal345 you are really not coming across as credible on here.

If you want to make an offer, you need to be able to articulate why you are going at the value you are.

Any direct question you have been asked on here you have ignored. why?

rainingsnoring · 16/11/2026 19:58

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 14:25

Properties are valued and condition is part of that. The listing will be advised in full knowledge that it needs work. If it was “done” the price would reflect that!!

Actually, most of these properties needing lots of work are not priced to reflect the degree of work needed. This is why many of them have not been selling for the last few years and are needing reductions to do so! You can see the reductions all over Rightmove and there has been thread after thread on here.

That said, I think @M0nst3r hadn't the 'negotiation' badly. He/she would have been better having max price in mind and sticking to that/walking away if the seller did not accept.

rainingsnoring · 16/11/2026 20:04

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 17:58

I agree. @Fairiesarereal345 you are really not coming across as credible on here.

If you want to make an offer, you need to be able to articulate why you are going at the value you are.

Any direct question you have been asked on here you have ignored. why?

I agree that @Fairiesarereal345 isn't really coming across as credible here and with @MrEdwardElizabethHitler that no one can advise regarding a specific percentage for a property they have never seen without knowing anything about you or your finances.

However, I don't agree that a buyer needs to be able to justify their offer at all. A buyer can simply make their offer and give details of their plans to finance. There is no need to justify anything. Unfortunately, a lot of sellers have been over valuing their homes for some time. I've seen some reduced by 30% now and still not sell. The market is likely to fall more so this situation won't go away.

rainingsnoring · 16/11/2026 20:07

PocketSand · 16/11/2026 14:47

It just looks like an attempt at justification. ‘I used to be able to afford a £500k property at 1% but now rates are 6% I can only afford £400k. What if I offer £400k for a £500k property based on my assumption that it is over valued/survey/buyers market?’

Surely part of the problem is that buyers have become used to viewing advertisements for properties with a value they could afford at much lower mortgage interest rates because they could afford the monthly repayments?

Instead of thinking ‘I can afford a property valued at x amount (on a 1% rate)’ they need to readjust to the new reality that they can now only afford a property valued a y amount (on a 6% rate).

At the moment there are still those on old fixed low rates but this is a time limited issue. It is far more likely that property prices will remain stagnant with inflation reducing gain than some sellers will take a double whammy of an additional fall in property values.

We seem to be in a transitional phase where those requiring a mortgage are thinking practically about how much they can afford in terms of monthly mortgage payments but then expecting sellers (who are also likely to be borrowers on onward purchase) to reduce the value of their house to keep one unrealistic buyer in the chain immune from the increased rate of borrowing.

There will always be those in a market with some advantage (first time buyers, renters and cash buyers who are chain free) and some disadvantage (probate and/or project, or forced to move - divorce/repossession etc) but the rest of the market either sells around valuation or all properties across the board lose similar percentage of valuation.

That's not what is actually happening though. Higher end properties have been falling more because there is less demand for them. Properties needing lots of work (usually those belonging to older people/probate properties) are tending to be very over valued and are not selling. The market is shifting downwards in general and I think it will be more a case of sellers needing to be realistic as time goes on, assuming they actually want to sell.

FennelSnack · 16/11/2026 20:08

Disagree with the advice to try to justify your low offer- it's not really relevant and just annoys people, because you're either saying things everyone already knows (interest rates are up), things that are irrelevant (you can't afford it) or things that are just annoying (you don't like X and will need to change it). Better just to make your offer, give relevant context (whether you are in a chain) and leave it at that. It's up to them whether they want to accept but if they do that'll be down to their own assessment of the market, need to move etc.

I know he's a bit Marmite on here but the Moving Home With Charlie videos on this stuff are really good IMO.

rainingsnoring · 16/11/2026 20:10

Good thought @FennelSnack. I think @Fairiesarereal345 would benefit from looking Charlie up!

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 20:30

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 15:58

Not what I am reading on countless MN treads. More like buyer thinks/believe updating or renovation or repair according to their opinion = money off. Which it doesn’t, properties are valued and marketed as per their condition at the time.

The buyer can think/believe anything they like, and offer whatever they like. Properties can be valued and marketed at any price but without a buyer it is just a number in the seller"s head.

KeepPumping · 16/11/2026 20:33

rainingsnoring · 16/11/2026 20:07

That's not what is actually happening though. Higher end properties have been falling more because there is less demand for them. Properties needing lots of work (usually those belonging to older people/probate properties) are tending to be very over valued and are not selling. The market is shifting downwards in general and I think it will be more a case of sellers needing to be realistic as time goes on, assuming they actually want to sell.

I think the post you quoted was a wind up?

Alexalee · 16/11/2026 22:27

PocketSand · 16/11/2026 14:47

It just looks like an attempt at justification. ‘I used to be able to afford a £500k property at 1% but now rates are 6% I can only afford £400k. What if I offer £400k for a £500k property based on my assumption that it is over valued/survey/buyers market?’

Surely part of the problem is that buyers have become used to viewing advertisements for properties with a value they could afford at much lower mortgage interest rates because they could afford the monthly repayments?

Instead of thinking ‘I can afford a property valued at x amount (on a 1% rate)’ they need to readjust to the new reality that they can now only afford a property valued a y amount (on a 6% rate).

At the moment there are still those on old fixed low rates but this is a time limited issue. It is far more likely that property prices will remain stagnant with inflation reducing gain than some sellers will take a double whammy of an additional fall in property values.

We seem to be in a transitional phase where those requiring a mortgage are thinking practically about how much they can afford in terms of monthly mortgage payments but then expecting sellers (who are also likely to be borrowers on onward purchase) to reduce the value of their house to keep one unrealistic buyer in the chain immune from the increased rate of borrowing.

There will always be those in a market with some advantage (first time buyers, renters and cash buyers who are chain free) and some disadvantage (probate and/or project, or forced to move - divorce/repossession etc) but the rest of the market either sells around valuation or all properties across the board lose similar percentage of valuation.

You don't see any correlation between low interest rates and the sharp rise in house prices?
Rates of 2% allowed prices to be bid up to where they stood in 2022. Now rates are back to normal 5% ish house prices will fall back.

DrySherry · 17/11/2026 07:01

I see rightmove reporting that average prices are down another 7k this month. I can see more months of successive falls coming in the spring.
Its a tricky time, and going to get harder, for anyone selling who does not, or can not, adjust pricing to whats happening. Equally its going to get even harder for buyers needing a mortgage. Another 2 interest rate rises will further curtail how much its sensible/possible to pay. Those further interest rate rises are coming soon. I can see significant numbers of people not being able to move. Particularly those that overpaid by buying in the tail end of the last boom around 2021 and in to early 2022.

daisychain01 · 17/11/2026 08:25

@DrySherry I've noticed some builders, mainly the independents rather that the Taylor Wimpeys and Bellways of this world, are putting Guide Price in their price lists to indicate they'll take an offer. And they're all doing lots of incentives like stamp duty payments, removal costs paid etc which brings down the headline price of the property.

XVGN · 17/11/2026 08:29

daisychain01 · 17/11/2026 08:25

@DrySherry I've noticed some builders, mainly the independents rather that the Taylor Wimpeys and Bellways of this world, are putting Guide Price in their price lists to indicate they'll take an offer. And they're all doing lots of incentives like stamp duty payments, removal costs paid etc which brings down the headline price of the property.

They are desperately trying to avoid reducing the headline price that appears in the Land Registry. The UK Gov should do something to stop these price-fixing shenanigans.

Fair3nough · 17/11/2026 08:50

DrySherry · 17/11/2026 07:01

I see rightmove reporting that average prices are down another 7k this month. I can see more months of successive falls coming in the spring.
Its a tricky time, and going to get harder, for anyone selling who does not, or can not, adjust pricing to whats happening. Equally its going to get even harder for buyers needing a mortgage. Another 2 interest rate rises will further curtail how much its sensible/possible to pay. Those further interest rate rises are coming soon. I can see significant numbers of people not being able to move. Particularly those that overpaid by buying in the tail end of the last boom around 2021 and in to early 2022.

Edited

im surprised Rightmove are admitting this! They are part of the problem. When you look at their estimated value section for most properties they still seem to be going up month on month. Of course many people know Rightmove valuations are not reliable but it sets a bar even subconsciously.

daisychain01 · 17/11/2026 09:21

XVGN · 17/11/2026 08:29

They are desperately trying to avoid reducing the headline price that appears in the Land Registry. The UK Gov should do something to stop these price-fixing shenanigans.

I expect it's for their annual report, balance sheet and share value.

Quite frankly if their 4 bed detached is £565,000 but they're willing to give me a bunch of upgrades and £20k help towards stamp duty, what's the problem. I'm a tart I'll take whatever they offer 😂

rainingsnoring · 17/11/2026 09:28

DrySherry · 17/11/2026 07:01

I see rightmove reporting that average prices are down another 7k this month. I can see more months of successive falls coming in the spring.
Its a tricky time, and going to get harder, for anyone selling who does not, or can not, adjust pricing to whats happening. Equally its going to get even harder for buyers needing a mortgage. Another 2 interest rate rises will further curtail how much its sensible/possible to pay. Those further interest rate rises are coming soon. I can see significant numbers of people not being able to move. Particularly those that overpaid by buying in the tail end of the last boom around 2021 and in to early 2022.

Edited

And Rightmove only report the initial asking prices, ignoring reductions and transaction prices. I don't know if the UK will see two more rates rises or not. I think it's a mistake myself but many of us know that central banks frequently make mistakes- see 2005/6 into the GFC with the rate rises, as one example.
I agree that some people will be or feel stuck, although sometimes it's best to 'panic first' if you possibly can.

rainingsnoring · 17/11/2026 09:29

daisychain01 · 17/11/2026 08:25

@DrySherry I've noticed some builders, mainly the independents rather that the Taylor Wimpeys and Bellways of this world, are putting Guide Price in their price lists to indicate they'll take an offer. And they're all doing lots of incentives like stamp duty payments, removal costs paid etc which brings down the headline price of the property.

I'm not surprised by this. I've seen so many reductions on new builds for 3 years or so now. I would definitely try to negotiate if you are interested.