Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Has anyone ever offered 400k on a 500k house?

201 replies

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

OP posts:
foursquares · 13/11/2026 18:52

Holisticthy · 12/11/2026 22:44

Makes sense you reduce by £50k. You will get a brand new roof. It would have been valued above £775k with the new roof. Old houses are expected to need maintenance and that's all built in to the price

Absolute ridiculous advice. You made an 775k offer based on what you could see, assuming that the structural integrity of the property was intact.

The roof was an unknown, so the full cost should be borne by the seller. The argument that you're getting a new roof is silly, in the same way you wouldn't pay half for the repairs on a car if the engine had an oil leak after AA inspection.

foursquares · 13/11/2026 18:55

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

Most sellers are in cuckoo land, so the property could be very overpriced. Look at recent sales data, how long property has been on market, etc. Make an offer on what you think it's worth, not what you think seller will accept.

XVGN · 13/11/2026 19:21

I've bought at 20% off. A few key points: 1) the property had been on the market 3mo (I wouldn't bother otherwise), 2) I didn't care whether my offer was accepted or not (if it was accepted then I'd got a bargain, but if not then I didn't care losing it), 3) I must have caught the vendor just at the weakest time when they were ready to capitulate.

KeepPumping · 13/11/2026 19:21

Twiglets1 · 13/11/2026 18:07

Agreed - there actually is something to lose by putting forward too much of a daft offer, it does affect your credibility as a serious buyer.

LOL, nobody gives a monkeys about being classed as a "serious buyer" now, and agents or sellers trying it on with silly high asking prices will just be ignored in this market, people are realising that they just cannot afford the mortgage debt anymore at these price levels.

Twiglets1 · 13/11/2026 19:24

KeepPumping · 13/11/2026 19:21

LOL, nobody gives a monkeys about being classed as a "serious buyer" now, and agents or sellers trying it on with silly high asking prices will just be ignored in this market, people are realising that they just cannot afford the mortgage debt anymore at these price levels.

What would you know about it, you have never bought a house have you?

Fair3nough · 13/11/2026 20:53

How long has it been on for? Have they had any other offers?

id go for it. In a falling market you might get it. Even if they are offended they may well come back to you in 6 months. Mind by then it might be worth less…

Holisticthy · 13/11/2026 21:25

foursquares · 13/11/2026 18:52

Absolute ridiculous advice. You made an 775k offer based on what you could see, assuming that the structural integrity of the property was intact.

The roof was an unknown, so the full cost should be borne by the seller. The argument that you're getting a new roof is silly, in the same way you wouldn't pay half for the repairs on a car if the engine had an oil leak after AA inspection.

You pay more for a house with a recently fitted kitchen

KeepPumping · 13/11/2026 21:38

Twiglets1 · 13/11/2026 19:24

What would you know about it, you have never bought a house have you?

LOL

Fairiesarereal345 · 13/11/2026 21:48

Thank you all. House has been up since end of July. No reductions yet. Apparently one other interested party but they need to get an offer on their house first.

It's a very unique, old property and unlike anything else so it's very hard to know if the pricing is right.

OP posts:
Minasama · 13/11/2026 21:50

TediousTim · 12/11/2026 22:38

We're just about to ask for a 100k reduction on our previous offer of £775k following the survey today showed serious issues with the roof on a Grade II listed property that needs specialist work doing. Surveyor thinks it'll cost us a minimum of £100k.

So, no, but I'll sit here with you and hope for some success stories.

We did that, they refused to drop the price and we pulled out. They ended up taking it off the market. No idea if it eventually sold.

Good luck!

M0nst3r · 13/11/2026 22:00

Whenever I read these posts, I think ‘I wonder if the OP would accept an offer on their house 100k under listing’ because I absolutely wouldn’t.

Zov · 13/11/2026 22:01

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

We did offer £34K on a £43K house back in the mid 1990s! (So like around 22% less...) Reason being is that it needed quite a bit of work doing to it, like £5K spending on it minimum. Also it was 35 years old and was likely to need work doing to the roof in the coming 5 years (4 or 5 other similar houses did around that time...)

They said no. Wouldn't even accept £37K. So we moved on and looked for something else.

About 4-5 months later it was still for sale (had dropped to £39K.) We had moved into another house by then.

One day (some 5 months after our offers were turned down,) we saw a news item in the local paper.... A sinkhole 12 feet across, and 30-40 feet deep had opened up in the garden, just 6-8 feet from the house. Over a week or so, the sinkhole grew massively, until it was 40 feet across, and over 100 feet deep.

tl;dr, the house, and 5 more in the row (3 semis/6 houses) had to be demolished, as part of an old mine had collapsed underneath.

Glad they didn't accept our offer! 😬

Didimum · 13/11/2026 22:23

foursquares · 13/11/2026 18:52

Absolute ridiculous advice. You made an 775k offer based on what you could see, assuming that the structural integrity of the property was intact.

The roof was an unknown, so the full cost should be borne by the seller. The argument that you're getting a new roof is silly, in the same way you wouldn't pay half for the repairs on a car if the engine had an oil leak after AA inspection.

If you are experienced with period properties, you’d know they are already priced on whether they have the original roof or not, not on ‘what you can see’ and what the survey reveals about it. Original roof will take X% off, having had a reroof will put X% on and partial reroof another X%. Any estate agent worth their salt (and they should be if they are working in an area with period property stock), will do this, and any seasoned period property buyer will know it has been priced accordingly.

Namechangedatheist · 13/11/2026 22:42

Different time but we offered 250k on a 300k house in 1998. Initially refused but accepted a few weeks later. Still in the same house today.

RoseWylie · 13/11/2026 22:49

Where I live sellers are knocking hundreds of thousands off the price. There’s a house I like that was on at £1.8m. It’s now listed at £1.5m. If it drops to £1.25 I’ll offer. If not, never mind.

These days people prove they are serious by providing proof of funds. The idea that you need to do it in your offer strategy doesn’t really work in this market. Offer what you’re happy to pay. If they don’t accept, that’s up to them, but a sensible seller is grateful for all offers because they are all information. Being offended is just silly.

foursquares · 13/11/2026 23:09

Didimum · 13/11/2026 22:23

If you are experienced with period properties, you’d know they are already priced on whether they have the original roof or not, not on ‘what you can see’ and what the survey reveals about it. Original roof will take X% off, having had a reroof will put X% on and partial reroof another X%. Any estate agent worth their salt (and they should be if they are working in an area with period property stock), will do this, and any seasoned period property buyer will know it has been priced accordingly.

Ermm no. You make an offer based on assumption that roof is not leaking and is structurally sound. Not sure if you're working with Mr Superman, but most estate agents are pretty clueless, and don't even understand what disintegrated torching is..

rainingsnoring · 13/11/2026 23:17

Zov · 13/11/2026 22:01

We did offer £34K on a £43K house back in the mid 1990s! (So like around 22% less...) Reason being is that it needed quite a bit of work doing to it, like £5K spending on it minimum. Also it was 35 years old and was likely to need work doing to the roof in the coming 5 years (4 or 5 other similar houses did around that time...)

They said no. Wouldn't even accept £37K. So we moved on and looked for something else.

About 4-5 months later it was still for sale (had dropped to £39K.) We had moved into another house by then.

One day (some 5 months after our offers were turned down,) we saw a news item in the local paper.... A sinkhole 12 feet across, and 30-40 feet deep had opened up in the garden, just 6-8 feet from the house. Over a week or so, the sinkhole grew massively, until it was 40 feet across, and over 100 feet deep.

tl;dr, the house, and 5 more in the row (3 semis/6 houses) had to be demolished, as part of an old mine had collapsed underneath.

Glad they didn't accept our offer! 😬

Wow. Thank goodness for that. The sellers missed out there!

Didimum · 14/11/2026 07:14

foursquares · 13/11/2026 23:09

Ermm no. You make an offer based on assumption that roof is not leaking and is structurally sound. Not sure if you're working with Mr Superman, but most estate agents are pretty clueless, and don't even understand what disintegrated torching is..

Ermm no. If you’re experienced with period properties – especially listed ones as was the original comment – or aren’t experienced but you’ve research and prepared, then you ask about the roof straight away. The owner will know. Thick estate agents also don’t tend to cover listed properties. You won’t stand much much getting £100k off for a roof leak when the property has been priced with the original roof.

daisychain01 · 14/11/2026 07:35

M0nst3r · 13/11/2026 22:00

Whenever I read these posts, I think ‘I wonder if the OP would accept an offer on their house 100k under listing’ because I absolutely wouldn’t.

I agree, I don't think people are deliberately and knowingly putting their house on the market at £100K more than it's worth.

unlike @KeepPumping I believe people do, and should, "give a monkeys" about someone being a serious buyer. There are an awful lot of chancers and time wasters about at the moment who will put in a "cheeky offer" when they actually don't have the funds, and have no sound rationale for such a drop yet claim to the EA that they are "cash buyers". The main justificaion is if the survey comes back with major structural issues.

I give a monkeys about the integrity of who we sell our house to, because if they mess around in the early negotiation stage and don't show themselves to be serious and wanting to do business, instead of messing about, they're often the same people who'll slice another £25k off at exchange of contract because they think they can get away with it, or ghost you and have everyone running around just because they claim to be "cash buyers" when they have to get a mortgage like everyone else.

id rather spin on my heals and walk away from those type of people. I'm not that desperate to sell to just anyone, because they'll always try things on if they feel they have the upper hand.

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 07:51

The market is terrible for sellers at the moment so nothing is impossible. Could be a distressed sale, could be someone emigrating, could simply be overpriced where the seller has self valued using a historical sale value from peak sellers market data whereas we are currently in a buyers market. In any of those situations 400k from a cash buyer exchanging and completing immediately is more attractive than yet another sale falling through with a chain buyer after months of delay at 480k. Do it.

socialbatteryisdead · 14/11/2026 08:10

Fairiesarereal345 · 13/11/2026 21:48

Thank you all. House has been up since end of July. No reductions yet. Apparently one other interested party but they need to get an offer on their house first.

It's a very unique, old property and unlike anything else so it's very hard to know if the pricing is right.

It would have sold if the price was right.

Fair3nough · 14/11/2026 08:20

i don’t think offering what you can afford in this market is a lack of integrity problem. It is what it is. People can’t afford as much as they could when rates were 1-2%. Now they are 5-6% they aren’t going to give sellers as much as they can’t afford to.

you can take offence to that and say they are chancers and time wasters but the fact is the market is going down. Buyers are taking a much bigger financial risk than a few years ago. They won’t be willing to throw money at you to avoid causing you offence. In this market we all need our hard hats on sadly.

eta: I meant to quote @daisychain01

Holisticthy · 14/11/2026 08:43

foursquares · 13/11/2026 23:09

Ermm no. You make an offer based on assumption that roof is not leaking and is structurally sound. Not sure if you're working with Mr Superman, but most estate agents are pretty clueless, and don't even understand what disintegrated torching is..

This is crazy. A house is worth £100k more with a new roof if the roof doesn't leak. But the day your house roof starts leaking it drops in value by £100k.
. Who knew?

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 08:50

Fairiesarereal345 · 13/11/2026 21:48

Thank you all. House has been up since end of July. No reductions yet. Apparently one other interested party but they need to get an offer on their house first.

It's a very unique, old property and unlike anything else so it's very hard to know if the pricing is right.

It is completely possible.

There are a number of comments in your two posts that make me think this isn’t for you.

A grade 2 property is different to what you appear to understand. Either get on that learning curve now or walk away.

BTW the roof is probably fine, and you are unlikely to get it fully replaced particularly if it is as “unique” as you claim.

Out of interest what makes it so “unique”?

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 10:51

Holisticthy · 14/11/2026 08:43

This is crazy. A house is worth £100k more with a new roof if the roof doesn't leak. But the day your house roof starts leaking it drops in value by £100k.
. Who knew?

And they come out of a box ready to cut to size or add an expansion kit, that’s why they are a fixed cost of £100k. 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread