Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Has anyone ever offered 400k on a 500k house?

201 replies

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 07:06

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:54

The seller certainly has the choice of whether to accept any offer or not but, if the market doesn't produce their desired price, they may have no choice but to stay put!
Sellers can choose to wait for better offers, and historically, they have often been fortunate, because the market has mostly risen, but they may well be less fortunate in a falling market.

All of those circumstantial aspects are valid, @rainingsnoring what I object to is someone on here saying that vendors who aren't willing to slash the price of their property, and decide to wait until someone comes along with an acceptable offer, are time wasters. One would have to be living under a rock not to recognise the current falling market, but equally, properties have fetched elevated prices in the past because people were willing to pay what the property was valued at and keen to invest in that asset.

DetectiveSt · 15/11/2026 07:20

You can’t like the house much OP

stillavid · 15/11/2026 07:26

Yes, we offered over £100k less and it was refused. 3 months later they came back and accepted our offer.

DetectiveSt · 15/11/2026 07:29

stillavid · 15/11/2026 07:26

Yes, we offered over £100k less and it was refused. 3 months later they came back and accepted our offer.

And?

TheCrowInNovember · 15/11/2026 07:54

General comment:

Here’s an interesting article from the Telegraph today.

Inflation wipes out 24 years of house price growth

However it’s actually London flats that are becoming much harder to sell.

Particularly in the capital, buyers are able to negotiate large discounts on flats.
“Some people are desperate to sell,” Mr Sykes said.
He noted a flat in north-east London that was first listed at £550,000 but had gone under offer at £480,000 – a 13pc price cut.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/11/14/inflation-wipes-out-24-years-of-house-price-growth/

So in the context of a tough market (London flats), a 13% drop is considered notable. So in other contexts, don’t expect any drop at or above that % to be accepted or acceptable, perhaps, short of the survey throwing up major issues?

stillavid · 15/11/2026 07:57

DetectiveSt · 15/11/2026 07:29

And?

Umm, I answered the question in the OP. We offered £100k less - actually was a little more and our offer was accepted and we bought the house.

You can offer whatever you want and the seller can accept or not. It is not a big deal.

RoseWylie · 15/11/2026 08:05

daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 07:06

All of those circumstantial aspects are valid, @rainingsnoring what I object to is someone on here saying that vendors who aren't willing to slash the price of their property, and decide to wait until someone comes along with an acceptable offer, are time wasters. One would have to be living under a rock not to recognise the current falling market, but equally, properties have fetched elevated prices in the past because people were willing to pay what the property was valued at and keen to invest in that asset.

Nobody has said that. My post (the one you got cross about) was about sellers who are not bothered whether they sell or not and can therefore wait indefinitely, and it didn't actually call those sellers time wasters, it only implied that they might be in comparison to buyers making bona fide offers, but hey ho.

properties have fetched elevated prices in the past because people were willing to pay what the property was valued at and keen to invest in that asset

The launch price suggested by an estate agent isn't a valuation, and a lot of agents deliberately go high in order to get your business, tie you into a long contract and then suggest dropping the price. Anchoring your expectations around that initial price in a falling market and getting angry about offers which reflect the actual market price is likely to be a mistake if you want to sell.

Good luck with your sale anyway.

RoseWylie · 15/11/2026 08:09

TheCrowInNovember · 15/11/2026 07:54

General comment:

Here’s an interesting article from the Telegraph today.

Inflation wipes out 24 years of house price growth

However it’s actually London flats that are becoming much harder to sell.

Particularly in the capital, buyers are able to negotiate large discounts on flats.
“Some people are desperate to sell,” Mr Sykes said.
He noted a flat in north-east London that was first listed at £550,000 but had gone under offer at £480,000 – a 13pc price cut.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/11/14/inflation-wipes-out-24-years-of-house-price-growth/

So in the context of a tough market (London flats), a 13% drop is considered notable. So in other contexts, don’t expect any drop at or above that % to be accepted or acceptable, perhaps, short of the survey throwing up major issues?

It's interesting that even within London flats there's lots of variation. Period conversions with share of freehold are down much less. New builds and newer leasehold flats have fallen off a cliff.

chirrupybird · 15/11/2026 08:12

Our neighbours sold for £100k less than asking, but they were flying a kite. We didn't think they would get anywhere near asking and no surprise they didn't. But if they had started at a sensible valuation I don't think they would have got what they did.

DetectiveSt · 15/11/2026 08:33

stillavid · 15/11/2026 07:57

Umm, I answered the question in the OP. We offered £100k less - actually was a little more and our offer was accepted and we bought the house.

You can offer whatever you want and the seller can accept or not. It is not a big deal.

Ummm - You didn’t clarify that you actually bought the house when they came back to you

rainingsnoring · 15/11/2026 09:04

daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 07:06

All of those circumstantial aspects are valid, @rainingsnoring what I object to is someone on here saying that vendors who aren't willing to slash the price of their property, and decide to wait until someone comes along with an acceptable offer, are time wasters. One would have to be living under a rock not to recognise the current falling market, but equally, properties have fetched elevated prices in the past because people were willing to pay what the property was valued at and keen to invest in that asset.

I agree with you but I'm not sure that is what the pp meant. I thought she meant sellers who weren't bothered whether they sell or not, ie non serious sellers, who are wasting the estate agent's time and money and arguably buyer's time too.
I completely agree that buyers have often been willing to pay asking price in the past. However, the current situation is that house prices are totally out of kilter with wages, the job market is poor, real wages are shrinking while the cost of essentials has risen, interest rates are far higher than they have been for a long period following the 2008 GFC, sentiment in general seems low and it seems clear that property is less of a great investment nowadays.

notafraidofthebigbadwolf · 15/11/2026 09:42

Yes, we originally offered £500k asking price on a quirky Victorian house that needed full renovation back in 2008 (but before the crash and interest rate collapse.) We paid for a full survey and the guy put the fear of God into us about a retaining wall and that if the foundations weren’t deep enough the whole house might come down. The seller was struggling with the stairs and needed to move. She didn’t want anymore than the one open day for viewings. She didn’t want us sending someone round to do an exploratory dig of the foundations. So we respectfully reduced our offer to £400k and we proceeded on that basis.

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 09:59

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 23:04

Roof: almost certainly won’t be fully replaced, it will need repairing.
Sandblasting: is not a conservation approved method.
Rendering will need to be Lime. Then limewash for colour.

LBC can take a long time to be approved, then you have the lead time on heritage trades. This is realistically a two year timescale for you or them.

If this work has been done without permission, what else has? what’s the interior decor? With the plastic paint outside, if this is also inside then the walls could be quite damp even if not showing yet. Plaster and paint may need to be stripped back internally too.

If you buy at 100k less than asking, can you afford the work required and do you have the patience for it? FYI I suspect the render will cost more than the roof repairs. Let’s say 3-4ksqft, 2 storey, 50-60k for heritage render removal then lime . You haven’t said the issues with the roof so can’t ball park that for you.

Edited

Thank you so much for this. It's really heartbreaking because we love the house, and it appears absolutely fine to an untrained eye, but yes, you're right, I worry about what else has been done without the proper buildings consent.

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 10:01

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:45

If that's the case, surely you need to pull out and let the sellers sort out their own mess!

Sadly you're most likely right. We absolutely love the house, and unfortunately can see it from our current house, so pulling out will be emotionally hard. But yes, it's almost certainly the right decision.

ElephantElephantElephant · 15/11/2026 10:13

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 22:28

Thanks for clarifying arrogant was the word I needed.

Zero emotion, anger or blame in my world, I deal with facts and people. You are correct with it all being in the sellers control, thanks for backing my point about not selling to somebody like you.

I think you’ve misread her posts actually.

@TediousTim

I agree with PP that this doesn’t sound like the house for you. For context, we bought a listed house that needed work- it can be incredibly expensive, the listing adds a fortune to the cost of everything and you will encounter all kinds of issues which you then have to resolve. Basically you’re writing a blank cheque. These days it only really makes sense as a labour of love- people buy these houses because they adore them and see the expense as a price worth paying, but its generally not economic (in that you’ll put far more in than you’ll make back on resale) and it’s a really bad idea on a tight budget.

daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 10:20

rainingsnoring · 15/11/2026 09:04

I agree with you but I'm not sure that is what the pp meant. I thought she meant sellers who weren't bothered whether they sell or not, ie non serious sellers, who are wasting the estate agent's time and money and arguably buyer's time too.
I completely agree that buyers have often been willing to pay asking price in the past. However, the current situation is that house prices are totally out of kilter with wages, the job market is poor, real wages are shrinking while the cost of essentials has risen, interest rates are far higher than they have been for a long period following the 2008 GFC, sentiment in general seems low and it seems clear that property is less of a great investment nowadays.

I'd just love to know their source of insights for people they've never met, to know they aren't bothered if they sell or not. Have they been round and quizzed them on their motives? There seem to be some broad generalisations going on.

IsStchasing · 15/11/2026 10:49

notafraidofthebigbadwolf · 15/11/2026 09:42

Yes, we originally offered £500k asking price on a quirky Victorian house that needed full renovation back in 2008 (but before the crash and interest rate collapse.) We paid for a full survey and the guy put the fear of God into us about a retaining wall and that if the foundations weren’t deep enough the whole house might come down. The seller was struggling with the stairs and needed to move. She didn’t want anymore than the one open day for viewings. She didn’t want us sending someone round to do an exploratory dig of the foundations. So we respectfully reduced our offer to £400k and we proceeded on that basis.

How did the renovation go?

IsStchasing · 15/11/2026 10:50

daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 10:20

I'd just love to know their source of insights for people they've never met, to know they aren't bothered if they sell or not. Have they been round and quizzed them on their motives? There seem to be some broad generalisations going on.

If a property has been languishing for 5 months - then it fairly reasonable to guess that the sellers aren’t in any screaming rush to move

Tortephant · 15/11/2026 11:56

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 09:59

Thank you so much for this. It's really heartbreaking because we love the house, and it appears absolutely fine to an untrained eye, but yes, you're right, I worry about what else has been done without the proper buildings consent.

If you want to private message the details or and survey I am happy to give you advice and insight, and interuprutation.

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 12:30

That is really very kind, @Tortephant . When we get the survey back in full, if there's anything that is confusing I may well take you up on that. We have joined the Listed Property Owners Club today so we can call on their advice.

Tortephant · 15/11/2026 12:35

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 12:30

That is really very kind, @Tortephant . When we get the survey back in full, if there's anything that is confusing I may well take you up on that. We have joined the Listed Property Owners Club today so we can call on their advice.

That's worth it, but also SPAB. They have an advice line too.

Flutteringfirefly · 15/11/2026 12:48

When I was selling a few years ago, I received an offer of 20% below asking price. I immediately refused and did not want to deal with people like that. My house had not been on the market very long and was having other viewings.

Some buyers (and vendors) are a nightmare and this type of offer indicates nightmare buyer to me.

FruAashild · 15/11/2026 15:05

So interesting how angry people get about low offers. When we last were buying we put a very low offer in for a house that was a probate sale. The people selling it had put the house on the market for the same price as an identical house two doors down. Except the other house was fully modernised and this one needed a complete refurbishment. We offered a price that reflected the work that needed to be done and they asked for a higher offer, we raised slightly because we liked the house but they turned that down. So we walked away. A few months later the sellers got in touch asking if we were still interested, we weren't (were in the process of buying our current house), and so it sat on the market for another year before selling for less than our initial offer. Our offer was never the problem, it was the seller's expectations.

TediousTim · 15/11/2026 16:11

Tortephant · 15/11/2026 12:35

That's worth it, but also SPAB. They have an advice line too.

Thank you.

KeepPumping · 15/11/2026 17:44

daisychain01 · 15/11/2026 07:06

All of those circumstantial aspects are valid, @rainingsnoring what I object to is someone on here saying that vendors who aren't willing to slash the price of their property, and decide to wait until someone comes along with an acceptable offer, are time wasters. One would have to be living under a rock not to recognise the current falling market, but equally, properties have fetched elevated prices in the past because people were willing to pay what the property was valued at and keen to invest in that asset.

People wanted the house and had access to cheap mortgage debt, they believed that rates would stay low and they could always get back what they paid so they went ahead because the monthly payments were manageable, many will be regretting that now, take away the belief that "property always goes up" and is always easy to sell and people become a lot more cautious.

Swipe left for the next trending thread