Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

teen son asked for reasonable adjustments, now being suggested he goes part time

114 replies

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:25

My niece started a job a few weeks ago. She has Autism so asked for a reasonable adjustment. This was agreed in writing last week. In the few weeks in role she has used her reasonable adjustment once ( ten minute task in which she undertook, but needed support). The point is, it was agreed in writing.

Her line manager suggested she was given a spare staff phone to get help as soon as she needed it, so her boss would ask the ceo for the phone.

Today, as she was leaving hr came and called her into a meeting with the ceo's deputy. Told the adjustment doesn't work ( its only been used once and the suggestion of the phone has bern tried yet) that she can take a completly different role and go part ttime.not sure of the alternative but suspect its the sack. No warning. No notes taken.said she would be emailed tonight but wasn't

Neice feels she has been set up. Had no previous warnings it wasn't working and never met this boss who is several levels above her line manager. The reasonable adjustment set out how and when it can be changed. None of which was followed.

What can she do if she is demoted and made part time over this or sacked?

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

Why would the big boss and hr arrange a meeting with no warning and no notes? They couldn't have just decided on the fly, neither was it a case of seeing her in passing and having a chat. It was hr that collected her and stayed in the bosses room.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:50

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 13:30

what I’m saying is - by standing up for them, are we actually making it worse?

The same argument has been made on here about standing up for the rights of pregnant women. Ignoring employers breaking the law will not make it any better.

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 13:51

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 13:08

Surely an employer agreeing to a reasonable adjustments doesn't mean they lose all right to question the employee ability to do their job?

In this case of not being to deal with sick. If the arrangement is that the employee has to inform someone else that sick needs cleaning but the employee still needs to stay with the poorly person, but an incident happens, the employee feels unwell, fails to inform someone and instead runs outside and stays there. In the meantime, the poorly person faints and someone slips on the sick and hurt their back.

Surely the employer would have a right to say that the reasonable adjustment did not work and the employee inability to even contact someone and stay with the person means they are a liability in their role. It would reasonable to consider an alternative role, but if none was available, that the person could be dismiss without it being deemed unfair?

Health and safety of clients and other staff has to come first surely!

But that wasn't the case. Someone was sick and she stayed and comforted and made sure the person was looked after and cleaned up. She just couldn't do the mopping. She was told she could have done it all alone. Deal with the customer , make them feel safe and cared for while mopping up the vomit would highly possibly make her rech. She wouldn't have fainted or needed a lie down or a day off. But she couldn't guarantee a wonderful discreet mop out in front of the customer. Like any disability, her reaction cant be presumed. Its a presumtion she would need two hours off. She wouldnt. At worse she would have done it and felt very uncomfortable and that would show on her face. There a chance she might have topped the bucket of sick with her own.

i think if she hadn't mentioned it and had realised it was a real possibility in winter bug season she could have quietly made plans to find another job ASAP. It was presumed it would have been agreed or refused at time of the reasonable adjustment meeting. Is it a possible reasonable adjustment yes or no?

But what has happened in reality that she was told its fine, until you need the adjustment and its not actually fine at all. Its the revokement and pissing about. Senior managers overuling the risk assessor. All of that is much worse than just saying "if someone is sick it falls under who ever is right there with the customer to clean it up. That's non negotiable.

Than saying "if someone is sick call for backup so theres two of you to sort it between you, to keep the customer comfortable, oh but scrap that the big cheese has overuled me".

OP posts:
Wintercold · Yesterday 13:59

I’m a nurse and if I see sick I will 100% of the time be sick. It wasn’t that often it happened but most of the time you were aware it was likely and those shifts I would tell my colleagues my predicament, ask for their future help and clean up any other bodily fluids for others that day just in case I needed said help! Sometimes it’s about actually talking to colleagues rather than a written document? I’m 100% sure that if I’d asked for ‘reasonable adjustments’ via a manager rather then making a bit of a joke about it with my colleagues then no one would have helped me

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 14:07

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 13:51

But that wasn't the case. Someone was sick and she stayed and comforted and made sure the person was looked after and cleaned up. She just couldn't do the mopping. She was told she could have done it all alone. Deal with the customer , make them feel safe and cared for while mopping up the vomit would highly possibly make her rech. She wouldn't have fainted or needed a lie down or a day off. But she couldn't guarantee a wonderful discreet mop out in front of the customer. Like any disability, her reaction cant be presumed. Its a presumtion she would need two hours off. She wouldnt. At worse she would have done it and felt very uncomfortable and that would show on her face. There a chance she might have topped the bucket of sick with her own.

i think if she hadn't mentioned it and had realised it was a real possibility in winter bug season she could have quietly made plans to find another job ASAP. It was presumed it would have been agreed or refused at time of the reasonable adjustment meeting. Is it a possible reasonable adjustment yes or no?

But what has happened in reality that she was told its fine, until you need the adjustment and its not actually fine at all. Its the revokement and pissing about. Senior managers overuling the risk assessor. All of that is much worse than just saying "if someone is sick it falls under who ever is right there with the customer to clean it up. That's non negotiable.

Than saying "if someone is sick call for backup so theres two of you to sort it between you, to keep the customer comfortable, oh but scrap that the big cheese has overuled me".

Is this in a care home type setting? Is the real problem that they are running on minimal staff and don't always have someone to help?

I mostly agree with @Octavia64 and @prh47bridge and have been on both sides of this equation myself but I had one question - did the adjustment agreement have anything about trial basis and review? This would be common IME and isn't suspicious - it should help both sides and should define the process for review. Are they claiming the conversation about a different role was the review? If so there should be documented decisions with reasons for a response.

All the posters jumping in to say the employer isn't wrong and should be free to ignore adjustments need to look at their tax bills - the harder you make it for people with disabilities to work, the higher that tax bill will be. Provide better access to work and most become tax payers rather than being dependent on support.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:10

I'm sorry but I can't get my head around someone applying for a job where it's patently obvious they are going to face problems and then asking for the employer to make adjustments for them to be able to do the job.

It's not as if jobs where you can reasonably expect to encounter vomit are the majority.

What next, someone with a peanut allergy applying to work in a factory making Snickers?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:14

the harder you make it for people with disabilities to work

Emetophobia is a disability only if you take a job where you expect to encounter vomit. It is not a disability if you work in Tesco or a bank call centre or in the vast majority of jobs.

What has happened to personal responsibility?!

chirrupybird · Yesterday 14:30

I think if she's only been there a few weeks and it's not working out they can sack her as long as it's not because of her disability. If she can't do the current role moving her to something she can cope with is a good idea.

I think a lot of people feel sick when they see vomit and cleaning it up is horrible, but if it's an intrinsic part of the job and she has to call someone else to do it that really isn't fair on her work mates, I would complain if I had to do her dirty work, while she did the hand holding.

BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 14:57

Being unable to clear sick is not an autistic characteristic

Exactly. I struggle with sick a lot and shit too. I avoided nursing for this reason even though I would have been great at the rest of it. What I didnt do is claim my fear of shit and sick was related to my disability and thus I could have a reasonable adjustment and not do it. That’s dishonest and taking the piss IMO.

TheSpook · Yesterday 16:30

mopping up the vomit would highly possibly make her rech. She wouldn't have fainted or needed a lie down or a day off.

Sounds like a perfectly normal reaction and nothing to do with ASD. I wouldn't think many people could mop up up bodily fluids including vomit without retching.

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 19:02

Hands up how many people like clearing up sick?

Alwaysjournalling · Yesterday 20:56

MalateOxaloacetate · 20/11/2026 23:33

You call me a pedantic prick when you just inferred that autism meant someone had ‘mental problems’. That is not acceptable wording to use around autism.

As an autistic person myself, I disagree. It is a mental problem. It originates in the brain. It's not a mental illness, which is what you incorrectly decided my comment meant. It's not a mental health problem and I didn't say it was, but it is a mental problem.

Although mental health issues often go hand in hand with the condition eg social anxiety, difficulty regulating emotions, depression or in this case a phobia the person has which OP states is due to their niece's autism. Not everyone with autism will experience any mental health issues but plenty do. It's a difficult condition to have and workplace stress can easily cause further health issues to develop.

So how about you stop policing my language around the condition eh? Nobody died and made you king.

KiwiFall · Today 12:22

So she can deal with sick, it may make her retch. This is very very common and not part of a disability. But if it is a very common occurrence and part of the job and she is refusing to do it then as said before maybe a move to a different role is best.

GaaNeen · Today 12:57

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 19:02

Hands up how many people like clearing up sick?

disgust about vomit is a completely normal and evolutionary response
disgust prevents us rolling in it, and giving infectious matter a wide berth protects us !
when I’ve been in job roles that require clearing up adult piss, shit and vomit, I have gagged, put cotton wool up my nose to mask the stench and had to cope

I suspect that the autistic person would have similar disgust response but will have different threshold to tolerating strong emotions like disgust or anxiety about having to do a disgusting horrible job

OP’s person is clearly in the wrong job for now,
but may benefit from increased exposure and distress tolerance skills

I think the aim should not be reasonable adjustments that aim to avoid something stressful, but provide the scaffolding needed to be able to learn to manage the issue

expect people to retort - no way ! You don’t get it !
but avoidance is a short term fix.
Coping with avoidance usually means what we avoid grows / spreads

4timesthefun · Today 13:37

Hope you get some clarity, OP! It might also depend on how frequently a vomiting customer/patient is likely to come up. My middle child once (extremely unexpectedly) vomited in a Schuh store. In that situation, it would probably be manageable for a staff member to have reasonable adjustments around dealing with vomit, because it would presumably be quite rare (you would hope!). If the role is in a health, childcare, education, or aged care setting then it’s going to be much harder as it would presumably be a more common occurrence.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page