Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

teen son asked for reasonable adjustments, now being suggested he goes part time

114 replies

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:25

My niece started a job a few weeks ago. She has Autism so asked for a reasonable adjustment. This was agreed in writing last week. In the few weeks in role she has used her reasonable adjustment once ( ten minute task in which she undertook, but needed support). The point is, it was agreed in writing.

Her line manager suggested she was given a spare staff phone to get help as soon as she needed it, so her boss would ask the ceo for the phone.

Today, as she was leaving hr came and called her into a meeting with the ceo's deputy. Told the adjustment doesn't work ( its only been used once and the suggestion of the phone has bern tried yet) that she can take a completly different role and go part ttime.not sure of the alternative but suspect its the sack. No warning. No notes taken.said she would be emailed tonight but wasn't

Neice feels she has been set up. Had no previous warnings it wasn't working and never met this boss who is several levels above her line manager. The reasonable adjustment set out how and when it can be changed. None of which was followed.

What can she do if she is demoted and made part time over this or sacked?

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

Why would the big boss and hr arrange a meeting with no warning and no notes? They couldn't have just decided on the fly, neither was it a case of seeing her in passing and having a chat. It was hr that collected her and stayed in the bosses room.

OP posts:
Hedgehogforshort · 19/11/2026 23:37

I just happen to be up late. It would be impossible to comment on your post since it is so vague.

mysittingduck · 19/11/2026 23:42

What is the adjustment?

Kirschcherries · 19/11/2026 23:43

I would advise niece to contact ACAS.

Ideally you want it in writing. So consider sending an email tomorrow stating what was discussed and asking why the reasonable adjustment is not working when it has only been used once.

Chinscratches · 19/11/2026 23:46

Your post says teen son but then you talk about your niece?
Either way it's hard for us to say without knowing what the "reasonable adjustment " is

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:58

Kirschcherries · 19/11/2026 23:43

I would advise niece to contact ACAS.

Ideally you want it in writing. So consider sending an email tomorrow stating what was discussed and asking why the reasonable adjustment is not working when it has only been used once.

Tried phoning tonight but they are unavailable. Sorry its vague as its a pretty unique situation so identifying.

The adjustment was very reasonable and arranged and set out as per policy in the proper documented form for her company. Think working with people who eg might be sick and they have emetophobia. They agree they will see sick, deal with someone being sick, see sick, get splashes of sick on them but actually mopping up the sick would be too much to handle. But its not just a whim, its part of their presentation of Autism and documented. If forced with being sacked maybe they could mop up the vomit but they would possibly vomit themselves over the public and be extremely upset. Its not just that no one likes sick, its debilitating. I know people will say suck it up and stop being pathetic, but she didnt choose to have this. She knew she be around unwell people but didnt realise the level of detail until it happened anything else is fine. Piss shit blood etc

I thought the part where it was agreed and revoked without prior warning or following policy was enough in law? Or is it not? Does it depend on how much a non nd person can suck up?

They are regretting the disclosure but its not possible to stay in the post long term without the adjustment.

OP posts:
SmashedFridgeMagnets · 20/11/2026 00:01

Sorry its my neice. Dyslexic and this has come to light via my son. Im trying to edit and paste and get mixed up.

I thought it sound off. Son has also got sen so I know a bit about reasonable adjustments but just via schools not work.

OP posts:
Itsthewoluff · 20/11/2026 00:07

How available are other people to help her when needed?

canisquaeso · 20/11/2026 00:14

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:58

Tried phoning tonight but they are unavailable. Sorry its vague as its a pretty unique situation so identifying.

The adjustment was very reasonable and arranged and set out as per policy in the proper documented form for her company. Think working with people who eg might be sick and they have emetophobia. They agree they will see sick, deal with someone being sick, see sick, get splashes of sick on them but actually mopping up the sick would be too much to handle. But its not just a whim, its part of their presentation of Autism and documented. If forced with being sacked maybe they could mop up the vomit but they would possibly vomit themselves over the public and be extremely upset. Its not just that no one likes sick, its debilitating. I know people will say suck it up and stop being pathetic, but she didnt choose to have this. She knew she be around unwell people but didnt realise the level of detail until it happened anything else is fine. Piss shit blood etc

I thought the part where it was agreed and revoked without prior warning or following policy was enough in law? Or is it not? Does it depend on how much a non nd person can suck up?

They are regretting the disclosure but its not possible to stay in the post long term without the adjustment.

I mean, to be fair if the reasonable adjustment is that someone else will always have to clean it up I can imagine that will create problems quickly.

I get that a phobia is a phobia, but I can imagine most people are always less than thrilled at having to deal with vomit.

HeddaGarbled · 20/11/2026 00:14

I think you’ll have to wait until you can get through to Acas. This is all too vague for a bunch of Mumsnet laypeople to be able to tell you anything useful.

Blackstar88 · 20/11/2026 00:23

It sounds very much like the job is in a healthcare setting, dealing with vomit may well be part and parcel of the job?

Yellowcakestand · 20/11/2026 00:26

It sounds as if the role isnt suitable for her long term. I qork for the NHS and reasonable adjustments from occupational health are just recommendations. If they dont work for the service then we dont have to adhere to them. If an alternative role would work better for the employee and service then that option could be explored. Though they cannot enforce a reduction in hours if she is actually able to complete full tasks required of the role she is in now. Which it seems she is unable to in this scenario.

Ditto speak to ACAS and HR ASAP.

JMSA · 20/11/2026 00:26

I’m guessing that they hadn’t been 100% happy with her performance before now.
Sorry, and hope I’m wrong.

SpidersAreShitheads · 20/11/2026 00:32

I think a lot depends on whether it’s a core and essential duty that needs a reasonable adjustment. And as part of that, the type of setting and how feasible the suggested reasonable adjustment is.

The fact that a phone was being proposed suggests that the workaround in place wasn’t very practical.

I’m autistic and I sympathise. But not all roles are going to be suitable for everyone and your niece really needs to consider whether the reasonable adjustment being requested is genuinely fair to co-workers and any customers. Obviously without proper details none of us can give a proper opinion.

alcovecupboards · 20/11/2026 00:42

It's not very clear but to use your example of mopping up sick - is that part of the job? If so - then it would not be a reasonable adjustment for it to be removed from the job in question, and therefore it is likely acceptable to dismiss or offer any suitable alternate employment.

caringcarer · 20/11/2026 00:44

Blackstar88 · 20/11/2026 00:23

It sounds very much like the job is in a healthcare setting, dealing with vomit may well be part and parcel of the job?

And I wonder if your niece can't do aspects of the job if she might be more suited to a different role eg paperwork. I'm unsure why a person who can't deal with sick would want to work in a role where dealing with sick was part of the job?

Alwaysjournalling · 20/11/2026 01:09

The one thing you do already know is that they're a shit employer. That meeting should have taken place during your niece's working hours, not outside of it in her personal time. I don't think you can expect them to play fair or comply with laws at all when they've already shown they won't.

Her options realistically are take the other role and start looking for another job or end up fired. Working somewhere where the boss has it in for you and wants you gone is basically a no-go for anyone, but for someone who already has mental problems it's a disaster. Her sanity isn't worth proving a point.

If she does want to take them to tribunal for disability discrimination and unfair dismissal she can do that regardless of whether she's left the role/company or is still in it. Maybe she has grounds for tribunal and might win, but the stress of it may impact her health and would realistically make her new role untenable too, as she'd just be labelled a troublemaker and got rid of more carefully next time.

ACAS can give you advice on the law but even if the company is in the wrong ACAS aren't going to do anything about it, it's on your niece to fight the employer if she wants to. Her being right doesn't make that easy or guarantee she'll win.

I wonder if that meeting has even been documented anywhere. Since it took place after her hours, they've not followed their own procedures about the reasonable adjustment and she didn't receive the promised email. It could be the start of an unofficial bullying campaign to get her to leave (that role, if not the company). Maybe banking on her being young, not understanding employment law and with her being autistic hoping she just won't want the hassle of standing up to them and will cave in and do what they want.

I know my take on it is negative but I've had enough rubbish jobs to know that laws don't really protect you from anything much. Good luck to her whatever she decides to do.

dancehysterical22 · 20/11/2026 04:06

Reasonable adjustments are reasonable because they don’t require more work for anyone else, but ‘needed support’ sounds like it does, and implies shes unable to do elements of the job,thats maybe why part time was suggested.

4timesthefun · 20/11/2026 04:06

Hopefully she can get some proper advice as I don’t think anyone can truly guide you without knowing the situation. In the example you provided, being able to phone someone else to make them clean up the vomit is unlikely to be a reasonable or practical accommodation in a healthcare setting. It also wouldn’t be managed by going part-time. If (for example) she could clean up the vomit but would then need a couple of hours off to manage her own nausea, then going part time might be able to help, as she could make up the hours at another time. Totally understand not sharing for privacy, it just means no one can really give you an answer!

IzzyLeng · 20/11/2026 05:30

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

they don’t need to deny it’s related to her autism. It’s related to her not being able to do part of her job role. The fact it’s related to her autism is irrelevant as long as reasonable adjustments have been considered. But ultimately whatever adjustment is put in place it sounds like she can’t clear up sick. Getting other people to take over your role is not necessarily reasonable or practical. So she could be sacked on capability grounds.

Thats my understanding anyway from a very similar situation where a very large and competent HR department started taking steps to sack a colleague who could not do part of their role due to disability.

LindorDoubleChoc · 20/11/2026 06:16

As someone with emetophobia she should recognise that some work places are really not going to be for her. I write as a fellow sufferer and know, and have always known, that I could not work with children in any capacity, or any kind of health care setting, or in a pub, or on public transport, even in animal care. It's limiting but c'est la vie.

PJ98 · 20/11/2026 07:03

This job isnt for her, so i wouldnt waste any energy on any of this, personally. It's very obvious.

Soontobe60 · 20/11/2026 07:12

In your analogy about vomit, someone who had a phobia about vomit would net be suitable for a job involving that! It’s like saying someone with a fear of heights can take a job as a scaffolder but only do the ground floor.

arethereanyleftatall · 20/11/2026 07:28

Your op isn’t going to be the full story. They are obviously not going to get rid of someone who was doing the job well but needed an adjustment for ten minutes.
wouldn’t a reasonable adjustment be something that supports that person but doesn’t negatively impact others? So - eg if you have adhd you can start late but you finish late. Or a special chair etc. Not stuff like someone else who works there having to pick up bits of your the role you’re paid to do.

rwalker · 20/11/2026 07:29

Alwaysjournalling · 20/11/2026 01:09

The one thing you do already know is that they're a shit employer. That meeting should have taken place during your niece's working hours, not outside of it in her personal time. I don't think you can expect them to play fair or comply with laws at all when they've already shown they won't.

Her options realistically are take the other role and start looking for another job or end up fired. Working somewhere where the boss has it in for you and wants you gone is basically a no-go for anyone, but for someone who already has mental problems it's a disaster. Her sanity isn't worth proving a point.

If she does want to take them to tribunal for disability discrimination and unfair dismissal she can do that regardless of whether she's left the role/company or is still in it. Maybe she has grounds for tribunal and might win, but the stress of it may impact her health and would realistically make her new role untenable too, as she'd just be labelled a troublemaker and got rid of more carefully next time.

ACAS can give you advice on the law but even if the company is in the wrong ACAS aren't going to do anything about it, it's on your niece to fight the employer if she wants to. Her being right doesn't make that easy or guarantee she'll win.

I wonder if that meeting has even been documented anywhere. Since it took place after her hours, they've not followed their own procedures about the reasonable adjustment and she didn't receive the promised email. It could be the start of an unofficial bullying campaign to get her to leave (that role, if not the company). Maybe banking on her being young, not understanding employment law and with her being autistic hoping she just won't want the hassle of standing up to them and will cave in and do what they want.

I know my take on it is negative but I've had enough rubbish jobs to know that laws don't really protect you from anything much. Good luck to her whatever she decides to do.

By the sounds of it they’ve tried to find a work round and it’s not practical so there offering different role that’s more suited to nieces abilities
any adjustment has to be practical and work for the business as well

I wouldn’t be shouting discrimination or tribunal some roles just aren’t suitable
it’s like applying to be a taxi driver and then saying in autistic and can’t drive
they are working with her

Swipe left for the next trending thread