Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

teen son asked for reasonable adjustments, now being suggested he goes part time

114 replies

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:25

My niece started a job a few weeks ago. She has Autism so asked for a reasonable adjustment. This was agreed in writing last week. In the few weeks in role she has used her reasonable adjustment once ( ten minute task in which she undertook, but needed support). The point is, it was agreed in writing.

Her line manager suggested she was given a spare staff phone to get help as soon as she needed it, so her boss would ask the ceo for the phone.

Today, as she was leaving hr came and called her into a meeting with the ceo's deputy. Told the adjustment doesn't work ( its only been used once and the suggestion of the phone has bern tried yet) that she can take a completly different role and go part ttime.not sure of the alternative but suspect its the sack. No warning. No notes taken.said she would be emailed tonight but wasn't

Neice feels she has been set up. Had no previous warnings it wasn't working and never met this boss who is several levels above her line manager. The reasonable adjustment set out how and when it can be changed. None of which was followed.

What can she do if she is demoted and made part time over this or sacked?

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

Why would the big boss and hr arrange a meeting with no warning and no notes? They couldn't have just decided on the fly, neither was it a case of seeing her in passing and having a chat. It was hr that collected her and stayed in the bosses room.

OP posts:
SnobblyBobbly · 20/11/2026 07:57

I agree with PP who suggest knowing your limitations if you have a phobia, extreme difficulty with something that forms part of the job. Other staff won’t want to support someone routinely when it’s obviously not a suitable role for them in the first place.

Branleuse · 20/11/2026 08:10

Is it in healthcare?

I know its only an example you used, but if someone works as a nurse or carer then Im not sure its reasonable to not have to deal with sick ever as its such a frequent occurance. The adjustment has to be reasonable.

That said. I think the fact your neice has to
disclosed to them she has a disability means they are careful to not just get rid and have offered her a different suggestion, which might be worth considering tbh.

GaaNeen · 20/11/2026 08:17

Someone with emetephobia is not suitable for a job that includes cleaning up sick
it is not appropriate to just not be able to carry out an essential duty
I guess the phone was to alert someone else to come and clear up sick -

this will be an infection control issue - the person on duty needs to be able to clean up the sick without delay -
just a case of wrong person wrong job
this is not an autism issue - it’s an emetephobia issue
(there is treatment for emetephobia- you can guess what the treatment looks like 🤢)

Branleuse · 20/11/2026 08:19

I don't think you should be framing it as demotion if they have offered her a different role.
Shes an autistic young person and has started a job that triggers her phobia regularly.
I think she should have a serious conversation with them and discuss it. If its a different role, is there any chance she could keep full time hours.

Im autistic too and have had to ask for reasonable adjustments myself and also for my adult kids too. Even had to get union involvement for one of them.
It's tricky out there, but the fact they have offered her something else in the company is actually really positive. They could have quite easily said that they cant accommodate that adjustment reasonably due to the nature of the role.

Imdunfer · 20/11/2026 08:29

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:58

Tried phoning tonight but they are unavailable. Sorry its vague as its a pretty unique situation so identifying.

The adjustment was very reasonable and arranged and set out as per policy in the proper documented form for her company. Think working with people who eg might be sick and they have emetophobia. They agree they will see sick, deal with someone being sick, see sick, get splashes of sick on them but actually mopping up the sick would be too much to handle. But its not just a whim, its part of their presentation of Autism and documented. If forced with being sacked maybe they could mop up the vomit but they would possibly vomit themselves over the public and be extremely upset. Its not just that no one likes sick, its debilitating. I know people will say suck it up and stop being pathetic, but she didnt choose to have this. She knew she be around unwell people but didnt realise the level of detail until it happened anything else is fine. Piss shit blood etc

I thought the part where it was agreed and revoked without prior warning or following policy was enough in law? Or is it not? Does it depend on how much a non nd person can suck up?

They are regretting the disclosure but its not possible to stay in the post long term without the adjustment.

The obvious answer here is for an emetophobic to work in one of the vast majority of jobs that would not expect her to deal with sick.

I don't really understand how anyone could come to any other conclusion. The "reasonable adjustment" is to find another job

Minasama · 20/11/2026 08:37

Obviously they need to abide by the law but I can imagine it is career suicide in a lot of private sector workplaces to require an adjustment.

Bosses want people on their teams who go the extra mile and deliver so that the work gets done, not people who create work and admin for them with their special requirements and then probably take more sick leave due to their condition. I expect that’s what senior management and HR are trying to avoid.

Especialky when young people are two a penny they’re thinking they’ve made a big mistake.

I worked for US companies though and it was brutal.

Lougle · 20/11/2026 08:40

I think it was just an example, but I used to gag if I was around vomit. I really wanted to be a nurse so I had to train myself not to.

Reasonable adjustments have to be reasonable. For example, working in a call centre means that not being able to answer a phone is not reasonable. Working as a roofer means that you have to be able to work at heights.

I think without the exact details it's hard to know where the line falls between reasonable and unreasonable, but if other staff have to change their work duties to accommodate the needs of your niece and she has to call for help to the extent that she needs a phone to do so at all times, that's unworkable.

BreatheAndFocus · 20/11/2026 08:43

If she didn’t realise the job involved vomit when she took it, that’s unfortunate, but it’s not the employer’s fault. There are certain jobs and duties I know I couldn’t do - so I’ve never applied for a position that has them. Now she’s found out, she either takes the suggestion of another position with the company or looks for a job elsewhere.

Reasonable adjustments should be small things that are needed to allow you to do your job that are needed because of your condition, not exemptions from a big part of the job, particularly not when emetophobia can affect anyone and isn’t just an autism thing.

I get reasonable adjustments at work but none of those are related to the duties I simply couldn’t bring myself to do, they’re related to my actual condition and are small adjustments.

Monty36 · 20/11/2026 08:45

She does need to get some advice.
Asking for a reasonable adjustment does not mean it will happen. The employer can decide it is not reasonable. But should explain why.
If they agreed it in writing it sounds as though they put something in place, but it has been used once. They either think it is not an adjustment that is really needed or they have had a shift in deciding whether they can feasibly manage it or not.
From what you suggest it sounds as if someone else has to clean up any vomit as she cannot. They may feel she is doing a job that she is not suited to do. And that they cannot provide enough consistent cover to enable someone else to clean up sick if she cannot.
It does seem as though they have not explained why to her.

BreatheAndFocus · 20/11/2026 08:45

To add - I appreciate you might be using vomiting as an example not the actual problem she has, but my point still applies. Don’t take a job where you’re going to have to do things you can’t cope with when there are other jobs you could do. We all have hates and dislikes.

thingstheydonttellyouu · 20/11/2026 08:51

I’m a teacher, have emetophobia to the point I couldn’t leave the house or attend school properly, nearly 25 years later I’m able to handle it better but struggle. If a child is sick I will do absolutely everything not to clean it up BUT if a child wees, has a poo then I will volunteer. It’s all about balance. Colleagues will resent doing more of the unpleasant stuff.

Chilly80 · 20/11/2026 09:17

Just to be clear the alternative role they've offered is PT and she's currently FT?
Can she do a hybrid job between both just not doing the part of the FT role she needs to adjustment for but filling that time with the PT job?

Chunkybabythighs · 20/11/2026 09:40

I'm guessing carer or childcare and she's refusing to clean up shit/change nappies/wipe arses.

It isn't fair if the adjustment is basically palming a crap (sorry) job off on someone else to do every time. I'd be complaining if I was her colleague.

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · 20/11/2026 09:46

That not a reasonable adjustment at all. She can't do her job.

Imagine her colleagues just being called to deal with the vomit when they're the same level as her when she's right there.

Sounds like it's not the job for her. And they've been quite fair to offer a different position.

BillieWiper · 20/11/2026 09:47

canisquaeso · 20/11/2026 00:14

I mean, to be fair if the reasonable adjustment is that someone else will always have to clean it up I can imagine that will create problems quickly.

I get that a phobia is a phobia, but I can imagine most people are always less than thrilled at having to deal with vomit.

Yeah if part of your job is cleaning you can't have a phobia of the substances you are required to clean. It's not practical or fair on others. Who TF likes cleaning strangers sick? I've never done it and I'd declare a phobia of it if someone tried to make me do it.
It means there's part of the job they can't do. Which is not something the employer needs to accept.

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 10:04

I disagree with those posters who say we need the details. We don't.

Withdrawing an agreed reasonable adjustment is almost always unlawful disability discrimination. If the employee takes this it to tribunal, the employer needs strong evidence to show that the adjustment is no longer reasonable. Further, dropping the adjustment without consultation and without offering a workable alternative increases the risk of a successful discrimination claim. Switching a full time employee to a part time role is unlikely to be regarded as offering a workable alternative. And, as we are talking about a discrimination claim, OP's niece is able to make a claim despite the fact she has only worked there for a few weeks.

Contrary to what some posters seem to think, if a small part of the job may involve cleaning and you have a phobia which prevents you from doing so, a reasonable adjustment may be for your employer to get someone else to do the cleaning for you. An employer cannot simply refuse to employ someone with this phobia. They must consider ways of working around it. If they decide not to employ you and you take them to tribunal, they will have to show that no reasonable adjustment was possible. Arguments like "it is not fair on others" won't fly.

fireplacetime · 20/11/2026 10:08

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · 20/11/2026 09:46

That not a reasonable adjustment at all. She can't do her job.

Imagine her colleagues just being called to deal with the vomit when they're the same level as her when she's right there.

Sounds like it's not the job for her. And they've been quite fair to offer a different position.

It depends how big a part of the job it is
for example my colleague couldn’t deal with the sound of people vomiting on a phone call so whenever someone was, she would take off her headset and give it to the nearest colleague. We all understood and were fine with it because otherwise it meant her being sick herself
probably happened once a week or so

NewquaySurfGirl · 20/11/2026 10:10

I wouldn't work in a zoo because I have a phobia of reptiles. So I don't ever apply for jobs in zoos or vets.

The persons (son, niece, whoever) is in the wrong job, OP.

canisquaeso · 20/11/2026 10:41

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 10:04

I disagree with those posters who say we need the details. We don't.

Withdrawing an agreed reasonable adjustment is almost always unlawful disability discrimination. If the employee takes this it to tribunal, the employer needs strong evidence to show that the adjustment is no longer reasonable. Further, dropping the adjustment without consultation and without offering a workable alternative increases the risk of a successful discrimination claim. Switching a full time employee to a part time role is unlikely to be regarded as offering a workable alternative. And, as we are talking about a discrimination claim, OP's niece is able to make a claim despite the fact she has only worked there for a few weeks.

Contrary to what some posters seem to think, if a small part of the job may involve cleaning and you have a phobia which prevents you from doing so, a reasonable adjustment may be for your employer to get someone else to do the cleaning for you. An employer cannot simply refuse to employ someone with this phobia. They must consider ways of working around it. If they decide not to employ you and you take them to tribunal, they will have to show that no reasonable adjustment was possible. Arguments like "it is not fair on others" won't fly.

But how is that fair on others and how won’t that create resentment? What if there’s no one available for whatever reason?

No one enjoys cleaning up after someone’s sick, excrements etc.

I have arachnophobia and go to great lengths to avoid anything related to them, but I would
never expect someone who dislikes them (not phobia, just general fear/irk) to get rid of the things for me when they show up in the office etc. I always try to get someone who isn’t bothered by it, otherwise I accept it and go sweat/cry somewhere.

MissMoneyFairy · 20/11/2026 11:00

This is not the job for her, who does she think enjoys or will volunteer to clean up a clients vomit?

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 11:06

canisquaeso · 20/11/2026 10:41

But how is that fair on others and how won’t that create resentment? What if there’s no one available for whatever reason?

No one enjoys cleaning up after someone’s sick, excrements etc.

I have arachnophobia and go to great lengths to avoid anything related to them, but I would
never expect someone who dislikes them (not phobia, just general fear/irk) to get rid of the things for me when they show up in the office etc. I always try to get someone who isn’t bothered by it, otherwise I accept it and go sweat/cry somewhere.

But how is that fair on others and how won’t that create resentment? What if there’s no one available for whatever reason?

Those are problems for the employer to resolve. They do not justify refusing to employ someone just because they can't do a small part of the job. If the job was entirely about cleaning up other people's vomit it would be another matter. But, as far as the law is concerned, it is no different from someone who has a disability that means they can't lift heavy weights. An employer can reasonably refuse to employ them if the job is entirely about lifting heavy weights, but if they are only occasionally required to do so the employer must consider adjusting things so that the employee can do the job. This may mean reallocating duties so that lifting heavy weights is no longer part of the role, or supplying machinery to lift the heavy weights, or exempting this individual from that part of the job.

The fundamental is that, if someone is unable to fulfil all the requirements of a role due to disability, the employer must consider making adjustments. In this case, the employer has agreed to adjustments in writing. The adjustment has only been used once. If this goes to tribunal, the employer will have to justify why the adjustment is no longer reasonable. Arguing they should not have agreed to it in the first place won't work.

NewYearVibes · 20/11/2026 11:11

If I'm a collegue, I'm sorry to say I don't want to mop up sick every time. I'd imagine we all don't want to mop up sick. I would say this job really isn't for her.

Gall10 · 20/11/2026 11:20

I’m a bit confused…I read that she needs a special phone?
Then she can be splashed with someone else’s vomit but can’t clean it from a floor?
Is the phone needed to call someone else to clean the vomit from the floor?
Or have I got this completely wrong?

Hedgehogforshort · 20/11/2026 11:28

I do not disagree with @prh47bridge. But it is entirely possible that the reasonable adjustment (the phone and assistance) may not have been used by the niece when she should have, causing service delivery problems.

it is just not very clear.

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 11:36

Gall10 · 20/11/2026 11:20

I’m a bit confused…I read that she needs a special phone?
Then she can be splashed with someone else’s vomit but can’t clean it from a floor?
Is the phone needed to call someone else to clean the vomit from the floor?
Or have I got this completely wrong?

I think OP used cleaning vomit as an example. I don't think that is the actual adjustment her niece required, but I may be wrong on that.

The phone mentioned in the OP is not a special phone. It is a normal phone her niece can use to call for help when she needs it.