Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

teen son asked for reasonable adjustments, now being suggested he goes part time

114 replies

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:25

My niece started a job a few weeks ago. She has Autism so asked for a reasonable adjustment. This was agreed in writing last week. In the few weeks in role she has used her reasonable adjustment once ( ten minute task in which she undertook, but needed support). The point is, it was agreed in writing.

Her line manager suggested she was given a spare staff phone to get help as soon as she needed it, so her boss would ask the ceo for the phone.

Today, as she was leaving hr came and called her into a meeting with the ceo's deputy. Told the adjustment doesn't work ( its only been used once and the suggestion of the phone has bern tried yet) that she can take a completly different role and go part ttime.not sure of the alternative but suspect its the sack. No warning. No notes taken.said she would be emailed tonight but wasn't

Neice feels she has been set up. Had no previous warnings it wasn't working and never met this boss who is several levels above her line manager. The reasonable adjustment set out how and when it can be changed. None of which was followed.

What can she do if she is demoted and made part time over this or sacked?

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

Why would the big boss and hr arrange a meeting with no warning and no notes? They couldn't have just decided on the fly, neither was it a case of seeing her in passing and having a chat. It was hr that collected her and stayed in the bosses room.

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 06:34

One of my reasonable adjustments was changed. This was in consultation with me because it wasn’t working for the job needs overall (was fine for me but gave employer a problem). After discussion, and more explanation from me about exactly what I needed, the adjustment was altered slightly.

I think this is reasonable. Sometimes an adjustment is agreed and then doesn’t work in practice for whatever reason. Yes, the employer should try to sort it out by making agreed amendments as mine did, but the fact that didn’t happen for the niece/son suggests there’s a bit more to this.

IzzyLeng · Yesterday 07:58

Even if it’s a small part of the role if it’s an essential part of the job and if there’s nobody else to do it then they might have grounds for dismissing someone.

so using the example of cleaning vomit. If someone is the only hcsw on a shift (feasible) on a gastro ward then they need to clean vomit up. If there are two hcsw per shift then it’s feasible to say the other hcsw does all the vomit cleaning but the other one picks up more tasks to balance the workload out.

I used to work with someone and our role involved xyz. She said she couldn’t do x because of disability so I had to do all the x and she was supposed to do more y. It worked well enough.

FearMaria · Yesterday 08:22

I think you should just say what it is. And what the adjustment is.

3teens2cats · Yesterday 08:32

Is it a reasonably small employer who doesn't have much experience of this? Could it be that they really wanted to do the right thing so agreed to an adjustment without considering wider implications on other roles? They are now trying to offer alternatives because it just didn't work maybe? What might be reasonable in a large organisation may not work in a smaller one where there are just not enough staff to cover or step in at the drop of a hat. Is it reasonable to expect an employer to hire an extra member of staff? I think probably not. It's shit for her that the reasonable adjustment isn't working for the employer though. Request another meeting and review the options.

HalzTangz · Yesterday 08:42

I'm not ND but there is no way I could mop up vomit without being sick myself. For that reason I would not apply for jobs or work in a sector where I would be expected to do that as part of the job.
I think if your niece can't handle all aspects of the job then she needs to find a job she can handle the aspects of

FearMaria · Yesterday 08:50

HalzTangz · Yesterday 08:42

I'm not ND but there is no way I could mop up vomit without being sick myself. For that reason I would not apply for jobs or work in a sector where I would be expected to do that as part of the job.
I think if your niece can't handle all aspects of the job then she needs to find a job she can handle the aspects of

Exactly.

I think if you can’t handle sick, don’t work in a primary school where it’s likely someone will be sick. It’s nit reasonable to expect someone else to always have to step in. But if you can’t handle sick and you work in a Hyundai showroom and someone throws up, it’s a reasonable adjustment that someone else will deal with that unexpected situation.

KiwiFall · Yesterday 09:05

Can’t really comment on the legal issue as don’t know the actual problem, the job or what reasonable adjustments were suggested and tried/not tried. If this was a known phobia before did no-one in the family think to persuade her not to apply for this job? Whether someone has Austin’s or not surely researching the job/asking these things in an interview are key. If it has come to light since starting then maybe working with the employer to find a suitable role (if this issue is such an integral part of the current role) isn’t such a bad thing.

Whyherewego · Yesterday 09:10

It could be that the adjustment was initially agreed and then when someone more senior heard about it then it was determined that it was not workable.
Reasonable adjustments have to be reasonable both ways. And if theyve been there a few weeks only, to be honest it may be felt it's just not worth the hassle

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 09:39

I have spoken to my sil and they have phoned ACAS. It seems legally employers can refuse any reasonable adjustment if another colleague could do the job and need no adjustments. I still dont understand why reasonable adjustments exist but never mind. I work with disabled children and now im thinking in reality who will ever want to employ them? Depressing. Anyone could do a better job and they would all need support.

She is going to look for another job and not declare her autism next time. Because she said the fear of sick stems from her ASD its starting to question if she can communicate etc. She is very outgoing and bubbly. But can interpret things wrong. plus didnt think she would be expected to clean sick up. Didnt realise how many people was going to be sick. They asked at interview if she would be happy to do any additional task if needed. So thats now come up that she was asked, but not explicitly. So her communication and understanding is in question. She wanted experience to work as a non vomit related HCP later in life so possibly for the best to find out now. But in that role you wouldn't deal with body fluids.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · Yesterday 10:15

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 09:39

I have spoken to my sil and they have phoned ACAS. It seems legally employers can refuse any reasonable adjustment if another colleague could do the job and need no adjustments. I still dont understand why reasonable adjustments exist but never mind. I work with disabled children and now im thinking in reality who will ever want to employ them? Depressing. Anyone could do a better job and they would all need support.

She is going to look for another job and not declare her autism next time. Because she said the fear of sick stems from her ASD its starting to question if she can communicate etc. She is very outgoing and bubbly. But can interpret things wrong. plus didnt think she would be expected to clean sick up. Didnt realise how many people was going to be sick. They asked at interview if she would be happy to do any additional task if needed. So thats now come up that she was asked, but not explicitly. So her communication and understanding is in question. She wanted experience to work as a non vomit related HCP later in life so possibly for the best to find out now. But in that role you wouldn't deal with body fluids.

Whilst ACAS generally give good advice, on occasions their telephone advisors are staggeringly bad. This is such an occasion. An employer cannot refuse reasonable adjustments just because a colleague can do the job. There is no basis in law for this idea, nor have the courts made any such ruling. The employer can only refuse if the adjustment is not a reasonable one for them to make. Furthermore, this misses the point that the employer in this situation is trying to withdraw an agreed adjustment. If your niece consulted a lawyer who specialises in employment law they would find that, on the information posted here, they have a case for disability discrimination.

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 10:32

prh47bridge · Yesterday 10:15

Whilst ACAS generally give good advice, on occasions their telephone advisors are staggeringly bad. This is such an occasion. An employer cannot refuse reasonable adjustments just because a colleague can do the job. There is no basis in law for this idea, nor have the courts made any such ruling. The employer can only refuse if the adjustment is not a reasonable one for them to make. Furthermore, this misses the point that the employer in this situation is trying to withdraw an agreed adjustment. If your niece consulted a lawyer who specialises in employment law they would find that, on the information posted here, they have a case for disability discrimination.

Really? The consensus on here is that neice is in the wrong. Also sil told acas the risk assessment had been agreed then withdrawn the first time it was invoked?

Nice says she feels they are gunning for her now anyway. I think she is planning on getting out asap but obviously needs the money so hoping not to get sacked. But there's a feeling that the top bosses are micro managing and therefore its all dysfunctional and toxic.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · Yesterday 10:39

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 10:32

Really? The consensus on here is that neice is in the wrong. Also sil told acas the risk assessment had been agreed then withdrawn the first time it was invoked?

Nice says she feels they are gunning for her now anyway. I think she is planning on getting out asap but obviously needs the money so hoping not to get sacked. But there's a feeling that the top bosses are micro managing and therefore its all dysfunctional and toxic.

There are a lot of people on this thread who clearly don't understand the law related to reasonable adjustments. Unfortunately we often get posts from people who want to give employers a free ride when they are breaking the law.

If your niece is completely unable to do the job due to her disability, the employer can fire her or ask her to move to another role. However, if she can do the job but there is a part of it she cannot do due to her disability, the employer is required to see if it can make reasonable adjustments to allow her to do the job. That is the whole point of reasonable adjustments. Having agreed adjustments, they cannot withdraw them unless something has changed which means they are now unreasonable. Further, even if they are able to withdraw the adjustments, they cannot penalise the employee as a result - their attempt to move your niece to a part time role is clearly penalising her.

It may be that there is some important factor you have missed from your posts that changes things but, on the information posted, this looks like a clear case of disability discrimination.

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:47

It may well be the law @prh47bridge, but the end result of all of it is unfortunately employers will just stop employing from the outset anyone with a disability. They will start making up anything off the back of the interview. The long term employment prospects for anyone with a disability will just get worse with every additional disability discrimination case. The government can make whatever laws they like, but at the end of the day, employers can choose who they hire.

canisquaeso · Yesterday 12:49

SmashedFridgeMagnets · Yesterday 10:32

Really? The consensus on here is that neice is in the wrong. Also sil told acas the risk assessment had been agreed then withdrawn the first time it was invoked?

Nice says she feels they are gunning for her now anyway. I think she is planning on getting out asap but obviously needs the money so hoping not to get sacked. But there's a feeling that the top bosses are micro managing and therefore its all dysfunctional and toxic.

I don’t think it’s about whether or not she’s in the wrong, she can’t possibly be wrong for having a phobia. A phobia is a phobia.

It sounds like whatever the RA was it just wasn’t feasible for the job long term.

BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 12:53

As I said, I have a disability and have reasonable adjustments at work, which I’m very grateful for. I work hard and I have very few days off compared to others as I’m keen to show I’m a good employee and not a liability.

From the OP, it’s hard to say if the niece/son has a genuine need related to the autism. I hate people taking the piss, so to speak. I’ve seen it done in previous jobs and it just gives us all a bad name, and as @arethereanyleftatall says, could put people off employing people with a disability.

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 13:08

Surely an employer agreeing to a reasonable adjustments doesn't mean they lose all right to question the employee ability to do their job?

In this case of not being to deal with sick. If the arrangement is that the employee has to inform someone else that sick needs cleaning but the employee still needs to stay with the poorly person, but an incident happens, the employee feels unwell, fails to inform someone and instead runs outside and stays there. In the meantime, the poorly person faints and someone slips on the sick and hurt their back.

Surely the employer would have a right to say that the reasonable adjustment did not work and the employee inability to even contact someone and stay with the person means they are a liability in their role. It would reasonable to consider an alternative role, but if none was available, that the person could be dismiss without it being deemed unfair?

Health and safety of clients and other staff has to come first surely!

Octavia64 · Yesterday 13:15

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:47

It may well be the law @prh47bridge, but the end result of all of it is unfortunately employers will just stop employing from the outset anyone with a disability. They will start making up anything off the back of the interview. The long term employment prospects for anyone with a disability will just get worse with every additional disability discrimination case. The government can make whatever laws they like, but at the end of the day, employers can choose who they hire.

People used to say this about women.

prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:20

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:47

It may well be the law @prh47bridge, but the end result of all of it is unfortunately employers will just stop employing from the outset anyone with a disability. They will start making up anything off the back of the interview. The long term employment prospects for anyone with a disability will just get worse with every additional disability discrimination case. The government can make whatever laws they like, but at the end of the day, employers can choose who they hire.

It has been the law for over three decades. I'm sure any employers excluding disabled employees have been doing it for a long time. That doesn't mean we shouldn't stand up for the rights of disabled employees.

prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:26

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 13:08

Surely an employer agreeing to a reasonable adjustments doesn't mean they lose all right to question the employee ability to do their job?

In this case of not being to deal with sick. If the arrangement is that the employee has to inform someone else that sick needs cleaning but the employee still needs to stay with the poorly person, but an incident happens, the employee feels unwell, fails to inform someone and instead runs outside and stays there. In the meantime, the poorly person faints and someone slips on the sick and hurt their back.

Surely the employer would have a right to say that the reasonable adjustment did not work and the employee inability to even contact someone and stay with the person means they are a liability in their role. It would reasonable to consider an alternative role, but if none was available, that the person could be dismiss without it being deemed unfair?

Health and safety of clients and other staff has to come first surely!

No, it doesn't mean the employer loses all right to question the employee's ability to do their job, but that is not what is happening here. The employer has unilaterally decided to withdraw the adjustment and tell the employee they must move to a part time role. That is not allowed. If, however, it was a case that OP's niece is unable to do the job even with reasonable adjustments, they would be entitled to dismiss her.

An employer can only say that a reasonable adjustment in limited circumstances. If they do, they must explore alternatives. They cannot simply drop the adjustment unilaterally without consultation and without considering alternatives. The law makes it hard for an employer to withdraw adjustments completely once they have been agreed.

prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:27

Octavia64 · Yesterday 13:15

People used to say this about women.

I still hear it about pregnant women.

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 13:30

prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:20

It has been the law for over three decades. I'm sure any employers excluding disabled employees have been doing it for a long time. That doesn't mean we shouldn't stand up for the rights of disabled employees.

what I’m saying is - by standing up for them, are we actually making it worse?

fulloflentils · Yesterday 13:32

I wonder if when they are saying if anyone else can do the job, they mean someone else with that specific disability can do the job?

Sone people without autism have a phobia of sick, and sone people with autism are fine to clear it up. Being unable to clear sick is not an autistic characteristic, it’s an individual issue. Different say from a job in a shoe shop where someone needs to climb a ladder in to retrieve shoe boxes. A wheelchair user could legitimately ask for a reasonable adjustment to work the tills and sell from the kids section if kids shoes are located on the bottom racks, not because they are scared of heights, but because no one in a wheelchair could feasibly be expected to climb a ladder and retrieve boxes from the top shelves.

That’s not to say she won’t have issues with communication around this and wouldn’t find it hard to navigate her phobia and without knowing what it is and what was agreed it’s hard to say, but I suspect it has to do with whether the actual issue is as a result of her disability, and it would seem maybe it isn’t

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 13:33

The employer has unilaterally decided to withdraw the adjustment and tell the employee they must move to a part time role. That is not allowed. If, however, it was a case that OP's niece is unable to do the job even with reasonable adjustments, they would be entitled to dismiss her
And that's the information we are missing here! All we know is that they think it doesn't work. We are missing the why.

Octavia64 · Yesterday 13:39

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 13:30

what I’m saying is - by standing up for them, are we actually making it worse?

Genuinely not joking when I say that this is literally what people used to say about women,

they’d say women can never work as well as a man, an employer will never choose a woman over a man at interview because she’s just not as good/she might get pregnant/women should be in the home.

i’m glad to live in a time where you don’t have to disguise your sex on cv. They could always tell at interview anyway if they bothered.

seriously, I’m disabled. I have an undergraduate degree from Cambridge and multiple post grad degrees. I’m retired now but I have taught from a wheelchair for over 14 years and been to multiple countries around the world to work with maths teachers there.

I have disabled friends who work on the software controlling the uk’s nuclear fusion reaction, who are research mathematicians, who work for the defence research agency,

in the same way that if you exclude women from the workforce you miss out on some amazing talent, if you exclude disabled people from the workforce you miss out on some amazing talent.

no, it doesn’t benefit our country if genuinely amazing people don’t contribute because they need a wheelchair or they need small reasonable adjustments.

prh47bridge · Yesterday 13:48

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 13:33

The employer has unilaterally decided to withdraw the adjustment and tell the employee they must move to a part time role. That is not allowed. If, however, it was a case that OP's niece is unable to do the job even with reasonable adjustments, they would be entitled to dismiss her
And that's the information we are missing here! All we know is that they think it doesn't work. We are missing the why.

If they think it doesn't work they must consult with the employee and consider alternative adjustments. They have not done so. They have simply made a unilateral decision to withdraw the adjustment and tell the employee they must move to a different, part time role. That is disability discrimination. The reason they think it doesn't work is irrelevant.