Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

teen son asked for reasonable adjustments, now being suggested he goes part time

114 replies

SmashedFridgeMagnets · 19/11/2026 23:25

My niece started a job a few weeks ago. She has Autism so asked for a reasonable adjustment. This was agreed in writing last week. In the few weeks in role she has used her reasonable adjustment once ( ten minute task in which she undertook, but needed support). The point is, it was agreed in writing.

Her line manager suggested she was given a spare staff phone to get help as soon as she needed it, so her boss would ask the ceo for the phone.

Today, as she was leaving hr came and called her into a meeting with the ceo's deputy. Told the adjustment doesn't work ( its only been used once and the suggestion of the phone has bern tried yet) that she can take a completly different role and go part ttime.not sure of the alternative but suspect its the sack. No warning. No notes taken.said she would be emailed tonight but wasn't

Neice feels she has been set up. Had no previous warnings it wasn't working and never met this boss who is several levels above her line manager. The reasonable adjustment set out how and when it can be changed. None of which was followed.

What can she do if she is demoted and made part time over this or sacked?

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

Why would the big boss and hr arrange a meeting with no warning and no notes? They couldn't have just decided on the fly, neither was it a case of seeing her in passing and having a chat. It was hr that collected her and stayed in the bosses room.

OP posts:
LumpyandBumps · 20/11/2026 11:48

Reasonable adjustments are sometimes contentious but it does need everyone to be ‘reasonable’
Disabled people are being encouraged, and in some cases likely to be pushed, into working.
We all need to find a way to help accommodate that.
It is fairly naive of an employer ( or employee) to think that one person’s reasonable adjustment does not sometimes have an unreasonable affect on other staff.
I think we need to accept that others will be inconvenienced and it is up to managers to ensure the best possible outcome for both parties.
I know from past experience that one colleagues ‘reasonable’ adjustment pushed so much extra work onto me that I could not do all of my own job. I pushed back hard. I needed to as if things had carried on I would have been facing action for poor performance. It was for the manager to accommodate the reasonable adjustment so that we could both do our jobs.
Managers need to recognise how other staff will be affected, and take this into consideration before allowing adjustments.
It sometimes the case that one person in a large team having a reasonable adjustment is fairly easily accommodated, but if that figure rose to, for example, half of the team it would likely not be workable.
If the law says that agreed adjustments can’t be taken away, it must surely make employers more cautious about agreeing in the first place.
An agreed trial period for both sides might actually be helpful.
Obviously this employer has got things completely wrong as they have agreed then removed without consultation or evidence. There is no excuse for this.

LegoLivingRoom · 20/11/2026 11:51

IzzyLeng · 20/11/2026 05:30

I guess her job could sake her and deny its related to her Autism, but its a bit now as too much has been said ( but not noted)

they don’t need to deny it’s related to her autism. It’s related to her not being able to do part of her job role. The fact it’s related to her autism is irrelevant as long as reasonable adjustments have been considered. But ultimately whatever adjustment is put in place it sounds like she can’t clear up sick. Getting other people to take over your role is not necessarily reasonable or practical. So she could be sacked on capability grounds.

Thats my understanding anyway from a very similar situation where a very large and competent HR department started taking steps to sack a colleague who could not do part of their role due to disability.

The fact it is related to her autism is not irrelevant. There is even a specific type of prohibited conduct called ‘discrimination arising from a disability’ to prevent employers using this as a get out clause, unless it’s a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

I’m not saying this definitely applies here, but it’s not as simple as saying it’s irrelevant.

Icedvanillacoffee · 20/11/2026 11:57

So tricky, the employer has to be exceptionally poor and proceed in a very stupid way to create evidence of unlawful discrimination. Im not surprised though, managing people is something so many organisations are terrible at.
Ive worked with many people who have not disclosed disabilities and even just normal things that can easily be accommodated because we all know asking for anything paints a target on your back.
I myself gave up banging on about my migraines because I got no understanding let allow allowances.

BreatheAndFocus · 20/11/2026 11:58

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 10:04

I disagree with those posters who say we need the details. We don't.

Withdrawing an agreed reasonable adjustment is almost always unlawful disability discrimination. If the employee takes this it to tribunal, the employer needs strong evidence to show that the adjustment is no longer reasonable. Further, dropping the adjustment without consultation and without offering a workable alternative increases the risk of a successful discrimination claim. Switching a full time employee to a part time role is unlikely to be regarded as offering a workable alternative. And, as we are talking about a discrimination claim, OP's niece is able to make a claim despite the fact she has only worked there for a few weeks.

Contrary to what some posters seem to think, if a small part of the job may involve cleaning and you have a phobia which prevents you from doing so, a reasonable adjustment may be for your employer to get someone else to do the cleaning for you. An employer cannot simply refuse to employ someone with this phobia. They must consider ways of working around it. If they decide not to employ you and you take them to tribunal, they will have to show that no reasonable adjustment was possible. Arguments like "it is not fair on others" won't fly.

We don’t need details but they’d help. There are a number of issues here. Not in any particular order, the niece has a ‘want’ or a ‘need’ that sounds like it might be unrelated to her autism. Employers don’t have to offer reasonable adjustments for that. I know two people with autism who work F/T. They have adjustments but those are because of their autism. There are probably other adjustments they’d be happy to have but they’re not entitled to them because they’re not due to their disability.

So that’s one point - the niece would have to prove it was a reasonable adjustment required due to her disability. Another point is that it seems her manager agreed something without having it approved by the boss. It might be that the manager has no power to approve reasonable adjustments so shouldn’t have done it, and it doesn’t count.

A final point is that it could be the niece is just not coping with the job in general, so they want to kindly move her on. The offer of a different role might have been made from that kindness because they know she has autism. If she’s only recently started the job, she’s probably under probation anyway, so if she was crap they could just be rid of her. It sounds like they’re being sympathetic in the circumstances and bearing in mind her autism.

Pursuing this might cause further stress to the niece and further upset. For her own sake, it might just be easier to take the offered role for now or just walk away totally. That’s not ‘giving in’. Sometimes it’s the sensible choice for your own mental well-being.

DangerousThingsILove · 20/11/2026 12:05

caringcarer · 20/11/2026 00:44

And I wonder if your niece can't do aspects of the job if she might be more suited to a different role eg paperwork. I'm unsure why a person who can't deal with sick would want to work in a role where dealing with sick was part of the job?

This.

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 12:18

BreatheAndFocus · 20/11/2026 11:58

We don’t need details but they’d help. There are a number of issues here. Not in any particular order, the niece has a ‘want’ or a ‘need’ that sounds like it might be unrelated to her autism. Employers don’t have to offer reasonable adjustments for that. I know two people with autism who work F/T. They have adjustments but those are because of their autism. There are probably other adjustments they’d be happy to have but they’re not entitled to them because they’re not due to their disability.

So that’s one point - the niece would have to prove it was a reasonable adjustment required due to her disability. Another point is that it seems her manager agreed something without having it approved by the boss. It might be that the manager has no power to approve reasonable adjustments so shouldn’t have done it, and it doesn’t count.

A final point is that it could be the niece is just not coping with the job in general, so they want to kindly move her on. The offer of a different role might have been made from that kindness because they know she has autism. If she’s only recently started the job, she’s probably under probation anyway, so if she was crap they could just be rid of her. It sounds like they’re being sympathetic in the circumstances and bearing in mind her autism.

Pursuing this might cause further stress to the niece and further upset. For her own sake, it might just be easier to take the offered role for now or just walk away totally. That’s not ‘giving in’. Sometimes it’s the sensible choice for your own mental well-being.

I don't see anything in OP's posts that suggests it is a want or a need unrelated to her autism. However, if it is, you are right that this is not disability discrimination.

Whether the manager had the power to approve reasonable adjustments is irrelevant. The employer is bound by their actions. They can discipline the manager for exceeding their authority, but withdrawing an agreed adjustment is likely to be disability discrimination.

Removing an agreed adjustment is not the way to move OP's niece on. If she is not coping with the job, they can dismiss her or ask her if she is willing to move to another role. Withdrawing the agreed adjustment means that a tribunal won't even consider whether the employer's reason for doing so is a misguided attempt to move OP's niece on.

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 12:22

DangerousThingsILove · 20/11/2026 12:05

This.

It is not clear if dealing with vomit is the issue or if OP used that as an example. However, from a legal perspective, if the job is vomit cleaner it would be clear that no reasonable adjustment was possible, so someone who could not clean vomit could not do the job. However, if the job is, say, a receptionist where once or twice a month someone will vomit in reception and historically the receptionist has cleaned it up, the courts are likely to take the view that the employer can get someone else to clean up the vomit and allow the disabled person to do the receptionist job.

Livpool · 20/11/2026 12:28

I suppose it depends how ‘reasonable’ the adjustments are as the employer needs to balance the needs of all staff.

MalateOxaloacetate · 20/11/2026 12:46

Alwaysjournalling · 20/11/2026 01:09

The one thing you do already know is that they're a shit employer. That meeting should have taken place during your niece's working hours, not outside of it in her personal time. I don't think you can expect them to play fair or comply with laws at all when they've already shown they won't.

Her options realistically are take the other role and start looking for another job or end up fired. Working somewhere where the boss has it in for you and wants you gone is basically a no-go for anyone, but for someone who already has mental problems it's a disaster. Her sanity isn't worth proving a point.

If she does want to take them to tribunal for disability discrimination and unfair dismissal she can do that regardless of whether she's left the role/company or is still in it. Maybe she has grounds for tribunal and might win, but the stress of it may impact her health and would realistically make her new role untenable too, as she'd just be labelled a troublemaker and got rid of more carefully next time.

ACAS can give you advice on the law but even if the company is in the wrong ACAS aren't going to do anything about it, it's on your niece to fight the employer if she wants to. Her being right doesn't make that easy or guarantee she'll win.

I wonder if that meeting has even been documented anywhere. Since it took place after her hours, they've not followed their own procedures about the reasonable adjustment and she didn't receive the promised email. It could be the start of an unofficial bullying campaign to get her to leave (that role, if not the company). Maybe banking on her being young, not understanding employment law and with her being autistic hoping she just won't want the hassle of standing up to them and will cave in and do what they want.

I know my take on it is negative but I've had enough rubbish jobs to know that laws don't really protect you from anything much. Good luck to her whatever she decides to do.

She has autism… not ‘mental problems’. It’s a neurodivergence not a mental illness.

cestlavielife · 20/11/2026 12:51

Maybe accept part time for now and give her time prove herself in the role.
If she starting out in employment she needs to learn and be willing .
She needs experience and good references to move ahead
Yes you can fight but do you also want long term for her to be seen as an asset not a problem

But is the role even right for her eg the vomit example

TheSpook · 20/11/2026 12:55

Minasama · 20/11/2026 08:37

Obviously they need to abide by the law but I can imagine it is career suicide in a lot of private sector workplaces to require an adjustment.

Bosses want people on their teams who go the extra mile and deliver so that the work gets done, not people who create work and admin for them with their special requirements and then probably take more sick leave due to their condition. I expect that’s what senior management and HR are trying to avoid.

Especialky when young people are two a penny they’re thinking they’ve made a big mistake.

I worked for US companies though and it was brutal.

Edited

I think this is true and part of the NEET unemployment issue.
Having autism or ADHD at school might give you some assistance, different treatment from other children. A young person who is used to that might expect an employer to be the same.
And it's perfectly true there's a legal requirement but in real life they will find a way to either not employ you or to sack you if it comes to light later. Wrong but true.

Alwaysjournalling · 20/11/2026 13:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Gengha · 20/11/2026 13:55

If she’s an emetophobe she can’t work in a job that involves being around sick to this extent. Her so called “reasonable adjustment” means other people will always have to clean up the puke and not her. That’s hardly fair or reasonable. What if everyone has emetophobia? The puke just gets left?

Why doesn’t she get a more suitable job rather than expecting the world to revolve around her in this one?

arethereanyleftatall · 20/11/2026 14:46

TheSpook · 20/11/2026 12:55

I think this is true and part of the NEET unemployment issue.
Having autism or ADHD at school might give you some assistance, different treatment from other children. A young person who is used to that might expect an employer to be the same.
And it's perfectly true there's a legal requirement but in real life they will find a way to either not employ you or to sack you if it comes to light later. Wrong but true.

Spot on. You say it’s wrong, but let’s for argument say this is your own business. You need as much profit as you can to feed your family. Are you going to employ the person who can clean up sick or the one who can’t. It’s all very well to say it’s discrimination but the more rights the person who can’t clean up sick has, the less likely the business owner is to employ them in the first place.

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 14:58

Gengha · 20/11/2026 13:55

If she’s an emetophobe she can’t work in a job that involves being around sick to this extent. Her so called “reasonable adjustment” means other people will always have to clean up the puke and not her. That’s hardly fair or reasonable. What if everyone has emetophobia? The puke just gets left?

Why doesn’t she get a more suitable job rather than expecting the world to revolve around her in this one?

To repeat, if cleaning up vomit is a small part of the job it is not unreasonable to expect the employer to make adjustments so that she can do the job. It would be different if it was a major part of the job or if there is no-one else available who could clean up. Arguments that it isn't fair on other staff will not fly with the courts.

Passaggressfedup · 20/11/2026 16:36

The adjustment was very reasonable and arranged and set out as per policy in the proper documented form for her company
Did she declared her disability before taking on the job? Did she have an Occ Health meeting or form to complete, if so, did she stipulated her needs then?

Did the instance of her using the agreed adjustment and things not working led to an incident?

Tessasanderson · 20/11/2026 16:49

Why do we always jump on the employer first?

If they were such a poor employer then they really could have made life so much easier for themselves if they really wanted to get the OP's niece off the payroll.

They have tried a reasonable adjustment - In their eyes it hasnt worked
They have offered a role change and reduced hours - This has resulted in OP going down every route of ism's available.

At the end of the day, we need to encourage people with phobias etc to work but not at all costs. At some point an employer should be able to act in their own best interests.

allthemind · 20/11/2026 16:59

I dont know why people self-sabotage like this. Either you can do a job well without causing the employer issues or you do a different job. Otherwise the business will replace you with one of the 1000s of other people who don't need adjustments. You're not allowed to say it anymore of course but that is how it has always worked in the workplace and still does, despite disability legislation etc. Anyone that thinks otherwise is deluding themselves. We've done this generation no favours by pretending otherwise. Being in a wheelchair is one thing, high functioning autism, ADHD and anxiety etc is a different issue which is open to abuse and difficult for companies to prove either way, so they will just replace. Harsh but really we should be helping these kids be able to complete their assignments that are part of the job without adjustments, or helping them to find roles they are better suited to. Nobody with a physical disability would take a job being a window cleaner or a steepljack, same way I wouldn't try and be a nurse or a teacher as I have OCD and little patience.

Octavia64 · 20/11/2026 17:20

Speaking as a disabled person who has had reasonable adjustments.

what the law says and what people think is fair are often two entirely different things.

i had reasonable adjustments at my workplace. I was working there prior to my accident and continued to work there using my wheelchair.

i however fully knew as others have said that there was no way I could change job as no employer will take on a disabled person if they have the option of a non disabled one. (I did try at one point to move schools but wasn’t successful…)

the situation if an employer has already taken someone on is obviously different.

my employer broke the law on a regular basis and I let it go/dealt with it internally because I wanted to keep working.

StillSpartacus · 20/11/2026 17:33

Tessasanderson · 20/11/2026 16:49

Why do we always jump on the employer first?

If they were such a poor employer then they really could have made life so much easier for themselves if they really wanted to get the OP's niece off the payroll.

They have tried a reasonable adjustment - In their eyes it hasnt worked
They have offered a role change and reduced hours - This has resulted in OP going down every route of ism's available.

At the end of the day, we need to encourage people with phobias etc to work but not at all costs. At some point an employer should be able to act in their own best interests.

I think this is the issue. It doesn’t sound great on behalf of the employer, but we don’t fully know what the reasonable adjustment was. Only that the employer agreed to something.

It is possible that the employee didn’t follow what the employer had expected in terms of the RA. Using the emetiphobia analogy in a nursery situation, the employer might have agreed that another member of staff would clean up when the employee phoned, but might not have agreed for example, that the employee could run out and leave children unsupervised. It is my understanding that employers can revisit RA if circumstances have changed, or if the employee still can’t do the job even with the agreed RA in place. Is it possible that that is the issue?

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 23:28

Tessasanderson · 20/11/2026 16:49

Why do we always jump on the employer first?

If they were such a poor employer then they really could have made life so much easier for themselves if they really wanted to get the OP's niece off the payroll.

They have tried a reasonable adjustment - In their eyes it hasnt worked
They have offered a role change and reduced hours - This has resulted in OP going down every route of ism's available.

At the end of the day, we need to encourage people with phobias etc to work but not at all costs. At some point an employer should be able to act in their own best interests.

If they think the adjustment isn't working they can hold a supportive review with the employee and explore alternative adjustments. They can, if necessary, get specialist advice. However, they cannot penalise the employee by, for example trying to move them from a full time role into a different part time role. That is unlawful disability discrimination. Far too many people on this thread seem to want to justify this.

MalateOxaloacetate · 20/11/2026 23:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You call me a pedantic prick when you just inferred that autism meant someone had ‘mental problems’. That is not acceptable wording to use around autism.

Mossyfox · 20/11/2026 23:35

I don't like dogs. So I wouldn't work in a role that required me to deal with dogs. It wouldn't make sense. I think you need to explain about reasonable adjustments. Does that mean she is unable to perform quite a substantial part of her role. In which case that role just wouldn't be feasible for her.

Batmanisaplaceinturkey · 20/11/2026 23:35

prh47bridge · 20/11/2026 23:28

If they think the adjustment isn't working they can hold a supportive review with the employee and explore alternative adjustments. They can, if necessary, get specialist advice. However, they cannot penalise the employee by, for example trying to move them from a full time role into a different part time role. That is unlawful disability discrimination. Far too many people on this thread seem to want to justify this.

You don't even know what the adjustment was so how can you be so sure it was reasonable in the first place? Redeployment if someone can't do a role can also be a responsible adjustment.

prh47bridge · Yesterday 00:27

Batmanisaplaceinturkey · 20/11/2026 23:35

You don't even know what the adjustment was so how can you be so sure it was reasonable in the first place? Redeployment if someone can't do a role can also be a responsible adjustment.

OP says this was an adjustment related to her niece's autism. Since it was agreed by both the employer and the employee, it is a reasonable adjustment. The employer cannot now decide that it was never reasonable. The time to do that was before agreeing it with the employee. If OP's niece takes this to tribunal, the employer would have to show that something has changed and, as a result, the adjustment is no longer reasonable. Even if they could justify that, they cannot resolve the situation in a way that penalises OP's niece, so their suggestion of a part time role is not acceptable.

And to say yet again, there is nothing in OP's posts to indicate her niece cannot do the role. It sounds like there is a small part of the role she cannot do. That is exactly the kind of situation where the employer is required to consider making reasonable adjustments to allow the employee to carry out the role. To redeploy her, they would have to show that no reasonable adjustments were possible. However, as they have already agreed adjustments with OP's niece, they have to show what has changed that means the agreed adjustment is no longer reasonable.