Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

143 replies

HangrySloth · Today 18:49

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

I’m pregnant with my first baby and I need a sanity check because I think my sister is being ridiculous.

I have a best friend I’ve had since we were 8. We are now in our 30s. Everyone knows how close we are. We’re long distance now but we have a scheduled FaceTime every Saturday morning without fail, we text almost every day, we’ve been through literally everything together.

She is family to me. She is the one friend who has stayed solid through everything. My sister knows this, she’s heard me say it a hundred times.

I gave her the title auntie. I told her she’s going to be auntie to this baby. My sister is aware of this, this wasn’t a surprise announcement.

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be.

My sister is upset about it. She’s upset that my best friend is going to be referred to as aunt and upset that she posted about being excited.

AIBU to think this is mental?

I can see it if I was calling every friend auntie, or some random cousin I see once a year or less that I barely have any connection with. I’d get it then. But it’s literally her.

Beside my husband and now my child, she is the closest person to me, alongside my sister and my parents. That’s it. That’s the list. She’s just as important to me as my relationship with my sister is.

At this point it’s almost a given she would be an aunt. It would be genuinely weird at this stage for her to be referred to as what any other standard coworker or friend would be called like “my friend Sarah” after 25 years of being my person. She’s not a coworker. She’s not a casual friend. Shes not a cousin. She’s auntie.

My sister needs to get over it. She doesn’t have a monopoly on my other relationships and she doesn’t get to decide who is family to my baby. I chose this. My baby is lucky to have someone who already loves it that much.

She’s been my best friend for practically as long as my sister has been my sister so what’s the difference really? That I share parents with my sister.

OP posts:
FearMaria · Today 20:11

Kilofoxtrot99 · Today 20:09

In my culture auntie is an honorific ame given to all females older than my children, same as uncle for all male friends as well as family. It’s a courtesy that my children call older adults auntie or uncle. Doesn’t take anything away from my siblings at all.

I think everyone is aware of how common it is to call adults auntie and uncle when they are close but it’s not the same as saying an unrelated child is your niece or nephew.

Bramblezz · Today 20:12

Yabu I’d be put out if I was your sister!

harriethoyle · Today 20:12

Honestly? You all sound utterly batshit and massively immature…

Millytante · Today 20:13

IPM · Today 19:09

'Auntie' is also a title given to all parent's female friends in Ireland and other countries.

It's not a massive deal but your friend is a bit strange to announce on social media that it means she'll have a niece.

Auntie is just an honorary title.

Having said that it's none of your sister's business and I think you're all being a bit PFB here.

Edited

I think that may have come about so that children didn’t address close adult friends of the family by their first names. (I can just picture my ‘Auntie’ Betty’s face had I ever called her Betty!)

EverythingElseIsTaken · Today 20:15

When I was growing up it was rude to call an adult by their forename so adults were Mr / Mrs / Miss surname but family friends were auntie / uncle forename.
my children and my friends children follow the same pattern. One of my friends daughters is now a mother and she is already referring to me as auntie to her baby. It’s a sign of respect and genuine affection.

weirdoboelady · Today 20:16

I've read all the OP posts, but only the first 2 pages of replies. (I got bored!)

  1. All our close family friends were aunties and uncles (in England)
  2. I totally agree with the PP who said that there can never be too much love in the world.
  3. I suppose there's no chance of best friend being a godmother? Even a secular one? That's a closer relationship than aunt, in my book.
canklesmctacotits · Today 20:17

Where I'm from, everyone the same age as your mum and older is an auntie unless she's your grandma! But it's VERY odd to have your friend refer to your unborn baby as her niece. It's actually a bit creepy, like she's stealing into your family. I wouldn't like that if I were your sister, mum or dad!

CheeseWisely · Today 20:17

FearMaria · Today 19:08

I think a child calling someone Auntie whatever is fine but the baby won’t be your friend’s niece in my opinion. If someone said to me ‘I went to my niece’s birthday party on Saturday’ and then it was revealed the niece wasn’t a niece at all but someone she called Auntie I’d think that was strange.

I agree with this really. DS calls my best friend ‘auntie X’ but she doesn’t refer to him as her nephew.

To those saying Auntie is only for actual sisters of parents, there are cultures where all older females are referred to as Auntie as a notifier of respect. ETA I now realise that had already been pointed out, apologies for repeating.

Bellyblueboy · Today 20:18

It’s all a bit silly - it’s just a word.

But this will be confusing to your daughter. Your friend isn’t her auntie and she isn’t her niece. Their relationship will be determined by how close they are, how much time they spend together and how they feel about each other. Not a a word that pretends this close friend is your sister when she isn’t.

i am very close to my tween neice. I see her two or three times a week and we head off on holidays together regularly, just the two of us. She just calls me by a shortened version of my first name. She knows she is my neice because her mum is my sister.

RockItLikeRocketFuel · Today 20:18

This OP has a LOT of family/friend controversy in their life. This isn't even the first one this week...

Hoardasurass · Today 20:19

supersonicginandtonic · Today 19:40

Im from a huge Irish family and have loads of aunties and uncles. The better ones have been the ones who aren’t blood related.

Can I ask those of you who are saying an auntie has to be blood related, what about parents step-siblings, adopted siblings, foster siblings etc?

Auntie is for your parents siblings and the wives/long-term partners of siblings including half siblings and adopted but not step siblings or foster siblings.
Its not a judgement on those who we taught otherwise its just how we were raised.

Metalmotha · Today 20:19

I get calling friends auntie so snd so but they’re not an aunt. What I find most peculiar is your friend referring to you child as her niece - that she will certainly never be. It was generally used when children didn’t call adults by their first names do it was a way to stop having to refer to your closest friends as Mrs Smith and Mr jones they became Auntie Jane and Uncle John but everyone knew they weren’t an actual uncle or aunt.

BlueRedCat · Today 20:20

Boreded · Today 19:09

Your friend isn’t auntie, unless you are from a culture who calls their elders auntie.

Your sister is auntie, because a child’s auntie is their parents sibling. I can see why your sister would be upset, becoming an auntie probably meant a lot to her and now it has been diluted by someone who does not have the relationship.

Your friend could have been given a different title or role, god parent if Christian for example.

I'm sorry but there are no rules on ‘culture’. Anyone can use that term for anyone they like if they so choose.

lots of people give their close friend’s ‘auntie’, certainly at the start. I would suggest it does tend to stop for most people after a while for friends but I am sure many do carry it on. I certainly used for my best girl friends when I had my children but they don’t use it now they are older.

OP it isn’t weird at all. Even though it is the same title, the difference between a blood aunt and an honorary aunt is clear. I agree In times gone by many of these aunties would have been god mother so they had a recognised position in the child’s life but I expect it is relatively rare now.

Yogabearmous · Today 20:21

My best friend of over 40 years is called uncle by my kids and dh’s best mate is also uncle D. Its great as they love our children dearly. Ironically their “real” uncle is a nasty piece of work who i would never allow around my kids as he is frankly toxic.

PollyBell · Today 20:21

She is not an auntie and it is not her niece, yes I know auntie can be used when not correct but this all seems weird

CheeseWisely · Today 20:22

To add, I’m very excited to be becoming an (actual) Auntie for the first time early next year, despite being called Auntie by various friends’ kids for years. I’m a grown up and can differentiate the two relationships despite them having the same name, as can most.

NewMonsteraLeaf · Today 20:23

yogzig · Today 19:09

I always find it weird when people have their children call people auntie who are not their auntie. What is the point?

It’s a sign of love. It’s fine. Crack on op. Ignore those who don’t understand. But don’t argue with your sister. She just needs some reassurance.

Mami2Cymraeg · Today 20:23

You can't have too many aunties!! I have loads as do my children. It did confuse my husband, he would ask if they were relatives or not

Bellyblueboy · Today 20:24

Yogabearmous · Today 20:21

My best friend of over 40 years is called uncle by my kids and dh’s best mate is also uncle D. Its great as they love our children dearly. Ironically their “real” uncle is a nasty piece of work who i would never allow around my kids as he is frankly toxic.

Do these men refer to your children as their neices and nephews?

I had a friend at schools who’s mum’s many boyfriends were ‘Uncles’. Ever since it has given me the creeps when unrelated men refer to themselves as uncle so and so.

Sassylovesbooks · Today 20:24

I can't say that I have ever referred to my best friend as 'Auntie' to my son, simply because she isn't. You obviously see the word 'Auntie' as a term to be given to close females, regardless if they're family or not. Your sister thinks the term should be used for Aunts that are actually biologically related (on both sides). You will have to agree to disagree with your sister.

The baby is yours, so therefore it's your choice what your best friend will be referred to by your child. If you want your friend to be 'Auntie Laura' rather than Laura, then that's your decision. Your sister doesn't get to make that choice for you.

Tell your sister that the term Auntie, is special to you, and is given to those people in your life and that of your child's who you are closest to and love most.

ClaredeBear · Today 20:24

I grew up calling only related adults “aunt” or “uncle”. However, lots of my friends called any female just a few years older than them “auntie”, so I know it’s pretty normal. What’s not normal is your friend announcing she has a niece. That’s a bit odd and I can see why your sister might be honest with you about that.

Maybeitllneverhappen · Today 20:24

Tell her not to move to Cameroon. My friend is from a small town there and all the adults are auntie and Uncle to all the children!

chickbean · Today 20:24

WhatHasATOnTheEndofIt · Today 18:57

If it is any help my DC only say auntie/uncle for non related adults in their lives. Their actual aunt and uncles (who are all very present) they call by their first name.

My family do this too. Next -door neighbours were "auntie" and "uncle", but not actual aunties and uncles. My great-aunt and great-uncle were best friends with a distant cousin - they were known as Kitty and George, he was "Uncle Frank". Bonkers!

Yogabearmous · Today 20:27

Bellyblueboy · Today 20:24

Do these men refer to your children as their neices and nephews?

I had a friend at schools who’s mum’s many boyfriends were ‘Uncles’. Ever since it has given me the creeps when unrelated men refer to themselves as uncle so and so.

Edited

They call my kids by their names and i havent heard either of them say they are their neices. I dont know if they refer to them as their nieces to other people, but i honestly wouldnt mind if they did. Both of them have done so much for our family and our girls adore them both.

Savvysix1984 · Today 20:30

It makes my teeth itch when people call people auntie and uncle when they’re not especially when they actually have real aunts and uncles. Why can’t they just be called by their first name?