Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

143 replies

HangrySloth · Today 18:49

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

I’m pregnant with my first baby and I need a sanity check because I think my sister is being ridiculous.

I have a best friend I’ve had since we were 8. We are now in our 30s. Everyone knows how close we are. We’re long distance now but we have a scheduled FaceTime every Saturday morning without fail, we text almost every day, we’ve been through literally everything together.

She is family to me. She is the one friend who has stayed solid through everything. My sister knows this, she’s heard me say it a hundred times.

I gave her the title auntie. I told her she’s going to be auntie to this baby. My sister is aware of this, this wasn’t a surprise announcement.

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be.

My sister is upset about it. She’s upset that my best friend is going to be referred to as aunt and upset that she posted about being excited.

AIBU to think this is mental?

I can see it if I was calling every friend auntie, or some random cousin I see once a year or less that I barely have any connection with. I’d get it then. But it’s literally her.

Beside my husband and now my child, she is the closest person to me, alongside my sister and my parents. That’s it. That’s the list. She’s just as important to me as my relationship with my sister is.

At this point it’s almost a given she would be an aunt. It would be genuinely weird at this stage for her to be referred to as what any other standard coworker or friend would be called like “my friend Sarah” after 25 years of being my person. She’s not a coworker. She’s not a casual friend. Shes not a cousin. She’s auntie.

My sister needs to get over it. She doesn’t have a monopoly on my other relationships and she doesn’t get to decide who is family to my baby. I chose this. My baby is lucky to have someone who already loves it that much.

She’s been my best friend for practically as long as my sister has been my sister so what’s the difference really? That I share parents with my sister.

OP posts:
AgentPidge · Today 19:43

Credittocress · Today 19:05

She can be called Auntie. When I was wee it’s what we called most close adult family friends, but the baby won’t actually be her niece- that bit is weird

Exactly. All my parents' female friends were called Auntie (plus their name).

Claireabella111 · Today 19:44

Meh - get your baby christened and then your best friend can have a godparent/goddaughter role and let your sis stew on that….while giving your friend an “official” role.

seriously though the more people who love a child the better and it’s not your sister’s business

EdgyLemonPoet · Today 19:44

My children have aunties who aren't actually aunties so that I think is fairly normal. However, I never asked them to be aunties or declared them as aunties, it just naturally unfolded i.e. 'were off to Auntie Jessie's today' x

Italiangreyhound · Today 19:47

Your sister is a nut case.

Your baby, you can get friends to call whoever whatever.

Mamma86688 · Today 19:48

PressedThistle · Today 19:02

You're being a bit ridiculous naming aunties to a baby that isn't even here yet but generally I am with your sister - only "blood aunties" get the title.

Asian cultures use auntie and uncle to refer to any adult for a child and any older adult for a younger adult. All elderly people are literally aunties and uncles to the younger generation.

It doesn’t have to be so black and white. Auntie and Uncle can be terms of endearment or respect to an older generation.

SandwichesAndGingerBeer · Today 19:49

I voted YABU because you’re inflaming the drama.

It’s fine to call your friend Auntie. She’s being OTT for making a Facebook announcement but whatever.

But it shouldn’t be that hard to understand why your sister might have different feelings. You can treat her with a bit of sensitivity and understanding without having to backtrack on your decision.

A bit less being outraged that she sees things differently might help deescalate the situation.

Poppingby · Today 19:49

Your sister is upset because she feels like you've replaced her with your friend, presumably. You can get narky about it or you can talk to her and say you love her and didn't mean to hurt her feelings without telling your friend she can't be 'auntie'. Is it the first grandchild in the family as well? She probably feels like her place in the family has been usurped if so.

Just depends how much drama as to whether you fall out with her or give her a hug really.

Acertwirl · Today 19:49

I’ll start by saying my kids call my best friends Auntie and their kids call me Auntie. I would never refer to them as my nieces and nephews, that would seem odd.

That said, a formal conversation never took place between my friends and I where I asked them to be an Auntie (or vice versa). It isn’t a title that is given out like Godparents. There was never a social media announcement. In the context you are using Auntie to signify a close relationship to the child, but she isn’t actually the Auntie to your child (as you well know).

My sister couldn’t care less that my kids call my friends Auntie (although, she may not be aware because no one flogs it on social media like they’ve been asked to be a bridesmaid). Maybe she’d find it a bit weird if they did!

ShadySide1 · Today 19:50

EdgyLemonPoet · Today 19:44

My children have aunties who aren't actually aunties so that I think is fairly normal. However, I never asked them to be aunties or declared them as aunties, it just naturally unfolded i.e. 'were off to Auntie Jessie's today' x

Exactly this. My best friends kids have all referred to me as Auntie. But my friend never made such a huge emotional drama about it when she was pregnant and officially declaring me an Auntie. It just happened naturally.
I would also never call them my nieces and nephews.

Worldinyourhands · Today 19:50

She's an honourary auntie not a real auntie. And the baby isn't her niece. She's being weird and attention seeking and your sister is understandably irritated by it.

In a few years when you have people to focus on besides yourselves (eg your kids, her kids, your sister's kids) and the intense friendship and phone calls etc have fallen by the wayside in favour of the Saturday morning football club and classmates' birthday parties, all this will seem very pointless and silly.

OriginalSkang · Today 19:50

Its absolutely fine and very common for children to call their parent's friends auntie. Its up to you who she calls that

Cherrysoup · Today 19:50

Aunty is the polite address for female friends acquaintances in some cultures. My parents’ female friends were ‘aunty’. I met a former neighbour at mum’s funeral recently and she was immediately ‘Aunty Sandy’ as she always has been.

LoudWriter · Today 19:51

I don't think it should be a problem calling your friend Auntie. I honestly think the issue is probably more about making it a big deal and your friend posting about it. That feels like it might have unintentionally felt like a bit of a fuck you to your sister who is the actual aunt. If you didn't make a big deal about her being an auntie, but are celebrating this friend it might almost feel as though you're replacing your sister or you see your friend as being more valuable to your future child(rens) life/lives.

OriginalSkang · Today 19:52

All this talk of 'some cultures'.. people do it in the UK too and everyone here knows it. Just because it isnt their taste that doesnt mean it doesnt happen

DreamyAmberKoala · Today 19:53

This something families either do or the don't, I know of families that friends are called aunt ect but it was not something my family ever did and not something my kids, nieces or nephews do so to an extent it depends what your family culture is.

Though the way you are talking you are elevating your relationship with you friend to that with your sister, and I can see why that may hurt your sister. You have said nothing to suggest your relationship with your sister is poor so the relationship should be different to that of a friend (thing is with sisters / brothers you aren't always daily close or even have a lot in common but they are still there for you when it counts and there to support that isn't a relationship with a friend).

CheeryOP · Today 19:53

Common for a good friend to be called 'auntie'. Usually not an announcement that she'll be called 'auntie', just call her it. Unusual for the friend to refer to the child a 'neice'. Weird for your DS to get hung up about it though.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 19:53

Username19893847477374 · Today 19:04

You can't just decide someone is an aunt. Aunt means sister of the mum or dad. I am close to my cousin's and my kids call them auntie whoever, but we all know they aren't actually their aunt. So I think you are being a bit mad. She's literally not an aunt.

Of course you can. I used to call my parents' friends auntie and uncle as a kid. It was quite normal then.

Artisticscience · Today 19:53

My best friend is 'Auntie' to my children (who are now in their 20's). Admittedly I don't have a sister, but she has been more involved and present in their lives that any of their blood aunties or uncles.

They still call her auntie and she would be the person they would go to if they needed help and their dad and I were unavailable.

Rachelshair · Today 19:53

It's all a bit childish? Like you want to emphasise that your sister is nothing to you compared to this friend and then she's put it all over social media, of course that would be hurtful to the "real aunt".
Why is your friend saying the baby will be her niece, that's really weird, it won't be! You can still call her Auntie Whatever, that is quite normal for a family friend.

FruAashild · Today 20:01

#TeamSister

I suspect this is the latest of a long line of comments from your friend diminishing your sister and it's the last straw for your sister. Your friend is your friend not your sister and you shouldn't be saying 'she's like a sister to me', that's the kind of thing only someone without sisters says. Unless she is going to help you care for your parents in their dotage she is not a sister. The relationship is different and you need to acknowledge the difference and value your sister more than you do. Frankly the way you take her for granted is not something you could get away with doing to a friend.

This is separate from the fact that in some cultures children call female family friends aunty. But the question I have is, did you call your Mum's best friend Aunty? Because if you didn't why are you introducing it? If you did then it's your friend's FB post that is the issue and your sister is telling you that your friend is overstepping her boundaries and you should stick up for your sister with your friend and point out that while you might be calling her 'aunty' as a courtesy title your child is not and never will be her niece or nephew.

TVHedgehog · Today 20:07

Whilst I know of children who will refer to parents friends as auntie, or cousins of parents as auntie, I’ve never heard of the “auntie” refer to the child as their niece, it would be their name or friends daughter, my cousins daughter. And I do find it odd that your friend has referred to the baby as her niece, I don’t like that. Saying auntie I this context seems like it’s respectful to the adult but saying it’s your niece just seems weird.

im also referred to as auntie by some friends children, id never think to refer to them as my nieces or nephews

Kilofoxtrot99 · Today 20:09

In my culture auntie is an honorific ame given to all females older than my children, same as uncle for all male friends as well as family. It’s a courtesy that my children call older adults auntie or uncle. Doesn’t take anything away from my siblings at all.

kiwiane · Today 20:10

Your child will probably not call anyone aunt or uncle in practice so it’s a bit over the top to designate your friend special status. Your child and friend may or may not be close, it would be nice for all adults to have good relationships in order to support your child. I’d apologise to your sister and say whilst your friend may be called auntie, your daughter will never be her niece.

Arlanymor · Today 20:11

OriginalSkang · Today 19:52

All this talk of 'some cultures'.. people do it in the UK too and everyone here knows it. Just because it isnt their taste that doesnt mean it doesnt happen

According to this thread not everyone does know it! Hence why mentioning other cultures is useful to really underline the point that it's very usual.

Meand2Ls · Today 20:11

She’d probably have a heart failure that my sister and my best friend are my daughter two middle names