Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

143 replies

HangrySloth · Today 18:49

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

I’m pregnant with my first baby and I need a sanity check because I think my sister is being ridiculous.

I have a best friend I’ve had since we were 8. We are now in our 30s. Everyone knows how close we are. We’re long distance now but we have a scheduled FaceTime every Saturday morning without fail, we text almost every day, we’ve been through literally everything together.

She is family to me. She is the one friend who has stayed solid through everything. My sister knows this, she’s heard me say it a hundred times.

I gave her the title auntie. I told her she’s going to be auntie to this baby. My sister is aware of this, this wasn’t a surprise announcement.

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be.

My sister is upset about it. She’s upset that my best friend is going to be referred to as aunt and upset that she posted about being excited.

AIBU to think this is mental?

I can see it if I was calling every friend auntie, or some random cousin I see once a year or less that I barely have any connection with. I’d get it then. But it’s literally her.

Beside my husband and now my child, she is the closest person to me, alongside my sister and my parents. That’s it. That’s the list. She’s just as important to me as my relationship with my sister is.

At this point it’s almost a given she would be an aunt. It would be genuinely weird at this stage for her to be referred to as what any other standard coworker or friend would be called like “my friend Sarah” after 25 years of being my person. She’s not a coworker. She’s not a casual friend. Shes not a cousin. She’s auntie.

My sister needs to get over it. She doesn’t have a monopoly on my other relationships and she doesn’t get to decide who is family to my baby. I chose this. My baby is lucky to have someone who already loves it that much.

She’s been my best friend for practically as long as my sister has been my sister so what’s the difference really? That I share parents with my sister.

OP posts:
IPM · Today 19:26

How are you going to cope when all the drama dies down OP and the novelty of the new baby has worn off for them?

Name your friend Godmother and have her refer to your baby as her daughter? 😁

Hatty65 · Today 19:27

I assume those who are saying 'but she's not an auntie' are young.

I'm born in the 1960s and every friend of my parents was Auntie Kath, Auntie Betty, Auntie Jean. It was too formal to call them Mrs Walsh - and the idea of referring to any adult by just their Christian name would have been seen as cheeky.

My own DC have called my siblings simply by their first names - never bothered with 'auntie' or 'uncle' and I suspect that's because I just called my brother 'Richard' for eg when he came round and they followed suit.

It's not worth anyone getting their knickers in a twist over. You can absolutely decide what your own children are going to call anyone in your circle - provided that the adult in question doesn't object, of course. It's not for your sister or anyone else to object.

She can be 'hurt' but she sounds a bit precious and it's not your problem. Your bf sounds as close to you as a sister, and it's entirely your choice.

Nofeckingway · Today 19:28

No need for either of you to make such a fuss . I can only assume that your sister is quite young . There is no fear of anyone ( like who for instance ) mistaking the " blood " link because you know what ? Nobody cares .

EatingHealthy · Today 19:29

Baby calling your friend Auntie fine.
Friend calling your baby her niece is weird and a bit creepy. I imagine it's that your sister is reacting to.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · Today 19:29

I think the ‘my niece’ bit probably stung more than auntie, but lucky you having two women who will adore your baby. Be kind to your sister.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · Today 19:29

EatingHealthy · Today 19:29

Baby calling your friend Auntie fine.
Friend calling your baby her niece is weird and a bit creepy. I imagine it's that your sister is reacting to.

Snap

HeddaGarbled · Today 19:30

why does my sister care so much

I suggest you have a little think about that and then find the words to reassure her rather than saying she “needs to get over herself”.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Today 19:31

I feel sympathy with your sister tbh.
Yes it's common for children to call their parent's best friends Aunt and Uncle - it's a respectful and friendly thing to do.
But to make your friend an official aunt and her to call your baby her niece before the child is even born is extremely strange behaviour. And yes, it really does come over as a deliberate slap in the face to your sister for you and your pal to behave like this. As though you want to emphasise to your sister your bond with with your friend is more important than your relationship with your sister.
I think you and your friend don't come out of this very well

Hoardasurass · Today 19:31

HangrySloth · Today 19:10

Well if I cater to my sisters feelings than my best friend will be hurt I’m treating her as any other friend and saying she is less important than my sister. My sister is insulting ny best friend saying she is more like a friend than a sister and my best friend may be thinking I’ve been consistent just as much as you have in your sisters life and who are you to say I’m the same as some random friend

Blood dose.
Tbh I don't see a problem with her being an honorary auntie and had she posted about being an honorary auntie that would be fine but to claim a blood relationship with with a child that is unrelated to her was ott and weird especially when she won't really be part of your child's day to day life

Nonnimuss · Today 19:31

Credittocress · Today 19:05

She can be called Auntie. When I was wee it’s what we called most close adult family friends, but the baby won’t actually be her niece- that bit is weird

This! When I was little, any non related adults in our lives were ‘auntie’ or ‘uncle’. But we knew the difference between them and our actual aunts and uncles. My kids had similar(but not with as many people, just a couple of really close friends). It’s an honorary title of respect.
Your friend posting about her ‘niece’ is strange, and I can understand why your sister is confused about that part.

JJWT · Today 19:32

PressedThistle · Today 19:02

You're being a bit ridiculous naming aunties to a baby that isn't even here yet but generally I am with your sister - only "blood aunties" get the title.

Incorrect! Uncle's wives also do.

Op, fwiw in the 70s it was completely normal for your mum's friends to be Aunty this and Aunty that... its a kinda half way house between Mrs X (too forml) and First name (too informal). We didn't call adults by their first name in the 70s!

watchingthishtread · Today 19:33

You're all acting daft. She's not an auntie so you are unreasonable for calling her one in anything other than a privately affectionate way. Now she is being unreasonable for announcing it on social media. Your sister is being unreasonable for doing anything other than rolling her eyes at the whole thing.

Nameynamechange21 · Today 19:33

Well it’s not so different to me to aunts and uncles by marriage etc. Lots of people refer to family friends as auntie or uncle.

So I think your sister is being a bit weird as are the proper who are all ‘blood only’.

But it does also make me think about how friends are so devalued in society. Like her being your closest friend isn’t enough somehow, not a special enough title. Feels like we should value friendship more.

localnotail · Today 19:35

Your sister is an auntie, your friend is not. Ridiculous.

HardShoulders · Today 19:36

HangrySloth · Today 19:10

Well if I cater to my sisters feelings than my best friend will be hurt I’m treating her as any other friend and saying she is less important than my sister. My sister is insulting ny best friend saying she is more like a friend than a sister and my best friend may be thinking I’ve been consistent just as much as you have in your sisters life and who are you to say I’m the same as some random friend

Way too much drama from both of you! This sounds like small children in the sandpit saying ‘You’re my best friend and I am going to give you a special daisy chain!’

ammf05 · Today 19:37

When I was little, which admittedly was a long time ago, I had two ways of referring to older non family adults. M&D’s good friends Aunty & Uncle, acquaintances of my parents or grandparents Mr & Mrs so & so.
I had one real Aunty & Uncle, my Dads sister & husband & loads of Aunties that were my Mums cousins. My real Aunty was the coolest person ever, well-travelled & always had real glass bottles of Coke in the fridge a fantastic thing to small me. I knew that Aunty A wasn’t my real Aunty it was more of an honorary name I understood to difference. I know it’s different now but I think it’s lovely that your friend will be your child’s Aunty.

Toddlergirly · Today 19:38

I have an ‘auntie’ who is my mum’s best friend. She doesn’t call me niece though! It’s fine for your friend to call herself Auntie friend’s name. It’s overstepping for her to call your dd her niece when that isn’t true. I can understand why your sister is a bit upset

thestudio · Today 19:39

I think there's a weird class thing (all class things are weird obvs) about 'aunty' for a non-relative.

MC English people used not to use it for anyone other than family, and even then it would be 'Aunt TheStudio'. Then that began to seem too formal so they just called aunts by their first name.

So now it really only exists as a non-MC denominator of close family friends anyway - so if you're MC I don't know what your sister is on about. She wouldn't be 'Aunty DSis', she'd just be 'DSis'.

Maybe she's not only a bit nuts but a snob in denial?

Although looking back at your OP I can see your friend called herself an 'aunt', which I do think is a bit weird. She can be closer to you than your sister, but that still wouldn't make her AN aunt, even if she's called 'Aunty BestFriend'.

So maybe everyone around you is slightly odd. Maybe you are too haha, because the closeness that longterm best friends have is very recognised in culture these days, she doesn't really need to be upgraded to a biological relationship for people to get her importance to you.

My BF of 40 years is godmother to both my kids! I'm not religious but it's a way of me showing her - and her being able to claim if and when she wants to - an exceptionally close relationship with both me and my family (and a huge debt of gratitude).

supersonicginandtonic · Today 19:40

Im from a huge Irish family and have loads of aunties and uncles. The better ones have been the ones who aren’t blood related.

Can I ask those of you who are saying an auntie has to be blood related, what about parents step-siblings, adopted siblings, foster siblings etc?

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · Today 19:40

' Aunty / Auntie ' is often a title / name given to adult friends of the family
/ In one local preschool to me all the childcare staff are known as and called ' Aunty '
/ When one of my dd's worked on a cruise ship and it was in the Carribean several of the parents esp the Mothers referred to the childcare staff as Auntie and the children of these parents did the same
/ My same dd has a small child in the school nursery where she works full time and one Mother and the child refer to her and call her ' Aunty ' - with that family it's a cultural respect.

If you have your child christened / baptised I guess your best friend will be the Godmother.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 19:40

thestudio · Today 19:39

I think there's a weird class thing (all class things are weird obvs) about 'aunty' for a non-relative.

MC English people used not to use it for anyone other than family, and even then it would be 'Aunt TheStudio'. Then that began to seem too formal so they just called aunts by their first name.

So now it really only exists as a non-MC denominator of close family friends anyway - so if you're MC I don't know what your sister is on about. She wouldn't be 'Aunty DSis', she'd just be 'DSis'.

Maybe she's not only a bit nuts but a snob in denial?

Although looking back at your OP I can see your friend called herself an 'aunt', which I do think is a bit weird. She can be closer to you than your sister, but that still wouldn't make her AN aunt, even if she's called 'Aunty BestFriend'.

So maybe everyone around you is slightly odd. Maybe you are too haha, because the closeness that longterm best friends have is very recognised in culture these days, she doesn't really need to be upgraded to a biological relationship for people to get her importance to you.

My BF of 40 years is godmother to both my kids! I'm not religious but it's a way of me showing her - and her being able to claim if and when she wants to - an exceptionally close relationship with both me and my family (and a huge debt of gratitude).

What is MC English?

PS5Gamer · Today 19:41

Normal to me. When I was a child, I called my parent’s best friends Auntie/Uncle.

carchi · Today 19:41

HeddaGarbled · Today 19:08

You can, of course, call people whatever you like, but would it kill you to be a little kinder about your sister’s feelings?

Would it kill her sister to be a little kinder about OPs feelings.

Glowingup · Today 19:42

People can call people what they like and it’s not anyone else’s business if the OP and her best friend see themselves as sisters. My uncle was only my uncle by marriage and we weren’t blood related but he was 100% my uncle and i preferred him to my blood relative uncles. My friend’s dad is his ex stepdad that was never even married to his mum but to him, it’s his dad and he’s always been there for him. Blood is so unimportant.

ShadySide1 · Today 19:43

You all sound really really immature.
And your friendship sounds very intense and a bit weird. She doesn't have "a fierce love" for an unborn child just because she put a status on Facebook for likes.