Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

148 replies

HangrySloth · Today 18:49

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

I’m pregnant with my first baby and I need a sanity check because I think my sister is being ridiculous.

I have a best friend I’ve had since we were 8. We are now in our 30s. Everyone knows how close we are. We’re long distance now but we have a scheduled FaceTime every Saturday morning without fail, we text almost every day, we’ve been through literally everything together.

She is family to me. She is the one friend who has stayed solid through everything. My sister knows this, she’s heard me say it a hundred times.

I gave her the title auntie. I told her she’s going to be auntie to this baby. My sister is aware of this, this wasn’t a surprise announcement.

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be.

My sister is upset about it. She’s upset that my best friend is going to be referred to as aunt and upset that she posted about being excited.

AIBU to think this is mental?

I can see it if I was calling every friend auntie, or some random cousin I see once a year or less that I barely have any connection with. I’d get it then. But it’s literally her.

Beside my husband and now my child, she is the closest person to me, alongside my sister and my parents. That’s it. That’s the list. She’s just as important to me as my relationship with my sister is.

At this point it’s almost a given she would be an aunt. It would be genuinely weird at this stage for her to be referred to as what any other standard coworker or friend would be called like “my friend Sarah” after 25 years of being my person. She’s not a coworker. She’s not a casual friend. Shes not a cousin. She’s auntie.

My sister needs to get over it. She doesn’t have a monopoly on my other relationships and she doesn’t get to decide who is family to my baby. I chose this. My baby is lucky to have someone who already loves it that much.

She’s been my best friend for practically as long as my sister has been my sister so what’s the difference really? That I share parents with my sister.

OP posts:
WhatHasATOnTheEndofIt · Today 18:57

If it is any help my DC only say auntie/uncle for non related adults in their lives. Their actual aunt and uncles (who are all very present) they call by their first name.

Kokonimater · Today 18:58

Children can have multiple aunties. What if you had two sisters? Or your husband had sisters? They’d all be aunties!

HangrySloth · Today 18:58

WhatHasATOnTheEndofIt · Today 18:57

If it is any help my DC only say auntie/uncle for non related adults in their lives. Their actual aunt and uncles (who are all very present) they call by their first name.

To me though why would I even have to make it a point to have a separate name for her to ask a point she isn’t “real” family. To me she is real family in every way and beside my best friend may feel like I am separating her out from my biological family and that would hurt her feelings and I would never do that to her. My sister will be ok

OP posts:
HangrySloth · Today 18:59

Kokonimater · Today 18:58

Children can have multiple aunties. What if you had two sisters? Or your husband had sisters? They’d all be aunties!

Exactly! It literally takes away nothing from
my sister. When I pointed this out to her she said it’s different bc they are actual sisters to either me or my husband but if I give a friend the same title as a sister would get it waters down the special role a sister has but again why would a life long close best friend automatically be less than a sister.

OP posts:
PressedThistle · Today 19:02

You're being a bit ridiculous naming aunties to a baby that isn't even here yet but generally I am with your sister - only "blood aunties" get the title.

Username19893847477374 · Today 19:04

You can't just decide someone is an aunt. Aunt means sister of the mum or dad. I am close to my cousin's and my kids call them auntie whoever, but we all know they aren't actually their aunt. So I think you are being a bit mad. She's literally not an aunt.

Stillreadingalot · Today 19:05

My dd called all my close female friends "auntie"

Stillreadingalot · Today 19:05

Her partner thought I had about 6 sisters 😁

Credittocress · Today 19:05

She can be called Auntie. When I was wee it’s what we called most close adult family friends, but the baby won’t actually be her niece- that bit is weird

OldCrohn · Today 19:06

It's all a bit silly really. You can call her auntie but she isn't. You're not doing no harm though. As many will think it's endearing as that thinks it's childish. Your sister is also silly for being annoyed about it.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 19:06

You both sound pretty dramatic to be honest. Declaring friends as aunties before the baby is even born is a bit odd to me, but it makes sense she has that title, it’s not like there’s a limit on how many people can love the baby.

Just ignore her, she’s jealous about something silly so those are her feelings to manage

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:07

I really wouldn't stress over this stuff in the end people end up with allsorts of random names and titles depending on what the kids can pronounce when their little and these names often stick

Hopefulsalmon · Today 19:07

Growing up my mum and dad's close friends were all referred to as auntie or uncle so it just seems normal to me.

HangrySloth · Today 19:08

Credittocress · Today 19:05

She can be called Auntie. When I was wee it’s what we called most close adult family friends, but the baby won’t actually be her niece- that bit is weird

To me and her it’s her niece I’m her honorary sister and we see each other as sisters blood isn’t everything. Besides what does my sister care so much if my best friend posts niece we been friends our whole lives!!!!

OP posts:
FearMaria · Today 19:08

I think a child calling someone Auntie whatever is fine but the baby won’t be your friend’s niece in my opinion. If someone said to me ‘I went to my niece’s birthday party on Saturday’ and then it was revealed the niece wasn’t a niece at all but someone she called Auntie I’d think that was strange.

HeddaGarbled · Today 19:08

You can, of course, call people whatever you like, but would it kill you to be a little kinder about your sister’s feelings?

HangrySloth · Today 19:09

OldCrohn · Today 19:06

It's all a bit silly really. You can call her auntie but she isn't. You're not doing no harm though. As many will think it's endearing as that thinks it's childish. Your sister is also silly for being annoyed about it.

Ever see the show firefly lane with Tully and Kate that’s our friendship except we been friends even longer

OP posts:
Boreded · Today 19:09

Your friend isn’t auntie, unless you are from a culture who calls their elders auntie.

Your sister is auntie, because a child’s auntie is their parents sibling. I can see why your sister would be upset, becoming an auntie probably meant a lot to her and now it has been diluted by someone who does not have the relationship.

Your friend could have been given a different title or role, god parent if Christian for example.

yogzig · Today 19:09

I always find it weird when people have their children call people auntie who are not their auntie. What is the point?

IPM · Today 19:09

'Auntie' is also a title given to all parent's female friends in Ireland and other countries.

It's not a massive deal but your friend is a bit strange to announce on social media that it means she'll have a niece.

Auntie is just an honorary title.

Having said that it's none of your sister's business and I think you're all being a bit PFB here.

Boreded · Today 19:09

HeddaGarbled · Today 19:08

You can, of course, call people whatever you like, but would it kill you to be a little kinder about your sister’s feelings?

This!

Rosieposy89 · Today 19:09

My cousin is an auntie to my daughter. We are as close as sisters and my mum sees my cousin as like a daughter

ItsWouldHaveNotWouldOf · Today 19:10

I think it's ok for very close friends to have an honorary uncle or auntie title, but your child won't be your friend's niece, that's daft.

HangrySloth · Today 19:10

HeddaGarbled · Today 19:08

You can, of course, call people whatever you like, but would it kill you to be a little kinder about your sister’s feelings?

Well if I cater to my sisters feelings than my best friend will be hurt I’m treating her as any other friend and saying she is less important than my sister. My sister is insulting ny best friend saying she is more like a friend than a sister and my best friend may be thinking I’ve been consistent just as much as you have in your sisters life and who are you to say I’m the same as some random friend

OP posts:
Arlanymor · Today 19:10

It's called 'community' - plenty of cultures call close people who aren't blood relations auntie and uncle. It's a symbol of respect and acknowledgement. I guess some people haven't travelled beyond the end of their own road if they think it's limited to blood ties... Interestingly enough, my father recently found out that he has three half-siblings... would love for those gatekeeping the term 'uncle' and 'auntie' to tell me what I am 'allowed' to call my new family... because obviously doesn't matter what I want to call them, or what they are happy to be called... it's just what the arbiters of pure blood determine!

Swipe left for the next trending thread