Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

143 replies

HangrySloth · Today 18:49

AIBU to think my sister needs to get over herself about my best friend being ‘auntie’?

I’m pregnant with my first baby and I need a sanity check because I think my sister is being ridiculous.

I have a best friend I’ve had since we were 8. We are now in our 30s. Everyone knows how close we are. We’re long distance now but we have a scheduled FaceTime every Saturday morning without fail, we text almost every day, we’ve been through literally everything together.

She is family to me. She is the one friend who has stayed solid through everything. My sister knows this, she’s heard me say it a hundred times.

I gave her the title auntie. I told her she’s going to be auntie to this baby. My sister is aware of this, this wasn’t a surprise announcement.

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be.

My sister is upset about it. She’s upset that my best friend is going to be referred to as aunt and upset that she posted about being excited.

AIBU to think this is mental?

I can see it if I was calling every friend auntie, or some random cousin I see once a year or less that I barely have any connection with. I’d get it then. But it’s literally her.

Beside my husband and now my child, she is the closest person to me, alongside my sister and my parents. That’s it. That’s the list. She’s just as important to me as my relationship with my sister is.

At this point it’s almost a given she would be an aunt. It would be genuinely weird at this stage for her to be referred to as what any other standard coworker or friend would be called like “my friend Sarah” after 25 years of being my person. She’s not a coworker. She’s not a casual friend. Shes not a cousin. She’s auntie.

My sister needs to get over it. She doesn’t have a monopoly on my other relationships and she doesn’t get to decide who is family to my baby. I chose this. My baby is lucky to have someone who already loves it that much.

She’s been my best friend for practically as long as my sister has been my sister so what’s the difference really? That I share parents with my sister.

OP posts:
ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 19:10

Boreded · Today 19:09

Your friend isn’t auntie, unless you are from a culture who calls their elders auntie.

Your sister is auntie, because a child’s auntie is their parents sibling. I can see why your sister would be upset, becoming an auntie probably meant a lot to her and now it has been diluted by someone who does not have the relationship.

Your friend could have been given a different title or role, god parent if Christian for example.

It’s common in British culture for kids to refer to parents friends as auntie! The actual auntie isn’t diluted, that’s not how things work

HangrySloth · Today 19:10

Soo my best friend put niece on her fb page why does my sister care so much

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:11

FearMaria · Today 19:08

I think a child calling someone Auntie whatever is fine but the baby won’t be your friend’s niece in my opinion. If someone said to me ‘I went to my niece’s birthday party on Saturday’ and then it was revealed the niece wasn’t a niece at all but someone she called Auntie I’d think that was strange.

I do agree with this. I had friends kids call me auntie more so when they where younger but they where not my nieces and nephews. I have nieces and nephews. I think people always go a bit crazy when its a first baby and all this stuff doesn't seem important anymore when others come along

OldCrohn · Today 19:11

HangrySloth · Today 19:09

Ever see the show firefly lane with Tully and Kate that’s our friendship except we been friends even longer

That may be but it's still just pretending rather than it being an actual thing

HangrySloth · Today 19:12

wtf how is it diluted if my best friend has been in my life nearly as long as my sister??? That makes no sense. Now if I was calling every single friend aunt or cousin or coworker sure ok that’s what diluted means but one single person when my sister knows how hear and dead my best friend is to my heart

OP posts:
IPM · Today 19:12

HangrySloth · Today 19:08

To me and her it’s her niece I’m her honorary sister and we see each other as sisters blood isn’t everything. Besides what does my sister care so much if my best friend posts niece we been friends our whole lives!!!!

Two mates can play make believe about being sisters, and about any offspring being blood relatives but it doesn't make it true.

Perhaps yours sister recognises this.

Femalemachinest · Today 19:12

My niece and nephews have never called me auntie. But I had an auntie and uncle (grandparents age) who i had no idea until I was an adult that they weren't actually my relatives. I'd always assumed they were my dads auntie and uncle.

Wooli · Today 19:13

I was closer to my DM’s two best friends than I ever was to my DM’s sisters. They are still very much in my life, and I still call them Auntie (50 years later!)

ChaToilLeam · Today 19:13

I'm a blood auntie to two but a friend "auntie" to many. That said, I don't call these children my nieces and nephews. It's just what some of us grew up calling adult friends of the family and we all knew the difference.

Rugrats103 · Today 19:15

I mean, I kind of get referring to your best friend as ‘Auntie Rachel’ or whatever to the baby once it’s here, sure. But I think you’re being a bit OTT with it all. She won’t be the baby’s actual aunt, that is just a fact and I personally think your friend posting on social media about her niece, when the baby won’t be her niece, odd.

I don’t think it’s worth your sister getting worked up over tbh, there’s bigger things happening in the world, surely?! I can understand her being a bit Hmm at you going on about how your best friend is going to be aunty though.

CharliePingPong · Today 19:16

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be

I get why you want your friend to be "Auntie Friend" - and that's fine, but she doesn't have a niece.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:16

You're are going to look back at this in 5/10 years time when you've had more kids, your sister has had kids and your friends had kids and realise how ridiculous you sound. Yes your kid calling your friend auntie is fine and common but it not something that needs an announcement a sit down conversation and Facebook posts before the baby is even born

HangrySloth · Today 19:17

Rugrats103 · Today 19:15

I mean, I kind of get referring to your best friend as ‘Auntie Rachel’ or whatever to the baby once it’s here, sure. But I think you’re being a bit OTT with it all. She won’t be the baby’s actual aunt, that is just a fact and I personally think your friend posting on social media about her niece, when the baby won’t be her niece, odd.

I don’t think it’s worth your sister getting worked up over tbh, there’s bigger things happening in the world, surely?! I can understand her being a bit Hmm at you going on about how your best friend is going to be aunty though.

Ok fine let’s say it’s weird or whatever that my best friend is saying niece on fb (I think it’s sweet and maybe that’s how much she will love my child so what’s wrong that her love for my child is already so fierce) why does my sister care so much and what does it have to do with her l. If anything she should be happy someone else is on her team as the aunt who will love my child. It isn’t a competition

OP posts:
HangrySloth · Today 19:17

CharliePingPong · Today 19:16

My best friend then posted saying how excited she is to have a niece for the first time and referred to herself as auntie because that’s what I asked her to be

I get why you want your friend to be "Auntie Friend" - and that's fine, but she doesn't have a niece.

It’s all semantics really to my friend and to me she is my niece what harm does it do that she sees her as such. We been friends our whole lives my best friend doesn’t have any sisters and I am her honorary sister

OP posts:
Dutch1e · Today 19:18

Your sister is being ridiculous.

The more love in the world, the better. The more loving relatives that a child has (by blood or bond), the better.

Morry15 · Today 19:18

Some people really have too much time on their hands. Enjoy your pregnancy. Who cares. I mean really. A healthy and happy baby should be the only concern. Titles, auntie, niece...whatever.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 19:19

HangrySloth · Today 19:17

Ok fine let’s say it’s weird or whatever that my best friend is saying niece on fb (I think it’s sweet and maybe that’s how much she will love my child so what’s wrong that her love for my child is already so fierce) why does my sister care so much and what does it have to do with her l. If anything she should be happy someone else is on her team as the aunt who will love my child. It isn’t a competition

“Why does she care” well it is actually her niece, not the friends. And posting it on Facebook doesn’t mean she loves the child any more, it’s just posting for likes isn’t it, the baby isn’t even born yet.

Again nothing wrong with the aunty thing but your kid isn’t her first niece and you are all a bit over the top about it.

stuffedanimalsandchocolate · Today 19:19

All my close friends are aunties to my kids. It's normal

It's not like it negates the blood relationship in any way

Is your sister usually jealous of your best friend?

WearingBeautifulShoes · Today 19:19

I agree it's not unusual for friends to be known as "Aunty X" as a term of endearment, but personally I find it very weird for her to refer to the baby as her niece (on social media - why??) and very weird the way you keep banging on nauseum about how she's as close as a blood sister etc. If you do it as much in real life I can see why your sister is a bit 🙄

WearingBeautifulShoes · Today 19:21

IPM · Today 19:12

Two mates can play make believe about being sisters, and about any offspring being blood relatives but it doesn't make it true.

Perhaps yours sister recognises this.

This

EatMoreChocolate44 · Today 19:21

You are all overthinking this. Many people call close friends 'auntie' to their kids. That's fairly common and it's a term of endearment. Your friend calling your baby her niece and announcing it on social media (before the baby has even been born) is definitely not the norm and I think most people would find that strange. Your child is literally not her niece in factual terms so by definition your sister is correct.

Ducksurprise · Today 19:22

PressedThistle · Today 19:02

You're being a bit ridiculous naming aunties to a baby that isn't even here yet but generally I am with your sister - only "blood aunties" get the title.

But that is ridiculous - I have eight nephews - but all by marriage non by blood.

I think it is lovely - and lovely you have such a great friendship. Cherish it

IPM · Today 19:23

HangrySloth · Today 19:17

Ok fine let’s say it’s weird or whatever that my best friend is saying niece on fb (I think it’s sweet and maybe that’s how much she will love my child so what’s wrong that her love for my child is already so fierce) why does my sister care so much and what does it have to do with her l. If anything she should be happy someone else is on her team as the aunt who will love my child. It isn’t a competition

You think this woman has a 'fierce' love for your unborn child? 😳

This thread is so weird.

RitaFires · Today 19:23

Do your sister and your friend get on? If they've had a fraught relationship then your friend declaring what an amazing Auntie she's going to be could rile your actual sister who might feel undermined and excluded. I wouldn't worry a pregnant friend or sister about it but I'd find the auntie post a bit OTT.

BoldlyLeaningPanda · Today 19:24

It's perfectly normal for your DC to grow up referring to your lovely friend as Auntie - It's a title of respect. I have half a dozen "courtesy aunts" - my own godmothers and my siblings' godmothers who have been my mum's closest friends since they were all teenagers. It's normal because it is an appropriate way to address a loved and trusted adult in a closer and more informal way than Miss/Mrs/Ms (Surname) but more respectful than just using their forename.

It's a bit weird for those aunties to refer to your baby as niece. The courtesy aunt relationship isn't "reciprocal" - my godmothers might refer to me as goddaughter but neither they nor the other women I call aunty would call me their niece.