Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

382 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
LeastOfMyWorries · Today 13:46

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:47

Even if she doesn't like it, can't you just tell her you're opting out of walks, and will be going to bed rather than watching a film? If she doesn't like it, I think you just need to point out that you are entitled to enjoy the break in your own way and she will have to accept it.

Ive tried n past - sometimes thats ok, sometimes she seems irritated and annoyed- and I want t keep the peace .
She seems to want to squeeze a lot in much of the time.

"Keeping the peace" isn't doing anyone any favours though is it- all you are doing is kicking the can down the road and making something a bigger issue each time.

DD, we love you and feel so lucky that you want to do so much with us, we are so glad you come to stay. We are starting to feel our age a bit though, and need a bit more chill time than you do- come, stay, come and go as you please, and we will make sure we do things with you but we will need some "pottering" or "chill" time

Scarecrowsweeding · Today 13:52

Has she always just got her own way when she pushes for something?

Alycie · Today 13:57

for example, you could Just say “DD, you are welcome to stay, but be aware that with hour dad’s condition we go to bed really early every night -6pm” “oh, but dont you want to make the most of the time” “yes, and I wish we could manage more, but nowadays we need more rest at night”.

And “DD, in the days that you propose I have to meet X friend” “can I come?” “Sorry, but she’s going through a rough patch and she needs to have a private conversation”.

she surely cannot be offended at such things.

theemmadilemma · Today 13:58

I'm tired just reading about her honestly. She sounds very needy in terms of not being able to function alone (and that to me is frankly worrysome) and also needing all the time she's with you guys have 'organised fun' - my god there is nothing more draining to me than running from one organsised fun activity to another.

Let me just sit and be for a minute for gods sake. I am a bit of an introvert. Although I'm very good at socialising and outgoing while I am, it sucks my energy and I need downtime afterwards to regroup and be able to be outgoing again. OP you sound a little similar.

I think you just need to tread carefully and try to explain this all to her. I kind of feel sorry for her bf. A present because she was alone all night? That is batshit to me.

Millytante · Today 14:02

Manxexile · Today 13:14

This ^

Late 60s?!?!! 😆

And….? Have people of that age no rights? Failing complete medical incapacity must parents be at the mercy of their offspring until they finally drop?

Millytante · Today 14:06

Alondra · Today 13:05

I'm often aghast at how older people are disregarded against their adult children on MN,, It's like we don't exist with independent automony, finances, feelings, or capable to say "no" irrespective of adult children's feelings.

I raised my sons to be adults. We gave them everything we could from a loving home to be financially be solvent when they left Uni. Giving them everything we could as a stepping in a ladder to be independent didn't mean to be controlled/manipulared by them. We're always open to discuss issues but our children won't make decisions involving our independence and automony..

We've fucking earned it.

Well said. This thread is astoundingly nerve-racking, as one absorbs the amount of power which this ghastly combination of lifelong childish entitlement, and willing parental self-abnegation wields out there.
In both, it strikes me that it’s the fault of great immaturity.

MinnieGirl · Today 14:07

At 27 she’s old enough to behave like an adult! But she’s actually behaving like a clingy toddler…. Who has to come everywhere with mummy and gets upset if you do anything without her. As for her boyfriend buying her a gift for being at home on her own while he’s working…..words fail me. Sadly this behaviour will continue as she continues to be enabled.
I would make it very clear that you love her, that you look forward to seeing her, but you clearly have very different expectations of how you enjoy the holidays, so there needs to be a compromise. So while you enjoy doing things together, you also enjoy meeting your friends in the village. And you don’t feel the need to be joined at the hip all the time. You would enjoy watching a film together in the evening far more if you’d had an hour or so of me time catching up with friends. And that doesn’t mean you aren’t enjoying her visit. But you are both different people and each have their own needs.
She does sound very needy, and at her age I would be a bit concerned…. And I would find her behaviour very suffocating.

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Today 14:18

See, my mum would never tell me I couldn't stay - because she wouldn't have to!

I have always said "we'd like to come and see you...." and "is it convenient if....". Because that's just manners! I don't think my mum doesn't require basic consideration.

Plus it's just the case thar some guests are easier than others.

We just had PILs over. We give up the master bedroom to them when they stay and camp out downstairs as no spare room. MIL notes that we have work, school in the morning, and asks, what time do you all need to be in bed tonight? FIL parks himself on the sofa and reads The Guardian obliviously till someone tells him "FIL .... our alarms are going off in six hours... we're sleeping in this room..."

My mum is a perfect houseguest who quietly helps with cooking or stacking the dishwasher and quietly occupies herself if we need to do a job or sort out the kids.

My sister otoh is very "organising" and will make plans and try to chivvy people into following them. They are often lovely plans but it's a bit exhausting after a bit.

The DD needs to learn to be a better guest and how to navigate an adult relationship with grace.

researchers3 · Today 14:18

AgileOpalLion · Yesterday 21:55

Having people in your home, even family, is hard work.
5 nights is more than generous.
Her declining in the past to specify the length of visit, and then extending it to 10 days, is not on, even if she is your daughter.
She is an adult and you are not responsible for how she manages her feelings. If she interprets it as rejection that's on her. Specifying 5 nights is not drama or rejection. She is pushing back against a perfectly reasonable boundary. Just keep repeating that 5 nights is all you're doing until she gets the message.
Just read that you wouldn't feel able to have a coffee with a friend because your daughter wouldn't like it! WTAF? You need to tell her where to get off.

I think the issue is that she is dictating to everyone. Ridiculous that you can't nip out for a coffee.

Sounds very overbearing to me.

I try and engage my parents in a game sometimes but we only go for one night and otherwise they just watch TV.

Meand2Ls · Today 14:19

Thank goodness I don’t have parents like this and may I never ever be a parent like this

MyLittleNest · Today 14:32

Late 60?! You make it sound like he is in his 80s! His daughter is in her TWENTIES!

I think you both have your priorities out of whack. So many parents wish their adult children would want to spend time with them, and you just want to limit the time because you're tired. In your 60s!!!! Really pathetic. And I suspect that in the end, this will end up pushing her away. Do you not stop to think about that?

I would set some expectations off the start about needing time to chill or see a friend, not constantly entertain, but I would absolutely not kick her out after five days for a Christmas visit.

FuckityFuckkIt · Today 14:34

It sounds like you're letting you and your DH be held hostage by your own child. She's not the boss in your home.

Go and meet friends if you want when she's there, ask what they want for a special breakfast/lunch on the day you've decided they're leaving and tell them it's been lovely but you're older and tired and need some downtime.
It sounds like she needs things spelt out to her and will not take hints.

As I say to people pleasing friends who are terrified of telling friends/family no but complain to everyone else - it's not rude to tell people what you need!

Snowcloud92 · Today 14:49

This thread is so sad and I really feel for your daughter. I cant see anywhere that you've mentioned it but it would be interesting to know how far away do they live from you/how frequently do they visit? As if they live far away and come to visit only a couple of times a year I dont think its unreasonable for your dd to want to spend quality of time together and make the most of it because they wont see you for a long time. If the see ou quite regularly then I would understand your point of view completely but not if you are only seeing them a few times per yr.

Honestly I feel like this could be a post written by my inlaws. we live an 8 hr drive away. so would spend most of our leave visiting them and attempting to foster some kind of relationship between them and their grandchildren. I think early on they used to put up with doing things with us when we visited but the last few years where we actually saw them they politely declined doing our "tiring activities" also known as "interacting inside or outside of the home in anyway outside of their normal routine" in favour of going for a wonder round town in hopes of bumping into their friends or going for coffees alone. the only time they would willingly spend time with us or interact would be during the adverts of whatever tv they wanted to watch.

We obviously took the hint and stopped going as much or inviting them anywhere which although they were happy with this arrangement. As time has gone on and our visits significantly less (havent actually been for 2 yrs now as the children hate the oppressive atmosphere and have 0 relationship with them anyway) is now met with complaints of how we never see them and how apparently we keep their grandchildren from them. The grandchildren who would run excited up to grandma and grandad to ask if they wanted to spend time with them (doesnt matter what they asked) only to be told oh no we cant do that today we are going for a coffee.

InBedBy10 · Today 14:50

Boomboomi · Yesterday 23:50

Lumpyteats

you dont seem to understand that when we have in the past said we will do our own thing at times - that he response is - but dont you want to make the most of our time together?

and takes me doing my own thing as the same thing as me not wanting to to be with her whilst she is here .

Can you sit down with her and explain that you love her dearly and enjoy your time together but "making the most of your time together " does not mean you have to spend every waking minute doing something. Tell her you are getting older now and you dont have the energy to keep up with her. Also remind her that you have a life and you will be meeting your good friend "Mary" for a coffee on Tuesday morning,, or whatever it is you want to do.

She may be disappointed/upset at first. And thats ok. You need to stop being so scared to upset her because its building up tension and will cause resentment. Let her be upset but after shes had time to process what youve said, maybe she'll take some of it in and stop dictating your every move.

CitizenofMoronia · Today 15:17

i have 2 weeks off work at Xmas I had an ex partner that every year would take over those 2 weeks -even when I stated I didnt want them over the whole 2 weeks, they turned up and made every excuse under the sun to stay the whole 2 weeks.. totallly exhausting, its not the same as living with someone, I work full time and they worked 3-4 days a week depending on if they wanted to - I need a break too so no your not unreasonable to be setting bounderies

Cherrytree86 · Today 15:38

Meand2Ls · Today 14:19

Thank goodness I don’t have parents like this and may I never ever be a parent like this

@Meand2Ls

do you expect your mother to attend to you 24/7 and not see anyone else or do anything she wants to do while you’re there?

Cherrytree86 · Today 15:46

HairsprayBabe · Today 12:38

@ThreadGuardDog I disagree, but I am welcome in my parents home whenever (and vice versa, and other family etc.)

It always surprises me when families don't want to see each other as much as possible. We only get one life, why wouldn't we want to spend it with people we love.

OP and her DH is absolutely able and with in her rights to not see her daughter or see her less or whatever but in my opinion it isn't nice, and she asked for opinions. I don't agree with yours and you don't have to agree with mine.

@HairsprayBabe

friends are important too. I wouldn’t have dreamed when I was 27 to tell my mum when I was visiting her that she couldn’t go for a coffee with her friend. On what planet is that ok?!

Applepiewithcream · Today 15:58

There appears to be a lack of comprehension of what OP has written on here, hence some of the responses, especially about how challenging and tiring OP and her DH find things. Whilst you have not mentioned what your DH’s condition is (and you shouldn’t have to), there have been some very ignorant comments. Those of us with an energy zapping condition will totally understand where you are coming from.

@Boomboomi I don’t think you are being unreasonable at all setting a limit on how long your DD and her partner stay with you. Most visitors start to go off like fish after a couple of days and five days is well beyond that. Not only are you trying to accommodate your DD and her partner (which changes the dynamics somewhat), you are also accommodating your DS, who also finds your DD/his DS challenging. It is also your Christmas as well. I hope you find a way forward that works for you all.

In the longer term your DD needs to step back and consider her actions and behaviour (a gift when partner is working late is mind boggling).

Monty36 · Today 15:59

She is 27 ? Unbelievable. She is very immature. And manipulative.

Good manners say you check with your host even if it is your mum and dad, how long you would like to stay for and if it is okay? If too long, you shorten it. Their house and home is not a hotel. And hosting can be tiring.

Just stick to your 5 nights only. Do not apologise. Just say it matter of fact. And no, you are not making any drama out of it. What is the drama ? It is all from her.

SorcererGaheris · Today 16:11

HairsprayBabe · Today 12:38

@ThreadGuardDog I disagree, but I am welcome in my parents home whenever (and vice versa, and other family etc.)

It always surprises me when families don't want to see each other as much as possible. We only get one life, why wouldn't we want to spend it with people we love.

OP and her DH is absolutely able and with in her rights to not see her daughter or see her less or whatever but in my opinion it isn't nice, and she asked for opinions. I don't agree with yours and you don't have to agree with mine.

@HairsprayBabe

But in this case, I don't think the innate issue is that the OP doesn't want to see her daughter. The innate issue is the way the daughter acts when she visits. If OP has given an accurate account, then her daughter seems to expect/insist that her parents spend the entire time catering to what she wants and partaking in activities that she has organised. She doesn't want them to spend a day relaxing in their pyjamas and gets upset if they decided that, during the course of her visit, they want to meet up with a friend for a coffee.

She naturally wants to make the most of her time with her parents, but it's not reasonable to try to dictate her parents' time to that extent. They are entitled to still live their own lives, to a degree, whilst she stays with them.

If you were staying with your parents, would you get upset about them meeting friends for a coffee? I'd assume not.

It's the way her daughter acts when she stays that is the main problem. Not the OP not wanting to see her.

Tryagain26 · Today 16:15

Yes I think it's mean we are in our 70s and I can't imagine telling our children they can only stay for a maximum of 5 days. Do you have health issues? Are your children's also your husband's?

SorcererGaheris · Today 16:21

Tryagain26 · Today 16:15

Yes I think it's mean we are in our 70s and I can't imagine telling our children they can only stay for a maximum of 5 days. Do you have health issues? Are your children's also your husband's?

@Tryagain26

The OP has said that her husband has a health condition.

She has also said that when her daughter visits, she is disapproving and rather controlling of how their parents use their time - objecting to them spending a day in their pyjamas and being put out if they decide they want to meet up with a friend.

Monty36 · Today 16:25

Your daughter, at best, is emotionally illiterate. Unable to think about her impact on other people. No ability to consider others. And unable to stand in their shoes. All about her.

I would be as firm with her as she is with you OP.

NimbleTaupeTiger · Today 16:25

I cannot believe the number of people on here who think getting tired in your 60s is something to be laughed at. Chronic medical issues can lead to intense fatigue, it's not funny, amusing, hilarious or cause for sneering, it's a very serious issue. This is why people over 60 get free prescriptions.

I get tired, I have an autoimmune disease, I'm early 60s. I can party with the best of them for a day, maybe two and then I need to have downtime to recharge. If I don't get downtime then my illness starts to play up and then I could be laid up for weeks. Hosting guests, even much loved family, is hard work and 5 days is really generous of OP.

But please, laugh all you want because clearly you don't suffer from chronic illness and fatigue so you have absolutely zero understanding.

Firefly100 · Today 16:35

You need to separate your DD and her partner staying in your home from ‘hosting’. Agree the period you are hosting them - eg the 5 days you mentioned, give them all the time you can, then say she is welcome to stay for as long as she likes but you and DH get tired these days so she will nerd to do her own thing after x date and mean it. When she gives you the guilt trip ‘don’t you want to spend time with me’. ‘No DD I need to rest’. Or ‘but we came to see you’ - ‘I know dear and it’s been lovely but I did explain that after x date you need to do your own thing.’