Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

381 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
Laurmolonlabe · Today 09:29

I don't think it it is you providing the drama- expecting an open ended invitation is not reasonable, you have a life just like DD does. How does she have so much time on her hands? When working I struggled to stay with my parents more than 3 nights due to work.

LucyLooh · Today 09:30

Sorry, I’m with your DD on this. I can’t imagine my mum wanting to set a limit on how long I stay for or not being happy to go without seeing her friends for 10 days! You have the rest of the year to see your friends, why can’t you prioritise DD for the short time she’s home? I’d also be annoyed if I made the effort to stay with my mum and she was then making plans with her friends instead. If you’re too tired to watch a movie or whatever just say no and go to bed.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 09:34

LucyLooh · Today 09:30

Sorry, I’m with your DD on this. I can’t imagine my mum wanting to set a limit on how long I stay for or not being happy to go without seeing her friends for 10 days! You have the rest of the year to see your friends, why can’t you prioritise DD for the short time she’s home? I’d also be annoyed if I made the effort to stay with my mum and she was then making plans with her friends instead. If you’re too tired to watch a movie or whatever just say no and go to bed.

DD is not only unhappy at the thought of OP seeing her own friends during her lengthy visits, it appears she’s actively rude if they bump in to them when out and about. Were she my DD, the first time she did that would be the last, and she’d be spending the next few christmases on her own until she learned some manners. This is a 27 year old woman we’re talking about and she’s acting like a spoilt petulant child with no thought for anyone else. The behaviour needs to be shut down, not enabled.

Ally886 · Today 09:35

ClairDeLaLune · Today 00:00

She’s your daughter! This thread is really sad, I can’t imagine feeling this way about my DD and DS. I love having them to stay, partners too.

My mum loves us dearly but has no issue saying "right I'm going for a walk on my own, I'm fed up of folk".

This year she's said "can everyone be gone by 11 boxing day so I can have a gap between family time and friends time"

I respect it, she wants our time together to be happy.

I hosted last year and asked people to come after 5 on Christmas eve, before 5 they won't be let in 😂

pusspuss9 · Today 09:37

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 21:41

Your DH is late 60s? The way you’re talking I would have expected late 80s! How tiring can it really be?

Have you ever had visitors who stay?
sometimes you are tired, not because you're old or weak but because you just feel you need to sit down have a cup of tea , watch something on TV, do a puzzle or just go for a walk . A bit of 'me' time without having to perform by constantly checking that they have something to do and are not just sitting around bored.
If you have visitors it is difficult to do this without appearing rude.

Yellow2024 · Today 09:40

My SIL actually does this too. Stays from the 23rd to new year. My FIL had hives one year he was so stressed.
It means that my ILs home doesn't become comfortable for them as they are continuously hosting and they are use to a quiet life. My MIL is very sociable and doesn't get to see her friends unless SIL tags along which obviously changes the dynamics.
Then you have the obvious constant washing, cleaning and tidying.

It also makes it hard for us to visit as the house is small and when we arrive everyone is midly annoyed with each other and there's no where to sit as everyone has claimed their spot. It makes us feel like we are intruding.

My PIL are now getting to an age where they only drive locally and SIL doesn't drive so they are all stuck together also.

I don't have any advice really as PIL hate it but can not bring themselves to ask her to reduce the time spent there either.

But I just wanted to let you know I don't think you are wrong at all for wanting the time spent at yours reduced.

Chilly80 · Today 09:41

I wouldn't want to stay in someone's house for 10 nights or have someone stay for 10 nights either.
I'm very surprised the partner is happy to stay that long as well.
My Dad tried to extend his stay with us over Christmas once and I promptly shut that down.

Littlejellyuk · Today 09:42

Boomboomi · Yesterday 23:50

Lumpyteats

you dont seem to understand that when we have in the past said we will do our own thing at times - that he response is - but dont you want to make the most of our time together?

and takes me doing my own thing as the same thing as me not wanting to to be with her whilst she is here .

This would drive me mad. I need some time alone to have coffee/ enjoy peace/stay in pajamas/fart without someone always there. 😬

I would be replying "yes, I do want to spend time with you! BUT there are 24 hours in a day and I'm spending 2 of them with my pal having a coffee. Alone. You have a whole 2 hours for yourself dear, enjoy it, byyeeee!" 👋

You said she was clingy as a toddler?
So it sounds like she is probably abit anxious/clingy as an adult and you need to stop enabling this behaviour, she is an adult and so are you.
Boundaries are a good thing.
Ignore any comments or guilt trips. She cannot hog you all day every day, you need some breathing space and having a coffee with a pal for a couple of hours doesn't mean the world will end. ☕️

https://www.betterhelp.com/advice/family/how-to-stop-enabling-grown-children-and-why-its-important/

@Boomboomi

How To Stop Enabling Adult Children | BetterHelp

Learn how to stop enabling adult children in seven steps. Explore signs of enabling to watch for and boundary scripts that build independence.

https://www.betterhelp.com/advice/family/how-to-stop-enabling-grown-children-and-why-its-important/

Wheniswinenight · Today 09:46

Totally understand. I have the reverse of this. My mother (70’s) came for 6 nights last Xmas. It was exhausting! I would love to be able to say in advance can it just be 3 nights? I don’t know how to though.
I also have a dd25 and there’s no way I’d want her and her bf here for the whole of Christmas. We all need our own space and peace & quiet.

Scottishskifun · Today 09:49

I think it's perfectly reasonable to say looking forward to seeing you but with your dad's health we need to reduce it to 5 nights going forward. I would also frame it that she needs to see and spend time with bf family as well.
Honestly she sounds exhausting with constantly wanting to do things.

Janetwin · Today 09:52

ByDeftPoster · Yesterday 23:37

As someone who has parents like this I feel your pain! We say a week to my parents and they’ll fly in for nine nights anyway and they want to do EVERY SINGLE THING together. Even going to the supermarket. No, I’m not joking. I hold firm on the activities and say things like “after the shops I’m going to have a lie down and read for a few hours”. They follow me into the kitchen even. I love them but I’m exhausted when they leave.

Just hold your ground and say “popping out on my own for an hour or two”.

That’s my mum and MIL when they visit. Lovely for 3 days. Doable for 5. Exhausting, like actually exhausting, for anymore than that. Funny thing is, with my mum, my siblings just ignore it. When she’s with them, they just go do their own thing. They think I’m an idiot for going along with the demand to spend every minute of every day with her.

Janetwin · Today 09:54

Janetwin · Today 09:52

That’s my mum and MIL when they visit. Lovely for 3 days. Doable for 5. Exhausting, like actually exhausting, for anymore than that. Funny thing is, with my mum, my siblings just ignore it. When she’s with them, they just go do their own thing. They think I’m an idiot for going along with the demand to spend every minute of every day with her.

I’ll add to this, I tried to discuss this with my mum once after she had stayed for 3 weeks. She just said “didn’t you go to the gym by yourself!” I went to the gym ONCE in the three weeks at 6am (while she was still in bed so I would be back to have breakfast with her)

NarnianQueen · Today 09:55

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:51

HeddaGarbled
yes because the partner also comes. And also because we cant get on with our own stuff as you say as they want to do things as a group.
for example in the ten days if i wanted to have a coffee with a friend - they dont like that .

In this case it’s not the number of days they stay that’s the problem! Just put your foot down and say of course I’m going out to see a friend? I have a life and it doesn’t stop when you come to stay!

If encourage them to do their own thing if they want to stay longer!

AlwaysExtraHot · Today 09:55

I totally get it, OP. It's not that you don't want to see her, you just don't want to be doing 'things' all the time.
I think you need an honest chat with her to explain what you've told us all here about needing downtime and to keep your own friendships going.
I'd also make clear that, if she can't be polite to your friends in the pub etc, she should not come, as it makes things awkward for you and them. She's old enough to be able to put a social face on.
As for 'She also says things like she does not like my clothes and that my home decor is miss matched.', I'd tell her straight that it's not OK to say rude things about someone when you're staying in their house. She either behaves politely or she will make herself unwelcome.
She sounds very immature and needy, TBH. Her bf brings her a present because she's been alone for one evening? Hmm I think she needs to do some work on herself.

Maddy70 · Today 10:00

Honestly it does seem like you are trying to get rid of them. My adult children are welcome to stay as long as they like I love seeing them and isn't it lovely they aren't rushing off after a "duty" visit
Christmas is exhausting. But can't you and your husband spend a day out in the middle just the two of you , go for a walk and pub lunch so he gets a bit of solitude? Or you go out with your daughter and leave him to watch TV?

WantEnergy · Today 10:01

Five days to a week is very reasonable to set as a limit on a visit. Just explain that DH has a medical issue that makes visitors tiring, as much as he enjoys them. If she takes it personally, that's on him. Or explain that she can stay ten days but due to said medical condition, you can't be on the go all the time. It's fine to set boundaries. It sounds like you are welcoming enough.

That said, I've gone LC with my parents recently since they would rather not see us than have us stay for just a weekend. For me it was a last straw thing. So I know how hurtful it can be. However, your DD is getting welcomed for a decent period of time.

AlwaysExtraHot · Today 10:04

Maddy70 · Today 10:00

Honestly it does seem like you are trying to get rid of them. My adult children are welcome to stay as long as they like I love seeing them and isn't it lovely they aren't rushing off after a "duty" visit
Christmas is exhausting. But can't you and your husband spend a day out in the middle just the two of you , go for a walk and pub lunch so he gets a bit of solitude? Or you go out with your daughter and leave him to watch TV?

But can't you and your husband spend a day out in the middle just the two of you , go for a walk and pub lunch so he gets a bit of solitude?
The OP has explained what happens if she tries to do this.

Janetwin · Today 10:05

Boomboomi · Yesterday 23:50

Lumpyteats

you dont seem to understand that when we have in the past said we will do our own thing at times - that he response is - but dont you want to make the most of our time together?

and takes me doing my own thing as the same thing as me not wanting to to be with her whilst she is here .

You need to be firm about your plans. Make them independent of her and stick to them. She won’t be happy, it may be bumpy for a while, but she needs to get used to new boundaries. Long term it will be better. Allowing her to be demanding of your time like she has thus far, will drive you further apart. I’d also address her rudeness / lack of friendliness to your friends.

HorseandHeron · Today 10:06

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:46

Because we do thjngs v differently when they are here - we cant just chill - they want to do stuff all the time and its exhausting to us to have a house full for ten days doing meals out, walks , games , without much chill time . Dh has a medical condition .

She's a grown up. tell her this. Say you love having her and seeing her. But you both find 10 days of constant activity exhausting. You are up for walks and board games etc for about 5 days but after that you really need to unwind with time alone doing nothing or getting back to your normal routine. That it is not a rejection of her but a reflection of your age and health that you need a slower pace.

Why don't you descend on her instead? She'll soon realise how exhausting it is to have other people in the bathroom when she usually is, wanting food she doesn't usually prepare, getting up and going to bed at different hours, needing to be entertained.

IsaTheIguana · Today 10:14

I think you need to sit her down and have an honest conversation about how you and your DH cannot cope with such a long stay for his helath reasons and that she needs to stop being so controlling when she is a house guest.

C8H10N4O2 · Today 10:15

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:38

I am actually quite sociable- i find it hard we cant go out in our own village for the duration of the stay - or rarley.

But you can.

She is 27 - why can you not just tell her "tonight we are seeing Peter and Jane, help yourselves from the fridge" or "nice idea but we don't all want to play scrabble tonight".

As you say, people are different but the advantage with close family is that you can tell them what you think and you don't need to be in host mode all the time.

One of mine is a bit inclined to organising the others (and I have this fault at times) - on the whole it works but occasionally one of us will remind them (or me!) that they are not at work now and won't be joining in community charades but will have a game tomorrow.

SixtySomething · Today 10:23

likelysuspect · Yesterday 22:09

I dont think you should feel awful, this is probably a terrible place to ask this sort of question

In real life, people have their space and own needs and dont act like martyrs.

If this was a thread the other way round and a daugther saying her mum wanted to come over xmas with partner/dad and stay and it tired them out or they wanted their space, they'd be told 'no is a complete sentence'

Whereas in this thread, you've already had the nasty threat of 'well dont be surprised if they want to spend less time with you in future'.

I think 5 days is very long, I wouldnt like someone staying for more than a couple of days. I like my space.

Its perfectly ok to say that me and your dad really need our space and it will be lovely to see you for that 5 days, after that we'll meet up if you're still in the area.

Exactly.

LemonChilliDrop · Today 10:36

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:49

This.is very interesting- there seems to be both a strong understanding about its perfectly ok to set boundaries- and another suggesting its totally not ok .

I dont think those berating you are reading this fully
Lets face it if this was a man he would be called controlling, quite rightly
Her behaviour is completely unacceptable
You are being perfectly reasonable to set boundaries, she needs to hear NO

Coconutcreamz · Today 10:41

LemonChilliDrop · Today 10:36

I dont think those berating you are reading this fully
Lets face it if this was a man he would be called controlling, quite rightly
Her behaviour is completely unacceptable
You are being perfectly reasonable to set boundaries, she needs to hear NO

I agree.
I have 4 adult children, one 26 that will be visiting for Christmas. The idea that they would control and dictate the whole house, rude to my friends if we bumped into them, not allowing pj days, is a complete joke and absolute madness.

I wouldn't want to see them if this was what it meant.

Unfortunately these things never come out of nowhere.
OP and her husband must have been entertaining this ridiculousness for years.

WhatNoRaisins · Today 10:47

I think OPs husband's health is a red herring. As a healthy 20 year old spending 5 days with someone who behaves like the OPs 27 year old would leave me exhausted. She's also old enough to be polite to her parents friends.

I'll take two weeks hosting a mature adult that can occupy themselves some of time and understand that I am a person with my own life over two days hosting someone like this.