Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

381 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:40

FirmSnake · Today 11:38

OP moved away to a village. So which friends and work is she supposed to be occupied with when she has travelled a distance to visit her parents?

The ones she sees when she isn't there?? 🤔 Adults don't tend to spend their entire Christmas holidays with their parents.

We used to get together for about four days. The rest of the time I'd be seeing friends or working.

ginasevern · Today 11:42

FirmSnake · Today 11:38

OP moved away to a village. So which friends and work is she supposed to be occupied with when she has travelled a distance to visit her parents?

What a weird thing to say. Why can't she work or have friends at nearly 30 years old just because her parents moved to a village (or Timbuktu for that matter)? My parents retired to West Wales when I was her age. Didn't stop me having an independent adult life.

FirmSnake · Today 11:44

ginasevern · Today 11:42

What a weird thing to say. Why can't she work or have friends at nearly 30 years old just because her parents moved to a village (or Timbuktu for that matter)? My parents retired to West Wales when I was her age. Didn't stop me having an independent adult life.

I didn't say she doesn't have work or friends. They just aren't in OPs village. Obviously.

Cherrytree86 · Today 11:51

LucyLooh · Today 09:30

Sorry, I’m with your DD on this. I can’t imagine my mum wanting to set a limit on how long I stay for or not being happy to go without seeing her friends for 10 days! You have the rest of the year to see your friends, why can’t you prioritise DD for the short time she’s home? I’d also be annoyed if I made the effort to stay with my mum and she was then making plans with her friends instead. If you’re too tired to watch a movie or whatever just say no and go to bed.

@LucyLooh

ffs, OP doesn’t need to be with her daughter 24/7 for 10 days for her to be her priority. Would it really be horrendous if OP had a few hours out one afternoon to have a coffee with a friend?!

at OP’s daughter age I recognised my mum as a person in her own right; OP’s daughter needs to learn to go the same

urgh talk about suffocating and needy. I couldn’t be arsed with that’s

ThisRedZebra · Today 11:51

We live on the opposite end of the country to a lot of our family and regularly host guests for at least a week or two. I think if you set expectations that people can stay, but that you're not going to be in host mode the whole time, it's a lot less intense

Cherrytree86 · Today 11:52

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

@Netcurtainnelly
yeah OP best get playing the Martyr…who cares about you or how you feel or your husband

nomas · Today 11:55

My mum loves having her kids and grandkids but she can get tired even after a day. A visit of 3/4 days is even more tiring for her. She would find it unbearable if we tried to jolly her along into activities.

I would tell dd that as you and DH get older, you find it harder having people to stay for longer than a few days.

Millytante · Today 11:58

FirmSnake · Today 11:38

OP moved away to a village. So which friends and work is she supposed to be occupied with when she has travelled a distance to visit her parents?

Is DD so helpless that she cannot occupy any of her time (with her BF, what’s more) independently of her parents, in the village and environs?

HairsprayBabe · Today 11:59

Is your DH her father? You don't just get to decide you don't like seeing your children because you are old and ill.

I don't think it is very nice but my family are really close and do fortnightly holidays etc together. Even my grandparents, grandad is 88 and had a stroke last year!

Crocsarentslippers · Today 12:02

I must admit I'm quite bemused to see 50% of people think you're being unreasonable, OP.

Unreasonable for limiting the time you have family staying in your own home hosting, not being able to comfortably socialise with anyone else.

There is another thread that syas ' AIBU to limit the amount of time family stay with us at Christmas' , and that's 91% YANBU .

Very strange!

FirmSnake · Today 12:04

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:40

The ones she sees when she isn't there?? 🤔 Adults don't tend to spend their entire Christmas holidays with their parents.

We used to get together for about four days. The rest of the time I'd be seeing friends or working.

Edited

Very much depends how far she is travelling doesnt it? OP has neglected to tell us, but seems to think his parents 2 hours away are "nearby". Some people prefer not to spend hours in a car for a couple of days visit, only to spend little time with the people they are visiting.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · Today 12:04

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:52

for those who judge - i wish it was different- but when they come we really feel we cant do anything that involves our normal life - like go for a coffee with a mate - the whole time does not feel like chilled family time , but one of action and activity .it feels intense .

I would have an open desk diary in the kitchen which clearly shows plans already made for coffees or whatever locally. Point it out that you have commitments and they should make plans to amuse themselves then.

If your husband needs an afternoon nap or regularly sits down with a book and some quiet time after lunch then make it clear to both your children that its necessary. If they don't feel like doing that, they can make themselves scarce. He shouldn't have to hide in his room.

Collect any leaflets or print out any walks you spot over the next few weeks for things she and her partner may be interested in doing without you so you can gently suggest she explore the area with her other half.

If you're going out on a solo basis, then it is perfectly fine to say "thank you for offering, but I would like some time by myself for a bit. I find it a good way to recharge my social batteries".

Alternatively you could buy her a hotel overnight stay for Christmas so they go off for a couple of nights between Christmas and NY?

Kindly, if they both work in an industry that shuts down over Christmas or they contract and are furloughed, this isn't a problem that will go away. It will be exacerbated if they have kids so you need to reset your routines with them. It's perfectly acceptable to make their stay boring by following your normal routines once Christmas Eve/Day/Boxing Days are out of the way and tell them they are welcome to stay but your lives are going back to normal over Twixtmas. They will find something to do if forced even if it's visiting the partners family for a change because it's not so much [forced] fun.

Lastly I hope you are not waiting on the three of them hand and foot? Make some meals and some chores their responsibility. Write and list and ask them to volunteer to do stuff whether it's bringing in logs, cooking a meal/leftovers inspiration welcome or running the hoover around the ground floor every morning. It's your Christmas too.

FirmSnake · Today 12:05

Millytante · Today 11:58

Is DD so helpless that she cannot occupy any of her time (with her BF, what’s more) independently of her parents, in the village and environs?

I don't see anything wrong with wanting to spend a week or so with family. If OP doesn't want to do that, she can say so. DD may visit less often as a consequence, which I suppose OP may see as a win.

PinkyFlamingo · Today 12:06

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:51

HeddaGarbled
yes because the partner also comes. And also because we cant get on with our own stuff as you say as they want to do things as a group.
for example in the ten days if i wanted to have a coffee with a friend - they dont like that .

So?

ginasevern · Today 12:07

If these were 60 something parents insisting on staying with their nearly 30 year old daughter and her partner for the entirety of Christmas and NYE, there'd be fucking uproar on this thread.

LemonChilliDrop · Today 12:14

C8H10N4O2 · Today 10:50

Well she isn't a man she is the adult child in this situation so the dynamics are very different.
Nobody has told her she is annoying by organising so how is she supposed to know? She may well think she is making everyone's Christmas by organising so much "fun" for them.

The answer is to actually talk to each other. However if people have been nodding and smiling for years instead of simply say "no thanks" I can see how it has reached the point of the OP not wanting them there and the DD not understanding why which is a shame.

Op has told her-she kicks off, perhaps read the Ops posts
Its still controlling behaviour

Millytante · Today 12:14

HairsprayBabe · Today 11:59

Is your DH her father? You don't just get to decide you don't like seeing your children because you are old and ill.

I don't think it is very nice but my family are really close and do fortnightly holidays etc together. Even my grandparents, grandad is 88 and had a stroke last year!

I’m not at all surprised, at that level of intensity.
Of course age, infirmity, and/or illness are legitimate reasons for limiting one’s obligations re family jollifications.

(I’m aghast at the level of demands so many people on MN in general feel free to make of their loved ones, to be honest. It’s quite as though family members have no rights to any kind of consideration, let alone autonomy.
In every instance, those flinging accusations of unforgivable selfishness at the reluctant relative are the sort who go through life insisting that the universe (and everyone in it) shape itself around their desires at every whim, and whose inevitable deadly, black mood when thwarted has been their means of dominating people since infancy)

Lyd8 · Today 12:19

She sounds like an absolutely brat if I’m being honest!

She is an adult, coming home to mummy & daddy at 27 for 10 days I just don’t get. Absolutely spend some time 23-27 sounds ample.

I am a daughter, I moved out at 20 and would spend Xmas with my parents (never 10 days though) but I would see friends, socialise. I wouldn’t monopolise my parents time for 10 days, and sulk if they made plans. And once I met my DH we would split it, or make our own plans.

She sounds like hard work & immature, getting gifts from her boyfriend because she is alone for a night!🙄

And I have an amazing relationship with my mum & dad and love spending time with them.

HairsprayBabe · Today 12:25

@Millytante I disagree, but maybe my family are just nicer than many others.

Very nasty and strange of you to imply that my grandad had a stroke because we do big family trips.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 12:28

FirmSnake · Today 12:05

I don't see anything wrong with wanting to spend a week or so with family. If OP doesn't want to do that, she can say so. DD may visit less often as a consequence, which I suppose OP may see as a win.

OP seems to be up for a five day visit, but not ten. I don’t blame her - that’s the whole of Christmas and NY hosting without a break. And given some of the behaviour OP has described, she needs to put her foot down more with DD and set some boundaries if she doesn’t want her own Christmas and NY to be a source of so much stress every year.

FirmSnake · Today 12:30

ThreadGuardDog · Today 12:28

OP seems to be up for a five day visit, but not ten. I don’t blame her - that’s the whole of Christmas and NY hosting without a break. And given some of the behaviour OP has described, she needs to put her foot down more with DD and set some boundaries if she doesn’t want her own Christmas and NY to be a source of so much stress every year.

Don't move far away if you're not up for hosting. Can't have it all ways.

Cherrytree86 · Today 12:30

FirmSnake · Today 12:05

I don't see anything wrong with wanting to spend a week or so with family. If OP doesn't want to do that, she can say so. DD may visit less often as a consequence, which I suppose OP may see as a win.

Yeah the daughter could go to the gym or for a run or something while her mother has a coffee and catch up with a pal @FirmSnake

ThreadGuardDog · Today 12:31

HairsprayBabe · Today 11:59

Is your DH her father? You don't just get to decide you don't like seeing your children because you are old and ill.

I don't think it is very nice but my family are really close and do fortnightly holidays etc together. Even my grandparents, grandad is 88 and had a stroke last year!

You don't just get to decide you don't like seeing your children because you are old and ill.

Totally uncalled for. OP hasn’t said she doesn’t like seeing her children - she’s saying that ten days of full on activities is too much - and her DH has a health problem, so that absolutely should be taken into account. She’s hosting, and she’s entitled to set boundaries. DD sounds like an entitled brat.

WarmHam · Today 12:32

Ineffable23 · Yesterday 21:49

You can do whatever you want, but don't be surprised or disappointed if your DD then doesn't plan to spend as much time with you in the future.

That would be a win, surely?

Cherrytree86 · Today 12:33

WarmHam · Today 12:32

That would be a win, surely?

Yeah I’d be relieved. She is way too needy and intense