Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

380 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
WarmHam · Today 12:33

FirmSnake · Today 12:05

I don't see anything wrong with wanting to spend a week or so with family. If OP doesn't want to do that, she can say so. DD may visit less often as a consequence, which I suppose OP may see as a win.

Sorry @Firmsnake I posted before I read this. Great minds think alike!

ThreadGuardDog · Today 12:34

FirmSnake · Today 12:30

Don't move far away if you're not up for hosting. Can't have it all ways.

My own mum moved to a UK destination resort a couple of hours away from the rest of the family. No-one in our family would be so thoughtless as to impose ourselves on her for the whole of Christmas. Just because you live there, doesn’t mean the rest of the family are entitled to a free holiday.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 12:35

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:13

Not horrible, realistic maybe.

Well OP's daughter's dad is definitely nearer death's door than her due to his age and medical condition so why doesn't she think about how much stress her behaviour is causing him?

ThreadGuardDog · Today 12:35

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

Nothing like chucking a bit of martyrdom into the mix. We could all pop our clogs at any time. It absolutely doesn’t give any of us the right to be entitled and rude arseholes.

HairsprayBabe · Today 12:38

@ThreadGuardDog I disagree, but I am welcome in my parents home whenever (and vice versa, and other family etc.)

It always surprises me when families don't want to see each other as much as possible. We only get one life, why wouldn't we want to spend it with people we love.

OP and her DH is absolutely able and with in her rights to not see her daughter or see her less or whatever but in my opinion it isn't nice, and she asked for opinions. I don't agree with yours and you don't have to agree with mine.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 12:56

ginasevern · Today 12:07

If these were 60 something parents insisting on staying with their nearly 30 year old daughter and her partner for the entirety of Christmas and NYE, there'd be fucking uproar on this thread.

Exactly.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:04

FirmSnake · Today 12:04

Very much depends how far she is travelling doesnt it? OP has neglected to tell us, but seems to think his parents 2 hours away are "nearby". Some people prefer not to spend hours in a car for a couple of days visit, only to spend little time with the people they are visiting.

I've suggested neither extreme but a compromise between being there for ten days and not allowing your own mother any time to go to the gym or catch up with her own mates over Christmas and a flying visit. Surely there must be some middle ground between passing like ships in the night and being sellotaped to one another 24/7 for ten days?

How would you feel about your parents staying for ten days and not allowing you to go out and see your friends while they are there?

My parents lived four hours away and used to come for a week at Christmas. But they were easy, they helped out, I didn't have to wait on them hand and foot, they were hands on with grandchildren, we spent time together and with wider family but also I could still put my feet up, do my usual exercise and see my friends.

Alondra · Today 13:05

Millytante · Today 12:14

I’m not at all surprised, at that level of intensity.
Of course age, infirmity, and/or illness are legitimate reasons for limiting one’s obligations re family jollifications.

(I’m aghast at the level of demands so many people on MN in general feel free to make of their loved ones, to be honest. It’s quite as though family members have no rights to any kind of consideration, let alone autonomy.
In every instance, those flinging accusations of unforgivable selfishness at the reluctant relative are the sort who go through life insisting that the universe (and everyone in it) shape itself around their desires at every whim, and whose inevitable deadly, black mood when thwarted has been their means of dominating people since infancy)

I'm often aghast at how older people are disregarded against their adult children on MN,, It's like we don't exist with independent automony, finances, feelings, or capable to say "no" irrespective of adult children's feelings.

I raised my sons to be adults. We gave them everything we could from a loving home to be financially be solvent when they left Uni. Giving them everything we could as a stepping in a ladder to be independent didn't mean to be controlled/manipulared by them. We're always open to discuss issues but our children won't make decisions involving our independence and automony..

We've fucking earned it.

AlexandraCarrington · Today 13:10

she wants to control being back home

But she's not 'back home'. This isn't the house or the place where she grew up.

Why is it always the mothers who are supposed to make doormats of themselves for fear of damaging their relationships with their adult or near adult offspring? Why is the onus never on the adult son or daughter to alter their behaviour?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:10

thepariscrimefiles · Today 12:35

Well OP's daughter's dad is definitely nearer death's door than her due to his age and medical condition so why doesn't she think about how much stress her behaviour is causing him?

Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

Indeed. So don't stress out your parents and hasten their demise by overstaying your welcome, expecting to be waiting on hand and foot and being an entitled little twat stopping your mum seeing her friends while you are there insisting you must be glued together 24/7 for ten days.

burnoutbabe · Today 13:13

I occasionally go visit my folks for a week when partner is away. But we have us mix of some days we go out and others we all work/study or craft in separate rooms. Ie I slot into their normal routine (though often mum is happy for any excuse to miss yoga!) for the week days. I can binge Netflix if bored or get a bus into town for shopping or cinema. Or play on dads Xbox.

and we’re all in our 50s or late 70s.

Manxexile · Today 13:14

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 21:41

Your DH is late 60s? The way you’re talking I would have expected late 80s! How tiring can it really be?

This ^

Late 60s?!?!! 😆

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:15

AlexandraCarrington · Today 13:10

she wants to control being back home

But she's not 'back home'. This isn't the house or the place where she grew up.

Why is it always the mothers who are supposed to make doormats of themselves for fear of damaging their relationships with their adult or near adult offspring? Why is the onus never on the adult son or daughter to alter their behaviour?

Quite.

I think people making these comments are either not parents of grown up children and are the type to say "I sacrificed everything for my children" then wake up when the kids are 21 and realise they don't have a life, or are the entitled enfant terribles themselves and don't see their parents quite as actual people with their own lives, but are stuck in child mode. Or they are serial CF visitors who don't host and regularly put people out and have no idea.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:15

Manxexile · Today 13:14

This ^

Late 60s?!?!! 😆

People can be ill or disabled much younger. Ignorant!

ByTipsyShark · Today 13:17

Some people really struggle with the whole having an adult to adult based relationship with their parents when they move out. Always find it bizarre when you have grown children revert back to being a child in their parents house, making demands . If you wouldn’t behave like that when staying at any other adults house, why would you do it to your parents? Works the other way when parents infantile their adult children.
Tell your daughter no and stop pandering to her - she’s 27 and too old to be acting like a bossy spoilt child. Does she drive or does she expect you to transport her everywhere when she comes to stay too?

SeniorSausage · Today 13:19

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

Don't use the death of a child to try and guilt the OP into doing things she's not comfortable with. That is completely out of order.

My mum has experienced the death of one of her adult children. It doesn't mean she has to put up with people walking all over her or pitching up to stay for weeks on end just in case they die as well. She's allowed some down time.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:19

My in-laws were and are great hosts, always having friends and family to stay. We don't have to as we live nearby.

I can't think of a time they had someone to stay for more than a few days.

godmum56 · Today 13:24

Its simple
IT IS YOUR HOUSE
IT IS YOUR LIFE
IT IS YOUR CHOICE

C8H10N4O2 · Today 13:27

Pennyfan · Today 11:20

People help but there is still the planning and cooking-especially as Christmas is an occasion so the food has to be decent. Endless meal planning and washing up when you have six people there for several days-even if everyone helps to clear up, it’s a lot of effort-especially if the house isn’t the largest. It was lovely to be at my son’s last year and not have to do anything! I enjoy having people to stay whether family or friends but am always glad to get the house back-I once read that guests are like fish-lovely when fresh but go off after 3 days!

But the planning can be shared as well - 4DC and their partners and DGC, when they were younger DC, two sets of parents and random siblings/others. None of us do 100% of any task. If I was covering Christmas day, my parents might do Christmas eve planning, the in-laws Boxing day, I have one sibling who hated the food planning but was happy to be kitchen porter for the duration. Now the children are older each of them will cover a day and we roughly coordinate - some gaps arise and some dupes but it all works because everyone will muck in.

For me its very different from "Guests" who, as you say, are more likely to be an effort because you are hosting rather than sharing your home with family (if that makes sense!).

Ozzieozzie · Today 13:32

YANBU OP . My darling son came home from Australia in the summer for a few weeks l I was so happy 💙…but every few days he was off to visit and stay with friends. I was absolutely fine with that because it meant we had the house back to ourselves. We are certainly not set in our ways ,very sociable and see our other children regularly but you do ,regardless of your age get tired .
My son actually is the same in Oz and we did joke that we would ignore each other for a couple of hours.
Likewise when I visited him this time last year in Australia I had the odd day when I didn’t see him at all. I was staying nearby . He definitely needed his ‘ down’ time .

EvelynBeatrice · Today 13:39

Alondra · Today 13:05

I'm often aghast at how older people are disregarded against their adult children on MN,, It's like we don't exist with independent automony, finances, feelings, or capable to say "no" irrespective of adult children's feelings.

I raised my sons to be adults. We gave them everything we could from a loving home to be financially be solvent when they left Uni. Giving them everything we could as a stepping in a ladder to be independent didn't mean to be controlled/manipulared by them. We're always open to discuss issues but our children won't make decisions involving our independence and automony..

We've fucking earned it.

This!! If an adult child expects to be treated as an adult by their parent with all the autonomy, respect etc that should be accorded to a fellow adult, then the other side of the coin is that the adult child grows up enough to show the same consideration and respect to the parent.

Some seem to believe that parents - usually the mother - should always always come secondary to adult offspring and grandchildren. They’re seen as a service or a device with no right to personal autonomy or desires.

I think there’s also an element of extrovert v introvert. Many people need alone time away from even their most beloved. I would crawl over glass to see my kids, but I can’t be with others 24/7 - I need some quiet time.

AnnPerkins · Today 13:40

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:21

babyproblems · Today 22:14
I think it’s really mean of you - she’s your daughter! My mum would never say something like this.

Thanks - I am not meaning to be .

Oh ignore this bollocks! It is not at all mean, you don't have to sacrifice your own needs and wishes because your adult child has demanded it. Five days is a more than generous amount of time to host two additional adults in your home.

You sound much more concerned about her feelings than she does yours. She's clearly not alone though, judging by some of these replies.

MimiGC · Today 13:41

@Boomboomi I wonder if the reason your daughter doesn’t get on with her partner’s parents is because they don’t put up with her incessant demands for activities and time together?
Also, I know she’s an adult, but there need to be some consequences for unacceptable behaviour ie being rude to your friends when you bump into them. If it was me, the consequence would be a direct communication along the lines of ‘you embarrassed me in front of my friends, don’t do that again when we are out or stay home if you don’t think you can be civil’. Tough if she doesn’t like it.

Coconutcreamz · Today 13:42

OP, so what if she sees it as rejection.

You NEED to reject her thinking she CAN control the family home, and those in it when she visits.

Utter madness to be entertaining her and her thinking.

You have done her zero favours that at 27, she is so deluded and self absorbed.

plasticplate · Today 13:43

It would be different if she was going to be on her own over Christmas but since she isn't and has a partner she can do things with, it's fine. Or you can you are happy to have her longer but you won't be ' hosting' all that time and will be wanting to chill or do somethings with with friends or with your partner. She should be old enough to understand this.