Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

381 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

C8H10N4O2 · Today 10:50

LemonChilliDrop · Today 10:36

I dont think those berating you are reading this fully
Lets face it if this was a man he would be called controlling, quite rightly
Her behaviour is completely unacceptable
You are being perfectly reasonable to set boundaries, she needs to hear NO

Well she isn't a man she is the adult child in this situation so the dynamics are very different.
Nobody has told her she is annoying by organising so how is she supposed to know? She may well think she is making everyone's Christmas by organising so much "fun" for them.

The answer is to actually talk to each other. However if people have been nodding and smiling for years instead of simply say "no thanks" I can see how it has reached the point of the OP not wanting them there and the DD not understanding why which is a shame.

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Today 10:56

I just don't think limiting the visits is the best solution though. If you can thrash this out with her and get to a way of being around her so you are both more comfortable that would be far healthier than telling her you can't bear to be around her for more than a handful of days. There is a massive difference between saying "I can only stomach you for 5 days, unlike your brother" and "You're welcome here as long as you like but understand we will be doing xyz without you while you are here"

You say she complains if you see other people. Let her complain, have conversations about it. Her complaining doesn't have to be the end point, it's a step in the process.

ginasevern · Today 11:01

For fuck sake. She's 27, not 16, and she lives with her boyfriend! Some of the answers on here are wild. She'll be staying all over Christmas (boyfriend and all) and no doubt being fed and waited on hand foot and finger. Surely that's enough for anyone. Why in god's name would a "coupled up" 27 year old want to spend NYE with their 60 something parents anyway. If that's the sort of thing that gives grown women "rejection anxiety" (or whatever ridiculous psychological tag you want to give it) then there's something seriously wrong with her and society.

WhatNoRaisins · Today 11:02

I think you have to treat it like when a toddler is having a tantrum over something unreasonable.

"Yes I will be meeting Beth for coffee tomorrow morning, no I need to spend some time alone with her, you'll just have to find something else to do"

Pennyfan · Today 11:03

Is it really that difficult for people to understand that having several adults stay with you for several days with all the preparation, catering and looking after and entertaining isn’t tiring? My son and his wife are coming this. Christmas and asked me can I host this year as they did it last year and it was effort-they hosted us for the afternoon and evening! I’ve said yes of course but expect them to leave after 3 days. With other family coming during the period, all expecting to be fed and entertained, of course it’s tiring much as I love them all. I don’t think you’re unreasonable at all-especially if, as many young adults do, revert to being children. I wouldn’t expect my kids to be offended if I gave them a time limit-just say you would
like to have some time to yourselves and don’t be apologetic about it.

Millytante · Today 11:05

Wadsworthy · Today 09:17

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

Well, yes. She sees that her parents don't want her there.

That's pretty much the definition of rejection, no matter how old one is.

It is not.
To read her mother’s simple desire for consideration, for the return to her own life’s routines after a very tiring Christmas entertaining such demanding guests, is utterly egotistic, and should instead strike any woman of DD’s age as a fair suggestion.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 11:05

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

That's a pretty horrible thing to say to OP. You are basically telling OP that her DD will probably die and then she'll be sorry.

Farmerswalk · Today 11:08

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

Ridiculous thing to say. I've lost a child and would be pissed off with OPs dd's behaviour

Pennyfan · Today 11:09

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

There is always one isn’t there? I lost both my parents when I was 16-it doesn’t mean that I can’t accept people venting about their parents or other relatives. It’s called normal life. Why on mumsnet is there this thing about martyring yourself because other people have died?

C8H10N4O2 · Today 11:09

Pennyfan · Today 11:03

Is it really that difficult for people to understand that having several adults stay with you for several days with all the preparation, catering and looking after and entertaining isn’t tiring? My son and his wife are coming this. Christmas and asked me can I host this year as they did it last year and it was effort-they hosted us for the afternoon and evening! I’ve said yes of course but expect them to leave after 3 days. With other family coming during the period, all expecting to be fed and entertained, of course it’s tiring much as I love them all. I don’t think you’re unreasonable at all-especially if, as many young adults do, revert to being children. I wouldn’t expect my kids to be offended if I gave them a time limit-just say you would
like to have some time to yourselves and don’t be apologetic about it.

Do your DC not muck in and help? We always went to a set of parents and then with time they came to us but I've never had a family Christmas where the hosts wait on the family in the way assumed by some on this thread. In many respects I found it easier having everyone to us than travelling to them.

99bottlesofkombucha · Today 11:11

Lumpyteats · Today 00:01

I understand she pressures you. What I don't understand is why you are incapable of standing your ground.

And why your DD doesn't already understand that you're a whole human with a life, separate from her and her needs and wants.

She needs some firm words to put her straight. It'll be uncomfortable, but less hurtful (and more helpful to her) than just having her visits limited without a proper explanation.

'We love having you here but we can't spend every minute of the day doing things with you. It's exhausting. We need rest time, alone time, quiet time pottering around the house or we'llgo mad, and we do have lives of our own to live too'.

Any more whining from her just shrug. 'Sorry, I know you don't like it but that's the way it is.' (I'd personally add a 'The world doesn't revolve around you, you know!' only because she really sounds like she needs to hear it.

This- I understand perfectly what the op is saying about her dd but I don’t understand not saying of course I love you but I do need some downtime, your dad and I would be long divorced if we couldn’t have some time to ourselves or with friends. You seem miffed but for goodness sake at your age you must know that your parents are people too.’

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:11

Pennyfan · Today 11:09

There is always one isn’t there? I lost both my parents when I was 16-it doesn’t mean that I can’t accept people venting about their parents or other relatives. It’s called normal life. Why on mumsnet is there this thing about martyring yourself because other people have died?

It's just a wake up call that people aren't here forever.
I'm sure I'm right that we all probably have a relative we moaned about but would give our right arm to see again.
It's not being a martyr it's been releastic and perhaps reminding people to be thankful for what they actually got.

Carry on sending messages to a daughter like that and don't be surprised if it causes an atmosphere.

Gloriia · Today 11:13

Just be honest. 'We of course love seeing you but it's very intense and full on, if you'd like to stay then please do your own thing occasionally so we all get some chill time'.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:13

thepariscrimefiles · Today 11:05

That's a pretty horrible thing to say to OP. You are basically telling OP that her DD will probably die and then she'll be sorry.

Not horrible, realistic maybe.

WhatNoRaisins · Today 11:17

Do many grieving people feel better knowing that other people are martyring themselves over other people's difficult behaviour? It's not something that ever gave me any comfort in grief.

Pennyfan · Today 11:20

C8H10N4O2 · Today 11:09

Do your DC not muck in and help? We always went to a set of parents and then with time they came to us but I've never had a family Christmas where the hosts wait on the family in the way assumed by some on this thread. In many respects I found it easier having everyone to us than travelling to them.

People help but there is still the planning and cooking-especially as Christmas is an occasion so the food has to be decent. Endless meal planning and washing up when you have six people there for several days-even if everyone helps to clear up, it’s a lot of effort-especially if the house isn’t the largest. It was lovely to be at my son’s last year and not have to do anything! I enjoy having people to stay whether family or friends but am always glad to get the house back-I once read that guests are like fish-lovely when fresh but go off after 3 days!

NimbleTaupeTiger · Today 11:21

Being early 60s ourselves with medical conditions I think 5 days is generous. 23rd-27th inclusive of hosting DD plus partner is enough for anyone let alone people with medical conditions. We invite ours on Christmas Day and hope they'll be gone same day before 8pm 🤣🤣🤣. They are!

We all enjoy getting together but also enjoy our own space and if your DD wants to do everything as a group, sounds absolutely exhausting.

I think be firm and explain that DH finds being on the go all the time very tiring and that you feel 5 days would be both lovely and manageable. If she takes umbridge well ... You and DH can go to an hotel for a pampering Christmas instead. Win win!!

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:23

I would suggest a compromise, that she can stay as long as she likes but there are only going to be a couple of days of more structured family time (say Christmas Day and Boxing Day) but other than that we will just be chilling out, seeing friends etc.

Also why is she so needy at 23? Does she not have friends to do stuff with or a job to go to? DD1 (21) came home with her boyfriend for a few days, we saw her for probably a few hours of that as they had plans!

AlphaBravoGamma · Today 11:25

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:48

Wow and all the parents on here who have lost their kids or don't see them who would love this,and your moaning
Not one of the better posts I've seen on here.
Imagine if she wasn't here anymore OP. You never know what's round the corner for anyone.

Wow.

And perhaps the daughter ought to realise that her father has a health condition that her busyness is probably making worse

ginasevern · Today 11:29

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:23

I would suggest a compromise, that she can stay as long as she likes but there are only going to be a couple of days of more structured family time (say Christmas Day and Boxing Day) but other than that we will just be chilling out, seeing friends etc.

Also why is she so needy at 23? Does she not have friends to do stuff with or a job to go to? DD1 (21) came home with her boyfriend for a few days, we saw her for probably a few hours of that as they had plans!

Edited

Exactly. And she's not 23 she's 27 with her own home and boyfriend! It's utterly pathetic.

firelightphoto · Today 11:37

seahorsessky · Yesterday 22:05

A lot of people, at age 60 and younger, have serious medical conditions that cause fatigue. It's quite hurtful when people act like that is unusual, or belittle it. It is horrible, and people saying things like that make it worse.
OP, just tell her to go to his parents-say it's only fair they see them too. It's true, and solves your problem.

Can you just tell her this?

It seems like your messages are by text and given it’s a bit delicate it might be worth a phone call instead.

Just explain that the medical condition makes it very tiring and her requirement that you spend all your time with her.

Would a compromise like telling her she may stay but you won’t be doing group activities the whole time and if she wants to stay more than 5 days, she needs to aldo agree that you will need some days and evenings to just do your own thing with your own friends or potter about?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:38

ginasevern · Today 11:29

Exactly. And she's not 23 she's 27 with her own home and boyfriend! It's utterly pathetic.

Ah sorry, I misread and thought the 27 year old was another child.

FirmSnake · Today 11:38

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 11:23

I would suggest a compromise, that she can stay as long as she likes but there are only going to be a couple of days of more structured family time (say Christmas Day and Boxing Day) but other than that we will just be chilling out, seeing friends etc.

Also why is she so needy at 23? Does she not have friends to do stuff with or a job to go to? DD1 (21) came home with her boyfriend for a few days, we saw her for probably a few hours of that as they had plans!

Edited

OP moved away to a village. So which friends and work is she supposed to be occupied with when she has travelled a distance to visit her parents?

Alondra · Today 11:39

5 days staying is more than enough. However, I don't think that the lenght of her staying is the root problem. A 'ew posters have mentioned she wants to control being back home disregarding your feelings and husband's. I agree.

She is 27 y.o. and wants to control what happens over Christmas. She won't allow you to have a coffee with friends or go to the pub together. She's oblivious to your needs and that being older and with a DH with a chronic health condition you can't keep up with her full on organising organising schedule.

Much as you don't like it because she's your daughter, you need to make it clear to her than 5 days is enough. If she complains say the truth - you and DH are older and can't cope with entertaining every day in the way she expects you to. You both need time to relax/chill while having a minimum of independence against her expectations. She may not like hearing the truth but she needs to hear it loud and clear from you.

I don't understand why some posters are giving you grief about the different relationship with your DS. I'm 66, have 3 adult sons and they have different personalites. I love all of them the same but their different adult personalities don't make me blind - we've said "no" when one specially, treated us like servants to be organised how they wanted to.

Establishing boundaries with your DD may be difficult but the only way to do it is telling her the truth. She may not like it, kick off and have a tantrum, but it's essential for you and your DH to establish an adult relationship with her.