Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from will.......

214 replies

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

OP posts:
nauticant · Today 16:53

Another thing. You have in mind that your half brothers will each receive a quarter of the money from your Dad. The day comes when you're to make good on your promise and your brother says "none from me". You're super kind and hand over half of the money you received and your half brothers go "hang on, we get an eighth?!"

Soontobe60 · Today 16:53

Unless there’s a massive back story here it’s an awful thing for a parent to do to his children. He’s basically telling them that he didn’t actually care for them at all. If my father had done that, I’d have done a deed of variation to ensure my siblings received a share of that money. If my husband, who has a daughter and a step daughter, wrote a will like that I’d disown him!

PropertyD · Today 16:54

How much are we talking about? Your Mum could decide to take expensive holidays business class and the money will go very quickly. Or decide to give out sums of money to whomever she likes.

The money is for your Mum to do with as she chooses. You should not make promises re other people’s money.

JustMyView13 · Today 16:58

Keep it factual if and when it’s bought up. The will leaves everything to mum in the event she survives dad. (Which is what occurred). If they request a copy then share it. As for your mum it’s her choice what she does with her money. If she choses to call into question the paternity of one of the siblings then that’s on her as an adult (albeit spiteful unless it’s to legitimately defend a legal claim to the estate). The more you try to protect grown adults, the worse this will look on you.

changeme4this · Today 16:58

You’ve been put in a very awkward position by your Father.

did he tell you why he was excluding his first children ? Was it anything to do with having to start over and their mum retaining joint assets at the time?

in your position as Executor, you have to park up your personal feelings. Do NOT try to smooth things over by offering money you may not receive given time. Your mum may have care costs down the line that will have to be met with private funds. It’s not yours to give out beforehand…

DH’s cousin has just gone through similar and it ended up in court. There is now no contact between the siblings and a lot of hate. It was felt Cousin should have spoken up at the time the new Will was formed but they didn’t.

keep it formal and keep your emotions out of it. Give each person a copy of the Will instead of you doing it verbally. Brace yourself for a bit of push back.

MajorProcrastination · Today 16:59

What a difficult position to put you as the executor in.

What is your relationship like with the older two? This matters because would it be usual for you to be in communications with them?

It is sad that they had a large chunk of time in their formative years (in the 80s) without their Dad in their life but at least it does sound like some relationship was rebuilt. I think the brother who supported your dad with appointments would be more put out at being cut out but I'm just guessing.

A relationship with a family member isn't transactional so I doubt he helped out because he expected some money from it, more that it was just the right thing to do. I did receive some (small amounts of) money from my grandparents after their deaths but I honestly hadn't really thought I would. Perhaps it's different as they weren't wealthy and I have lots of cousins, aunts and uncles.

I wouldn't start promising money for a future date when your mother dies. I know why you've thought of it and you're very welcome to make that happen but what would happen if your mother needed extended and expensive care in her later years or some disaster means the money isn't what you thought it would be, or (heaven forbid), she doesn't approve of your decision and changes her own will to give her money to a charity.

Also, this isn't a pleasant thought, but what would happen if you died before your mum and that promise could never be enacted upon? It gets really messy.

It is important to be open and honest and transparent and I think your immediate recognition of this change in the will as something that feels inequitable and unfair reflects well on your personal values. So, do let your older siblings know, be clear that you legally have to stick to your dad's wishes, even though you don't agree with his decision and you know that this news will be upsetting to them.

Really sorry to hear that you're navigating this while also experiencing the grief of losing a parent. I hope you're being well supported.

Ilovelurchers · Today 16:59

I don't understand why you are getting such harsh responses - it's a tricky situation and you clearly want to do the right thing.

I am in a somewhat similar situation, in that my dad made a conscious decision to disinherit my half brother, leaving everything to me and my brother had my mother predeceased him. She didn't, and most of his estate has gone to her, though my full brother and I have each inherited a quarter of their property.

In my case, my half brother made the choice not to see dad for the last 11 years of his life (during which he battled dementia). Therefore I don't particularly feel compelled to give him much, should my mom pass and leave my brother and I a substantial inheritance. However he may be expecting a share of what was once dad's money, and that is something my brother and I will have to navigate sensitively should my mom pass before us.

I have no answers really. You know your half brothers and are best placed to know how you should communicate with them. If I were you I would speak to them both soon, let them know the money has all gone to your mom, but that you and your bro intend to share your inheritance with them if possible. (Just don't promise anything. Nobody can predict the future - you may not inherit as much as you expect to).

Good luck, and sorry for your loss. X

Eristealviper · Today 17:02

“After someone dies: Beneficiaries who would be worse off can agree to change how an estate is distributed within 2 years of the death using a variation (or deed of variation)”
https://www.gov.uk/alter-a-will-after-a-death

Change a will after a death

Changing an inheritance after death (a 'variation') and how it can affect amounts of Inheritance and Capital Gains tax due

https://www.gov.uk/alter-a-will-after-a-death

Banjas · Today 17:03

You sound like a really nice person @CalmAquaEaglewanting to be fair to your half brothers. As does your brother- he too thinks the will is unfair.
Often on Mumsnet we see the children of a first marriage starting threads where they feel they have been unfairly treated by a parent in comparison to their step siblings as a result of a second relationship.
Was your Mum the “other woman” ?

Nylonflares · Today 17:04

A deed of variation might have IHT implications here

PurpleThistle7 · Today 17:04

I am sorry for your loss. Came back to this as I think you didn’t really note that you too were left out of the will. In fact, no one was in it and your dad didn’t ensure any of you would benefit from any of it. So I can’t see any drama here exactly - unless you were all expecting and been promised an inheritance now. Blended families are complicated and all the examples in my family had mirror wills so it was all for the spouse to decide - my dad’s stepmom got everything when his dad died and my dad didn’t even get his family pictures or his mother’s mother’s family wedding ring. All pawned off to support his stepsisters drug habit. These things are so important to think about if you marry twice.

nauticant · Today 17:06

The OP doesn't have the power to make a deed of variation of her Dad's will. It would be her mother's uncoerced choice.

BoredZelda · Today 17:07

This is a dick move by your father. He left his two children once in his life then did it again in his death. Regardless of any money and who needs it or who spent time with him, that’s a shitty thing for a father to do. From a legal standpoint though, nothing can be done unless your mum wants to pass on a share. I would, in her situation, but it’s her choice.

Blueberrybonanza · Today 17:07

Nothing to do with you, it has all gone to your mum. It will come out when your mum dies as your dad wished.
Even your inheritance is not guaranteed she can change her will at anytime or it could all go in care fees

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Today 17:10

MissMoneyFairy · Today 15:54

No one should expect to be a beneficiary, the only person here that inherits is his 2nd wife, if the family spend money they haven't got that's their own fault, they can ask if they are receiving anything.

But they were told they were in the will. That had been communicated to them, they have no idea the will was later chaged if I read that correctly. In that instance, I can understand them expecting money.

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 17:10

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:12

Hello, they were told by dad they are in the will. They think they are getting something. Now they are not. A solicitor advised my dad to tell them, my dad didn't tell them.

Your dad's dead now. All bets are off. He chose not to tell them.

I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes

Why would you do that. Your mum might not leave anything to you, she might spend it all or it might all get spent on care home fees. You are in no position to promise anything. The money isnt yours and may never be.

Mossyfox · Today 17:12

Hoppinggreen · Today 15:09

Your Dad did his will according to his own wishes and he had a right to do so
I have no idea why you want to cause trouble and be all dramatic with your talk of telling people they have been "deleted from the will"
When and if you inherit anything you can share it how you want but your Mum doesn't have to

It's not up you to convey this information. You can't start promising money to people. It's not your money and no guarantee it ever will be. Just keep quiet.

GFBurger · Today 17:12

I agree with the majority, the will states the estate passes to your mum.

That is the end of the story really - it's not up to you to promise anything at this point, as you do not know if you and your brother will outlive your mum.

Sorry to say that, it's a horrible and morbid thought, but you can't promise anything that isn't yours yet.

Your mum might change her will, it sounds like that is unlikely too, but there are no promises to make to anyone at this stage.

If your mum wants to carve up her estate in her will and allow some inheritance to trickle down to the half brothers then that's her decision.

So sorry to the half brothers, but you can't change what has happened.

As to the actual question, soonest is best. Waiting until after Christmas is unnecessary and cruel. What if they overspend on Christmas as they feel some money is incoming?

Pipsquiggle · Today 17:15

Although this is incredibly awkward for you, as you seem like a nice person, you need to do your job as executor and let them know.

I personally would get the solicitors to write to them when they are allowed to do so, not sure why waiting until January will make the news any different to how they will receive it in December. Also you don't want them to have a 'blow out' Christmas with them thinking they will receive an inheritance in the near future.

Also @CalmAquaEagle I wouldn't be promising part of your inheritance to your half brothers at this stage. It's very well meaning but naive. There could be lots of future scenarios where you may not be able to keep that promise.
When your DM does die, make that decision at that point.

Lozlegs · Today 17:17

Well you are not fit to be if you don't understand you simply execute the will as per legal instructions, any thoughts you have are irrelevant.
The money is going to his wife anyway?!......

sesquipedalian · Today 17:18

OP, your DF was of sound mind when he died; his will leaves everything to your DM. Your half brothers may have had some expectations, but it’s not as though you’ll be getting any money now- it all goes to your mother, so as executor, that is what happens and your tell your brothers that no DC are getting money at the moment. How your Dm chooses to leave her money is up to her. For all you know, she may need to go into a nursing home and all her money will be used up doing that. I most certainly wouldn’t go round stirring up trouble by telling your brothers they’re excluded from the will, nor would I be making any promises about the future - you don’t know what will happen, and to do so might in fact be stirring up more trouble. When your DM dies, IF she leaves you something, then is the time to decide what to do with it - not now.

EdgyNewt · Today 17:18

@CalmAquaEagle - when your half brother said that his father had told him he was in the will, when was this? I'm assuming quite a while ago, probably before 2015 when it was changed??

It's quite straight forward though. Your dad left everything to your mum.

I don't think I'd say anything until they raise the subject, then I'd politely just say "everything was left to my mum when he made his will in 2015 - he probably wanted to make sure she had enough to live off in case she needed care".

I wouldn't even mention you giving them some money once your mum passes. Things like that tend to get remembered and twisted. Plus there might not be any left if your mum needs care.

If they want to contest the will, then deal with that if it arises.

Washingupdone · Today 17:22

First of all, you all have to wait until your mother dies. Some, if not all, may have to pay for her home care if she becomes unable to live alone.

Other than that, if your father used money, from the sale of property etc. bought during his first marriage, to buy another house or invest for his second marriage, that sum could be use, as a percentage in today’s money, as to what his first two sons could be given.

FridayPieday · Today 17:24

A marriage generally marries the money together as well as the people. This is reflected in the fact that there is no inheritance tax between husband and wife. That's why you generally get half of the money if you divorce. So your Dad leaving everything to his wife is what should have been expected.

Don't promise any money to your half brothers. It's not your money. You haven't inherited anything. You are just there to do what your Dad wanted. The fact they might be upset is their problem.

Vulpini · Today 17:24

NoisyMonster678 · Today 15:13

Wait until after xmas - but what ever you choose to do, regardless of their circumstances, make it so so that no one loses out as balance is key here and what ever you choose to do in the end, get a Solicitor to draw it up, and everyone who it concerns recieves a copy. They will know where they stand.

I disagree. They should not go against the father’s wishes. It’s his will.