Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from will.......

214 replies

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

OP posts:
PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · Today 15:56

I feel for you - I'll never understand how parents can write their own children out of their will (unless for some dastardly reason). Your Dad must have known the stress this would cause you, and the hurt to your half brothers.

I would tell them now OP - waiting till after Xmas just puts a huge weight on your own shoulders.

MyDpsanarse · Today 15:57

It doesn't sound as if your DM has any relationship with her DSS so I suppose she won't see them at Christmas anyway so hopefully she won't get into any quarrels with them about her will. Just tell them the truth Op, none of you were included in the will, hopefully knowing that might make it easier for you all. Say nothing about your DMs will, if they know she's cut them off it will damage your relationship with them, wait and see what happens when your DMs gone

Happyjoe · Today 15:58

Unfair of your dad.. esp not to tell them.
But there may not be anything of your mums to pass on to you either - she may change a will or need it all in nursing care fees. Just can't predict the future when we get on a bit.
I would just tell them the truth, I wouldn't mention that you'd give some to them just yet, just do it if and when the time comes. It's a nice thing to do - my siblings and I promised each other the same when dad was alive as he could be quite unpredictable and a bit vindictive.

Firefly100 · Today 15:59

This would have been easy had you not been the executor, but you are. I would crack on doing the job of distributing the funds to your mum and closing the matter down and don't raise it with your half brothers at all. You only need to tell people they HAVE inherited, not that they haven't. When they ask or raise it, state the truth - your DM is the only beneficiary of the will, Simple, to the point. If they ask for a copy, give it to them.
Personally I wouldn't set expectations they will get something from you - I can pretty much guarantee whatever the sum is, it will cause bad feeling if they are told to expect one. You also can't guarantee you WILL get an inheritance. Chances are good but she might change her will too or have nothing to pass on. If they ask what is in DM's will, tell them to ask her not you, you don't know. Sympathise with them that you agree their dad has treated them unfairly if you want, but stress you have no choice but to execute the will as written.
If they ask you to split your inheritance with them, answer 'I don't even know if I will inherit anything myself yet'

PrettyPickle · Today 15:59

@CalmAquaEagle So OP, ultimately, whilst you are the executor, your Dad has left his entire estate to your Mum, having updated his Will many years ago form the one that left something to his first family, He was wrong not to tell them of the update if he had already told them they were getting something and now they are not.

But I can see the issue. Had he left something to his children now, as surely he couldn't give to them without giving to you - where would that have left your Mum? Its not as if he has favoured you over them so this is not your fault. He could have left the house in Trust for the benefit of his kids, allowing your Mum to stay in the house but then I assume they would have been joint tenants which means the house falls outside the estate and becomes your mums anyway, so there is money within the estate too?

I understand the argument about waiting until after Xmas, to save peoples feelings but I would counter that those hopeful of inheriting may splurge at Christmas in anticipation of the inheritance they will not be getting.

I would be honest, this was not your decision, you Dad was a coward and ultimately your Mum could change her Will and none of you will get anything, It will be hurtful for your half siblings to come to terms with your Dads arrangements but this is not on you. And its not as if he has left it to you and your brother and avoided them.

Be honest, tell them that no-one inherits just now, everything goes to Mum but when your Mum dies, if you and your brother inherit from her estate, you will share with them and if your Dad did not challenge the paternity of one son, then that decision is made, he is his son and should be treated as such.

Being named as Executor by someone is a show of real love and trust but the reality can also be a big burden.

Sorry for your loss OP.

MissMoneyFairy · Today 16:00

None of his children are in his will so there's nothing to explain, telling one lad he's not even your late dad's son would be cruel and pointless, he'd only get a test from his brother agreeing to a dna, he can't get a dna test from his late father.

MatriarchCaz · Today 16:01

webbedfeets · Today 15:37

It isn’t normal to disinherit dc from a previous marriage. Many countries don’t allow it.

My husbands dad has been married to another lady for many years,

I assume when he passes all will go to his wife, and then when she passes, it will all go to her (and his) children, his half sisters. There has been little contact with his dad due to his wife's wishes and his dad not caring much.

It's sad really but this is what he expects.

Grammarnut · Today 16:01

NorthernJim · Today 15:22

It's probably too late now, but maybe you should have declined to be executor if you don't want to be the one executing the instructions of the will?

And you don't need to tell the brothers that they've been written out of the will, just what the current one states. In some ways it'll be easier because your mum is still alive - he's left everything to his wife, end of story.

But he did not. He left instructions that when his wife dies the estate is to be divided between their two mutual DC. Not sure how well that stands in law because it looks like a life interest in the estate and not leaving it absolutely. Feel for OP and think that her DF should have been a bit more thoughtful about his will.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · Today 16:02

TBH I’d have thought it entirely normal for the first spouse to die, to leave everything to the widow/widower. At least that’s what’s always happened in this family.

LadyWiddiothethird · Today 16:03

Completely normal for the wife to inherit all the estate! I did when I was widowed,my family have to wait until I die to get anything.

Presumptuous that your brothers just expected their Fathers will not to have changed over the years.Don’t promise them any money,you might end up with none anyway.

Namechangefordaughterevasion · Today 16:03

They weren't deleted from the will. That's overly dramatic. Circumstances changed and they were not included in the newer will.

As executor you have a legal obligation to do exactly what your father requested in his will. No more and no less.

My mum changed her will the year before she died. The original will split her sizeable estate equally between 3 siblings and 5 grandchildren. For some reason she changed it and it was split equally between the thee siblings only.

IMO my brother is an absolute waste of space. He is a deadbeat dad who hadn't contacted laid eyes on his children for over 20 years. He hadn't visited my mum for over 10 years. He doesn't work and lives on benefits and scrounging off whatever woman will give him house room. He didn't even talk to his children at mums funeral.

His two children (both young adults now) are lovely. First their mum and later the two of them made a lot of effort to stay in touch with my mum (not easy on a budget and a 700 mile round trip). They now stay in touch with me - they are a tribute to their mums parenting.

As executor it absolutely stuck in my craw to send my brother a life changing sum of money for being an absolute bastard whilst his two lovely children missed out. But it's what I had to do.

PrettyPickle · Today 16:04

Grammarnut · Today 16:01

But he did not. He left instructions that when his wife dies the estate is to be divided between their two mutual DC. Not sure how well that stands in law because it looks like a life interest in the estate and not leaving it absolutely. Feel for OP and think that her DF should have been a bit more thoughtful about his will.

Sounds to me like a standard mirror will, in that the first one to die leaves everything to the other, and then when the 2nd one dies, 50 percent goes to each of their children from that marriage. He has intentionally left his first kids out, which is sad.

Ethelspagetti · Today 16:04

I’d refer it to a solicitor and let them deal with it. They will need to be told though. I would not share out your money as your parents didn’t want that to happen.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · Today 16:05

webbedfeets · Today 15:37

It isn’t normal to disinherit dc from a previous marriage. Many countries don’t allow it.

I honestly didnt know that but have just looked it up. Its eye opening seeing how other countries deal with inheritance

Genevieva · Today 16:05

How do you know they aren’t in the will for when your mother dies? If you feel strongly about including them and they are excluded then you can do a deed of variation and divert a portion of your inheritance to them.

godmum56 · Today 16:06

so your mother inherits everything and you are the executor? What does your mother want done?
I don't think you can promise to give them money when you inherit from your mother. She may need it for care or leave it to the cat's home.

chirrupybird · Today 16:08

I just think your Dad wanted his wife to be well provided for in her old age, his children are well grown up and should be able to fend for themselves. They may have discussed his wife leaving money to all of the children in her will and she may or may not do so. It is very usual for someone to leave everything to the surviving spouse.

PrettyPickle · Today 16:08

@CalmAquaEagle Is there more than the house to leave? I only ask this because if its Joint Tenant ownership, when one dies, the ownership falls automatically to the other names owner, this is not something he can gift by his Will. So if there is only really the house, it may be that there is nothing to inherit until your Mum dies.

Not that it excuses him not asking for your half siblings to be included at that stage unless of course but if the house was purchased solely within his marriage to your mum and he felt the value was built in this marriage and eventually should be yours. Not excusing him, just trying to find palatable explanations.

Did he give part of a prior home to his ex when they split that perhaps the half siblings will inherit?

AutumnOakTree · Today 16:09

Unless I’m missing something thing, how do you knjw who your mother will leave her money to? She may leave it all to the donkey sanctuary? Or had a conversation with your dad and will honour your dad’s wishes and leave some money to the older siblings? Or spend it all on a round the world cruise.

ParkFirstDesk · Today 16:11

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:12

Hello, they were told by dad they are in the will. They think they are getting something. Now they are not. A solicitor advised my dad to tell them, my dad didn't tell them.

You will be very foolish to promise them something when your mum dies as there may not be anything if she has to pay care fees or you might have your own interests to look after. Nobody knows what is going to happen in the future.

nauticant · Today 16:13

I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

This is a truly terrible idea. Have this intention, sure, but keep it to yourself. You have no idea how things will lie when this becomes relevant, you'll be stirring things up, and you're setting yourself up to face an angry response and even legal action (which even if it were to go nowhere would be an utter pain to deal with) when, almost inevitably, they decide what you offer them isn't enough.

I think your motivation in this is to be seen to be kind. That's nice of you but you'll be making a rod for your own back.

CalmAquaEagle · Today 16:14

AutumnOakTree · Today 16:09

Unless I’m missing something thing, how do you knjw who your mother will leave her money to? She may leave it all to the donkey sanctuary? Or had a conversation with your dad and will honour your dad’s wishes and leave some money to the older siblings? Or spend it all on a round the world cruise.

Because she shared her Will with me.

OP posts:
TheGander · Today 16:14

This sounds awful for all children concerned ( and for this reason alone in most European countries including Scotland it is illegal to disinherit your children). Easily said there is doubt as to half brother’s paternity- sounds like your mum didn’t like them v much and was possibly stirring. Jeez. I have an uncle who left everything to 3rd wife, kids got nothing. Does not seem at all fair . Your Dad dumped you in it I’m afraid.

bellhawk · Today 16:15

Just say there was a new will which does not include them and they can verify it with the solicitors if they have questions

Also I would suggest you at least learn from this situation in one small way and don't copy your Dad by making promises about wills before the time comes - don't tell the half brothers that as a consolation you'll give them a share when your Mum dies.

TheCountessofLocksley · Today 16:18

I agree with previous comments. As executor you are responsible for administering the estate as per the wishes in the will. You are not obliged to tell people they are not beneficiaries.

if you inherit from your mum, she will make her wishes clear, ie she’ll include them or not. You’re asking for all sorts of family bother promising them you’ll give them some of your (potential) future inheritance. If you do inherit in time from your mum, you can always gift them something then but I’d not say/promise anything because circumstances change .