Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from will.......

214 replies

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

OP posts:
Sassylovesbooks · Today 15:37

I would execute the Will as per your Dad's instructions and say nothing to your half brothers. If they ask about the Will, give them both a copy. There's no point in telling them they were named in the 2005 Will but not in the updated version, it serves no purpose.

At this point I definitely wouldn't be promising your half brothers money upon receiving your inheritance from your Mum. You can't see into the future, and you have no idea if you'll be able to keep that promise. Your Mum's money could end up being eaten by care home fees etc.

You aren't responsible for cutting your half brothers out of your Dad's Will, so this situation isn't your fault. Unfortunately, you can't stop your half brothers approaching your Mum or from contesting the Will. It sounds to me if your Mum didn't have a relationship of any kind with your Dad's older sons, and for whatever reason, your Dad chose not to pursue a relationship with them either.

webbedfeets · Today 15:38

When I did my will the solicitor asked about previous dc & what would happen if one of us were to remarry.

B0D · Today 15:41

This is a difficult situation for you OP for two reasons (I think)

  1. half brothers were told they were in the original will and not told that had been rewritten. Therefore the decision will be the Elephant in the room if OP doesn’t mention it.
  2. it sounds as though you and your brother do have a relationship and like the half brothers so it will be awkward when it does come up.
If that’s all correct, in your shoes, I would tell them now in a personal level not as an executor. But don’t mention any future money that might be spent by the time your mum dies. If it makes you feel better, you could say you and DB would have split your shares with them if you’d been included in your dad’s will because it would have felt fairer, but that is only hypothetical as your mum inherited everything
MissMoneyFairy · Today 15:42

Has anyone actually seen the 2005 will,that stated your stepbrothers will be beneficiaries

Arlanymor · Today 15:42

Executors just execute the will, they don’t tell people who aren’t in it that they aren’t in it. You just fulfil it in line with the deceased’s wishes. If they ask for a copy you can furnish them with a copy. But that’s it. Don’t go promising future monies, you have no idea what the future holds and if those promises could or would ever be fulfilled.

tripleginandtonic · Today 15:42

I 4hink you should tell them and gift them the portion they thought they were getting when you inherit. Well done OP for seeing tge bigger picture a.d not being grabby like a lit of posters seem to be when it comes to wills.

FamBae · Today 15:42

Octavia64 · Today 15:12

This is absolutely not your problem in any way shape or form.

your dad died your mum inherited. End of conversation.

This

MissMoneyFairy · Today 15:42

Once your dad remarried he would have to,make a new will anyway

Zanatdy · Today 15:42

Just say it all went to your mum, which is true.

Holeymoley28 · Today 15:45

Surely they don’t need to know they were written out just simply he left all his assets to his wife.

You don’t need to make it harder than it is and tbh yes the child who may not be his should actually know that little bit on information for their own life.

FunGoldStork · Today 15:45

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

Your dad left his estate to his spouse, that is a pretty standard move, avoids inheritance tax on his death.

That's it, there is no way anyone can take any action or challenge the will in those circumstances.

Kay00 · Today 15:47

I am in a very similar situation to your half brothers where me and my siblings have been cut out of my grandparents will because my father who died before his parents had died. This has left a huge rift in the family and whilst I understand it was up to my aunts and uncle to respect my grandfather's wishes, as it is also up to you to respect your father's wishes, you will also have to expect it will lead to the breakdown of that part of the family.

There's no two ways about it. If your mother doesn't want that to happen then she can give them something or leave them something in her will. Otherwise it will lead to the breakdown of the relationships

FamBae · Today 15:47

FamBae · Today 15:42

This

Sorry, just seen your update that you're the executor. Bloomin eck op that's awkward. I would be inclined to tell them, not so well off brother might decide to splash out for Christmas if he thinks he's inherited.

ThatUmberCritic · Today 15:48

Sorry but why is your mum going to bring up the paternity issue , as if only biological children deserve to inherit?

Kay00 · Today 15:49

Furthermore, it really is up to you and your mum to fix the situation if you want to. If you want to retain those relationships, then you need to think long and hard about whether those half siblings should be included in any future wills, a token amount might mean a lot, it doesn't have to be 25 %.

If you and your mum decide not to, then those relationships will end. And that's it.

Cosyblankets · Today 15:49

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:28

Yes, her will excludes them, gives it to me and brother.

And it could all go on care fees don't go promising anything

Formyinvestment · Today 15:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DaisyDooley · Today 15:51

Hoppinggreen · Today 15:09

Your Dad did his will according to his own wishes and he had a right to do so
I have no idea why you want to cause trouble and be all dramatic with your talk of telling people they have been "deleted from the will"
When and if you inherit anything you can share it how you want but your Mum doesn't have to

This.
First post- As it often does -nails it.
Why on earth are you being so dramatic about this?

Whatwouldnanado · Today 15:52

This really isn’t your issue. As executrix your responsibility is to action the will and distribute as he wanted. He may have had reasons which are no one else’s business.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Today 15:52

My advice would be your solicitor writes to them to confirm they are not in the will. They might be spending money they think they will receive.

SleepingisanArt · Today 15:53

When my Mum died everything went to my father. There was a clause for what to do if he predeceased her but it was irrelevant because he was alive. When he dies my sibling and I will inherit 50% each if there's anything left (he's in a nursing home now) according to his wishes in his will. If I want to give anything to anybody else after his death then it's on me and from my share. But there might not be anything left due to care costs so I'm certainly not making promises I may not be able to keep. I suggest you do the same OP. Your dad wrote a will leaving everything to his wife - you need to respect that as his executor. When your mum dies if there's any money left you can deal with it then but only after the estate has been distributed according to her will.

Miyagi99 · Today 15:53

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:20

Me and my bro both want to give something out of our shares when mum passes, we are completely agreed on that.

Agreed is unfair, I don't want stress on my mum too as she's been through a very tough time but she will bite if they challenge now and I don't want xmas to be doubt over who one of their dads are.

They can request a copy themselves anyway, it’s a public document (less than £10 I think). I’d probably share the will but don’t make any promises or try to reason it.

MissMoneyFairy · Today 15:54

GeorgeMichaelsCat · Today 15:52

My advice would be your solicitor writes to them to confirm they are not in the will. They might be spending money they think they will receive.

No one should expect to be a beneficiary, the only person here that inherits is his 2nd wife, if the family spend money they haven't got that's their own fault, they can ask if they are receiving anything.

chirrupybird · Today 15:55

You don't say they are deleted from the will, they are just not included in the latest will. It is very common to leave everything to a surviving spouse, it will be up to your mum how she treats all her DH's children in her will. Nothing has happened to them yet, she may choose to include them or not. And what you do when your mum dies is hopefully far off.

PetulaGordeno · Today 15:55

Do not create trouble now by blowing this up it might you feel a bit better but it will just create a firestorm. Having witnessed something similar up close, don’t.
And in these emotional states we all start making promises - don’t.
Don’t do anything.
Your dad will have had his reasons and yes he’s left you in the shit a bit but it’s his will.