Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from will.......

214 replies

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

OP posts:
rosagarten · Today 16:37

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

What a thoughtful post! However, I don't think it is your responsibility to tell them. I would allow them to find out from the solicitor or presumably work it out when the solicitor doesn't contact them. The danger though if you tell them is that you become somehow caught up in it even though it has zero to do with anything you have done. I would advise you to ride this one out, make no promises as at present you have had no money from either parent. Sometimes less is best. Obviously if either of them pursue it with you, you can just point out that you had no part in it and are as surprised as they are (if that is true).

Good luck though, you sound like a thoughtful half sister - hopefully they'll see that they are lucky to have you, whatever decisions your parents made or your mother makes in the future.

Edit: If you do decide to tell them anyway then I would frame it that you have all been left out of the will but make no promises.

Haydugee · Today 16:37

Surely the message is that your father didn’t leave anything to any of his DC. Why make your half brothers feel singled out?

If your DM chooses to leave you and your brother something in due course – she may not - then that’s entirely separate. He didn’t remember any of his children in his Will.

EppingIsFun · Today 16:38

Pretty disrespectful of you to disregard your dad's wishes tbh. I would leave this well alone. Don't stir up drama telling them they have been deleted from the will, and promising them money you don't have. He left everything to your mum. That's it. It will tell them all they need to know, and they'll know not to expect any inheritance from him.

SamphiretheTervosaur · Today 16:39

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:13

I'm the executor.

Ok..that makes my response a little different.

  1. What you your inheritance from your mum if/when you get is up to you
  2. Your dad wrote his will as he chose
  3. As executor you don't have an opinion, you just have to ensure the will is fully enacted

As you know they expected to be included you can send them a copy of the will and that's it! But I would not do that. Get the solicitor to write to them saying he left everything to his wife

You cannot and should not even try to make future adjustments. Your dad did what he wanted to. Your mum will too. Then and only then can you make any decisions over whatever you may inherit

Aligirlbear · Today 16:39

CalmAquaEagle · Today 16:14

Because she shared her Will with me.

Even though you and your brother are in her will (and she doesn’t change it) there may be nothing left by the time she passes. Even if she doesn’t spend it all on holidays etc. she may need to pay for extensive care if her health declines which is incredibly expensive. Please don’t promise to your half siblings what might not be available when the time comes as this may well cause even more unpleasentness.

Based on the current will any inheritance you or your sibling / half siblings would inherit are irrelevant anyway as in the first instance it all goes to your mum.

Your dad has left you with a tricky situation to navigate but as executor you don’t need to use any emotive language about being cut out or removed from the will. You just say you are acting as executor on the terms of your father’s latest will.

Thatsalineallright · Today 16:39

Don't tell your half brothers you're going to share an unspecified amount with them. That way lies disappointment/entitlement/misunderstandings. Imo either say you will give them X% exactly or don't mention it at all.

TheDenimPoet · Today 16:39

sparepantsandtoothbrush · Today 15:11

Surely it's normal for the remaining husband or wife to be the beneficiary when the other passes away. Why on earth were any of you expecting to be in the will

To be honest, if I had children who weren't shared with my current partner, I would make sure they were left something in the will - otherwise they would just be completely left out as it would end up going just to the shared children.

Genevieva · Today 16:39

sittingonabeach · Today 16:31

Where there are DC from a previous relationship I would have thought mirror wills were not normal. and a solicitor would have advised accordingly. I assume the original will followed that advice. OP's dad then changed his mind

It certainly complicates matters but everyone I know in the OP’s situation has had parents with mirror wills, leaving years of uncertainty over whether the surviving step mother will leave them anything at all. Mothers tend to be more careful to ensure children from a first marriage are not excluded, but where the second wife has no prior family, the husband is much more likely to make no provision for his children from his first wife.

Newyearawaits · Today 16:39

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:12

Hello, they were told by dad they are in the will. They think they are getting something. Now they are not. A solicitor advised my dad to tell them, my dad didn't tell them.

I haven't voted OP.
You are clearly a very decent, caring person who doesn't want anyone to be hurt.
My question is why do you have to say anything within a specific time frame?
I don't have any advice as to when to tell them. They are likely to be very upset, understandably so. It feels like they are '' less than ' u and your brother.
Then the potential uncertainty re parentage.
Whatever decision you made OP, someone will be very upset.
Take care OP.

sittingonabeach · Today 16:40

FunGoldStork · Today 16:36

Exactly, it would be unfair to divvy the estate up and potentially cause the wife to have to move etc. Its entirely normal for the wife to inherit the estate, and then, if she wishes, deal with the fair distribution in her will.

It's quite common to give a life interest in the property to the spouse and then to DC after death where there are DC from different partners. MIL's will stated that DH's stepdad would have life interest in the house if she predeceased him, then when he died it would be split between DH and his siblings. As it was stepdad died first. He didn't have any DC. MIL still alive and kicking so will amended so will go straight to her adult DC on her death.

Bigcat25 · Today 16:42

You needtotell them asap. Being kept in the dark, just bc of christmas, will make things worse and more upsetting for them.

AutumnOakTree · Today 16:43

Haydugee · Today 16:37

Surely the message is that your father didn’t leave anything to any of his DC. Why make your half brothers feel singled out?

If your DM chooses to leave you and your brother something in due course – she may not - then that’s entirely separate. He didn’t remember any of his children in his Will.

Yes, true. Rather than navigating whether to give any or nothing to older and/or younger children, he chose to make it simple and give it all to his wife. Although that just passes the dilemma onto her…

Manxexile · Today 16:43

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:13

I'm the executor.

Then carry out your father's wishes

You don't have to approve or disapprove of them

Or if you don't want to be involved, renounce the executorship

It's not your problem

ItalianoSl · Today 16:43

Your Dad left everything to your Mum. Easy. That's all you have to execute.
Don't be looking into the future and fretting about £ that may or may not come your way.

UsernameHoarder · Today 16:44

What a mess.

Do NOT tell them you will give the money when your mum dies! There might not be any money! It would be really foolish to do this. It also doesnt erase or mitigate any potential potential hurt that the half brothers may feel about being written out.

Your duty as executor is to execute the will. That's it. So if you tell them you just stick to telling them the contents of the will. Dont use words like exclude or make it about them. You just state the will. Everything passes to my mum.

Hi John. I have dad's will here and as executor I felt I should tell you that everything goes to to my mum. It was written in 2015. I can share a copy with you if you'd like. Let's have a catch up.

InterIgnis · Today 16:45

I really wouldn’t make promises for the future. I think that’s a knee jerk response, and those often don’t age well. Calm down, don’t rush to any action here beyond the remit of your role as executor.

Fwiw, I don’t think promising a variation in future will ease the hurt. If the hurt is caused by them being left out, then that won’t change because you and your brother have varied your mother’s will. If they resent you and your brother because of your father’s choices then they may perceive you both as the chosen children as offering money out of pity and resent you for that too. Let it play out and see how the land lies before you make any decisions.

If your father wanted to have more of a relationship with his children it wouldn’t have mattered what your mother did or didn’t say to him. Your mother may have been unpleasant in her own right, but your father was an adult man with agency, and responsible for his own choices.

Manxexile · Today 16:48

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:13

I'm the executor.

Also I don't think people are "deleted" from wills.

You tell them they were excluded from your father's last will

that's it.

(Or if you prefer, not included)

BigSuse · Today 16:48

But he hasn’t left any of his children anything, the fact they wouldn’t have inherited had your mum died first is neither here not there because she didn’t die first. There is nothing to tell them. If you want to vary your mums will after she dies that’s up to you, but as it stands they wouldn’t be getting anything now even if they were in his will.

BerryTwister · Today 16:48

When you say your half brothers are expecting something in the will, do you mean they're expecting something now, before your Mum gets her share? Or are they expecting there to be a clause in the will that leaves them something when your Mum dies?
And did they know that the previous will included them?

PetulaGordeno · Today 16:49

I have witnessed a good family friend (wife) been left a whole sizeable estate and after several years of these battles where others got involved and stated what was fair/unfair, every single penny apart from a funeral was spent on her care.
Yes, she had children and also grandchildren but she needed care for a prolonged period of time and when she was still able to, she chose it for herself.
Then there was the chorus of anger - that’s our inheritance, mum.
Actually it was mum’s money and she spent it accordingly.
Older people give this stuff a lot of thought and do mirror wills for this reason.
Trying to access any kind of card can be a nightmare so to actually be able to pay for really good care - in the case I’ve mentioned it was really high standard residential care - then you’ve no idea of the pressures.

wildnwilde · Today 16:50

In the previous 2005 will what percentage did they get ? Was their a reason he changed it that you know of

Gloriia · Today 16:50

Obviously you tell them now. Just a brief 'just to let you know will states dm is sole beneficiary' and leave it at that. If they're expecting anything better to let them know sooner rather than later.

PropertyD · Today 16:51

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:20

Me and my bro both want to give something out of our shares when mum passes, we are completely agreed on that.

Agreed is unfair, I don't want stress on my mum too as she's been through a very tough time but she will bite if they challenge now and I don't want xmas to be doubt over who one of their dads are.

Do NOT promise anything when your Mum passes. She could live for 20 plus years with the last 5 years in a care home costing £100k per year.

She might choose to change her will and not tell you. You have then promised money to someone who isn’t even in your Mum’s will (you might not be too!!).

Your Dad was selfish to leave this job to you after telling half brothers they were getting something.

Manxexile · Today 16:52

And how do you even know that there is a question mark over the paternity of one of your half-brothers?

Keep out of it

sittingonabeach · Today 16:53

BerryTwister · Today 16:48

When you say your half brothers are expecting something in the will, do you mean they're expecting something now, before your Mum gets her share? Or are they expecting there to be a clause in the will that leaves them something when your Mum dies?
And did they know that the previous will included them?

OP says her dad told them they were in the will. He then revised the will and took them out but he didn't tell them that