Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from will.......

214 replies

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:03

Hello, need some help.

Dad died in September. Had a sizeable will, and left it all to my mum.

Dad had four kids, me and my brother from his second marriage. Then two with his first wife, many years ago in late 60s. We are all in 50's early 60's now.

For whatever reason, dads contact with my half brothers was next to nothing in the 80's, and then sporidac a few times a year in recent years. I think some of that is partly down to my mum, who has zero relationship with my half brothers, and my dad not seeming overly bothered. One of the half brothers had more contact and supported dad with appointments when he was unwell recently, the other didn't.

My problem is this. The half brothers think they are in the will for Dad. They haven't seen a copy and only I have recently from solictors. Half brothers are not in the will at all. Seems there was one from 2005 where they were, but a new will deleting them was created in 2015.

The one that spent more time with him is very wealthy, doesnt need any money, but will be devastated at being deleted from the will for that reason only, he is unlikely to be bothered about the money.

The other half brother, isn't in a great position, has a job etc, but still a mortgage etc and has to be sensible.

I am going to tell them they have been deleted from the will, and give them a copy of the last will. I am going to tell them I will give them some money when my mum passes, I don't know how much and when, but I want to give them something as feels like right thing to do.

My full brother wants to wait until after xmas, because it will cause alot of upset. Also, sadly, there is a doubt on paternity on one of the half brothers, and if they go to my mum/complain/take legal action, she will very likely tell them.

I want to get them told now, as I hate witholding the truth from them, and it doesnt feel like "I waited for a good xmas, and told you in Jan" is enough of the reason.

Don't know what to do, I am going to be devastated if a challenge comes up and my mum starts saying that one isn't even my dads child, is just going to drive a division in the family.

Come clean now, or wait until Jan?

OP posts:
Boomer55 · Today 16:19

People can leave money to whoever they want to. Receiving anything is a bonus, not a right.

PurpleThistle7 · Today 16:20

The thing is, nothing has actually happened yet - his will left it to your mum, it's your mum's will that isn't leaving them anything. It's not his money anymore, it's hers. She might spend it all on nursing care or cruising or donkeys or anything really. It's not an inheritance yet and your dad didn't actually leave anything to you either - it's her choice to split it between her children. I wouldn't say anything except that your dad left it all to your mum, the end. The rest is all speculative.

Edit to add - and definitely don't go off and promise anything. You have no idea what the situation will be if and when you inherit. My mother was tied up in knots about this but by the time her own mother passed away, every penny was spent on specialised nursing care as my grandmother lived years past when she had planned and had terrible health issues. You have no idea what situation either you or your mother will be in in the future so it's best not to make any promises.

sittingonabeach · Today 16:22

MissMoneyFairy · Today 15:29

How did his first marriage end, did his first wife receive money, I don't see why your mum is expected to include them in her will.

I don't think there is an expectation that OP's mum will leave them anything. That is the issue, the dad should have crafted the will so DC from first marriage don't miss out.

allthingsinmoderation · Today 16:22

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:13

I'm the executor.

as executor you dont have any responsibilities to non beneficiaries of the will.
The contents of the will are private (until after probate if probate is needed,
I can see why you might want to manage family expectations though.
Its a shame your Dad didnt discuss his wishes with his sons or a least leave a letter of explanation.
People can leave their estate to whoever they please (with some exceptions)
Something akin to this happened in my family. My husband dies aged 48 yrs and his mother changed her will 6 months after my husband died. She removed our children and left her estate to her daughter(my husbands sister) and her 3 children. My husbands sister was executor and never discussed anything with my children. My children were shocked when they got a copy of the will after probabte was issued. they felt upset that their grand mother disinherited them after their father died,it felt as if they matter to her only whilst ther father was alive and it was painful for them. No one explained why and i think an explanation would have helped.
Good luck

PigletJohn · Today 16:25

sparepantsandtoothbrush · Today 15:11

Surely it's normal for the remaining husband or wife to be the beneficiary when the other passes away. Why on earth were any of you expecting to be in the will

This is not always good plan if you are imagining that the spouse will eventually pass it on to the children.

Puzzledandpissedoff · Today 16:26

FOJN · Today 15:31

You can inform them of the contents of the will but I think you should avoid getting involved in any discussion about your dad's decision or issues around paternity. It sounds like your mum is sole beneficiary and you have no authority to change who receives what.

Do not promise anything in the future. You have no idea if your mum will require care or what your own financial situation will be at that point in time. If there are funds available and you are well placed after receiving your inheritance you can decide what to do then. If you make a promise now there could be resentment later if they don't feel they received what they feel they are due. Do not create a problem for future you.

They may be angry and feel unfairly treated, they are allowed to feel that way, it is not your job to fix what your dad broke. Tell them you only recently became aware of the changes your dad made and fulfill your role as executor. If they make a challenge there is nothing you can do to stop that so you shouldn't try.

Sensible as always, FOJN

The only thing I'd add is that after probate they may well apply for a copy of the will anyway, but it'll be the mum's money then, OP will have discharged her duty as executor, and if they have any queries they'll have to take it up with the mum

Genevieva · Today 16:27

CalmAquaEagle · Today 16:14

Because she shared her Will with me.

Tell your half brothers, but say both you and your full brother are agreed on a deed of variation to give them something when your mother dies, assuming there is anything at that point (you never know if she will need to pay years of care home fees etc). It is actually normal for spouses to have mirror wills that leave everything to the surviving spouse in the first instance, so this part of the will should not be a surprise. Offspring don’t normally inherit until both parents have died.

caringcarer · Today 16:27

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:13

I'm the executor.

That's irrelevant. You just tell your brothers that your Dad left everything to your Mum which is very normal. After your Mum died and it comes to light she has not left them anything then you can consider offering your brother's a share of your inheritance but don't expect or pressure your other siblings to do likewise.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · Today 16:27

Don't wait until after christmas. If they are in your life sufficiently to affect anything about christmas then keeping this secret is a shitty thing to do.

Don't be dramatic about it. Just let them know that the latest will from 2015 leaves everything to your mum. Don't make promises about what you will do when you inherit.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Today 16:29

sparepantsandtoothbrush · Today 15:11

Surely it's normal for the remaining husband or wife to be the beneficiary when the other passes away. Why on earth were any of you expecting to be in the will

Because generally speaking parents leave their estate to their children with a lifetime interest for living in a house for any subsequent long term partner.

Hankunamatata · Today 16:29

They dont need to know. All they need to know is everything got left to his wife and that she hasnt decided about her will - white lie

caringcarer · Today 16:29

Also by kicking the can down the road until after your Mum dies it means the question of paternity wont come up.

PigletJohn · Today 16:29

Genevieva · Today 16:27

Tell your half brothers, but say both you and your full brother are agreed on a deed of variation to give them something when your mother dies, assuming there is anything at that point (you never know if she will need to pay years of care home fees etc). It is actually normal for spouses to have mirror wills that leave everything to the surviving spouse in the first instance, so this part of the will should not be a surprise. Offspring don’t normally inherit until both parents have died.

I think it is a mistake to raise expectations for something that may or may not happen at some future date.

Genevieva · Today 16:30

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Today 16:29

Because generally speaking parents leave their estate to their children with a lifetime interest for living in a house for any subsequent long term partner.

That’s not true. Most couples have mirror wills leaving everything to the surviving spouse in the first instance, as this is an IHT exempt transfer.

nauticant · Today 16:30

Imagine this scenario. You promise to give your brothers a future inheritance in order to feel good about yourself, half of the money from your Dad gets used up in care home fees for your Mum, she dies and you kindly say to your half brothers "here's your share of Dad's money, it's the remainder that's been split 4 ways" and your half brothers go "no, you and your brother spent half of Dad's money on looking after your Mum, not ours, me and my brother expect half of the original amount".

Don't make financial promises you don't know whether you'll be able to keep especially when what you might ultimately offer would be far less than what's been expected for years.

sittingonabeach · Today 16:31

Genevieva · Today 16:27

Tell your half brothers, but say both you and your full brother are agreed on a deed of variation to give them something when your mother dies, assuming there is anything at that point (you never know if she will need to pay years of care home fees etc). It is actually normal for spouses to have mirror wills that leave everything to the surviving spouse in the first instance, so this part of the will should not be a surprise. Offspring don’t normally inherit until both parents have died.

Where there are DC from a previous relationship I would have thought mirror wills were not normal. and a solicitor would have advised accordingly. I assume the original will followed that advice. OP's dad then changed his mind

PashaMinaMio · Today 16:31

RedLabel · Today 15:18

Don't be promising future money you have no idea if you'll even inherit anything. She might blow the lot, remarry or leave it all to a donkey sanctuary.

This isn't your problem at all. Your Dad left everything to his wife, that's the end of it.

I’m sorry for your loss. I’m sure you’ll miss him. 💐

Keep your thoughts about your half brothers to yourself!

Just get on with executing the will as per your dad’s wishes.

Use a solicitor for probate process if you need to. Fees will come out of your dad’s estate prior to disbursement so no actual cost to you. In my recent experience, legal fees were worth every penny.

It will cost your half brothers a huge amount of money to contest what is an up to date perfectly executed will so leave them
out of any disclosures. If you pre-empt matters and say things like “deleted from the will” those kinds of words sound quite inflammatory.

Further more don’t go promising them anything “after mum passes.” It’s not your place to foretell that.

IF you do say anything to yr half brothers say it gently otherwise you might come over as gloating. It’s a sensitive issue maybe left to a solicitor to divulge. Might be better coming from a 3rd party? Take advice.

It’s a shame but your dad had his own reasons at the time for leaving his two previous sons out. You are nothing to do with that. Play dumb.

There’s no point in having a will if it’s not abided by.

Good luck.

Paganpentacle · Today 16:32

Hoppinggreen · Today 15:09

Your Dad did his will according to his own wishes and he had a right to do so
I have no idea why you want to cause trouble and be all dramatic with your talk of telling people they have been "deleted from the will"
When and if you inherit anything you can share it how you want but your Mum doesn't have to

This.
Its not your will.
It's really none of your business who your dad left - or didnt leave- money to.
Lets the solicitor deal with it.

PrestonHood121 · Today 16:33

I wouldn't go into a ton detail with them if it comes up. "Everything was left to Mary." I wouldn't elaborate. A simple, "I'm following the current will and everything was left to Mary. Yes, I do understand it seems unfair." Down the road, if you inherit and want to share, that is a lovely gesture but I dont think all the specifics need to be hammered out just yet. They are adults and should have a reasonable understanding that spouses inherit 100% in many, many cases. Hopefully they will be given something by their own mother when she passes.

Jaxhog · Today 16:33

It was your Dad's choice to leave everything to his current wife. This is not unusual tbh - it's exactly what my dad did. It's unfortunate for them, but there is NOTHING you can do about it, as it their choice. Equally, it is absolutely your Mum's choice to whom she leaves everything she now has, regardless of how much came from your Dad.

I agree that it was a bit shitty of your Dad to leave it to you, his executor to have to tell them of the changes to his will. I was almost in a similar situation last year with my Mum, as she tried to change her will just before she passed. Her proposed amendments were because of an imagined slight, which would have split the family badly. I was the executor and she told me not to tell anyone either.

I would also echo a previous responder who said using a solicitor was good value. It may be slower, but it gives you much peace of mind. But get a fixed price. They then do any disbursements etc. exactly in accordance with the latest will and do the probate part, pay bills etc. I also went so far as to share a copy of the latest will with my siblings - without comment. It isn't your responsibility (even as executor) to explain the contents or make any side offers.

Good Luck.

sittingonabeach · Today 16:34

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:12

Hello, they were told by dad they are in the will. They think they are getting something. Now they are not. A solicitor advised my dad to tell them, my dad didn't tell them.

When your dad revised his will was that with full capacity and no coercion from anyone

Genevieva · Today 16:34

PigletJohn · Today 16:29

I think it is a mistake to raise expectations for something that may or may not happen at some future date.

In general I think you are right. This is why it would need a caveat, but the OP seems adamant and also wants to alleviate upset, so it would achieve their aim of sibling harmony. I think over sharing is a mistake. Any earlier will is irrelevant. And the OP’s mother is free to change her will in the future to leave everything to charity, so guarantees are impossible. Plus, the OP’s full brother may feel pushed into agreeing with the OP, but when the time comes, he may need his full inheritance. She should tread carefully, stay factual and not over promise, but I think something needs to be said kindly.

Grapewrath · Today 16:34

Keep out of this one- who knows what the future holds?
your dad was a proper spiteful twat to do this and leave you in the firing line.
Walt until the will is read and let them see your Dad for who he was. This is not your problem

Coconutter24 · Today 16:35

CalmAquaEagle · Today 15:16

His will sent everything to mum if she was alive, which she is. If she wasnt, it gave 50% to me, 50% to brother, nothing to half brothers. When mum passes, unless she changes it, me and my bro get 50% each.

So why don’t you tell them only your mum inherited from your dad and no one else did? You haven’t inherited any money either if your mum has it all

FunGoldStork · Today 16:36

LadyWiddiothethird · Today 16:03

Completely normal for the wife to inherit all the estate! I did when I was widowed,my family have to wait until I die to get anything.

Presumptuous that your brothers just expected their Fathers will not to have changed over the years.Don’t promise them any money,you might end up with none anyway.

Exactly, it would be unfair to divvy the estate up and potentially cause the wife to have to move etc. Its entirely normal for the wife to inherit the estate, and then, if she wishes, deal with the fair distribution in her will.