Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
B1anche · Yesterday 10:57

Happylife32 · Yesterday 10:54

YABU. What a fuss about a key being cut. She probably had it cut in case you needed her to pick up your child again in another emergency. You surely don't imagine that she's going to use it to snoop around your house. Someone else having a house key can be very useful.

Oh my god, the point is that SHE DID IT WITHOUT ASKING!! Why are people finding this so difficult to understand.

koffielepeltje · Yesterday 11:00

RudePhthaloDalmadoodle · Yesterday 01:29

I'd be careful even if you get it back from her or change the locks; she'd only needs a minute alone with the key to make an impression in her makeup compact and get a new one cast in secret. However, I'd also suspect that if confronted she'll plead good intentions and pretend not to understand the issue: after all, she DID tell you she'd had it made!

I'd be pretty cross, too, if either my late mother or my late mother-in-law had got a key cut for my house without discussing this first but I doubt there are too many mothers and mothers-in-law making impressions of keys in their Max Factor compacts and nipping into Timpsons for a copy. 😂

LoveItaly · Yesterday 11:00

If nothing else, this thread has shown the appalling level of reading comprehension that exists today.

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · Yesterday 11:04

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 10:42

Read the rest of the post... i didn't ask.

It's Mumsnet, @TiredAF123 , more half the posters can't read properly :) Just ignore 'em

Happylife32 · Yesterday 11:04

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:36

Don't see the need. We both work remotely. One of us is almost always at home. If we leave the country, we leave a key with a trusted neighbour.

So you leave a key with 'a trusted neighbour' but you object to your MIL having a key. You obviously don't trust her then.

FOJN · Yesterday 11:04

This type of threads highlights how poor the reading comprehension of the general population is and how many people assume their boundaries are universally held. It explains why so many people have complicated relationships with friends and family.

TheMarkleDebacle · Yesterday 11:08

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:35

Thank you for all the comments! Some really balanced perspectives here. Some thoughts...

  1. It's almost definitely done with good intentions. But good intentions doesn't mean it's ok. She should have asked us first. It's our house and our key. Nobody else has copies of our keys.
  1. It's our choice not to give out keys to our house! I appreciate that lots of people here are happy for family members to have spare keys. That's your choice. Choice being the word there to focus on!
  1. Yes there is obviously a back story. There always is! She is a wonderful MIL. We get on very well. Never had an argument or disagreement. However, she often oversteps, can be quite the project manager, makes decisions without discussing them with us first in relation to our family and assumes we will go along with it. I don't want to go into the specifics on here. I usually speak to DH about it and if we deem it worth a discussion, he will talk to her about it. All of this past behaviour makes me think that now she has a key, she might let herself in for some reason, to do something she feels is helpful. But we don't want that. It makes me feel very uncomfortable.
  1. DH agrees that her intentions are mainly good, but that she can be overbearing and not consider our wishes at times. He is very good at discussing these things with her if necessary. They have a great relationship.
  1. I won't be changing the locks. That feels a bit much for me, but thanks to those who suggested it.
  1. I think DH will have a word. Let her know that it wasn't ok to do it without asking. Explain that nobody has keys to our house, we don't see the need. In 8 years we have never felt the need to have someone have a copy. If she offers to give it back, we will accept. If she doesn't offer, I'd probably just let her keep it to save the argument and awkwardness. But if she ever used it in a way that was inappropriate, we would ask for it back. We have cameras.
  1. Lastly, as I've already said, we don't rely on her for childcare. This was a one off where she wanted to spend time with our youngest boy. But for those suggesting that if we DID rely on her for childcare, that we should basically let her away with doing this, we can't have it both ways etc... I highly disagree! No matter what your arrangement, you should always feel safe to hold boundaries in your own home.

Do you have security cameras or ring doorbell? Would you know if she did let herself in?

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:09

Happylife32 · Yesterday 11:04

So you leave a key with 'a trusted neighbour' but you object to your MIL having a key. You obviously don't trust her then.

Well, she went and made a key without asking our permission. So I don't fully trust her judgement of what it ok and what is not ok to do when it comes to our home.

Big difference with leaving a key with a neighbour for a week holiday and having someone have permanent access to your home.

OP posts:
HighlandsSnow · Yesterday 11:09

Would she ever use it? I have a key for my parents and sisters house and they have one for mine, none of us have ever used them, but I thought this was quite a common thing? We do it incase one of us ever loses our keys and is locked out.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:09

TheMarkleDebacle · Yesterday 11:08

Do you have security cameras or ring doorbell? Would you know if she did let herself in?

We do yes.

OP posts:
SandyCastles · Yesterday 11:10

It is a little odd, unless she is thinking it will be a regular event?

If she is a genuinely helpful person, then I think you're blowing it out of proportion, there's no need to get furious or make a big deal of it, just get DH to tell her that for security reasons you don't want copies of keys to your house anywhere but with you and ask for it back.

Asking for it back is no cheekier than making a copy without consent.. so really it's just a mistep on her part that can be rectified.

Unless there's a drip feed, then there's no need to make a massive deal of it.

cuddlebear · Yesterday 11:11

Obviously she knew she had to give it back or she wouldn’t have made a copy of the key. Definitely cheeky fucker territory.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:13

HighlandsSnow · Yesterday 11:09

Would she ever use it? I have a key for my parents and sisters house and they have one for mine, none of us have ever used them, but I thought this was quite a common thing? We do it incase one of us ever loses our keys and is locked out.

She might use it. I don't know. And that's what makes me uncomfortable. I can't explicitly say that I trust she would never use it. Because she has done things in the past that we did not want to happen, all good intentions I think. She has a problem understanding boundaries.

This doesn't mean i don't like her, as previous posters have suggested. She is wonderful and the children adore her. She sometimes oversteps and makes me feel inferior in my own home. And I am uncomfortable with her having a key to my home. But I am most uncomfortable that she made herself a copy without asking us first.

OP posts:
TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:17

SandyCastles · Yesterday 11:10

It is a little odd, unless she is thinking it will be a regular event?

If she is a genuinely helpful person, then I think you're blowing it out of proportion, there's no need to get furious or make a big deal of it, just get DH to tell her that for security reasons you don't want copies of keys to your house anywhere but with you and ask for it back.

Asking for it back is no cheekier than making a copy without consent.. so really it's just a mistep on her part that can be rectified.

Unless there's a drip feed, then there's no need to make a massive deal of it.

It won't be a regular event. We have a childminder.

Sorry, I don't understand what you mean by drip feed?

There is a difference between being helpful and overstepping.

Help needs to be offered and accepted. Help that is pushed upon someone without their consent isn't help. It's overstepping.

OP posts:
lirfvhb · Yesterday 11:18

No this is super odd. My Dsis has a key that she keeps at our house (which has been extremely useful when we've got locked out on more than one occassion!!) but to copy a key without asking is totally bizarre and not on

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:18

DH is going to speak to her about it. Thank you all so much for your comments!

OP posts:
SpainToday · Yesterday 11:21

You should tell your DH that until he reclaims the key (or has the locks changed) there will be no more s*x, because you can't relax when you're worried about being interrupted.

Widow90210 · Yesterday 11:30

My MIL would absolutely do this and is why she has never been given a key in the 12 years we lived in our house, others have spare keys, because I can trust them not to go though our draws, I cant trust her not to and so it makes me anxious if she had the opportunity. We had a previous property which she had an emergency key for and she abused it by being nosy and overstepping. She never got the chance a second time.
Massive overstep

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:33

SpainToday · Yesterday 11:21

You should tell your DH that until he reclaims the key (or has the locks changed) there will be no more s*x, because you can't relax when you're worried about being interrupted.

Hahaa!! While I would never withhold that particular joy, I did mention to him that one of my fears is that they show up, don't get an answer at the bell and let themselves in during one of our child free afternoons! That certainly got him thinking!! A reminder that we both work remotely and all children are of school going age... we take our opportunities where we can 🤣

OP posts:
Mich1986 · Yesterday 11:33

My mil had a key for when she used to look after our son, but then started using it at other inappropriate times and letting herself into our house when visiting, instead of knocking and another time went over and sat in our house and had a coffee when we were abroad etc. DH had a word and got the key back luckily, so get yours to have a word and say she doesn’t need a spare, set the boundary straight away.

FlotsamJetsamsam · Yesterday 11:52

Astonished that 11% of people think YABU!

It's clearly insane to have a key cut for someone else's house without asking first, the audacity! Bizarre that some posters can't see the difference between that and being GIVEN a key to hold onto (several family members have keys to my home; I'd still be shocked if anyone got a key cut for themselves without asking!).

I'd definitely change the locks.

hallomynameisinigomontoya · Yesterday 11:56

I wouldn't say anything to her.

But, I would read about anti-snap locks and decide it's a good idea to change to those. They're far more secure and your home insurance will like them.
If you already have them, then perhaps your home insurance recommended a different brand that needs a code to cut new ones, and you decided to swap to them.

I wouldn't even tell her you've done it, act like it was a non-event. She'll find out when she tries to use hers.

BrassyLocks · Yesterday 12:11

My ex-in-laws did this too, with ex not seeing anything wrong with it, even though the house is mine. They then proceeded to let themselves in without warning - no phone call, no ding of the bell to let me know someone was at the door. I'd be doing something, maybe not dressed and not guest ready and suddenly I'd hear the key turn in the lock. I told them they could have it while they were visiting (they live far away, and would stay in hotels near us) but they absolutely could not take it away with them. Your MIL should have asked first.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:12

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 10:17

we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon
So yes, she did ask.

So what? That didn't give the MIL the right to get a key cut to house that isn't hers.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 12:14

WimbyAce · Yesterday 10:21

It is odd she has done it without asking first but as others have said both sets of our parents have the key to our house and vice versa. It does sound like you don't like her very much which is a shame.

I love mine. She doesn't have a key to our house.