Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · Yesterday 13:45

Honestyatalltimes · Yesterday 12:44

The majority of people voted YANBU. I'm interested to know if it was their own parents would they vote the same way. We have keys to son & dil house but I agree its a bit much to make a copy before asking.

Yes, I would. It doesn’t matter which parents, it still wrong when the homeowners weren’t asked.

My parents and in-laws don’t have a key to our home nor would they make ones without asking and vice versa.

Their house is not mine and our house is not theirs.

Plus, there is the topic of home insurance. If a family member lets themselves in and causes damage in the home by accident, it may not be covered depending on the circumstances and policy.

Luckyingame · Yesterday 13:47

Opus3 · Yesterday 00:04

Change the locks. What an odd thing for her to do.

Even "more odd" not to keep it quiet afterwards. 😂

SanFairyAnnie · Yesterday 13:48

Install a key safe. When next you see mil ask for "her" key to go in the safe. Don't tell her the pass code.

Tisthesesaon · Yesterday 14:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

outerspacepotato · Yesterday 14:03

She overstepped when she had a duplicate key made without even asking if it was ok with you guys. She's one of those would rather ask for forgiveness than permission.

Change your locks, don't tell her. Your husband needs to get the key back and tell her she overstepped and no, she can't have open access to your home. People who overstep like that should not have access to your home.

DND locks really aren't enforceable, you can get those copied at a self service machine or home improvement store. You're always going to have to keep an eye on her because she feels entitled. If you don't have a doorbell camera, get one. She's tricky.

Beerhy · Yesterday 14:12

Momon45 · Yesterday 08:15

I'm a MIL , all my kids and partners have given me keys and I them . If it bothers you then change the locks but never ask her to do childcare for you . You can't have it both ways .

How weird that you’d withhold help if your children or their partners wanted to keep their own house private. Very controlling tbh and totally not the same thing at all.

Tulipsriver · Yesterday 14:18

I have give a few people keys to my house incase of emergencies, but if anyone made one without asking, I'd change the locks.

I'd worry that anyone who would overstep to that degree would think nothing of letting themselves in uninvited and unannounced.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:20

OffTheMap · Yesterday 13:21

No doubt she thought it could be useful in the case of emergency school pick up or whatever.

She TOLD you she had it so obviously she had good or at least reasonable intent. She didn't keep it a secret.

I understand you feel it is a bit much - but your reaction is OTT and you risk a permanent rift and hostility.

Edited

How is it OTT?

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I couldn't cope with the lack of privacy in a situation like that. Everybody and their Granny has a key to your house?

Pallisers · Yesterday 14:31

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 14:26

I couldn't cope with the lack of privacy in a situation like that. Everybody and their Granny has a key to your house?

Most people who have a key to your house wouldn't dream of using it without your permission so it isn't really a risk. My neighbour has my key as does my cleaner, the woman who sometimes minds the dog, and maybe another friend (can't quite remember -I know we have theirs). I'd bet my house and pension that not one of them would ever use it without my permission.

I wouldn't be happy at all with anyone making a copy without my permission. Personally I'd say nothing but change the locks.

FreyaW · Yesterday 14:35

Well out of order. Not on.

Rachelshair · Yesterday 14:41

If she lets herself in unannounced you'll have an even bigger row, so best to ask for it back and risk a small row now. You'll be waiting on tenterhooks for her to use it otherwise. Taking a key without asking is totally different from being given one.

PuggyPuggyPuggy · Yesterday 14:43

a) People deciding to give a close family member a spare house key.

b) People deciding to give themselves a spare key to someone else's house.

I can't believe how many people on here think b) is normal 😲

Tortielady · Yesterday 14:49

I'm the first to tell you that I'm as territorial as a wolverine with a hangover, so my opinion can be taken with a family-sized pinch of salt. I've got/have had family members who range from egregious boundary stompers to completely hands-off and aloof and none of them behave like @TiredAF123 's MiL. I think I'd be really angry with anyone who pulled a stunt like that. The fact that she had your key for an afternoon and snuck off to get it copied suggests she's had this in mind for a while and only needed an opportunity to apply it.

I would be wary of assuming that the copy she has is the only one out there in the wild; should you have a break-in and there are questions about who might have a key, your insurance claim might be refused. On that basis, changing your locks seems like a basic precaution; you might decide that something more wrap-around like Uliton would be better. As to whether you tell MiL about your changed arrangements, that too is something only you and your DH can decide. Telling her lets her know that her shenanigans will have consequences. Not telling her means you'll know if she ever tries to put her copy of your old key to illicit use.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 14:49

Havingitallnot · Yesterday 12:17

I have a key to my DS and DIL’s house, they have a key to mine. Isn’t this what families do?

Not all families are the same. I'm astonished at how many people on here seem to think that everybody is the same and has the same kind of relationships as they do.

CountryMouse22 · Yesterday 14:53

Have the locks changed!

Tortielady · Yesterday 14:55

PuggyPuggyPuggy · Yesterday 14:43

a) People deciding to give a close family member a spare house key.

b) People deciding to give themselves a spare key to someone else's house.

I can't believe how many people on here think b) is normal 😲

If I was related to b) I'd move without leaving a forwarding address! I can't imagine living in a house where family members not even living with you thought you'd less right to privacy than you'd give your teenager in the bedroom next to yours. Absolutely insufferable.

Coconutcreamz · Yesterday 14:55

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:33

Hahaa!! While I would never withhold that particular joy, I did mention to him that one of my fears is that they show up, don't get an answer at the bell and let themselves in during one of our child free afternoons! That certainly got him thinking!! A reminder that we both work remotely and all children are of school going age... we take our opportunities where we can 🤣

20 years ago that exact thing happened my friend.
3 children under 5 and a really rare opportunity for some "afternoon delight".
Her MIL was inclined to overstep and had also made a key a couple of years earlier.
She lived only a few minutes away on the next street.
She came into the house and went upstairs and entered their bedroom.
They hadn't heard each other so everyone got the most awful shock.

My friend said a few times she had noticed a few things but had dismissed them as paranoia.

She had also been patronised a bit by her husband over the years when she mentioned niggles with his mother, but this time she was quietly done.
The locks were changed, no discussion.

She never said a word to her MIL but told the rest of the family and her neighbours about it, in an extremely jokey PA way.
Her mother was a complete Mrs Bucket and was mortified.

After years of snide little put downs my friend thoroughly enjoyed bringing it up every time she came near her.
It did the trick, she STFU and became wary of her.
She also told her husband that his mother had sullied her association with afternoon sex to piss him off, which it did nicely.

Pumpup · Yesterday 14:57

Ah, I’ve been here. A couple weeks later it was Christmas and the In Laws let themselves in on Christmas Day morning, (when they weren’t invited!) and I was on the stairs in underwear as was running down to the washing machines to get my clothes. Joys.

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 14:59

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 14:49

Not all families are the same. I'm astonished at how many people on here seem to think that everybody is the same and has the same kind of relationships as they do.

Not all families are the same for sure. However, in this case, the MIL is apparently OK (apart from having made some unfortunate choices re decisions concerning her family). The OP has lived in the house for 8 years but doesn't seem to have concerns about snooping etc. which could just as easily be done whilst childminding the GS if she was that way inclined. Was she wrong to get the key cut? .... absolutely and isn't something that I would personally do but a lot of people on here are assuming it was done with awful intent. Only the OP + DH know MIL well and what she could be capable of but perhaps this was just another of MIL's unfortunate decisions and she really just has the best of intentions however misguided they are.

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 15:00

This whole thread is absolutely bonkers .... Based on a couple of assumtions

a) She hasnt or will not use the key to enter your house with prior notice and permission

b) She has told you she got a key cut - It isnt something she has hidden.

So based on these assumptions Im going to suggest this a complete over reaction on the OP part ..... to the point i would suggest ungrateful. Its a total loss of perspective.

She is your partners/husbands mother .... what do you think she is likely to do with the key, break in when you are out at work, or turn up unnanouced in the evenings? ..... Im guessing probably not. You are happy for her to look after your child, so im going to also assume your MIL is a reasonable person of sound mind?

My advice is dont sweat this small stuff, dont be so paranoid, it such a small issue (unless she uses key for her own benefit) and dont risk upsetting your MIL for such a trivial matter, and who probably genuinely thought she was doing a good thing

Using a key unnannounced = Overstepping

Getting a key cut at her own expense and informing you = Not overstepping

I actually feel a bit sorry for her if this is the reaction.

Minasama · Yesterday 15:03

This is to me a huge step over the boundary. Definitely talk to DH about this and have him ask for the key back. She absolutely should not have done this without your permission. If he won’t talk to her, tell him you will.

TheHouseofBamboo · Yesterday 15:06

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 07:41

This is so weird and sad. If my mil cut a key for our house so she had another spare I would be thrilled.
and for those saying the point is that she cut it not that she had it, the question is why didn’t she have one in the first place?
the changing the locks and then hiding the key again in case she makes an imprint in her make up compact - I am assuming that was a joke and if so very funny! If not this thread is such a rich seam for a modern anthropologist of the break down of family life and the complete atomisation of households.

Agreed, nicely put.
My family all have each other's keys. It has come in useful multiple times but no-one has ever used a key to do anything untoward. Puzzled about what they think MIL might do with it.

FOJN · Yesterday 15:17

TheHouseofBamboo · Yesterday 15:06

Agreed, nicely put.
My family all have each other's keys. It has come in useful multiple times but no-one has ever used a key to do anything untoward. Puzzled about what they think MIL might do with it.

Why does OP need to be concerned that MIL might do something nefarious to justify not giving her a key? She gave MIL a key when she needed it and MIL thought she could just cut a spare without discussion. If someone is OK with cutting a key to someone else's house without asking why wouldn't they just let themselves in when it suited them? I'm baffled that anyone would trust someone who cut a spare key without permission.

It's OP's house, she can choose who she wants to hold a spare key or not. Just because your family all have each others keys doesn't make people who don't want that arrangement weird or wrong.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:18

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 14:59

Not all families are the same for sure. However, in this case, the MIL is apparently OK (apart from having made some unfortunate choices re decisions concerning her family). The OP has lived in the house for 8 years but doesn't seem to have concerns about snooping etc. which could just as easily be done whilst childminding the GS if she was that way inclined. Was she wrong to get the key cut? .... absolutely and isn't something that I would personally do but a lot of people on here are assuming it was done with awful intent. Only the OP + DH know MIL well and what she could be capable of but perhaps this was just another of MIL's unfortunate decisions and she really just has the best of intentions however misguided they are.

I can't understand how anyone can thinks it's appropriate to get a key cut for someone else's house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread