Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

470 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
mummymeister · Today 15:33

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:29

So deal with fraudsters, don't remove it from an entire generation of young adults wholesale.

again, can you not see how this is going to work? everyone reapplies under new criteria. those that meet the criteria receive more, those that dont, receive nothing.

this is how they propose to deal with fraudsters. this is how they are going to redefine the system.

rather than tinkering at the edges and making people who are never going to be able to go to work go for yet another assessment, they will assess and categorize and those that can never work will not have to go for endless reassessments. And again, why would you not be in favour of scrapping endless reassessments for those whose condition is never ever going to change? why would you be against putting more money into therapies for those that it can make a difference to?

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:34

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:29

So deal with fraudsters, don't remove it from an entire generation of young adults wholesale.

And the fraudsters will just find other ways its the genuine who will get screwed over. Its like if pip became vouchers the dodgy people will sell them the genuine people will get stuck with unusable vouchers and not be able to fund what they need.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:35

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:31

This is nonsensical.

Oh right! Of course it is. You get benefits but you think it should be removed from an entire age group.

That age group have gone through failing schools. Their families have had to fight education systems to get support in place, fight for services that don't exist. And now their kids will not receive support in young adulthood.

My daughter was refused PIP despite not being able to function without me, she would starve and would not be able to leave the house. She wants to go to university next year on a course that is not available locally. Without PIP she will not be able to go.

We are seeking mandatory reconsideration and will go to tribunal, only potentially to have it removed.

The future for these young people is bleak, but you're OK right?

hoolaho · Today 15:35

x2boys · Today 15:21

There is no right and wrong answer guide
And they can back etc other up all they want but they still need evidence and i mean proper evifence not just a patient says letter from the Gp.

You’re missing the “doctors” who will take payment to provide diagnosis online. Another one of this crowd paid for a private consultation (£190 in case you’re interested). That consultant took what they said (can’t leave the house, can’t eat, suicidal ideation, panic attacks, forgets to take medication) and gave them a diagnosis of severe anxiety and depression with suspected ADHD. Advised an ADHD assessment, medication and CBT and/or EMDR for the panic attacks.

The same online doctor has gone on to diagnose 3 of the group with ADHD.

They all think it’s hilarious, they don’t even attempt to hide it. The mum of the girl brags about it and has shown me the paperwork.

This fraud is not as difficult as you are saying and it’s endemic. They don’t believe anyone can “prove what’s going on in my head” and they have never ever applied for a job despite now being in their 20s.

ETA - there is an answer guide. With answers that will give you a much higher chance of getting enough points for PIP. A tenner she paid for it.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:35

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:34

And the fraudsters will just find other ways its the genuine who will get screwed over. Its like if pip became vouchers the dodgy people will sell them the genuine people will get stuck with unusable vouchers and not be able to fund what they need.

love to know how when genuine claims are refused with strong medical evidence.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:36

hoolaho · Today 15:35

You’re missing the “doctors” who will take payment to provide diagnosis online. Another one of this crowd paid for a private consultation (£190 in case you’re interested). That consultant took what they said (can’t leave the house, can’t eat, suicidal ideation, panic attacks, forgets to take medication) and gave them a diagnosis of severe anxiety and depression with suspected ADHD. Advised an ADHD assessment, medication and CBT and/or EMDR for the panic attacks.

The same online doctor has gone on to diagnose 3 of the group with ADHD.

They all think it’s hilarious, they don’t even attempt to hide it. The mum of the girl brags about it and has shown me the paperwork.

This fraud is not as difficult as you are saying and it’s endemic. They don’t believe anyone can “prove what’s going on in my head” and they have never ever applied for a job despite now being in their 20s.

ETA - there is an answer guide. With answers that will give you a much higher chance of getting enough points for PIP. A tenner she paid for it.

Edited

A diagnosis alone will not get you pip!

Honestly the ignorance on here is astounding.

hoolaho · Today 15:37

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:36

A diagnosis alone will not get you pip!

Honestly the ignorance on here is astounding.

Where did I say it would? They know exactly what to say…

cool4cats2020 · Today 15:38

They all need to be assessed properly as soon as possible. I know a 16 year old who's just transferred from child DLA to pip. There's no way in the world that he meets the criteria for it (absolutely nothing wrong with him at all, wasn't really eligible for DLA either). I can only think that the transition doesn't involve any kind of assessment at all. I know people who have genuine disabilities and had to fight so hard to get pip so I'm not sure what's going wrong with the system, but something is badly broken.

mummymeister · Today 15:39

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:32

Isn't it like 0.2% fraud rate as you need reports from medical professionals. I sent reports from my cardiologist, vascular surgeon, neurologist, respiratory consultant, psychiatrist, endocrinologist and care coordinator and I still got refused first time.

A lot of it comes down to how you write and what you write on the form. thats why successful forms are passed around and wording copied for those who are fraudsters. this is the governments admission that there is widespread fraud in the system without admitting that there is widespread fraud in the system. if there wasnt they wouldnt be changing it.

Who completed your form? did you do it yourself or get professional help? I guarantee that the problem lies in the wording that you have used and how you have presented yourself as if you are on your best day rather than your worst.

Here is a real example. Old lady asked if she can wash herself without help. says yes she can. later on in discussion it turns out that her neighbour has to come in when she wants to shower, help her undress, get her into the shower onto the seat, get her out again, help to dry her. yet she said she could wash herself.

KitsyWitsy · Today 15:39

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:36

A diagnosis alone will not get you pip!

Honestly the ignorance on here is astounding.

She didn't say diagnosis only though>? Surely you understand that an official diagnosis helps a lot and the rest can be made up?

There are some really naive people on this forum. It IS possible to pay for diagnoses, sorry but it is.

Boomer55 · Today 15:39

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

It'll take a while, but they are just trying to reduce the sickness and amounts of PIP to young people. And to get young people into some sort of work. Those with severe physical disabilities, if they mean they cannot ever work, will get extra money.

Whether they honour existing claims remain to be seen. 🤷‍♀️

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:40

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:35

love to know how when genuine claims are refused with strong medical evidence.

Because thats what scammers do. They have skills and contacts the average person doesn't. How do you think people get fake passports. The average person wouldn't have a clue but you don't take everyone's passport away because a handful off people have fake ones

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:40

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:35

Oh right! Of course it is. You get benefits but you think it should be removed from an entire age group.

That age group have gone through failing schools. Their families have had to fight education systems to get support in place, fight for services that don't exist. And now their kids will not receive support in young adulthood.

My daughter was refused PIP despite not being able to function without me, she would starve and would not be able to leave the house. She wants to go to university next year on a course that is not available locally. Without PIP she will not be able to go.

We are seeking mandatory reconsideration and will go to tribunal, only potentially to have it removed.

The future for these young people is bleak, but you're OK right?

Sigh, maybe come back when you have read the proposal and can contribute something other than a ridiculous rant?

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:40

hoolaho · Today 15:37

Where did I say it would? They know exactly what to say…

Who knows exactly what to say? The claimant? They can say what they like but unless it is backed up with medical evidence their claim will be rejected.

My daughters claim was rejected EVEN with specific medical evidence. We're now seeking mandatory re-consideration.

You appear to believe every word that the press has riled you up to believe.

hoolaho · Today 15:40

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:35

love to know how when genuine claims are refused with strong medical evidence.

Well, you’ve said that your daughters assessor lied.

Presumably the assessors that these youngsters dealt with took them at their word (and the neatly manufactured “evidence” they presented)

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:41

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:40

Sigh, maybe come back when you have read the proposal and can contribute something other than a ridiculous rant?

The proposal to put extra support in?

How long will that take exactly?

Support services are woefully underfunded. It's pie in the sky.

x2boys · Today 15:41

hoolaho · Today 15:35

You’re missing the “doctors” who will take payment to provide diagnosis online. Another one of this crowd paid for a private consultation (£190 in case you’re interested). That consultant took what they said (can’t leave the house, can’t eat, suicidal ideation, panic attacks, forgets to take medication) and gave them a diagnosis of severe anxiety and depression with suspected ADHD. Advised an ADHD assessment, medication and CBT and/or EMDR for the panic attacks.

The same online doctor has gone on to diagnose 3 of the group with ADHD.

They all think it’s hilarious, they don’t even attempt to hide it. The mum of the girl brags about it and has shown me the paperwork.

This fraud is not as difficult as you are saying and it’s endemic. They don’t believe anyone can “prove what’s going on in my head” and they have never ever applied for a job despite now being in their 20s.

ETA - there is an answer guide. With answers that will give you a much higher chance of getting enough points for PIP. A tenner she paid for it.

Edited

It goes off need not diagnosis so the " on line doctor "can give umpteen diagnoses but unless you have prooif of need it wont help.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:42

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:40

Who knows exactly what to say? The claimant? They can say what they like but unless it is backed up with medical evidence their claim will be rejected.

My daughters claim was rejected EVEN with specific medical evidence. We're now seeking mandatory re-consideration.

You appear to believe every word that the press has riled you up to believe.

Good luck with mr i went from zero points to hr for both at mr because the original report was just a work of fiction it was ridiculous

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:42

hoolaho · Today 15:40

Well, you’ve said that your daughters assessor lied.

Presumably the assessors that these youngsters dealt with took them at their word (and the neatly manufactured “evidence” they presented)

Where did they get this 'neatly manufactured' evidence from!!!

I'm not saying it never happens but it really does not happen on the scale you suggest.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:43

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:42

Good luck with mr i went from zero points to hr for both at mr because the original report was just a work of fiction it was ridiculous

Thanks, i do fear for her though as she is in the age group that they look to attack. She should be HR. It's appalling.

plasticplate · Today 15:44

Periperi2025 · Today 14:47

Presumably you would have a car anyway as the majority of people in the UK do.
When my Dad had a brain tumour we quickly and easily sourced a second hand Berlingo with a ramp and sold it again no problem when he died a year later. Probably best to get in quick though if you need an adapted vehicle as the cost of second hand ones will presumably start the rise with these changes.

My son wouldn't as he lives in supported living and his motability car is at his address to be driven by his carers.
Although access to motability cars will continue. It will just be via a 3rd route other than DLA or PIP.
So gleefully stirring the pot is pointless.

Karma2023 · Today 15:44

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:16

I'm sorry but this is ridiculous, have you ever claimed PIP?

The idea what disability benefits are handed out like smarties is laughable.

Fraud should be dealt with rather than taking away PIP from young people who need it!

Unfortunately PIP claims can be fraudulent- many people know someone who claims PIP, mobility car.

Surely if you have 000ks in the bank, assets of over £1m you shouldn't be entitled ir need benefits?

hoolaho · Today 15:45

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:40

Who knows exactly what to say? The claimant? They can say what they like but unless it is backed up with medical evidence their claim will be rejected.

My daughters claim was rejected EVEN with specific medical evidence. We're now seeking mandatory re-consideration.

You appear to believe every word that the press has riled you up to believe.

Mate, I know these people. I have seen the paperwork with my own eyes and have sat around a kitchen table and spoken to them about it. They think it’s hilarious and give zero shits. The young lad acted out how he had behaved during the assessment and what he said. Then creased up at the mother saying he always was best at GCSE drama…

I am not in any way riled up. Personally, I think it’s disgusting but that’s as much head space as I give it. I have other things to worry about and I’m just glad that my kids will never be like that bunch of wasters.

You have said that your daughter’s assessor lied. And there are other assessors who will take it at face value.

NettleTea · Today 15:46

ilovebrie8 · Today 13:53

The amount his is receiving in a month must be about £1800 per month as a rough guess.

Pip in a month would be £843 per month if you work out a monthly equivalent.

UC with disabled would be even more.

Genuinely, that is a heck of a lot for someone of 19.

He clearly cannot work; but how can benefits be so high when your ordinary person doesn’t make that in a month working full time?

I think you are over estimating by 4-600 a month, but anyway, remember that is his limit. For life. People dont seem to recognise that.

So maybe a great 'starting salary' for a young person (although still below FT min wage by a long shot), but it wont go up. He wont be progressing his career any time. That is his maximum for ever. Most people in work are getting alot more than that. Would you still think £1400 a month is great for a 45 year old? A 55 year old?

And if he has care needs they need to be paid for.

mummymeister · Today 15:47

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:42

Where did they get this 'neatly manufactured' evidence from!!!

I'm not saying it never happens but it really does not happen on the scale you suggest.

It absolutely does and it is on a massive scale. just because you dont know about it, you have never done it and its not something you have come across personally does not mean its not the case.

I have posted my evidence. every single day on a local forum there is someone asking for help to get a diagnosis and get PIP.

you start with the medical evidence from an internet doctor and then you lie on the form using the key words that you know will get you the points.

If it wasnt a big issue, then you wouldnt have so many people claiming.

the govt know this. they know about the widescale fraud and this is their answer. to start again. and those with severely disabled family members should be rejoicing at this because then the money can actually be spent on those that need it and they can get more.