Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

476 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:49

mummymeister · Today 15:47

It absolutely does and it is on a massive scale. just because you dont know about it, you have never done it and its not something you have come across personally does not mean its not the case.

I have posted my evidence. every single day on a local forum there is someone asking for help to get a diagnosis and get PIP.

you start with the medical evidence from an internet doctor and then you lie on the form using the key words that you know will get you the points.

If it wasnt a big issue, then you wouldnt have so many people claiming.

the govt know this. they know about the widescale fraud and this is their answer. to start again. and those with severely disabled family members should be rejoicing at this because then the money can actually be spent on those that need it and they can get more.

Spot on.

hoolaho · Today 15:50

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:42

Where did they get this 'neatly manufactured' evidence from!!!

I'm not saying it never happens but it really does not happen on the scale you suggest.

A private clinic, all went to the same consultant. And a few visits to the GP. And one had a referral to CAMHS from school that they added to the pile. They are all on the very long waiting list for CBT, one had 3 private EMDR sessions (£70 per session) followed by a report (£120).

It really does happen on a large scale, especially in certain pockets of the country. Maybe you don’t live there so don’t see it or hear of it?

Mossyfox · Today 15:50

I think all the people claiming PIP should be reassessed if new criteria are being brought in.

hoolaho · Today 15:52

x2boys · Today 15:41

It goes off need not diagnosis so the " on line doctor "can give umpteen diagnoses but unless you have prooif of need it wont help.

Ok then

IzzyLeng · Today 15:52

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:40

Who knows exactly what to say? The claimant? They can say what they like but unless it is backed up with medical evidence their claim will be rejected.

My daughters claim was rejected EVEN with specific medical evidence. We're now seeking mandatory re-consideration.

You appear to believe every word that the press has riled you up to believe.

Yes and how do you think that medical evidence works. Claimant while talking to the gp about stuff throws in that they are so badly affected a relative has to help them with food prep and personal,hygiene. That gets noted down in medical records. That’s now gospel.

person claims, asks for medical evidence. GP duly writes a statement saying that person needs assistance for xyz. Now if they also have a medical condition making that possibility stronger (I know you don’t need a diagnosis for pipe, also that a diagnosis doesn’t guarantee you pip….its all about how it affects you) then you’re on a winning ticket. Nobody is sitting in someone’s house every evening watching them to see how true it is.

my daughter could easily say that due to her formally diagnosed condition she can’t hold stuff to prep food, that she can’t wash herself, that she can’t carry shopping, that she can’t walk far. She could se her gp tomorrow and they’d put that in her notes, they’d believe her because of her diagnosis. And then she could apply for pip. But it would be bollocks.

mummymeister · Today 15:53

hoolaho · Today 15:50

A private clinic, all went to the same consultant. And a few visits to the GP. And one had a referral to CAMHS from school that they added to the pile. They are all on the very long waiting list for CBT, one had 3 private EMDR sessions (£70 per session) followed by a report (£120).

It really does happen on a large scale, especially in certain pockets of the country. Maybe you don’t live there so don’t see it or hear of it?

I wish I could ask a couple of the posters on here over to mine for a day, take them to spoons in the town, show them the facebook groups and then ask them to say its not absolutely rife.

These scammers are robbing genuine claimants of their money. I just cannot understand how people dont see this.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · Today 15:53

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I think the idea is that some young people will be placed in a "never going to be able to work" category, and they will receive a higher level of benefits than they do at present.

Of course, the devil is in the detail, as we don't currently know how those decisions will be made, and the uncertainty will clearly create anxiety for many.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:58

mummymeister · Today 15:53

I wish I could ask a couple of the posters on here over to mine for a day, take them to spoons in the town, show them the facebook groups and then ask them to say its not absolutely rife.

These scammers are robbing genuine claimants of their money. I just cannot understand how people dont see this.

I understand and agree with what you are saying.

If it is managed properly, it should be good for the genuine claimants, good for the country and ultimately good for the young people who will have to work as they will have a more fulfilling life rather than wasting it fraudulently on benefits.

Itchthescratch · Today 15:58

IzzyLeng · Today 15:52

Yes and how do you think that medical evidence works. Claimant while talking to the gp about stuff throws in that they are so badly affected a relative has to help them with food prep and personal,hygiene. That gets noted down in medical records. That’s now gospel.

person claims, asks for medical evidence. GP duly writes a statement saying that person needs assistance for xyz. Now if they also have a medical condition making that possibility stronger (I know you don’t need a diagnosis for pipe, also that a diagnosis doesn’t guarantee you pip….its all about how it affects you) then you’re on a winning ticket. Nobody is sitting in someone’s house every evening watching them to see how true it is.

my daughter could easily say that due to her formally diagnosed condition she can’t hold stuff to prep food, that she can’t wash herself, that she can’t carry shopping, that she can’t walk far. She could se her gp tomorrow and they’d put that in her notes, they’d believe her because of her diagnosis. And then she could apply for pip. But it would be bollocks.

Edited

Exactly this.

The problem is there is no objective, definitive test for ADHD. If you research ADHD symptoms and go to the Doctors claiming you are experiencing them and detailing how they are impairing your daily life then do you expect a GP to accuse someone of lying? This is especially true when someone has some ADHD traits (like most of us do) and looks to exaggerate them rather than manufacture traits completely. They will have a ring of authenticity. If you can pass the initial screening then some clinics have a 95% conversion rate from referral to diagnosis. You will then have an ADHD diagnosis and evidence of your impairment document. You can then use websites and YouTube to help complete the PIP form so that you have the best chance of success.

How do you expect the DWP to distinguish this kind of claimant from genuine claimants that are severely impacted? Especially when lots of people genuinely have had chaotic home environments as children and we know that this can mirror ADHD impairment and sometimes exacerbate underlying relatively mild ADHD traits. It's a grey and complex area that is open to obvious manipulation and abuse when the incentive is clear.

PollyPocket80 · Today 15:59

Private ADHD/ASD assessments are fuelling an epidemic of ill teens/young people and even adults. I've read many of these 'reports' in the course of my job -believe me the bar isn't set high at all and the assessor has no means or inclination to investigate what they are told. They also get paid a nice bung and Big Pharma do quite nicely out of it too. One big cartel.
The average person with any intelligence would know what to say to tick the right boxes and the same goes for benefit claims, it's not difficult to research the criteria online. I feel very sorry for those young people who will suffer but as always when something is allowed to get out of control it's always the genuine who suffer when the rug is pulled.

DiligentDandelion · Today 16:00

Ubertomusic · Today 14:25

Therapy for incurable conditions? Great idea!

if you read the article you’ll see that’s not what it says. A good proportion of new pip claimants are young people with anxiety or depression, who will benefit from therapy. Access to therapy for young people with mental health issues is currently appallingly scarce. If they got the help they need they very well might not need benefits. No one is going to suggest someone with life long and severe disabilities or illness is going to be ‘cured’ by therapy.

gamerchick · Today 16:01

Isobel201 · Today 13:27

Existing claimaints won't be affected, it would only be for new claimants. They had already brought in some changes which doesn't affect me because I'm an existing claimant, like being able to make meals in microwaves that they have reduced the points needed for.

A review is essentially a new claim. Don't think it won't come for you as well.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 16:04

hoolaho · Today 15:50

A private clinic, all went to the same consultant. And a few visits to the GP. And one had a referral to CAMHS from school that they added to the pile. They are all on the very long waiting list for CBT, one had 3 private EMDR sessions (£70 per session) followed by a report (£120).

It really does happen on a large scale, especially in certain pockets of the country. Maybe you don’t live there so don’t see it or hear of it?

Perhaps the solution is to invest in the NHS services and reduce waiting lists. Then people can be assessed, supported and treated. If someone is waiting 6 years or more to even be seen by a service, it's no wonder they are not coping in the meantime.

hoolaho · Today 16:04

PollyPocket80 · Today 15:59

Private ADHD/ASD assessments are fuelling an epidemic of ill teens/young people and even adults. I've read many of these 'reports' in the course of my job -believe me the bar isn't set high at all and the assessor has no means or inclination to investigate what they are told. They also get paid a nice bung and Big Pharma do quite nicely out of it too. One big cartel.
The average person with any intelligence would know what to say to tick the right boxes and the same goes for benefit claims, it's not difficult to research the criteria online. I feel very sorry for those young people who will suffer but as always when something is allowed to get out of control it's always the genuine who suffer when the rug is pulled.

Yup, the naivety of some posters here is astounding. Lets hope they find a way to sort the wheat from the chaff and give better payments to those who need it.

IzzyLeng · Today 16:05

And the thing about tightening up benefits like this it should hopefully mean there is more money for those who genuinely need it. Including but not limited to disabled people! It boils my piss that there are people for whatever reason genuinely struggling, using food banks, etc. wouldn’t it be better if such people had a higher payment even if that meant a 16yo who’s capable of full time education wasn’t getting £200 a month to spend on video games?

hoolaho · Today 16:06

Shardonneigghhh · Today 16:04

Perhaps the solution is to invest in the NHS services and reduce waiting lists. Then people can be assessed, supported and treated. If someone is waiting 6 years or more to even be seen by a service, it's no wonder they are not coping in the meantime.

I agree for those that need it.

The problem is these hoards of scammers are not anxious, nor do they have ADHD, nor do they need treatment. But they’ll take it, play up to whatever they need to, and walk away laughing.

mummymeister · Today 16:07

Shardonneigghhh · Today 16:04

Perhaps the solution is to invest in the NHS services and reduce waiting lists. Then people can be assessed, supported and treated. If someone is waiting 6 years or more to even be seen by a service, it's no wonder they are not coping in the meantime.

HOORAY! someone is seeing my point. yes the solution is to invest but you cannot invest money that you do not have because its being pissed up against the wall on scammers. thats the point.

Genuine people need more money. scammers need nothing. thats it in a nutshell

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:08

mummymeister · Today 16:07

HOORAY! someone is seeing my point. yes the solution is to invest but you cannot invest money that you do not have because its being pissed up against the wall on scammers. thats the point.

Genuine people need more money. scammers need nothing. thats it in a nutshell

I saw your point too. Did you miss my reply?

OrganicDecafEarlGrey · Today 16:09

Two DSs and I all have diagnoses of autism from NHS CLASS clinic in Cambridge and we get nothing. Waiting for tribunal hearing because my body has been so wrecked by stress/anxiety that I can only work about 2 hours a week. I'd love to find a flexible job that I could do from home from my sofa but they don't really exist.

I guess I find all the talk of fraudulent claims a bit triggering because I feel that people would think I'm a fraud (as they only see me when I'm well and I always wear make up and dress nicely so I look far more well than I am).

One of my DSs has a non 24 hour circadian rhythm and it's a complete nightmare as he wakes up two hours later every day in an endless cycle. I've just applied for PIP for him and he's waiting to hear back about the UC health element. Luckily he'll be 25 in just over a year but it's so unfair on everyone else. My youngest lost his PIP when he went to uni and I had a nervous breakdown (not because of that!!) so I had to pay over £500 every term for taxis.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:10

IzzyLeng · Today 15:52

Yes and how do you think that medical evidence works. Claimant while talking to the gp about stuff throws in that they are so badly affected a relative has to help them with food prep and personal,hygiene. That gets noted down in medical records. That’s now gospel.

person claims, asks for medical evidence. GP duly writes a statement saying that person needs assistance for xyz. Now if they also have a medical condition making that possibility stronger (I know you don’t need a diagnosis for pipe, also that a diagnosis doesn’t guarantee you pip….its all about how it affects you) then you’re on a winning ticket. Nobody is sitting in someone’s house every evening watching them to see how true it is.

my daughter could easily say that due to her formally diagnosed condition she can’t hold stuff to prep food, that she can’t wash herself, that she can’t carry shopping, that she can’t walk far. She could se her gp tomorrow and they’d put that in her notes, they’d believe her because of her diagnosis. And then she could apply for pip. But it would be bollocks.

Edited

Pip don't accept gp statements. My renewal form specifically said don't pay for a gp statement there only interested in secondary care

mummymeister · Today 16:11

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:08

I saw your point too. Did you miss my reply?

Yes sorry thank you. I just keep feeling like its head against a brick wall on this subject. I know its emotive. its horrible that the people who need help arent getting it and I genuinely want to see them get more. but we have to accept its a massive scam at the moment and real genuine people are just so missing out. Yet it seems to be the many genuine people on here dont want this to happen!

I just cant get my head around it sometimes.

Happyindevon · Today 16:12

If you research ADHD symptoms and go to the Doctors claiming you are experiencing them and detailing how they are impairing your daily life then do you expect a GP to accuse someone of lying? This is especially true when someone has some ADHD traits (like most of us do) and looks to exaggerate them rather than manufacture traits completely

This is what nobody can ever satisfactorily answer. If asked to describe everyone I know, each would have a couple of ‘traits’ of something. Nobody would be completely average and functional in every single way.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:14

mummymeister · Today 16:11

Yes sorry thank you. I just keep feeling like its head against a brick wall on this subject. I know its emotive. its horrible that the people who need help arent getting it and I genuinely want to see them get more. but we have to accept its a massive scam at the moment and real genuine people are just so missing out. Yet it seems to be the many genuine people on here dont want this to happen!

I just cant get my head around it sometimes.

Yes, I think alot of the genuine claimants feel that it is a personal criticism of them when others acknowledge that there is rampant fraud in the system. The two things are not mutually exclusive and unfortunately it seems that honest, genuine claimants are more likely to be refused PIP than the frauds who know how to play the system.

Chiefunderling · Today 16:14

What’s most worrying is there was barely any mention of the NHS. Access to treatment is one of the biggest issues here for young people struggling with mental ill health. Treatment is only accessible following diagnosis. Diagnosis is taking years in many cases. Then years more languishing on waiting lists for treatment. And treatment isn’t always a one & done. Many people with significant mental illness need treatment at various points in their lives. Where I live, the local health board had been in special measures for just shy of a decade. We have been completely failed by local & national government. I cannot see the necessary changes in accessing treatment & support happening here in the next decade. It is complete chaos & people of all ages are suffering terribly. This crisis cannot be solved until the NHS is brought up to scratch where mental health services are concerned.

CatkinToadflax · Today 16:15

I would like to know how taking my son’s PIP and LCWRA off him is going to get him a job.