Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

430 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
Noras · Today 15:12

KitsyWitsy · Today 14:25

My middle son is 24 next month so hopefully this won't affect him but it is still worrying. He lost his pip 15 months ago and it's taken me this long to get it back. I was finally able to breathe and now this.

Don’t worry you are out of the woods - they need to set up all the resources first

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:14

I'll just leave this here

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured
Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:14

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:10

Honestly I reckon some on here think this is preferable.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, this is not how civilised societies treat the disabled.

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that benefits should be cut for the genuinely disabled. The issue is the huge numbers who are playing the system to fraudulently get benefits for less serious issues.

GiaGia16 · Today 15:15

Itchthescratch · Today 15:11

Yes, loads of posters were defending her. She definitely wasn't a troll. Others were gloating that they put their PIP towards a holiday etc. If you questioned it then you got accused of not wanting disabled people to have nice things and viewings them as lesser people.

Then the usual starving and workhouses hyperbole starts up

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:16

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:14

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that benefits should be cut for the genuinely disabled. The issue is the huge numbers who are playing the system to fraudulently get benefits for less serious issues.

I'm sorry but this is ridiculous, have you ever claimed PIP?

The idea what disability benefits are handed out like smarties is laughable.

Fraud should be dealt with rather than taking away PIP from young people who need it!

Hotsirballloon · Today 15:16

I was abused sexually as a child and then spent many years on drugs/ I am clean now but I have bpd bipolar ocd cptsd and adhd. I get disability benefits and I applied for pip. I work full time I just want to be able to afford
therapy so I can be better mum and leave my past alone. Not all pip is for extra spending

Itchthescratch · Today 15:17

TigerRag · Today 15:11

I sometimes wonder what century I'm living in with some of the comments. I don't remember it being this bad growing up

The percentage of people claiming disability benefits wasn't so high in the past and there was also less recognition of milder conditions. Many cases of ADHD and ASD were missed entirely. This combines to make people more suspicious of just how impaired some people are that are claiming disability benefits or not working. ADHD and anxiety are the new 'bad back'.

A young person can triple their benefits if they qualify for the highest level of disability benefit. Like it or not, there is a clear incentive for people with dodgy intentions to try and maximise their payouts.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:20

Itchthescratch · Today 15:17

The percentage of people claiming disability benefits wasn't so high in the past and there was also less recognition of milder conditions. Many cases of ADHD and ASD were missed entirely. This combines to make people more suspicious of just how impaired some people are that are claiming disability benefits or not working. ADHD and anxiety are the new 'bad back'.

A young person can triple their benefits if they qualify for the highest level of disability benefit. Like it or not, there is a clear incentive for people with dodgy intentions to try and maximise their payouts.

It really pisses me off when people talk about anxiety disorders like that I didn't leave the house for 2 years because of an anxiety disorder. I attempted suicide because of an anxiety disorder. I haven't been on holiday in over 15 years because off an anxiety disorder.

mummymeister · Today 15:21

TigerRag · Today 15:04

And disabled people who can't work? Or do we just let them starve?

Actually try reading what I have written??? I do not want disabled people who cannot work now and/or who can never work to starve. I want them to get MORE money. I want them to have enough money to get the help and the therapies that they need to live a long and rewarding life without unduly burdening their families with the cost.

You can ONLY do this if you have the money. and that comes about by taking it from those who have and continue to game the system.
@mamaof4losingmymind We cannot treat the genuinely disabled people the way they need to be treated if the vast majority of the money in the pot is being scammed.

This isnt about the kind of situation you outline. Its about being on facebook forums and reading every single bloody day how groups of people that you clearly have no connections to or know about or speak to or hear from who pass around PIP forms because they LIE on them. they pay willing doctors to get a diagnosis that is a LIE. PIP is an income supplement to these people who are also unemployed.

This is the reality. and all the time they are scamming this money you and your family arent getting what you need. You need to open your eyes to this and see its what is happening and its to your and your families detriment.

x2boys · Today 15:21

hoolaho · Today 14:56

Absolutely. I know several late teens/early 20s PIP claimants who have zero intention of getting a job because of their “anxiety”. They all helped each other with the forms after one girls mum paid for a copy of a strangers forms and an “answer guide” on Facebook.

This extreme anxiety didn’t stop them all going to a festival and taking a shitload of drugs. They didn’t “forget to eat” despite their ADHD, diagnosed by a fraud on Facebook obviously.

It’s disgusting. And other than the tax payer, the people who will suffer are genuine disabled people.

There is no right and wrong answer guide
And they can back etc other up all they want but they still need evidence and i mean proper evifence not just a patient says letter from the Gp.

Vikingforexample · Today 15:21

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:54

I disagree. I reckon I have at least 3 different conditions that would qualify me for PIp and indeed given me an excuse not to work. I do work but mainly spend the rest of my life housebound and recovering. And yes they cost me more, but people go through all sorts of adversity in life that costs them. That's just part of life

I am so glad I have chosen to work (and grateful to my supportive employers). I have a career, a network of friends and colleagues and a decent pension fund.

We need better legislation so everyone can experience the same support to work I have. But we should be enabling people to work wherever possible

PIP is not an out of work benefit. So you could claim and carry on working. And maybe brush up your comprehension skills.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:21

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:16

I'm sorry but this is ridiculous, have you ever claimed PIP?

The idea what disability benefits are handed out like smarties is laughable.

Fraud should be dealt with rather than taking away PIP from young people who need it!

Yes, I’m on PIP myself and it’s recently been extended until 2032.

hoolaho · Today 15:22

Happyindevon · Today 14:58

Yep. I’m absolutely certain that following through the medical system to create a paper trail to claim PIP is far less arduous than actually working 8 hours a day.

So naive. The first one of this group was a lazy stoner who refused school for a while. Once “anxiety” was recorded and her mum decided that she had ADHD (as an excuse for failing to parent her child) it was easy. Couple of trips to the GP, a self referral to join the 4 year waiting list for CBT and a prescription for sertraline that she doesn’t take and bobs your uncle. Give the right answers…and she got PIP.

How is that not easier than working full time?

ShutupLwren · Today 15:23

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I have a child similar to how you describe your own son. Mine is 8. I am genuinely terrified for the future. Nothing to add, sending solidarity I suppose 💐

OneHazelBird · Today 15:23

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Surely it should be on a needs basis.

People like your son absolutely need it.

Whereas I know a few people who’ve been getting £500 a month but do not need that much.

It’s frustrating when my DC (who is also ND) does A-levels and works a PT on top but her friends can get tattoos, driving lessons and go out on the piss every weekend without needing to work.

It also sends a bad message because one of her friends is never planning on working (his parents don’t either) and so is flunking his A levels.

KitsyWitsy · Today 15:25

Vikingforexample · Today 15:21

PIP is not an out of work benefit. So you could claim and carry on working. And maybe brush up your comprehension skills.

People keep saying this but most people on PIP don't work and if you do, then they use that against you to take your pip away saying you obviously don't need it.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:25

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:21

Yes, I’m on PIP myself and it’s recently been extended until 2032.

Ah so it's alright for thee but not alright for them.

That's absolutely abhorrent.

You know then that it is not easy to falsify a PIP claim.

My daughter has been refused PIP even though she can't prepare a simple meal for both physical and mental health reasons WITH medical evidence to support.

She has been refused PIP even though she struggles with mobility and meets the criteria WITH medical evidence.

She scored a total of 2 points, for her least serious area of disability. The assessor has lied.

So we are now onto mandatory consideration.

The idea perpetuated in the press that you can get it for a simple ADHD/ autism diagnosis is completely unfounded.

Nsky62 · Today 15:27

x2boys · Today 14:12

All claimants?
My son is 16 with severe autism and learning disabillties hes cogntivly around 2 or3 totally non verbal and can only conmunicate very basic needs
I think its clear that his needs are not going to change
What would your justification be for him to be reassesed regularly.?

None

mummymeister · Today 15:27

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:20

It really pisses me off when people talk about anxiety disorders like that I didn't leave the house for 2 years because of an anxiety disorder. I attempted suicide because of an anxiety disorder. I haven't been on holiday in over 15 years because off an anxiety disorder.

and you should be at the front of the queue to get the help and support that you need to deal with your anxiety in a positive way and be able to take part in the family activities that other people do like going on holiday. But all the time there are tens of thousands of people claiming fraudulently the money goes to them to fund their lifestyle and not to support their disability.

If this is actually implemented as Millburn sets out and not bastardised by back benchers, you will end up with more money for support and therapies. And you are against this? you dont agree that this is a good thing?

Sunshineheres · Today 15:28

I think reform probably is needed, and IMHO enabling people to stay at home indefinitely with many MH issues is probably doing them more harm than good, but i don't really see why that's different because they're under 25.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:29

OneHazelBird · Today 15:23

Surely it should be on a needs basis.

People like your son absolutely need it.

Whereas I know a few people who’ve been getting £500 a month but do not need that much.

It’s frustrating when my DC (who is also ND) does A-levels and works a PT on top but her friends can get tattoos, driving lessons and go out on the piss every weekend without needing to work.

It also sends a bad message because one of her friends is never planning on working (his parents don’t either) and so is flunking his A levels.

I think this is part of the issue as there are now 2nd and 3rd generations of families who have never worked and know everything they are entitled to claim

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:29

mummymeister · Today 15:27

and you should be at the front of the queue to get the help and support that you need to deal with your anxiety in a positive way and be able to take part in the family activities that other people do like going on holiday. But all the time there are tens of thousands of people claiming fraudulently the money goes to them to fund their lifestyle and not to support their disability.

If this is actually implemented as Millburn sets out and not bastardised by back benchers, you will end up with more money for support and therapies. And you are against this? you dont agree that this is a good thing?

So deal with fraudsters, don't remove it from an entire generation of young adults wholesale.

x2boys · Today 15:30

OneHazelBird · Today 15:23

Surely it should be on a needs basis.

People like your son absolutely need it.

Whereas I know a few people who’ve been getting £500 a month but do not need that much.

It’s frustrating when my DC (who is also ND) does A-levels and works a PT on top but her friends can get tattoos, driving lessons and go out on the piss every weekend without needing to work.

It also sends a bad message because one of her friends is never planning on working (his parents don’t either) and so is flunking his A levels.

It is a needs basis but to get enhanced rate care you need 12 points ,when i was adding up what my son should get it was in excess of 55 points
There will always be some people who just about meet the criteria and others who way exceed the criteria and they will get the same award.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:31

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:25

Ah so it's alright for thee but not alright for them.

That's absolutely abhorrent.

You know then that it is not easy to falsify a PIP claim.

My daughter has been refused PIP even though she can't prepare a simple meal for both physical and mental health reasons WITH medical evidence to support.

She has been refused PIP even though she struggles with mobility and meets the criteria WITH medical evidence.

She scored a total of 2 points, for her least serious area of disability. The assessor has lied.

So we are now onto mandatory consideration.

The idea perpetuated in the press that you can get it for a simple ADHD/ autism diagnosis is completely unfounded.

This is nonsensical.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:32

mummymeister · Today 15:27

and you should be at the front of the queue to get the help and support that you need to deal with your anxiety in a positive way and be able to take part in the family activities that other people do like going on holiday. But all the time there are tens of thousands of people claiming fraudulently the money goes to them to fund their lifestyle and not to support their disability.

If this is actually implemented as Millburn sets out and not bastardised by back benchers, you will end up with more money for support and therapies. And you are against this? you dont agree that this is a good thing?

Isn't it like 0.2% fraud rate as you need reports from medical professionals. I sent reports from my cardiologist, vascular surgeon, neurologist, respiratory consultant, psychiatrist, endocrinologist and care coordinator and I still got refused first time.