Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

524 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
ThreadGuardDog · Today 19:36

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:30

A very small fraction of PIP recipients work. And if you think that the 8.2% of English under 25s that currently claim PIP are so ill they can never work you are very naive.

PIP isn’t an out of work benefit and doesn’t assess the ability to work. It’s a disability cost related benefit.

ChunkyMonkey36 · Today 19:37

ThisHazelPeer · Today 19:32

I find it strange that there are whole generations of children who are disabled in some way. Why is this happening in the 21st century? Is it immunisations causing it? Is there something in the water? Is it because women are old when they have babies? Are we deliberately being poisoned by some airborne drug? There have always been disabled people, but definitely never in these absurd numbers. What will happen to these dependant children when their parents die?

You almost lost me at “airborne drug poisoning,” to be honest.

When their parents die, they’ll likely live in some sort of supported living or care facility.

That’s certainly our plan, anyway. Before death, ideally.

Shrawby · Today 19:40

I dont really understand pip for adhd or anxiety as money wont help those things.

In terms of cost to uk
they need to be pushing towards people having kids younger (so making housing more affordable) as older people are more likely to have autistic children
Keep on pushing the no drinking in pregnancy to reduce the 5%+ of kids with fasd
And encourage more sensible choices (and early diagnosis or parents and kids) so that people do not continue to have 2,3,4 disabled kids.

As being aware of couples who have dc out of school have a young baby and ttc. Completely illogical when both parents are adhd, not supporting themseves already and very high likelihood of obviously adhd in all the dc. If they were faced with funding as well as caring for the kids i would think they would make a different choice.

During diagnosis info to parents of likelihood of further sen kids and that the severity could be different.

Reading a post from a dad where he was feeding the dc mcdonalds every day! Yes i get arfid but possibly people need to consider not feeding very picky kids foods like mcD. There was a separate parent feeding their kid 50 nuggets a day not mcd and the 9yo was 10st!. We do need to get the nhs back to working with parents to expand foods (or supplement with more nutritional substitutes)

There is an issue woth available jobs but it doesnt necessarily mean people with milder disabilities need pip etc to top up the unemployment money.

Getting kids the adhd diagnosis and meds much younger is likely to help in future. But otoh kids eg skipping q at theme parks, only eating exactly what they want etc etc isnt setting up for life of eg driving, waiting for publoc transport, being extremely bored at work.

Laura95167 · Today 19:42

ThisHazelPeer · Today 19:32

I find it strange that there are whole generations of children who are disabled in some way. Why is this happening in the 21st century? Is it immunisations causing it? Is there something in the water? Is it because women are old when they have babies? Are we deliberately being poisoned by some airborne drug? There have always been disabled people, but definitely never in these absurd numbers. What will happen to these dependant children when their parents die?

So in no particular order:

Vaccines save lives. So many lives. 2 generations ago it was normal to loss a sibling in childhood. Now its a tragedy that society sees as against the natural order when I child dies before their parents. Vaccines are a massive reason for that.

Medical care has advanced so people with complex health conditions thrive more and there are many living who 2 generations+ ago may have survived.

Women historically started having children post puberty and continued as long as they were able - this means in years gone by with less reliable birth control and higher infant mortality women on average had children from 16 - 45 depending on fertility.

We understand mental health more therefore have more diagnosis and we have more understanding of neurodiversity and can recognise more easily if the level of neurodiversy impacts someones abilities or is accompanied by a learning difficulty or disability.

Pregnacy is viable at the lowest gestation in history so children that may of sadly passed even 30 years ago now live.

Disabled doesnt always mean needs full time care. You can currently qualify for PIP without needed to be dependant on others.

Chikenpotpoe · Today 19:43

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:30

A very small fraction of PIP recipients work. And if you think that the 8.2% of English under 25s that currently claim PIP are so ill they can never work you are very naive.

Who said they can never work??

From what I understand the OP was saying they should honor the existing PIP award until their next award date. And that is what I agree with.

If at their next review it's deemed they don't need PIP that's fine. But that's seperate from work anyway as they may already be working on PIP. There is often but NOT always an overlap with PIP and out of work benefits. And Universal Credit is still going to be available for under 25s, its the disabled they are going after again. I mean the health element for UC was already slashed by almost half earlier this year.

I just googled the PIP award lengths as I'm not too familiar with how it works, but from what I can see they give awards for varying lengths of time. So say a 21 one year old were given a 4 year award in 2024, I believe they should get paid until 2028.

MyLimeGuide · Today 19:48

Shrawby · Today 19:40

I dont really understand pip for adhd or anxiety as money wont help those things.

In terms of cost to uk
they need to be pushing towards people having kids younger (so making housing more affordable) as older people are more likely to have autistic children
Keep on pushing the no drinking in pregnancy to reduce the 5%+ of kids with fasd
And encourage more sensible choices (and early diagnosis or parents and kids) so that people do not continue to have 2,3,4 disabled kids.

As being aware of couples who have dc out of school have a young baby and ttc. Completely illogical when both parents are adhd, not supporting themseves already and very high likelihood of obviously adhd in all the dc. If they were faced with funding as well as caring for the kids i would think they would make a different choice.

During diagnosis info to parents of likelihood of further sen kids and that the severity could be different.

Reading a post from a dad where he was feeding the dc mcdonalds every day! Yes i get arfid but possibly people need to consider not feeding very picky kids foods like mcD. There was a separate parent feeding their kid 50 nuggets a day not mcd and the 9yo was 10st!. We do need to get the nhs back to working with parents to expand foods (or supplement with more nutritional substitutes)

There is an issue woth available jobs but it doesnt necessarily mean people with milder disabilities need pip etc to top up the unemployment money.

Getting kids the adhd diagnosis and meds much younger is likely to help in future. But otoh kids eg skipping q at theme parks, only eating exactly what they want etc etc isnt setting up for life of eg driving, waiting for publoc transport, being extremely bored at work.

😐 dont get how pushing for younger ppl to have kids instead of older (because older people produce SEN) kids is the answer. Firstly women want careers now instead of just being baby making machines. No2. An older women in her 30s would most likely be a better mum due to life experience thus bringing up a better human child (fact).
But I definitely agree with you about no pip for ADHD and anxiety.

thatsgotit · Today 19:48

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:32

But what’s your solution? Because currently we’re handing them money to lower their aspirations to a life on benefits. Millburn has produced a strategy to improve these people’s long term prospects and this thread is packed with whinging. Should we just palm them off with cash for life? Is that good for the person? Or the country?

Because currently we’re handing them money to lower their aspirations to a life on benefits.

No. We are 'handing' them money to survive, in many instances.

needastrongone · Today 19:50

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:32

But what’s your solution? Because currently we’re handing them money to lower their aspirations to a life on benefits. Millburn has produced a strategy to improve these people’s long term prospects and this thread is packed with whinging. Should we just palm them off with cash for life? Is that good for the person? Or the country?

Agree. It’s probably also worth considering how a Conservative or Reform government would approach the issue, and I suspect there will be rather more straight cuts.

MyLimeGuide · Today 19:52

thatsgotit · Today 19:48

Because currently we’re handing them money to lower their aspirations to a life on benefits.

No. We are 'handing' them money to survive, in many instances.

Thats what needs to be done. Determining the 'many' or half or whatever.

needastrongone · Today 19:53

As I said just now though, what do you think Reform or the Conservatives will do @thatsgotit? Both are talking about much deeper cuts, and far more quickly too.

Shrawby · Today 19:54

Also parents of other kids are being expected for fund uni in whatever subject the child wants for 3-5k per child a year.

Adhd assessment for kids os based on teacher reporting issues but obviously some kids wont do as they are told for various reasons - iq, parents not being strict. The assessment is very usa like in that its expecting the school to actually know the child but with 30kids in class and no 1-2-1 with teachers that is not uk. The process doesnt look for actual evidence in form of eg child being excluded temporarily at young age, or issues at clubs, not able to do extra clubs, or even ask how often the child is doing xyz. It doesnt ask in secondary for how many negative points they are getting.
So end up with kids with actual adhd being rejected vs kids showing off for mates and attention.

Extremely soft parenting and possibly schooling is ultimately fueling this as you arent seeing if they wpuld stop if the consequences were enough

ChunkyMonkey36 · Today 19:55

Shrawby · Today 19:40

I dont really understand pip for adhd or anxiety as money wont help those things.

In terms of cost to uk
they need to be pushing towards people having kids younger (so making housing more affordable) as older people are more likely to have autistic children
Keep on pushing the no drinking in pregnancy to reduce the 5%+ of kids with fasd
And encourage more sensible choices (and early diagnosis or parents and kids) so that people do not continue to have 2,3,4 disabled kids.

As being aware of couples who have dc out of school have a young baby and ttc. Completely illogical when both parents are adhd, not supporting themseves already and very high likelihood of obviously adhd in all the dc. If they were faced with funding as well as caring for the kids i would think they would make a different choice.

During diagnosis info to parents of likelihood of further sen kids and that the severity could be different.

Reading a post from a dad where he was feeding the dc mcdonalds every day! Yes i get arfid but possibly people need to consider not feeding very picky kids foods like mcD. There was a separate parent feeding their kid 50 nuggets a day not mcd and the 9yo was 10st!. We do need to get the nhs back to working with parents to expand foods (or supplement with more nutritional substitutes)

There is an issue woth available jobs but it doesnt necessarily mean people with milder disabilities need pip etc to top up the unemployment money.

Getting kids the adhd diagnosis and meds much younger is likely to help in future. But otoh kids eg skipping q at theme parks, only eating exactly what they want etc etc isnt setting up for life of eg driving, waiting for publoc transport, being extremely bored at work.

My very first thought re anxiety is that prescriptions aren’t free, and neither is therapy.

Yes there’s the NHS for therapy, but the wait list is incredibly long, and the sessions are limited.

My 10 year old is 9.5st, and I’d love to tell you that’s because he eats McDonald’s every day, but it isn’t. He eats a fairly broad diet nowadays, but has food fixation that means he demands food basically 24/7 and escalates when he isn’t given it. It’s sensory, routine based and PDA related.

At school, they give him twice the amount of food, because that’s genuinely their safest option. He’s not neglected, I know what healthy food is, and he does eat veg etc, but he’s also incredibly difficult to have that battle with because he’s a big lad.

He’d tear a fridge lock off, or pull the fridge over. So instead, we limit where we can and otherwise get kicked to high heaven because he can’t have 6 breakfasts.

On a wider level, I don’t think it’s acceptable to start telling people if and when to have kids. Many people don’t want have their kids early or younger, they want to build their career, do various other things. I don’t think we should be encouraging anyone to do anything, family planning is a personal choice and should stay that way.

Ladybarnaby · Today 19:56

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Same situation here. Our kids won’t lose their benefits, stop panicking.

Kirbert2 · Today 20:07

Shrawby · Today 19:40

I dont really understand pip for adhd or anxiety as money wont help those things.

In terms of cost to uk
they need to be pushing towards people having kids younger (so making housing more affordable) as older people are more likely to have autistic children
Keep on pushing the no drinking in pregnancy to reduce the 5%+ of kids with fasd
And encourage more sensible choices (and early diagnosis or parents and kids) so that people do not continue to have 2,3,4 disabled kids.

As being aware of couples who have dc out of school have a young baby and ttc. Completely illogical when both parents are adhd, not supporting themseves already and very high likelihood of obviously adhd in all the dc. If they were faced with funding as well as caring for the kids i would think they would make a different choice.

During diagnosis info to parents of likelihood of further sen kids and that the severity could be different.

Reading a post from a dad where he was feeding the dc mcdonalds every day! Yes i get arfid but possibly people need to consider not feeding very picky kids foods like mcD. There was a separate parent feeding their kid 50 nuggets a day not mcd and the 9yo was 10st!. We do need to get the nhs back to working with parents to expand foods (or supplement with more nutritional substitutes)

There is an issue woth available jobs but it doesnt necessarily mean people with milder disabilities need pip etc to top up the unemployment money.

Getting kids the adhd diagnosis and meds much younger is likely to help in future. But otoh kids eg skipping q at theme parks, only eating exactly what they want etc etc isnt setting up for life of eg driving, waiting for publoc transport, being extremely bored at work.

I've fed my son McD's twice in one day at times. It's called desperation when your child is so thin and absolutely will not eat. Anything will do at that point.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 20:10

Ladybarnaby · Today 19:56

Same situation here. Our kids won’t lose their benefits, stop panicking.

My son doesn't have a learning disability. He has autism and adhd but was failed by secondary school and college, and waited years for assessment through the covid lockdowns. He never leaves the house unless i'm taking him to an appointment. Does your wisdom stretch to me and should I panic? Because I think this will apply to my son. He isn't able to work and as his only parent financially supporting him to 25 will be down to me.

thatsgotit · Today 20:10

needastrongone · Today 19:53

As I said just now though, what do you think Reform or the Conservatives will do @thatsgotit? Both are talking about much deeper cuts, and far more quickly too.

My answer to that is that as unpopular as Labour's measures are with many people at present, things could be a hell of a lot worse for the vulnerable in this country if a different govt was in power.

Purplesuns · Today 20:12

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

I think you're deluded! Why do you believe the gossips on your local fb page! Please rest assured that it is, in fact, incredibly difficult to apply for and receive pip. My son has recently been awarded pip and it took me weeks to fill out all the paperwork. I also needed to supply evidence of his condition, even though he was diagnosed autistic age 3 and has received dla for many years. I really wish all these people that think it's so easy to apply for pip would have a go. Go on, try it, I can guarantee you'll change your mind.
In the meantime, families like mine live in fear of what will happen to their disabled child in the future but I've started to realise that nobody gives a fuck!

LakieLady · Today 20:15

3DPrintedDragon · Today 18:33

A quick Google says housing support costs are 11.6% of the total welfare bill.

And a fair chunk of that will be going to private landlords.

Building lots of social housing would reduce that cost, and possibly create some training and work opportunities for young people into the bargain; not just in construction, but in housing associations and local authorities, as they would need more staff to manage and maintain the new homes.

LakieLady · Today 20:24

Blackcat2026 · Today 19:22

Pensioners who have worked, whether they wanted to or not, and contributed in taxation.

And plenty of us are still contributing!

I get a few pounds extra added to my SRP because I paid SERPS for many years. That takes my pension above the personal allowance and I pay tax on it. It's collected by giving me a negative tax code on my occupational pension.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 20:27

ThreadGuardDog · Today 19:36

PIP isn’t an out of work benefit and doesn’t assess the ability to work. It’s a disability cost related benefit.

I know that, but if you’d RTFT you’d know that endless people have been saying that cutting pip will mean people will have to give up work - when only 20% of those on pip work anyway!

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:38

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 18:38

All these posters who know people who are boasting about scamming PIP, does it ever occur to you that they're lying to you, not to PIP?

I used to know a woman, very extrovert and confident, who'd loudly tell anyone that her daughter wasn't potty trained because she was too lazy to do it. Actually the daughter had a bowel issue but the mum would rather people think she was a lazy mother than tell people that, to preserve her daughter's privacy.

When I was too ill to work with anxiety and PTSD (from abuse which happened at work, irony) I used to tell people I was signed off because of a heart condition, because I didn't want to admit I had such crippling anxiety that I couldn't leave the house and had panic attacks in my sleep (and yes I was on both medication and therapy).

Some people think anxiety is what you feel about the dentist, actual diagnosed anxiety disorders can be extremely debilitating, and being open about them risks being judged by people like some posters on this thread, as being lazy or a scammer or that you have a bit of nervousness you can just get over.

You really don't know what's going on in other people's lives, and just because they tell you something, even boast about something, doesn't mean it's true.

I do this nobody knows I have bpd and they know less then a quarter off my medical conditions even people im closest to

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:39

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 20:27

I know that, but if you’d RTFT you’d know that endless people have been saying that cutting pip will mean people will have to give up work - when only 20% of those on pip work anyway!

Only 20% thats a lot when you realise how disabled you have to be to get pip

3DPrintedDragon · Today 20:45

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 20:27

I know that, but if you’d RTFT you’d know that endless people have been saying that cutting pip will mean people will have to give up work - when only 20% of those on pip work anyway!

PIP claimants who reach pension age continue to still claim PIP once they get to that age. So many people who are on PIP are not working because they are pensioners.

Neurodiversitydoctor · Today 20:48

mummymeister · Today 16:45

This is an anonymous forum. no one is going to tell you where they live as you well know.

I have been on MN for years - since it started. I am not a liar. I see these posts every single fucking day on the facebook "gossip girls" type forums.

I drink coffee in spoons. I hear the conversations.

You choose not to believe me, thats fine, I can live with that. But it doesnt change the actual facts - the system is being scammed. The govt accept that that is why its being changed yet you dont?

Which Towns ?
My best guesses are:
Blackpool
Hull
Welsh Valleys ( possibily Llenli)
Parts of Liverpool
and Hastings or Bognor in the South

Basically places with few employment opportunities, low particpation in higher education and predominantly White working class population.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 20:52

Shrawby · Today 19:40

I dont really understand pip for adhd or anxiety as money wont help those things.

In terms of cost to uk
they need to be pushing towards people having kids younger (so making housing more affordable) as older people are more likely to have autistic children
Keep on pushing the no drinking in pregnancy to reduce the 5%+ of kids with fasd
And encourage more sensible choices (and early diagnosis or parents and kids) so that people do not continue to have 2,3,4 disabled kids.

As being aware of couples who have dc out of school have a young baby and ttc. Completely illogical when both parents are adhd, not supporting themseves already and very high likelihood of obviously adhd in all the dc. If they were faced with funding as well as caring for the kids i would think they would make a different choice.

During diagnosis info to parents of likelihood of further sen kids and that the severity could be different.

Reading a post from a dad where he was feeding the dc mcdonalds every day! Yes i get arfid but possibly people need to consider not feeding very picky kids foods like mcD. There was a separate parent feeding their kid 50 nuggets a day not mcd and the 9yo was 10st!. We do need to get the nhs back to working with parents to expand foods (or supplement with more nutritional substitutes)

There is an issue woth available jobs but it doesnt necessarily mean people with milder disabilities need pip etc to top up the unemployment money.

Getting kids the adhd diagnosis and meds much younger is likely to help in future. But otoh kids eg skipping q at theme parks, only eating exactly what they want etc etc isnt setting up for life of eg driving, waiting for publoc transport, being extremely bored at work.

The autistic children in my wider family are the ones who had a truly traumatic birth. If the NHS stopped gate keeping c-sections I can see the rate of autism falling. My autistic child was the one who of my four children needed resuscitation as the midwives had ignored dropping heart rates for so long that they waited until my child’s heart stopped completely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread