Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

487 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
JenRummy · Today 17:48

There’s already a cliff edge for families. It’s absolutely appalling. Some disabled young people again lose out. Labour are a disgrace. What hope do young people without an inheritance really have these days, disabled or not? No longer a case of work hard enough not to mention Rachel has made employing young people unaffordable and AI deleting entry level jobs. Those at other end working longer so even less available and fact most of us are skint thanks to freezing of personal allowance, wage freezes, increased costs means we have less to spend in butchers and bakers too so whole economy fxxxed. Never recovered since 2008 and printing over £900billion to gift to the banks and financial markets who caused it all is insane.

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:49

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:46

He genuinely thinks you can get ill from a computer virus. He is schizophrenic.

That's really sad and of course there will be people who simply cannot work. But that doesn't mean there aren't others who are absolutely gaming the system

Happyindevon · Today 17:50

Mumsnet will also have a high ratio of benefit users who are not piss taking as it tends to attract a certain type of posters. The people I encounter at work almost certainly won’t be on this website.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:51

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:49

That's really sad and of course there will be people who simply cannot work. But that doesn't mean there aren't others who are absolutely gaming the system

But he goes on holidays, has friendships and some hobbies. According to some on here, that means he is a scammer. He absolutely can not work.

Pearlstillsinging · Today 17:52

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 17:38

They paid for those properties through hard graft though, they weren’t delivered by fairies in the night

Not really!
I am one of the generation you are talking about, although living in Yorks, I am far from an 'on paper' millionaire. Most people worked 'a fair day's work for a fair day's pay', in order to keep themselves and their families as comfortably as they could. House values shot up especially in the South of England but because of speculators, not because of anything that we did out of the ordinary.
If those houses were sold, to realise the capital, who do you think would buy them?

Temporaryname158 · Today 17:53

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Your son isn’t who they are trying to get off disability benefits.

Kirbert2 · Today 17:53

Boreded · Today 17:46

But that doesn’t fit the OP and PP’s narrative

Or they simply aren't holding their breath that it will be as effective and as simple and seamless as it's been said due to their current experience with the system, the government and having a disabled child/young person.

Lambch0p · Today 17:53

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 17:42

They are replacing it though - a youth allowance for those with mild and moderate MH needs and adhd and a higher rate complex needs benefit for people like the previous poster’s son.

The review recommends a new benefit – Severe and Complex Needs Insurance – for young people “where paid work is not realistically possible”. This would include “young people with severe or profound and multiple learning disabilities or those whose disability means they require continuous, 24-hour care and support”.
According to the report, Severe and Complex Needs Insurance would provide a “stable, long-term income set above the maximum benefit rates available today”.

Define mild and moderate and what sanctions?

My autistic dd has years of severe MH struggles involving hospitalisations. Her MH fluctuates. She absolutely wants to work but needs the right job and needs to be handled by those with expertise in her conditions not somebody with an ology at the job centre otherwise she I’ll end up seriously unwell at great expense to the tax payer. She absolutely won’t sail off into the sunset cured and will fluctuate as to need and ability ie she might not always be able to work.

Where does she stand?

“Milburn went on to reveal that claimants with low or moderate anxiety,depression, ADHD or autism would be “expected and enabled” to work, implying there would be sanctions for those who don’t engage with job seeking and admitted reform would not come without “pain”

Happyindevon · Today 17:54

Lambch0p · Today 17:53

Define mild and moderate and what sanctions?

My autistic dd has years of severe MH struggles involving hospitalisations. Her MH fluctuates. She absolutely wants to work but needs the right job and needs to be handled by those with expertise in her conditions not somebody with an ology at the job centre otherwise she I’ll end up seriously unwell at great expense to the tax payer. She absolutely won’t sail off into the sunset cured and will fluctuate as to need and ability ie she might not always be able to work.

Where does she stand?

“Milburn went on to reveal that claimants with low or moderate anxiety,depression, ADHD or autism would be “expected and enabled” to work, implying there would be sanctions for those who don’t engage with job seeking and admitted reform would not come without “pain”

If you can go in holiday, date, have kids, then you’re well enough to work.

FirmSnake · Today 17:57

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:51

But he goes on holidays, has friendships and some hobbies. According to some on here, that means he is a scammer. He absolutely can not work.

What sort of holidays and hobbies can he manage? Are we talking knitting and a caravan park?

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:57

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:51

But he goes on holidays, has friendships and some hobbies. According to some on here, that means he is a scammer. He absolutely can not work.

And I work full time and pay taxes and claim no benefits yet I am too ill to holiday or have hobbies. So you can see why there's a need for debate and review . There's no binary here

ShutupLwren · Today 17:57

Noras · Today 17:10

They are exempt

my son is more borderline due to spiky profile - not sure how he could work in a normal paid job with white matter issues / demylination.

It was hard thinking of best equipment for university as he has the ASD speech pattern for talk to write and he has motor coordination that tired in for typing - we opted for him to type but he has soft ware to abbreviate notes / record lectures and mind maps etc. It’s hard to overcome disability with tools.

I just worry so much for his future, he might be capable of brilliant things one day but he wont ever be able to walk in the community independently. Right now he honestly should have 2 people supervising him but obviously we can’t have that all the time so it’s usually me solo with him in the community and I’ve repeatedly had to tackle him from running into traffic, he is what’s known as an eloper.
I understand the frustration people feel about hearing how much money is spent on benefits and whilst I can’t even imagine how you’d be able to fraudulently claim because of the amount of evidence you need, I also know that most people seem to know several people fleecing the system getting all sorts of free shite that I don’t even get for my son even though he once ran into the road and headbutted the floor so severely he needed stitches because he was so upset by the noise of a car alarm. I just am so worried. He needs me to care for him, if I could return to work I would but I don’t get to sleep, he sometimes attacks me quite badly and I don’t think many places want to hire a woman who is flaky if her son is sent from school or looks like she’s been fighting Tyson anyway tbh.

Sorry for offloading, I’m just so anxious about my son’s future. I know I’m able to evidence things but people are so focused on people with disability at the moment and removing what they can, I just live in a state of uncertainty for his future needs.

I was pleased to see your son is thriving. I wish you both all the very best. 💐

Ponoka7 · Today 17:57

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:13

Of course there are people who really cannot work, and children who need extra support, and our benefit system is meant to be for them.

I know 2 people who get PIP and they shouldn’t. One hasn’t worked since they were 40 and with the money they get from the state and other means they are living the life of Riley. How come they need PIP but are perfectly able to self drive down to the south coast of Spain 3 times a year?

I work with someone who didn’t live here since they were 22 (after graduated) and then came back aged 65 as they run out of money, healthcare was too expensive and they had no pension. They now get pension credit for 2, housing paid for, and 2 sets of attendance allowance, but have never paid any NI. That’s over £4K a month in benefits.

People are taking the absolute piss and my household is getting hammered in tax to sub it.

I don’t want to pay tax for other people to suck the country dry. I only want it to go to those who really can’t, rather than won’t.

Edited

How do you feel about asylum seekers? Migrants getting benefits, especially thise who can't speak English? (I know the no recourse to public funds system and I've actually helped people get benefits awarded, in case people say they absolutely can't get anything). Or people having babies in war zones, in uninhabitable environments, rejecting birth control etc and then wanting refuge? What about the billions given away (not international aid), without consultation? Foreign nationals serving long sentences in our prisons?
I'm exceptionally disappointed because they've just handed the vote to Reform. As our population rises, there's less resources. We are now taking those from some of the most vulnerable in our society. We'll spend more across Health, social services and the justice system. Thankfully assisted dying was voted out. In other countries disabled people are opting for death because of a lack of housing and benefits. We'd be there within five years.

Lambch0p · Today 17:58

Happyindevon · Today 17:54

If you can go in holiday, date, have kids, then you’re well enough to work.

She doesn’t have kids or date and hasn’t been on holiday in years.So does that mean she qualifies?

Many disabled adults over 25 date, have kids and go on holiday, is that not allowed? They will be keeping their benefits

Lambch0p · Today 18:00

Temporaryname158 · Today 17:53

Your son isn’t who they are trying to get off disability benefits.

But there is a massive breadth of very complex needs. Who is going to be assessing everybody, how and when?

BruFord · Today 18:00

3DPrintedDragon · Today 17:51

But he goes on holidays, has friendships and some hobbies. According to some on here, that means he is a scammer. He absolutely can not work.

@3DPrintedDragon Schizophrenia is a completely different mental illness to anxiety, which is what that poster was referring to.

I imagine that the hallucinations and other symptoms of schizophrenia make holidays, for example, very challenging for him, poor man.

Rustybike · Today 18:02

Even if the existing claim should not be honoured, or the claimant is no longer eligible, OP?

Unreasonable, I would say.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:02

Lambch0p · Today 18:00

But there is a massive breadth of very complex needs. Who is going to be assessing everybody, how and when?

and they will absolutely decide that someone isn't complex when they are. Hopefully tribunals will still be allowed.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:02

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:47

No they didn't . A lot of that gain was from house price inflation
My parents bought a house for £50k when I was a child and it's now with well over a million. That's not hard graft it's the luck of the house price lottery

That’s not real money then if they live there! It hardly makes them rich

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:04

Pearlstillsinging · Today 17:52

Not really!
I am one of the generation you are talking about, although living in Yorks, I am far from an 'on paper' millionaire. Most people worked 'a fair day's work for a fair day's pay', in order to keep themselves and their families as comfortably as they could. House values shot up especially in the South of England but because of speculators, not because of anything that we did out of the ordinary.
If those houses were sold, to realise the capital, who do you think would buy them?

Read what I was responding to!

cornflakecrunchie · Today 18:07

I don't know what people expected when they voted Labour in. Unicorns & everything free, I think. And, yes, refugees flooding in. 21.4 million per day on accomodation.. & now trying to get us back into Europe.. because other european countries are doing SO well, aren't they? It all drives me utterly crazy.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 18:10

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 17:15

He isn’t - young people like your son aren’t the people the changes are aimed at.

Who are the people the changes are aimed at? The kids whose parents have had to fight all the way through school to get the support they need? The ones who can't get a place at a specialist unit because they are too academically able yet they cannot cope in a mainstream school. The young people on the 7 year waiting list who get diagnosed and then immediately discharged with no support?

I recommend watching this.
These are the kids who cannot cope with school, and now will not be able to claim anything if they also can't cope with work. And it's their parents, predominantly their mothers, who will suffer for the rest of their lives in a multitude of ways because of it.

GiaGia16 · Today 18:11

cornflakecrunchie · Today 18:07

I don't know what people expected when they voted Labour in. Unicorns & everything free, I think. And, yes, refugees flooding in. 21.4 million per day on accomodation.. & now trying to get us back into Europe.. because other european countries are doing SO well, aren't they? It all drives me utterly crazy.

Yes.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:15

Shardonneigghhh · Today 18:10

Who are the people the changes are aimed at? The kids whose parents have had to fight all the way through school to get the support they need? The ones who can't get a place at a specialist unit because they are too academically able yet they cannot cope in a mainstream school. The young people on the 7 year waiting list who get diagnosed and then immediately discharged with no support?

I recommend watching this.
These are the kids who cannot cope with school, and now will not be able to claim anything if they also can't cope with work. And it's their parents, predominantly their mothers, who will suffer for the rest of their lives in a multitude of ways because of it.

Why are there so many kids who need support in school these days?

TigerRag · Today 18:16

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:15

Why are there so many kids who need support in school these days?

Because some of us were just left to get on with it