Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

526 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Yesterday 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:33

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:25

And what jobs do they do? What % of WFH are entry level?

Call up any customer service or government helpline and someone will answer the phone with their doorbell ringing and dog barking in the back.

Online training given to people, resources sent to them. I do online learning at home all the time. If you have a laptop and a phone, you can work.

Kirbert2 · Yesterday 17:33

Simonjt · Yesterday 17:22

This is a huge issue.

We have left the UK now, but my husband has a significant physical disability he was born with. Due to that so many jobs are completely out of his reach, no matter what adaptations are provided. But lots of careers and jobs are within his reach. He’s lucky that hes academic, so he could gain a career based on those skills. When he qualified and was looking for work he was on three occasions told when he booked in for his interview that the post had been filled. On two of those occasions another guy on the same training scheme was interviewed on the same day at a later time. When he did finally get a job his line manager actively moaned that he needed a different keyboard, mouse and for when he was tired eyegaze technology and would ask at every single line management meeting for him to just try harder at using normal equipment. He was hitting all of his targets and often early, but that didn’t matter to then.

So many employers actively discriminate against people with disabilities.

As I said, hes academic, if he wasn’t all the trades, shop work, care work, cleaning, driving jobs, and anything that requires you to hold something heavier than a bag of sugar, or to type/use a mouse for more than about 40 minutes without a break just aren’t possible for him.

This is similar to my son except he isn't very academic.

I'm actually not sure what he'd be classed as on not-PIP when he ages out of DLA because he is physically disabled but doesn't have any learning disabilities. The jobs you listed wouldn't be suitable for him either or like you said with typing, very unlikely without regular breaks which I can't imagine many employers would be very keen on as I can't imagine he'd get much done compared to someone who doesn't need those breaks.

Happyindevon · Yesterday 17:33

The problem is once someone has been on benefits for a few years it makes them unemployable even if they weren’t before. They spend years lying in bed all day, getting lazy, smoking weed/drinking, eating garbage and letting their brain and work ethic atrophy. They then get MH issues from the effects of lack of work.

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:34

lifeturnsonadime · Yesterday 14:51

I'd have more support for removing child benefit than for this. People make a conscious decision to have children, which should include working out if they can afford it. No one chooses to be disabled.

What about removing the state pension from millionaire pensioners?

I read today that UK homeowners aged 65 and over hold £2.25 trillion (£2,253 billion) in housing equity.

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:35

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:33

Call up any customer service or government helpline and someone will answer the phone with their doorbell ringing and dog barking in the back.

Online training given to people, resources sent to them. I do online learning at home all the time. If you have a laptop and a phone, you can work.

This was probably during Covid where people were forced to work from home in an emergency.

WFH is completely different now.

BruFord · Yesterday 17:36

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:12

Working is totally different to going on holiday and dating. Totally different demands.

@3DPrintedDragon I'm diagnosed with GAD so I've personally experienced different anxiety levels. IMO, if you're well enough to date and go on holiday, you can do some type of work. Not hugely stressful work, but you can do something.

When someone is really ill with anxiety, they couldn't go on holiday.

Dimpkhimniaa · Yesterday 17:36

mamaof4losingmymind · Yesterday 17:30

There is still a significant stigma around mental illness. My work certainly don't pander to my health conditions I use all my holidays on hospital appointments and the rest I have to take unpaid. Occy health reports are just suggestions. So no help there.

True there is still some stigma but IMO it honestly isn’t to anywhere near the same level. I was lucky to keep my jobs though when I was off for years at a time, otherwise I would be in a very different place professionally and personally now.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:36

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:33

Call up any customer service or government helpline and someone will answer the phone with their doorbell ringing and dog barking in the back.

Online training given to people, resources sent to them. I do online learning at home all the time. If you have a laptop and a phone, you can work.

And if you don't have a laptop? Are computer illiterate?

How does someone who has not worked for 20 years, and thinks a computer virus means you need to wear mask, get a WFH job?

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:36

The government needs a massive drive to get employers to hire the under 25s. What happened to YTS schemes and training up in a vocation with college.

Apparently we are at the bottom of the EU youth unemployment list, just above Romania.

Its a catastrophe.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:37

Happyindevon · Yesterday 17:33

The problem is once someone has been on benefits for a few years it makes them unemployable even if they weren’t before. They spend years lying in bed all day, getting lazy, smoking weed/drinking, eating garbage and letting their brain and work ethic atrophy. They then get MH issues from the effects of lack of work.

That is a ridiculous stereotype.

Lambch0p · Yesterday 17:38

Happyindevon · Yesterday 17:33

The problem is once someone has been on benefits for a few years it makes them unemployable even if they weren’t before. They spend years lying in bed all day, getting lazy, smoking weed/drinking, eating garbage and letting their brain and work ethic atrophy. They then get MH issues from the effects of lack of work.

That’s absolute rubbish. My dc is at university .

Dimpkhimniaa · Yesterday 17:38

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:34

What about removing the state pension from millionaire pensioners?

I read today that UK homeowners aged 65 and over hold £2.25 trillion (£2,253 billion) in housing equity.

They paid for those properties through hard graft though, they weren’t delivered by fairies in the night

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:39

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:36

The government needs a massive drive to get employers to hire the under 25s. What happened to YTS schemes and training up in a vocation with college.

Apparently we are at the bottom of the EU youth unemployment list, just above Romania.

Its a catastrophe.

They are. They are going to pay the wages of young people for 6 months.
Sounds good, until you realise it just means free labour for businesses.
It has been done before, albeit under a different name.

ilovebrie8 · Yesterday 17:39

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:36

The government needs a massive drive to get employers to hire the under 25s. What happened to YTS schemes and training up in a vocation with college.

Apparently we are at the bottom of the EU youth unemployment list, just above Romania.

Its a catastrophe.

A lot of jobs are going to non Brits that’s another aspect at play.

Pearlstillsinging · Yesterday 17:40

PestoPastaPizza · Yesterday 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

He won't be, that has already been made clear.

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 17:40

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:36

And if you don't have a laptop? Are computer illiterate?

How does someone who has not worked for 20 years, and thinks a computer virus means you need to wear mask, get a WFH job?

Get them in the job centres training up and updating skills. I’m talking about younger people.

It’s not actually that hard.

FYI I am in 50’s and I’ve just changed career via training. If I can do it people younger than me can.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Yesterday 17:42

Lambch0p · Yesterday 17:20

It isn’t either or. There are people all the way through the spectrum of need and also those who are on very long difficulties journeys. It’s utter madness just taking it from all. Many people are using it to fill gaps from the NHS. They will no longer be able to have treatment or therapy! What happens to them and the NHS lists they will need to go on?

They are replacing it though - a youth allowance for those with mild and moderate MH needs and adhd and a higher rate complex needs benefit for people like the previous poster’s son.

The review recommends a new benefit – Severe and Complex Needs Insurance – for young people “where paid work is not realistically possible”. This would include “young people with severe or profound and multiple learning disabilities or those whose disability means they require continuous, 24-hour care and support”.
According to the report, Severe and Complex Needs Insurance would provide a “stable, long-term income set above the maximum benefit rates available today”.

I have ADHD and autism – disgusting benefit cuts won’t help young people work

A new report is due to recommend redrawing the benefits system for young people amid a youth unemployment epidemic

https://inews.co.uk/news/adhd-autism-disgusting-benefit-cuts-young-people-work-4901796?ico=in-line_link

FirmSnake · Yesterday 17:43

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:36

And if you don't have a laptop? Are computer illiterate?

How does someone who has not worked for 20 years, and thinks a computer virus means you need to wear mask, get a WFH job?

Does this person reside in 2005?

AirborneElephant · Yesterday 17:43

BurntBroccoli · Yesterday 17:23

Tax burden pensioners
£177 billion

Tax burden PIP
£27.3 billion

That’s a really misleading statistic. The total cost of disability benefits is now more like £77bn, and projected to reach £120bn by 2030. It’s not some small number that we can keep ignoring, it needs major change right now.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:44

FirmSnake · Yesterday 17:43

Does this person reside in 2005?

No, just ill

FirmSnake · Yesterday 17:44

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:44

No, just ill

With a computer virus?

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 17:46

FirmSnake · Yesterday 17:44

With a computer virus?

He genuinely thinks you can get ill from a computer virus. He is schizophrenic.

Boreded · Yesterday 17:46

needastrongone · Yesterday 13:16

From listening to Alan Milburn’s speech, listening to a lot of his interviews in the media recently, those claimants with the greatest level of need will receive an enhanced package of support, with fewer reviews.

But that doesn’t fit the OP and PP’s narrative

Heatedblankettime · Yesterday 17:47

Dimpkhimniaa · Yesterday 17:38

They paid for those properties through hard graft though, they weren’t delivered by fairies in the night

No they didn't . A lot of that gain was from house price inflation
My parents bought a house for £50k when I was a child and it's now with well over a million. That's not hard graft it's the luck of the house price lottery

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · Yesterday 17:48

There are some people who just can’t work and we need to fully support those financially and also by funding the necessary care etc. However, there are a lot who can work with the right support/training and for these we should be supporting them to work and get jobs rather than to supporting them to not work - they may be a period when they can’t work where they are supported but it shouldn’t be indefinitely

Swipe left for the next trending thread