Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask of your adult child meet someone at uni, that was privately educated, would that put you off them ?

528 replies

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:40

or wouldn't you care?

OP posts:
allthemind · Today 17:48

I think generally private school kids come out better educated in thetarditional sense because their parents are paying and are therefore usually particularly motivated, and pro-education themselves, as that is how they have got a well-paid job to afford the fees, and they are therefore more likely to nag and make sure their kids do their homework, study for exams, get tutoring etc and also the kids are in smaller classrooms, esp at A level, so get more individual attention and the teachers are generally better paid/more motivated (or if they are not, they are moved on more quickly, becasue it's a business).

Of course there are lots of parents exactly like this in state schools, of course there are, but there are also many disinterested parents, who don't value education, don't get involved and don't particulary care how well their kids do in their GCSEs becasue they fully expect them to leave school at 16 or go to vocational college courses. Statistically, this is going to result in a higher proportion of PE kids doing well in external exams and being interested in going to university. More than half the kids in state school sixth forms or colleges aren't even put on the A level/university pathway, wheras its very unuusal in a private school and those kids who arent that way inclinde never make it into sixth form in the first place.

dontquotemenow · Today 20:12

The poster arguing IGCSEs are 'easier' is talking clear nonsense. Obviously. You might as well argue AQA are easier than Edexcel, or WJEC or any other board. There are different types of IGCSE anyway.

Even if some papers on some boards may be deemed 'easier' in any given year for a given subject, it just obviously means less will achieve the top grades. Grades are standardised across all boards. Just like within a given examining board, if a paper is easier one year, it just means the grade boundaries shift upwards.

There is NO way Maths IGCSE is easier than other boards because those students are basically up against all the international schools in China, India and Korea where maths standards snd expectations are another level, as are work ethics.

It's not even the case that independent schools do 'all IGCSEs' anyway. Only schools with high concentrations of ex-pat families (mainly).

And if it were the case that IGCSEs were 'easier', how would the pp explain students who get all 9s in IGCSE going in to get 4 A stars at A-level? As if a 9 in one board is the equivalent of a 7 in another.

The very selective independent schools and grammars will have them doing 4 A-levels, plus an EPQ and many of them are doing music or drama exams as well at Grade 8, plus sports and D of E and all sorts. These kids are flat out to the max, so din't tell me they have it easy in these intense, high expectation environments.

Don't even get me started on the IB which some independents offer as an alternative to A-levels. In terms of UCAS points, top scores in IB are equivalent to 5 A stars at A-level.

Finally, in terms of applicants versus places, it is harder for an 11 year/old to get into say, St Paul's or Godolphin and Latymer or any of the top maybe 20 independent schools, than it is to get into any top uni. There is a school around me where over 1,500 11 year-olds sit exams for 120 places every Jan. it's not just exams, it's interviews. These kids are put though it. And if you are in a school where 98% of GCSEs every year are 9-7s, you'd better get your head down and keep up because nobody is going to be making excuses for you; nor will anybody be celebrating you, or calling you 'gifted and talented' or whatever. You can come out with 4 A stars, a top EPQ and all sorts of other qualifications and achievements and, in the context of the school, that's just 'ok.' On the other hand, the stand out kids at less of non-selective schools (state or private) who are used to being celebrated as 'top' or 'gifted', can really struggle at top unis when they realise they are just average in that cohort.

Independent schools vary as much as state and this whole thread is odd.

dontquotemenow · Today 20:45

And as for uni applications, of course it's easier to get a string of A stars at a very academic school (state or private) than at a non-selective school. Terns will generally conform and measure themselves against the 'norm' in their peer group. If you're in classes where everyone is on track for the top grades, the teaching will move at that pace and that's all those students will know, so they run with it. As opposed to a mixed-ability school, where teaching might just be aimed at getting as many as possible to get over the C threshold. To get a A star in that type of school environment, kids have to be outliers and push against mediocrity basically. It's so often true that "you can only be what you can see.'" It's hard to push against the 'norm' of school expectations, especially as, at that age, fitting in with peers is everything.

But the top unis are obviously acutely aware of this and that's why admissions are heavily contextualised. If you are applying from a bog comp with A star, A, A this will be looked at as more of an achievement than an applicant from a top independent (or grammar) with 4 A stars. Students from those very academic schools will need something extra, on top of very top grades, to stand a chance of an offer.

At Cambridge now, almost 80% of students are from the state sector. This almost mirrors the 17% of sixth formers who are in independent education across the U.K.. It is also true though, that when you look deeper, most of the state school students are not from comprehensives, they are from the top grammars and academies. Just like most of the stufents who get in from the independent sector, are from the very selective schools as opposed to some sleepy, 'all rounder' private school which parents choose for reasons that are not particularly academic and anybody who can pay will get in. Of course there are also s proportion from overseas schools and they have to be contextualised too. But it will always be the case that selective schools, whether state or private, will, by definition, have higher numbers of applicants to Oxbridge, or Imperial or St Andrews etc. Unis can only assess those who actually apply and then contextualise as much as possible.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page