Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask of your adult child meet someone at uni, that was privately educated, would that put you off them ?

528 replies

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:40

or wouldn't you care?

OP posts:
allthemind · Yesterday 13:50

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 13:23

The elite universities are part of the system that perpetuates inequality.

I'm not railing against the machine. I can't change it. But we don't have to pretend it doesn't exist.

No they're not. Have you been to one recently? They are incredibly diverse and egalitarian now after initiatives for many years to make sure state school pupils are represented. They are massively represented now. Contextual offers make it much easier to get into university from certain postcodes and applicants are penalised if one of their parents has a degree. Like many on this thread, you are very out of touch.

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 13:59

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 07:58

I also examine A Levels in addition to GCSEs. Is that enough research for you? (Most examiners work on a whole raft of different exams at different levels.) The pattern is the same.

Pretending the playing field is level is bullshit.

Edited

Examiner as a Marking exams?

Is Cambridge IGCSE equivalent to the UK GCSE? – What can we help you with?

"They are aligned to the standards of the UK GCSE, and are equivalent on a subject–for–subject, grade–for–grade basis."

Sorry, you're embarrassing yourself.

ETA: even if I chose to believe you and not Cambridge International, you can't explain the fact that the students who do iGCSEs with 8-9s and then UK standard A-Levels and get all A-As are actually at grade 6 GCSE?

Tortephant · Yesterday 13:59

allthemind · Yesterday 13:50

No they're not. Have you been to one recently? They are incredibly diverse and egalitarian now after initiatives for many years to make sure state school pupils are represented. They are massively represented now. Contextual offers make it much easier to get into university from certain postcodes and applicants are penalised if one of their parents has a degree. Like many on this thread, you are very out of touch.

wow, that’s simply not on. If that’s true it needs addressing.
Coming full circle to the original post, penalising a sixth former for their parent having a degree is judging them on their parents and not their own merit. extraordinary

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 14:03

Private ed students are 6 times more likely to get into Oxbridge than state school applicants. Despite benefitting from easier to pass international GCSEs & A Levels.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 14:05

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 13:59

Examiner as a Marking exams?

Is Cambridge IGCSE equivalent to the UK GCSE? – What can we help you with?

"They are aligned to the standards of the UK GCSE, and are equivalent on a subject–for–subject, grade–for–grade basis."

Sorry, you're embarrassing yourself.

ETA: even if I chose to believe you and not Cambridge International, you can't explain the fact that the students who do iGCSEs with 8-9s and then UK standard A-Levels and get all A-As are actually at grade 6 GCSE?

Edited

Not sure what you mean by this? Examiner as a Marking exams?

I mark both international and UK. CIE & AQA are not comparable. AQA is widely reputed to be the hardest and CIE one of the easiest. This aligns with my examining experience which is not just based on being an examiner but other roles within the exam boards.

So by all means doubt. There is a reason elite schools pick iGCSE. Because they're guaranteed higher grades.

HoleMealFlower · Yesterday 14:08

What a weird question!

I say that as the only one out of husband and two kids that wasn’t privately educated 😂

allthemind · Yesterday 14:10

Sigh. International A levels in UK schools isnt a thing. All UK students studying A levels in private schools in the UK do the same A level syllabus and the same examining boards as kids in state schools or sixth form colleges. International A levels aren't easier but are designed for students outside of the UK, so the History syllabus will be different, more international literature in English Lit etc. It is very difficult for an in the UK kid to do them and its only a few remote learning, online school, specialist colleges that offer them. Nowhere near enough to make any difference to uni applications.

Where are your recent and up to date statistics that kids that do A levels at private schools are 6x more likely to get into to Oxbridge compared to kids that do A levels at state schools or colleges?

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 14:16

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 14:05

Not sure what you mean by this? Examiner as a Marking exams?

I mark both international and UK. CIE & AQA are not comparable. AQA is widely reputed to be the hardest and CIE one of the easiest. This aligns with my examining experience which is not just based on being an examiner but other roles within the exam boards.

So by all means doubt. There is a reason elite schools pick iGCSE. Because they're guaranteed higher grades.

Edited

They pass UK A-Levels!

Top private schools use iGCSE because they are aligned with multinational use and these schools attract significant proportion of international families.

Level of complexity is reflected in grade boundaries.

"I also examine A Levels in addition to GCSEs. Is that enough research for you?"

No, it's not enough and it's not a research. You use predefined marking scheme and follow it, you don't do research. You share your personal biased views.

allthemind · Yesterday 14:19

Tortephant · Yesterday 13:59

wow, that’s simply not on. If that’s true it needs addressing.
Coming full circle to the original post, penalising a sixth former for their parent having a degree is judging them on their parents and not their own merit. extraordinary

It really annoys me. I have helped teens with their UCAS applications and you have to state whether either of your parents has a degree. I dont see the relevance. I do but my husband flunked his A levels and got a job driving a truck. How is that relevant years later for kids born in a completely different world? Why are they penalised in terms of offers because I was a studious swot that enjoyed science and learning? We both earn the same anyway.

My recent experience is that to get an offer from any university you have to meet, or be very close to the stated entry requirements for the course in your predicted grades and for the top 10 unis you need stellar predicted grades and 8s and 9s at GCSE, or come from a very deprived background. For Oxbridge, Imperial, a few others for certain subjects, you clearly have to be extremely academic with a proven track record of being so. As it should be. It makes little difference ime what type if school you were at now. Some people are so out of touch, harping back to how things were 30 or 40 years ago.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 14:24

allthemind · Yesterday 14:19

It really annoys me. I have helped teens with their UCAS applications and you have to state whether either of your parents has a degree. I dont see the relevance. I do but my husband flunked his A levels and got a job driving a truck. How is that relevant years later for kids born in a completely different world? Why are they penalised in terms of offers because I was a studious swot that enjoyed science and learning? We both earn the same anyway.

My recent experience is that to get an offer from any university you have to meet, or be very close to the stated entry requirements for the course in your predicted grades and for the top 10 unis you need stellar predicted grades and 8s and 9s at GCSE, or come from a very deprived background. For Oxbridge, Imperial, a few others for certain subjects, you clearly have to be extremely academic with a proven track record of being so. As it should be. It makes little difference ime what type if school you were at now. Some people are so out of touch, harping back to how things were 30 or 40 years ago.

I think the question about parents having degrees is for the First in Family data, rather than an entry criterion.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 14:30

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 14:16

They pass UK A-Levels!

Top private schools use iGCSE because they are aligned with multinational use and these schools attract significant proportion of international families.

Level of complexity is reflected in grade boundaries.

"I also examine A Levels in addition to GCSEs. Is that enough research for you?"

No, it's not enough and it's not a research. You use predefined marking scheme and follow it, you don't do research. You share your personal biased views.

And what is your experience?

Any work within the exam boards? I hold several roles beyond that of examiner in more than one exam board. If you're comparable, possibly you have a relevant POV. Otherwise, you merely have a bias based on nothing. Other than defending a child with international qualifications I suspect.

allthemind · Yesterday 14:33

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 14:24

I think the question about parents having degrees is for the First in Family data, rather than an entry criterion.

There must be some potential benefit to being able to answer No and qualify for First in Family though or otherwise why ask it? And why just one of your parents? Why dont you qualify if you only have one parent where nobody in the family went to university and one where you were the first, as in my children's case?

Katiesaidthat · Yesterday 14:43

Shalalaa · 17/11/2026 06:46

You know what OP.. I would have thought nothing of it before.

but I’m a state school student my husband went to boarding school. Looking back I shouldn’t have married him. He seemed fine but he has slowly morphed into his parents and schools ideology. Deeply misogynistic.

i like to think if I had married someone from a similar background to me we could have had a more harmonious life

My aunt married the boy next door, literally. It ended like the French Revolution. Except the French revolution was more peaceful.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 14:46

allthemind · Yesterday 14:33

There must be some potential benefit to being able to answer No and qualify for First in Family though or otherwise why ask it? And why just one of your parents? Why dont you qualify if you only have one parent where nobody in the family went to university and one where you were the first, as in my children's case?

genuinely I don’t know if some universities prioritise applications from first in family candidates - but in some post-92s you’d be in a distinct minority if you were not FiF, and that is not due to preferential treatment of applicants.

allthemind · Yesterday 14:52

There must be a quota for FIF I'd have thought. Same as there's a quota for state school applicants, deprived postcodes etc. What there isnt a quota for though of course is kids who have ended up at a private school for sixth form for a myriad of reasons, including bullying, special needs, parents having being bullied at their schools, kids from extremely deprived backgrounds on 100% bursaries etc etc.

SquigglePigs · Yesterday 14:54

I was that person- state educated, met my privately educated DH at university. Our outlooks are very similar and the differences in our educational background are completely irrelevant to any aspect of our life and relationship.

Both my family and his were very welcoming to each of us.

To be fair we had similar upbringings in apart from schooling so that probably helped.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 14:59

allthemind · Yesterday 14:52

There must be a quota for FIF I'd have thought. Same as there's a quota for state school applicants, deprived postcodes etc. What there isnt a quota for though of course is kids who have ended up at a private school for sixth form for a myriad of reasons, including bullying, special needs, parents having being bullied at their schools, kids from extremely deprived backgrounds on 100% bursaries etc etc.

Well those things would be a lot more difficult to argue wouldn’t they? Imagine the poor admissions tutor having to decide if the level of bullying was severe enough to mean the applicant had had no choice but to go to private 6th form. And the cynic in me thinks that would be very open to playing, as a criterion

allthemind · Yesterday 15:09

I dont think anyone is asking for special treatment, other than for kids that have come from extremely under privileged backgrounds or abusive situations (like the boy on a 100% bursary at our local private school that I know that is extremely good at maths but was born to a 16y old mother and lived in a 1 bed flat with 3 siblings and a physically abusive partner). Equal treatment and consideration for all teenagers, based on consistent and demonstrated commitment and performance in externaly moderated exams is what I want, and an end to the ridiculous chippiness from decades ago about public schoolboys that has little to do with most kids at private schools today.

FateAmenableToChange · Yesterday 17:27

The kid didn’t choose the school, their parents did. Do you always judge people for decisions their parents made for them when they were children or just in this case?

Alisonsy · Yesterday 19:59

FateAmenableToChange · Yesterday 17:27

The kid didn’t choose the school, their parents did. Do you always judge people for decisions their parents made for them when they were children or just in this case?

And even if the children had a say in the decision, what is there to judge? That the family values education?

Harrysmummy246 · Yesterday 20:05

Husband went to a grammar, I went to a bog standard comp, we met at Oxford- chances are most people we talked to were privately educated. Just how it was

Vitrolinsanity · Yesterday 20:08

Gosh I hope not. My DS is PE. It’s not all misogyny, fuck the peasants and zero empathy. You simply cannot conflate all PE kids with some notion that they loathe anyone not PE. They just happened to go to a school their parents paid for.

Vitrolinsanity · Yesterday 20:08

Gosh I hope not. My DS is PE. It’s not all misogyny, fuck the peasants and zero empathy. You simply cannot conflate all PE kids with some notion that they loathe anyone not PE. They just happened to go to a school their parents paid for.

spritzwiththat · Yesterday 20:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Vitrolinsanity · Yesterday 20:15

My son’s A levels were all AQA. So are his state educated girlfriend’s.