Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask of your adult child meet someone at uni, that was privately educated, would that put you off them ?

528 replies

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:40

or wouldn't you care?

OP posts:
Gengha · Yesterday 20:17

No, that’s really weird. My sister and I are state school educated but both met and married men who were privately educated, my parents never had a chip on their shoulders about it

Vitrolinsanity · Yesterday 20:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

apologies PP. I hope I did not offend you. DS’s best friend from PE is a LAC and there were many on bursary (ours was 50% due to horrifically unforeseen circumstances mid-way through GCSE. Our experience is that PE kids meet as they find; just kids.

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 20:18

allthemind · Yesterday 13:50

No they're not. Have you been to one recently? They are incredibly diverse and egalitarian now after initiatives for many years to make sure state school pupils are represented. They are massively represented now. Contextual offers make it much easier to get into university from certain postcodes and applicants are penalised if one of their parents has a degree. Like many on this thread, you are very out of touch.

What do you mean that state school pupils are now 'over represented'. Do Oxford and Cambridge now take well over 90% of their UK intake from state schools? Do you not understand the reason for contextual offers? Is it actually a fact that applicants get penalised if their parent has a degree?
What is definitely a fact is that it was, historically, far easier to get into a good University from a private school, for various reasons, and that private school parents weren't complaining that it was unfair back then!

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 20:20

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 14:16

They pass UK A-Levels!

Top private schools use iGCSE because they are aligned with multinational use and these schools attract significant proportion of international families.

Level of complexity is reflected in grade boundaries.

"I also examine A Levels in addition to GCSEs. Is that enough research for you?"

No, it's not enough and it's not a research. You use predefined marking scheme and follow it, you don't do research. You share your personal biased views.

In fairness to the other poster, if she has many years of experience as a marker of various exam boards, she is well placed to make a comment.
Well all have our personal biases but she (or he) has professional experience in this realm.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 20:43

Alisonsy · Yesterday 19:59

And even if the children had a say in the decision, what is there to judge? That the family values education?

Yes good point. My children went to state school because I place no value on education whatsoever. It’s the same for most of us

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 20:49

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 20:20

In fairness to the other poster, if she has many years of experience as a marker of various exam boards, she is well placed to make a comment.
Well all have our personal biases but she (or he) has professional experience in this realm.

Let's agree to disagree.

I trust creators of exam papers and marking schemes more than a person who is employed to follow a script. I shared the link to the official explanation. That poster didn't share any evidences apart from their opinions.

If that poster's logic was correct, than PS kids with 9s and 8s in iGCSE, which is their view are equal to 6s in GCSE, would be unable to get A/As in A levels. There are no iA levels, just UK standard ones.

Smallestshadow · Yesterday 21:02

I wouldn’t judge them to be a bad person in anyway, but I would wonder how much they have in common. My DC are from a very working class family and I’ve never had a significant relationship with anyone from the upper echelons of society. I wouldn’t verbalise any of this, however and would still be polite and welcoming if they seemed like a decent person.

TonTonMacoute · Yesterday 21:21

No. If they hooked up with someone who had a prejudiced parent like you, however, I would warn them to run a mile

Vitrolinsanity · Yesterday 21:22

You understand that not all PE kids are from upper echelons. I’m from a solid working class background, really where there’s muck there’s brass. There are lots of reasons to PE and lots of reasons why PE kids are just kids like yours.

Flamingojune · Yesterday 21:26

Alisonsy · Yesterday 19:59

And even if the children had a say in the decision, what is there to judge? That the family values education?

So the majority of parents in the uk don't value education. What a crass, small minded thing to say

jgjgjgjgjg · Yesterday 21:30

You come across as extremely naive OP, with a very narrow and stereotypical view of those who were privately educated and demonstrating a lack of critical thinking skills. I assume you live a very sheltered life in which you mix only with people from a narrow segment of the ocioeconomic scale - I'd assume the bottom end of it?

If you've managed to bring up your children to think the same way you do, their chances of forming a successful relationship with anyone outside of your immediate comfort zone and social class is very small.

InterIgnis · Yesterday 21:30

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 20:49

Let's agree to disagree.

I trust creators of exam papers and marking schemes more than a person who is employed to follow a script. I shared the link to the official explanation. That poster didn't share any evidences apart from their opinions.

If that poster's logic was correct, than PS kids with 9s and 8s in iGCSE, which is their view are equal to 6s in GCSE, would be unable to get A/As in A levels. There are no iA levels, just UK standard ones.

This. Someone employed to mark test results can also have their own personal biases.

If it were true that iGCSEs were easier than standard GCSEs, then this would be reflected in A level results. As it is, private school students are roughly twice as likely to achieve A or A* grades than their state counterparts.

raffiabunny · Today 04:37

Yeah the igcse question is way off the mark - they are the same thing ffs. Not ‘easier’ than GCSEs.

CountryShepherd · Today 08:18

Blinky21 · 17/11/2026 07:26

I wouldn't like it, based on my own family members who are privately educated and my own moral values, but of course it comes down to the individual.

I have to say I have nephews at super expensive private schools and I don't warm to them - I find them rather brash and superior. One of them is at the same uni as his cousin (a niece of mine) who was state educated - she says they move in very different circles.

My own DD has started at Oxbridge recently and she said the first few weeks were full of 'and where did you go to school?' Funnily enough, no one had heard of her comp! It's settled down now but I think she is a bit in awe of some of the backgrounds she has heard about - a different world to us! Although I went to private school decades ago.

She has a new boyfriend from a private school background - he seems lovely! So, of course, it comes down to individuals but I think its naive to say it has no bearing on anything at all.

rainingsnoring · Today 08:47

InterIgnis · Yesterday 21:30

This. Someone employed to mark test results can also have their own personal biases.

If it were true that iGCSEs were easier than standard GCSEs, then this would be reflected in A level results. As it is, private school students are roughly twice as likely to achieve A or A* grades than their state counterparts.

I don't think your A level conclusion necessarily follows as there are so many other factors.
I did say that everyone has their biases. I definitely don't think parents of children in private schools are the best judge though and would be more likely to take the opinion of a professional teacher seriously.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 09:45

raffiabunny · Today 04:37

Yeah the igcse question is way off the mark - they are the same thing ffs. Not ‘easier’ than GCSEs.

Do you across several exam boards?

In that case, HOW do you know?

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 09:46

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 20:49

Let's agree to disagree.

I trust creators of exam papers and marking schemes more than a person who is employed to follow a script. I shared the link to the official explanation. That poster didn't share any evidences apart from their opinions.

If that poster's logic was correct, than PS kids with 9s and 8s in iGCSE, which is their view are equal to 6s in GCSE, would be unable to get A/As in A levels. There are no iA levels, just UK standard ones.

Good!

In that case, I rest my case. IGCSE = easier (or at least, lower grade boundaries) than GCSEs.

nearlylovemyusername · Today 13:16

IGCSE = easier (or at least, lower grade boundaries) than GCSEs.

Bingo!
This is exactly what drives this perception and shows amazing lack of critical thinking.

Grade boundaries are fluid and decided each year to ensure that roughly the same proportion of students get 9s, 8s etc, whilst also keeping comparable complexity across years.
Lower grade boundaries mean that the paper itself is actually harder, so to make sure the outcome is comparable across exam boards they have to lower the thresholds.

Computer Science Edexcel grade 9 boundary is 82%
Computer Science OCR grade 9 boundary is 88%

OCR is not harder than Edexcel, it's Edexcel paper which is harder so grade boundary is set up lower.

GCSE and A level grading: what you need to know - GOV.UK

"Where grade boundaries increase between one year and the next, or are higher with one board than another, it does not mean it is more difficult to achieve a grade. Rather, it reflects that that exam paper was easier. Equally, where grade boundaries are lower with one exam board than another that reflects that the paper was harder, not that it is easier to get a particular grade. "

So the fact that established examiner believes that iGCSEs are easier based on lower grade boundaries doesn't work nicely for their credibility.

crazycrofter · Today 13:22

Dd did a couple of iGCSEs, alongside GCSEs in her other 7 subjects. She got 8s and 9s in all of them and never mentioned that the iGCSEs were easier.

bobiwien · Today 13:26

Even private school kids have to work to get their qualifications you know.

What a stupid post.

raffiabunny · Today 13:42

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 09:45

Do you across several exam boards?

In that case, HOW do you know?

I know because your argument makes no sense. It's exactly as @nearlylovemyusername explains. There are multiple exam boards and multiple subjects.

If it were a reality that 'one GCSE board is harder than this one, or iGCSEs are easier than GCSEs', imagine the headache it would cause university admissions tutors! Do you think with all the tens of thousands of young people applying to uni each year, this would actually be a thing? Of course not!

I say this as a parent who didn't even know my child's GCSES were iGCSES until about a year ago - everyone just called them 'GCSEs'. And her 'easier' 10 grade 9 iGCSEs didn't seem to have an impact on her 4 astars at A-level, and Cambridge admission, so...😉

nearlylovemyusername · Today 14:14

raffiabunny · Today 13:42

I know because your argument makes no sense. It's exactly as @nearlylovemyusername explains. There are multiple exam boards and multiple subjects.

If it were a reality that 'one GCSE board is harder than this one, or iGCSEs are easier than GCSEs', imagine the headache it would cause university admissions tutors! Do you think with all the tens of thousands of young people applying to uni each year, this would actually be a thing? Of course not!

I say this as a parent who didn't even know my child's GCSES were iGCSES until about a year ago - everyone just called them 'GCSEs'. And her 'easier' 10 grade 9 iGCSEs didn't seem to have an impact on her 4 astars at A-level, and Cambridge admission, so...😉

but your DD didn't have to work hard for any of these, right? you just paid school fees and that's it 😉

raffiabunny · Today 14:16

@nearlylovemyusername - absolutely! She's just a posh thicko that's had everything handed to her on a silver plate 😂

nearlylovemyusername · Today 14:22

raffiabunny · Today 14:16

@nearlylovemyusername - absolutely! She's just a posh thicko that's had everything handed to her on a silver plate 😂

Make sure she's not dating OP's child - their values don't align

InterIgnis · Today 17:27

rainingsnoring · Today 08:47

I don't think your A level conclusion necessarily follows as there are so many other factors.
I did say that everyone has their biases. I definitely don't think parents of children in private schools are the best judge though and would be more likely to take the opinion of a professional teacher seriously.

I suppose you could say it suggests that private students are educated to a higher degree despite it being easier for them to achieve GCSEs?

It would hardly be unheard for a teacher in the state sector to be vehemently against private education, and for this view to color any opinions about private schools they express. Conversely, I’ve also heard it stated by educators that iGCSEs are harder (particularly when it comes to mathematics).

Swipe left for the next trending thread