I’m not convinced the good manners is even accurate. People are people. I think good manners come from how you were brought up rather than where you were educated.
My background is working class Northern comprehensive (so rough that we made headlines in the region’s newspaper for fighting with another school at lunchtimes and the local residents being “terrified”). Out of the 200 kids in my year, less than 10 of us went to university.
On my graduate training scheme after uni, I met someone who has now been one of my closest friends for 30+ years. It was years before I found out she was privately educated (although I knew she went to Oxbridge early on). Made zero difference to me. I am very close to her now adult children (both of whom went to £60k/year private schools) because we ‘bubbled together’ during Covid lockdown. The daughter is a fabulous example of how encouragement and attention and all those great things that come with a very expensive education can really help form a young person. Quite frankly, if 18 year old me had met 18 year old her, she would have scared the shit out of me! OMG the confidence!! The first time we spent time together, she threw a huge wobbly because I refused to do what she was demanding. Because she hadn’t said please to me. She stropped around saying “I don’t have to say please to YOU”. 😂I gave her the raised eyebrow look and said calmly “you do if you want me to do something”. More stropping then eventually a very loud please. She has always said please ever since. Apparently ‘treat em mean, keep em keen’ really does work. 🤗 Her mother finds it hilarious that I am much tougher on her kids than she is and that they take it from me and even seem to like it. (Don’t tell anyone but I love them to bits).
Despite my background, my family drilled manners into us like we were in the Manners Army. I don’t care where you went to school, you will treat me and those around us with respect and good manners or things will not go well for you. In my defence, I am trying to stop saying please and thank you to Alexa.