Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask of your adult child meet someone at uni, that was privately educated, would that put you off them ?

528 replies

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:40

or wouldn't you care?

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 17/11/2026 23:14

Flamingojune · 17/11/2026 17:45

Good manners and great conversation apparently

I’m not convinced the good manners is even accurate. People are people. I think good manners come from how you were brought up rather than where you were educated.

My background is working class Northern comprehensive (so rough that we made headlines in the region’s newspaper for fighting with another school at lunchtimes and the local residents being “terrified”). Out of the 200 kids in my year, less than 10 of us went to university.

On my graduate training scheme after uni, I met someone who has now been one of my closest friends for 30+ years. It was years before I found out she was privately educated (although I knew she went to Oxbridge early on). Made zero difference to me. I am very close to her now adult children (both of whom went to £60k/year private schools) because we ‘bubbled together’ during Covid lockdown. The daughter is a fabulous example of how encouragement and attention and all those great things that come with a very expensive education can really help form a young person. Quite frankly, if 18 year old me had met 18 year old her, she would have scared the shit out of me! OMG the confidence!! The first time we spent time together, she threw a huge wobbly because I refused to do what she was demanding. Because she hadn’t said please to me. She stropped around saying “I don’t have to say please to YOU”. 😂I gave her the raised eyebrow look and said calmly “you do if you want me to do something”. More stropping then eventually a very loud please. She has always said please ever since. Apparently ‘treat em mean, keep em keen’ really does work. 🤗 Her mother finds it hilarious that I am much tougher on her kids than she is and that they take it from me and even seem to like it. (Don’t tell anyone but I love them to bits).

Despite my background, my family drilled manners into us like we were in the Manners Army. I don’t care where you went to school, you will treat me and those around us with respect and good manners or things will not go well for you. In my defence, I am trying to stop saying please and thank you to Alexa.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 23:26

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:42

I suppose I wonder about a clash of cultures values and lifestyle, and also I suppose part of me thinks my child grafted so hard through state school, suppose I thought they get with someone the same, not that, that means that person hasn't worked but possibly not to the same extent

People at private schools are often working hours people in many state schools would not begin to experience and it begins young. The expectations can be very high for hours of homework as well as dedication to extra curricular activities.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/11/2026 23:45

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 17:16

Congrats!

I haven’t once presumed to know what any actual children at actual private schools things about … okay, let’s call it the general populace, to be as neutral as possible. The issue is private schools as a reality and as a concept do separate those whose parents are wealthy/invested enough and children who are wealthy/clever/invested in enough from the population at large, and I don’t think that is a good thing. Some do. I know plenty, just like I know zionists and free palestiners, Tories and lefties, TRAs and sex realists. None is awful by definition but obviously there are ideological differences. This seems self-evident, and is why I’d be unlikely to get past polite acquaintance with someone in favour of private schools, either for their own children or in theory.

How would you feel about a family of children educated by a mother with a first from Oxbridge who, if she were hired out as a tutor would be a ‘super tutor’ for the likes of oligarchs? Is it the advantage children get from a private education or that they pay that you feel strongly about?

Also, looking at differences, simply being in a state school does not mean one group of state educated children is not massively more advantaged than another also state educated. In fact there could be far less difference between children at a comprehensive in a wealthy area and those at a nearby private day school, and between both those groups and schools in a disadvantaged area.

ChillyNGrateful · Yesterday 00:40

you really need to dig into the details; oxford, cambridge, and durham don't notice the state school advantage in their applicants. so overall even though overall state kids are said to outperform at uni, it's more like some state students outperform some private students. top private school students maintain their top grades when they transition.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Yesterday 02:27

PleasantPedant · 17/11/2026 18:52

@CornishDaughteroftheDawn , Ms Abbott was a single mother and working family-unfriendly hours.

What’s that got to do with anything?

I’m sure there are lots of parents in that situation who would like to make choices ‘for the wellbeing of their children’ who are not also trying to remove that option for others. It is just blatant hypocrisy.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Yesterday 02:37

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 18:51

I’m sure that’s so. I was asking which are the politicians who say they’re against private schools but send their children to them.

of course I know about Diane Abbott criticising Blair and Harman for using selective state schools about 25 years ago and then sending her son privately because “west African mothers will go to the wall for their children”, but which politicians have stated they are against private schools? And then used them?

Diane Abbott chose private for her son and has subsequently supported and voted for Labour policies and law changes targeting private schools.

Other parents use private schools for all sorts of reasons including the reasons she cited, yet it’s ok for her to do so but not others?

A socialist when it suits her. I wonder how she could afford the £10,000 per year fees on her humble MP wage - £56k at the time. Did she have some other unsocialist sidelines?

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Yesterday 02:54

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 18:53

There are many more politicians who benefited from private or grammar education that are deliberately destroying the same opportunities for others

but as many have said, it’s not a child’s decision what school they get sent to? Moving the goalposts a bit there I feel

I gave the examples you asked for, then added a further group. That is not ‘moving the goalposts’.

Of course the child often has no choice in the matter (DH did though) but by the arguments of a number of posters, going to private or selective schools gave these people tools and advantages that led to their positions of power. So they personally benefitted from going to private school (whether they wanted to or not isn’t the point) but want to take that option away from others. It’s just huge hypocrisy.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · Yesterday 02:59

Knoblauch1664 · 17/11/2026 19:29

Yes it would. I'm very surprised at the vote. It's not inverse snobbery, it's self preservation. The attitude of private educated towards state educated is appalling and at its absolute worst during university. It would have to be an exceptionally strong relationship or exceptional people to deal with that. I don't think the people who are voting have thought about it very hard.

That’s rather a sweeping and negative generalisation about a whole cohort of people. Do you know all these people personally or are you just prejudiced?

My boarding school educated dh has absolutely no ‘appalling attitude’ towards state educated me and nor have any of his lovely school friends that I have got to know over the years. I have other friends who are privately educated and haven’t seen a sniff of the attitudes you accuse them of.

It sounds like you and OP are the ones with the appalling attitudes.

JMSA · Yesterday 03:06

No, because I don’t have that much of a chip on my shoulder.

moonraker0 · Yesterday 04:11

I wonder if the other parents are worried that their child is slumming it with some common state educated riff raff?

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 07:56

Coffeewinecake · 17/11/2026 19:39

You have rumbled them - better get onto Oxbridge admissions.

Even with GCSEs there are different exam boards.

Yes, and I'm an examiner for more than one of them. IGCSEs are much easier. But the grades are accepted as comparable. An iGCSE 8 is equivalent to a UK GCSE 6. Unfair advantage. Little Johnny Eton isn't cleverer than Little Freddy state. He's being given yet another leg-up.

But this is yet another reason why people pay a fortune for these schools. Every little advantage helps. It's capitalism. 'All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.'

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 07:58

nearlylovemyusername · 17/11/2026 19:16

I'd suggest you do some research.

iGCSEs aren't easier than GCSEs at all. Grade boundaries are lower because papers are harder.
The schools you listed still do the same A-Levels as everyone else but their results are way above most of state schools, so the issue is really not with iGCSEs.

I also examine A Levels in addition to GCSEs. Is that enough research for you? (Most examiners work on a whole raft of different exams at different levels.) The pattern is the same.

Pretending the playing field is level is bullshit.

Coffeewinecake · Yesterday 08:25

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 07:56

Yes, and I'm an examiner for more than one of them. IGCSEs are much easier. But the grades are accepted as comparable. An iGCSE 8 is equivalent to a UK GCSE 6. Unfair advantage. Little Johnny Eton isn't cleverer than Little Freddy state. He's being given yet another leg-up.

But this is yet another reason why people pay a fortune for these schools. Every little advantage helps. It's capitalism. 'All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.'

But have you told the universities that the private school pupils they are admitting on to their courses are actually thickos? I am sure they will appreciate your insights.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 08:33

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 07:56

Yes, and I'm an examiner for more than one of them. IGCSEs are much easier. But the grades are accepted as comparable. An iGCSE 8 is equivalent to a UK GCSE 6. Unfair advantage. Little Johnny Eton isn't cleverer than Little Freddy state. He's being given yet another leg-up.

But this is yet another reason why people pay a fortune for these schools. Every little advantage helps. It's capitalism. 'All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.'

They also used to (may still but I haven’t looked in a while) mean the schools couldn’t be fairly ranked in local league tables

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 08:35

Coffeewinecake · Yesterday 08:25

But have you told the universities that the private school pupils they are admitting on to their courses are actually thickos? I am sure they will appreciate your insights.

Do you understand that “not cleverer” =/= “thicko”?

Coffeewinecake · Yesterday 08:38

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 08:35

Do you understand that “not cleverer” =/= “thicko”?

that was lost on you!

Elbowpatch · Yesterday 08:40

Coffeewinecake · Yesterday 08:25

But have you told the universities that the private school pupils they are admitting on to their courses are actually thickos? I am sure they will appreciate your insights.

In my (long) experience of higher education, academically there’s no difference between private and state educated students. All students have their strengths and weaknesses.

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 08:50

Coffeewinecake · Yesterday 08:38

that was lost on you!

How so? You seemed to be trying to deride the other poster and her professional knowledge of the qualifications concerned by suggesting she’s implying they’re thickos abd that the universities would be unimpressed should she try to express the opinion you’re attributing to her.

DeetSheet · Yesterday 09:03

Anyone can do well in this company if they work hard enough (barring medical reasons)

5128gap · Yesterday 09:14

PassTheHemlock · 16/11/2026 23:48

Reverse snobbery is just as toxic as the standard sort.

How so? In what way do wealthier people suffer if less wealthy people don't want to associate with them? It's not like everyone's desperate to infiltrate the less economically advantaged echelons of society, which are being unfairly gatekept from them, is it?

crazycrofter · Yesterday 09:47

This is all so strange and divisive. My husband went to state primary til 9, a small private school til 13, then a ‘public school’ til 17, then a sixth form college. Is he state or private school educated? He married me, state educated throughout - but my brother went to an academic private school from 11-18. Dd went to the girls version of that school from 11-16, after a primary that was in special measures in a deprived area. She went to grammar for sixth form. Ds went to grammar 11-16 and then a comprehensive for sixth form. So we’ve done the full range between us. Actually ds was home educated for 2.5 years too! We don’t define ourselves or others by how we were educated. The kids have lots of friends from all types of schools. DD’s last boyfriend went to a comprehensive. Ds’ girlfriend went to a comp, then grammar for sixth form. In real life, surely no one finds out the educational background of potential friends or partners before getting to know them?

EweCee · Yesterday 09:54

CokeAColaZero · 16/11/2026 23:42

I suppose I wonder about a clash of cultures values and lifestyle, and also I suppose part of me thinks my child grafted so hard through state school, suppose I thought they get with someone the same, not that, that means that person hasn't worked but possibly not to the same extent

The only thought I have here is anyone who has such a narrow minded and judgemental attitude is not someone I'd want around my child. In our area, the private school children are working phenomenally hard, as are the state school children - yet its the state school children who are on constant overseas holidays (like 3 times a year) living in big houses and 'flashing the cash' - the private school families we know live in smaller houses and don't go overseas on holiday at all, their hard earned money is spent on their child's education. So their 'values' ARE different, but not the way you think!

raffiabunny · Yesterday 12:25

Haven't read all the replies, but what a crazy question! All families circumstances, finances, and choices are different.

No, it's not fair that money can buy a better education (and before people pile on to argue that private education isn't better, I know that in some cases it's not - but in many cases it unfortunately is!) but life isn't fair, is it?

If my DC was happy with a partner whose parents made that choice for them, why would it be a problem? It's possible their education may have brought them some advantages in life but so what?! To judge a DC's partner for how their parents chose to educate them seems very unpleasant.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Yesterday 13:23

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 08:50

How so? You seemed to be trying to deride the other poster and her professional knowledge of the qualifications concerned by suggesting she’s implying they’re thickos abd that the universities would be unimpressed should she try to express the opinion you’re attributing to her.

The elite universities are part of the system that perpetuates inequality.

I'm not railing against the machine. I can't change it. But we don't have to pretend it doesn't exist.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · Yesterday 13:44

5128gap · Yesterday 09:14

How so? In what way do wealthier people suffer if less wealthy people don't want to associate with them? It's not like everyone's desperate to infiltrate the less economically advantaged echelons of society, which are being unfairly gatekept from them, is it?

PassTheHemlock said it was toxic. Not that it was toxic to the wealthy.

Crabs pulling each other back into the crab bucket is toxic for the crabs. It does little harm to the crab fisher.

Building walls between different strata of society is most harmful to those at the bottom, and least harmful to those at the top. That's true regardless of which side the wall is built from.