Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to tell ex-in-laws at Xmas about why I ended the relationship?

221 replies

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

OP posts:
outerspacepotato · 16/11/2026 16:21

I voted you're being unreasonable because this is such an ill advised plan to take your 18 month old out of the country to spend Xmas with your cocklodger ex and his family whom you haven't heard a peep from since your split. What are you thinking?

Cancel.

lottiegarbanzo · 16/11/2026 16:32

Neither. Don’t criticise him, they’ll defend him. They may try to ‘campaign’ for you to take him back. Likely if you make your decision-making process sound current, so unfinished.

Keep it about you and fairly neutral.

Life together wasn’t what you’d expected / wasn't working for you / the relationship hadn’t worked out. You’re finding it much easier to live and parent separately.

QueenietheGreat · 16/11/2026 17:00

@singlepringle23
Why are you visiting/staying with the family of a man you've nothing to do with anymore?
If they get you on their turf and with his tales of cruelty and violence (believe me I've friends who had foreign husbands and with some of what was claimed if the family had had their way those women would've been in jail)
You will not stand a chance and be ripped to shreds
Quite simply, you don't say nothing because you don't go
Stay here and keep DDs/your own passports somewhere off the premises perhaps a lawyer or someone else official? - sorry I don't know how that part goes and start planning to get away from this leech
Are you sure he's not arranged marriage for DD which is what this trip is really all about??
Happened to a girl I was at school with.

godmum56 · 16/11/2026 17:05

SavBlancTonight · 16/11/2026 16:06

Obviously, you must decide on the risk for yourself. Based on what you've said, I don't think there's a risk of him trying to keep the child in his country. He's not an active or involved parent and he only would do something like tha tto get at you... but he's lazy, so it's too much effort. I've seen controlling cocklodgers who absolutely WOULD do this but I've also seen many who absolutely won't because they don't actually want anything to do with the effort of a child.

In your case, I still think you shouldn't go - why the fuck should you be doing all the work here. He needs to move out. And then his family can come visit and if yo have a good relationship with them, then erhaps they might invite YOU to stay in due course andyou can decide if you want to do that or not.

he personally might not but his family might.

Canitrustagain · 16/11/2026 17:06

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:42

So that DD can build a relationship with her ex's side of the family too and know that side of her heritage/culture, learn the language, etc. I would also like to see her cousins again and keep the family ties as much as possible. I don't want to split the family apart more than necessary just because her dad was a rubbish partner to me

Edited: that being said, if the lawyers say its too risky to go then that will trump the reasons outlined above

Edited

They can come here. Also it’s not your responsibility to ‘connect’ your dd to her dad’s family.

If you go you’re making it look like you’re in a relationship. You are blurring the lines already by still living with him!

edit - I’m mixed race and I didn’t need to go to the country half my family is from to learn about my family’s culture and language. It really sounds like you don’t want to break up with this awful man.

Ohwhatfuckeristhis · 16/11/2026 17:07

Hide your passports and birth/marriage certificates. He might be too reckless to try and abduct your child, but his family? If they want a relationship they've had 18 months to initiate one.

watchingthishtread · 16/11/2026 17:33

At 18 months she is not going to develop any kind of a relationship from a brief visit at Christmas. She won't even remember it. When he has moved out, you are both over the hurt, his family are back on speaking terms and your dd is a little older, then attempt to facilitate her building a relationship with them. The timing now is terrible. It will not go well.

ginasevern · 16/11/2026 17:38

@singlepringle23 You've got your priorities all wrong and this is all totally bonkers! You've said yourself that the in-laws have stopped contacting you and that your waste of space ex is a lousy father. So stop worrying about maintaining contact when they clearly aren't. At best Christmas will be beyond awkward and at worst it could be explosive and highly unpleasant. You are also putting your DD at risk. A lawyer can only quote the law, they can't actually prevent something bad from happening. I'm even more perplexed that you've actually planned further seasonal trips. What on earth are you thinking OP?

outerspacepotato · 16/11/2026 17:48

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:42

So that DD can build a relationship with her ex's side of the family too and know that side of her heritage/culture, learn the language, etc. I would also like to see her cousins again and keep the family ties as much as possible. I don't want to split the family apart more than necessary just because her dad was a rubbish partner to me

Edited: that being said, if the lawyers say its too risky to go then that will trump the reasons outlined above

Edited

I've reached out to a lawyer in the ex's family's country to get advice about whether its a risk - if they say it's risky, we won't go.

Do you really trust the family that raised a cocklodger? Geez.

You're still enabling your shitty cocklodger ex. You haven't even truly split from him from the sounds of it. This is going to be his job to keep them in contact with his family, not yours. Your kid will not benefit from this visit at 18 months, this will probably throw her off for some time.

Firefly100 · 16/11/2026 17:50

Your daughter is 18m. She can’t build relationships at that age. Personally I would not go over Xmas but you do you. I don’t think you are running any serious risk of not being allowed to return from an EU country given you both live here, but sounds like you are checking legally anyway. Is he paying for where you are staying? Did he buy his own ticket? If the answer is no to either of those questions, if you insist on going I would cancel his flight and tell him to book it himself and book a single room for you and DD and tell him to sort himself out or stay with family. You are not a couple - start acting like it!
You need to focus on getting him out of your shared home and standing on his own feet. 3 months is long enough. Can I assume you are not married? Do you both own your home jointly? If so sell or buy him out. If rented serve notice and ask your LL to put the agreement in your name only (if you are paying anyway, hopefully not an issue). If you are not married and he is not on the rental agreement and not a part owner, give him 2 weeks to move out then make it happen. Pack up his stuff and stick it outside and demand the key back. If necessary, change the locks.
ETA if you want her to have a good relationship with the other side of the family, best thing you can do is learn the language.

PaddyMcGintysGoats · 16/11/2026 17:58

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 12:09

I've more or less never heard of anyone warning someone of not letting their child spend time with their ex in the UK. While maybe the legal mechanisms are easier to work out if the ex has parental responsibility they could absolutely take them. Yet on this thread basically every second reply is "he'll probably kidnap her!". I get the risks are greater if he did, but I think lots of people are defiitely concluding that he might (which, as i said, does just not come up where the father is British).

You never answered about your DH.

I don't know why you're getting all bent out of shape about this.

If people are worried he's going to keep his child in his country of birth, it's not for you to moan about it.

It's simply a worry that many people have raised.

Nothing to do with you really and certainly not something you should try and silence posters about.

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 17:59

PaddyMcGintysGoats · 16/11/2026 17:58

I don't know why you're getting all bent out of shape about this.

If people are worried he's going to keep his child in his country of birth, it's not for you to moan about it.

It's simply a worry that many people have raised.

Nothing to do with you really and certainly not something you should try and silence posters about.

I'm not getting bent out of shape. It's still pretty offensive to assume he's a kidnapper just because he is foreign.

PaddyMcGintysGoats · 16/11/2026 18:01

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 17:59

I'm not getting bent out of shape. It's still pretty offensive to assume he's a kidnapper just because he is foreign.

Be offended then.

Enjoy 🤷‍♂️

Still makes no difference to the fact it's something the OP needs to seriously consider.

ginasevern · 16/11/2026 18:32

@BusyGreySnail "I've more or less never heard of anyone warning someone of not letting their child spend time with their ex in the UK. While maybe the legal mechanisms are easier to work out if the ex has parental responsibility they could absolutely take them. Yet on this thread basically every second reply is "he'll probably kidnap her!". I get the risks are greater if he did, but I think lots of people are defiitely concluding that he might (which, as i said, does just not come up where the father is British)."

The situation would be more complex if a child was prevented from returning home. It could take a long time and a lot of legal fees to sort it all out. You'd be navigating foreign lawyers and a foreign police force in a language and legal system you don't understand. That's why poster are more concerned about the possibility than if the child was taken in the mother's home country, not because they're racist.

PyongyangKipperbang · 16/11/2026 18:33

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 17:59

I'm not getting bent out of shape. It's still pretty offensive to assume he's a kidnapper just because he is foreign.

No it is sensible to consider that he might be. Would the advice be different to (say) an Italian Mother who's English ex wanted to take them to the UK? No it would be exactly the same.

Hell I have seen threads on MN advising women to do this! Marriage breaks up, ex husband wont give permission for the kids to go with their mother back to the UK so people on here have said "Take them on holiday and refuse to take them back" especially if it is non Hague country.

CosyPandas · 16/11/2026 18:41

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:14

Yes I think I am still enabling the entitlement, ie I have "given up" asking him to pull his weight doing chores or anything else - I just got sick of asking and being infuriated when he made an excuse, it was really making it a toxic living situation especially for DD. I need to set a deadline about the moving out, that's a good idea.

Spoke with a lawyer who said that realistically he/his family wouldn't be able to block DD and I from leaving the country as he has no "proof" that she lives in his family's home country (as she doesn't), as long as I make sure I keep DD's passport safe. So figure it's "worth it" as would be nice for DD to have a relationship with both sides of her family. Of course if they do try anything then we won't go back there again

Just a heads up. Knew of a mum whose child had travelled to spend a holiday with paternal grandparents ( mum and dad had long separated) Can’t remember if mum took the child or they went with dad. Child travelled on UK passport but unknown to mum the dad had given up his job, house etc in uk, moved in with his parents and obtained the child a foreign passport , as he could prove he was the father , lived in the country, had a home there. Child was then enrolled in a local school and subsequent Court case decided the mum had “ abandoned the child to the care of their father and grandparents” I remember the wording as there was huge outrage at the word abandoned, amongst the ex pats anyway.
Be very wary. Community I lived in was small but I heard of at least three mothers in similar situations.

Bringflowersofthefairest · 16/11/2026 18:55

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 13:02

Yes apparently he has told them we are not together, and I think thats true because I haven't heard from them since he says he told them, although he continues to speak with them when I'm not around/in the other room (in his native language so I don't understand what's being said). Don't know if the reason I haven't heard from them is because they think I'm being horrible and he's the victim (thats my guess), or they feel awkward and don't know what to say (plausible) or something else. Doesn't really matter I guess, except maybe regarding potential bad intentions" from their side (I would be very very shocked and surprised if they tried to keep DD in their country, but people can always surprise you).

You would be very shocked and surprised if they tried to keep her in their Country.
Dear God woman, surely you would be absolutely devastated not just shocked and surprised.
Are you okay, seriously?
Your airy fairy attitude to this is quite alarming.
I can’t decide whether your just a massive soft touch or winding us up.

Oxo01 · 16/11/2026 20:53

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:28

What does it mean though, for the ex to facilitate this? I certainly wouldn't want DD to go with her dad to another country while I stay in the UK without her. She hasn't even really attached to her dad so wouldn't be good for her at all

I think I would say they can come to yours to see G/Child rather than you go to them at least your in your own home with your family around if anything blows up with them / him.

Goldengirl123 · 16/11/2026 20:53

Just tell them the truth

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 17/11/2026 11:23

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:33

Thanks for the advice. The country is in the EU, its part of the Hague convention. Don't want to share the precise country for privacy reasons (ex knows I use MN).

The thing is, if it's a theoretical risk now it would always be one right? Postponing until next Christmas means if the family did decide to try to stop DD leaving the country, they could do it in a years' time, 5 years' time etc, the risk would be the same? But it seems unreasonable to then never allow DD to go to that country until she turns 16?

I've reached out to a lawyer in the ex's family's country to get advice about whether its a risk - if they say it's risky, we won't go.

They can come to your country to see their grandchild.

PLEASE get him out of your house. If you don't push him out, he won't leave.

You are still paying all the bills?

Isittimeformynapyet · 17/11/2026 19:07

seahorsessky · 16/11/2026 13:28

Think about how hurt and upset they'll be. No doubt there'll be comments, generally blaming the mother, not father, for "enabling" him, but sometimes the best parents have the worst kids and vice versa. Some amazing people had awful parents. They will be really worried about your child-and remember she is half them (and half your parents) so cutting them off would be spiteful, and children from broken families suffer even worse when they don't have grandparents. I have a friend who said she wouldn't be here now if she hadn't had her gran's support when her parents broke up.
So be kind to them, and maybe ask their advice/opinion on how to move forward. You don't mention culture, but for many parents, the worst thing they can imagine in the world is their child's marriage breaking down, having watched them promise to support each other forever. Not everyone has to agree with this, but it is a fact.

They will be really worried about your child-and remember she is half them (and half your parents) so cutting them off would be spiteful, and children from broken families suffer even worse when they don't have grandparents.

How unnecessary to point all this out to OP when she clearly has no intention of cutting them off!!

Don't tell her to "remember" what she clearly knows!

It comes across as though you think you have superior insight into other people's situations.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread