Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to tell ex-in-laws at Xmas about why I ended the relationship?

221 replies

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

OP posts:
Bringflowersofthefairest · 16/11/2026 09:58

Theres no way I would be putting myself through that.
Imagine if they are hostile towards you.
Your useless partner will not defend you and you will be utterly miserable.
I can’t believe you are seriously considering going.
It’s madness.

MajorProcrastination · 16/11/2026 10:00

Others have already asked about the staying near the ex in-laws and the living arrangements so I'll skip over that and straight to the "should I tell them the reasons?" bit. Yes.

Do it in a very clear and factual way. I would personally do this in writing or provide a print out. Petty AF I'm sure but it's the best way to present the data in a way that isn't skewed by loyalty or feelings. Do a spreadsheet or a pie chart. Display the information in a crystal clear format, whatever. I know it sounds weird but my fear is that you could tell them verbally and they just won't listen or they think the sun shines out of his bum and that you're twisting things.

It could be an email, something like "I've been asked about our reasons for splitting and didn't want to talk about it out loud in front of my child but thought it would be helpful for you to see the facts and the reasons for our separation. I understand that you all love and support (name of ex) and I loved him too but for my own wellbeing, financial security and self worth I couldn't continue in a relationship with the situation I'll show you below. I believe that a marriage is a partnership and ours didn't feel that way, it was inequitable and I hope that the facts and figures below will illustrate my reasons for this huge decision. (insert all the facts and figures and charts and graphs). To conclude, I want (name of child) to have a good relationship with her Dad and you guys. I'm a private person and don't want to share the reasons for our separation widely or publicaly so I appreciate your discretion. I do think you deserve to know the whole truth as I have understood that some people feel that I've been very harsh and unfair. I hope that the above shows why I've made this life-changing decision."

Or something.

ByRedBee · 16/11/2026 10:01

Your being naive let him sort out seeing his family he probably won’t going by your description

LlynTegid · 16/11/2026 10:01

Agree with not going and being factual. I am sure you can explain not going to your DD in an appropriate way.

EsmeSusanOgg · 16/11/2026 10:04

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:28

What does it mean though, for the ex to facilitate this? I certainly wouldn't want DD to go with her dad to another country while I stay in the UK without her. She hasn't even really attached to her dad so wouldn't be good for her at all

I would knock the holiday on the head. Too much scope for things to go wrong at this stage. Have something quiet with your DD at home. Not with ex.

GreenOnio · 16/11/2026 10:06

Isittimeformynapyet · 16/11/2026 01:29

You can’t really insult him to his family on Christmas Day

She could wait until boxing day...

Anyway, telling the truth by way of an explanation is not, in my book, "insulting".

If she told his parents that they'd raised a lazy knob head, that would be.

That’s true that the truth isn’t necessarily an insult. I think it would just be an awkward atmosphere to have to discuss it and then spend Christmas together. But I suppose it will probably be awkward anyway!

DraigCymraeg · 16/11/2026 10:11

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:49

Yes, ex will be there too. Sorry made it sound like we would stay with them. In fact, we will stay nearby but not with them. Its because ex wants our DD to also be close to his side of the family, and we live near mine so see them multiple times a week. Ex is still living with me and DD, he hasn't moved out yet (sigh)

Is there a risk he will snatch the little one and stay with his family?

UnwillingAdvocate · 16/11/2026 10:14

Did he only become like this after you had a child, or did you already know he wasn’t the best choice but still have a child with him anyway?

InterestedDad37 · 16/11/2026 10:22

OP - your heart is in the right place, but I think you're being terribly naive. Kick him out asap, and don't spend Christmas abroad with his family.

SavBlancTonight · 16/11/2026 10:36

I am going to tell you the story of my SIL and BIL. Like your ex, he was a waste of space - contributed nothing financially, refused to work more than part time ein a minimum wage job but also didn't step up to do the chores or childcare. He had a nice line of emotional abuse mixed in too whereby she couldn't so much as go for a drink after work with a girlfriend without him making out that she as cheating/abandoning him etc.

Eventually, they broke up. But he stayed in the house because where was he supposed to go? He didn't have enough money for his own place and he felt bad for him as he was so sad the relationship was over and so traumatised that he wouldn't see their DC so much. Meanwhile, there were fights every day. He accused her of shagging anything tha tmoved, he accused her of being abusive and narcissistic. He managed to alienate all her friends but also his own friends by calling and texting and emailing them reams of abuse about her about them etc. If she asked him to do the ONE childcare thing he had always done... he used it as a tool and would regularly ust refuse, requiring her to find alternatives or skip work.

Eventually, she got him out. But, he couldn't have the DC in his new place where he was a lodger so she allowed him to come to her house. Where, of course, the bheaviour continued. He'd come into her house and "look after" the DC while leaving the place in a mess. He had keys so he'd come and go as he pleased. She once woke up to discovered he'd come in at 3 in the morning and decided to sleep there. He'd "accidentally" leave things behind and just let himself in to collect them. She could never relax.

There was some mild violence.

Eventually, she told him he couldn't do any of this naymore. So he disappeared. For months. Not a word. Until, he get in touch because he was now homeless and jobless and "desperate". So she let him come back. And he lived there for another six months, supposedly depressed, while she fed and housed and clothed him, sorted doctor's appointments etc and he did fuck all.

Eventually she got him out again and, you guessed it, he disappeared again. This time, she sort of knew where he was but obviously he didn't call or contact her or the DC and it was far away. And he pissed off the people he was living with so much that for some reason they kepy calling HER to complain. Like he was their child. his family wrote him off at this time too which was particularly irritating as theykept expeting her to fix it too.

And then he came back. And she put him up again while she sorted out housing for him and benefits and more doctor's appointments. And for a while, he was "grateful" and he was helpful and he looked after the DC. But then, the behaviour started all over again and she had to ban him from her house. I think we are now on the 4th iteration of this version - with him living nearby and going through phases ofbeing helpful andpresent for their DC then descending into abuse, unreliability and awfulness.

Please don't be my SIL. Tellhim he has to move out within a month. If he wants to spend Christmas with your DC and his family, that's something you'll consider in the future. Doing it now is just going to create more expectations from him.

As for his family, if they ask, tell them the truth "He wasn't present, he didn't support us in any way and I couldn't live with someone who wasn't able to actually be an active participant in the relationship or the parenting."

Namechangewegovyjune26 · 16/11/2026 10:48

99bottlesofkombucha · 16/11/2026 00:46

Neither. ‘Unfortunately I was doing all the parenting, housework and paid work, so unsurprisingly I was completely maxed out and the only thing within my power to cut out was him. I do wish he’d been more present in our lives and this hadn’t happened but I’d never go back to that.’

Yes. There is a middle ground.

I wouldn’t lie but I would say it in a diplomatic way.

DPotter · 16/11/2026 10:50

Sorry if this feels like a pile-on, however I'm with everyone else. Please cancel the trip to ex's parents and kick him out asap. It doesn't matter to you if he has nowhere to go - that's his problem. Why should you continue to feed him and give him a roof over his head ? And don't tell me it's because he's the father of your child. He's an adult and it's about time he started doing adulty things, like finding a job and paying his way.

I think it would be fool hardy to go to his parents in another country - there's all sort of legal shit potentially there.

I would email them and explain now you have broken up it would not be appropriate for you to go there for Christmas. Tell them you are happy to facilitate a relationship with your DD but this will be in this country not theirs, ie they can visit you here. To be honest the reason for your break up is none of their business.

As an additional action I would alert the passport office and ask for a marker to be put on your DD's passport that she is not to travel without you.

Please, please don't go abroad with him this Christmas or ever

Lovingbooks · 16/11/2026 11:05

He’s still living with you and your planning seasonal holidays with his family. Not much of a breakup. Don’t mention it doubt he will. I honestly can’t understand if your at odds with each other why you think the added pressure spending time with his family in another country would make this any better?

MsPrufrockk · 16/11/2026 11:21

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:49

Yes, ex will be there too. Sorry made it sound like we would stay with them. In fact, we will stay nearby but not with them. Its because ex wants our DD to also be close to his side of the family, and we live near mine so see them multiple times a week. Ex is still living with me and DD, he hasn't moved out yet (sigh)

Why on earth have you agreed to this? Tell him that you've come to realise it's inappropriate and not something you want to do, you'll bemaking your own plans for Christmas.

AshCullen1894 · 16/11/2026 11:36

Don't go. You are mad to be catering to this prick and his family who haven't contacted you in months. Your child is only 18 m and will not remember any of this while you suffer the indignity of a week near these people who do not give a tinker's cuss about you. I cannot believe you are putting yourself through that. Are you in counselling?

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2026 11:54

You really need to heed the posts saying not to take your dd. If his parents want a relationship with your dd, they come here.

It is likely your ex can get a foreign passport made for your dd as long as he has her birth certificate or that he has one. And it doesn’t matter if the country is signatory of The Hague convention. If he is planning to take her, it could take years to get her back.

You will need lawyers and barristers both in this country and his country to fight him. It will cost you tens upon tens of thousands, if not more. And meanwhile your dd will be getting older. And even if you win, the courts may decide she’s settled over there and refuse to return her. I have read all of this on past threads. I remember a desperate mum some years ago describing how complicated it was. Idk the outcome.

And you’re prepared to risk this, all for a cocklodger, who hasn’t bonded with your dd. Please stay in the uk and keep your dd safe.

@BusyGreySnail
This isn’t about you. My dd is 18 now. My dh is foreign. He never attempted to take dd from me. But some men will. Especially entitled men. And this one has all the hallmarks. It’s often not about wanting their child, but about possessing them, so that the mother cannot.

Op’s ex has no real ties to the uk. He doesn’t even have a place to live. That’s a dangerous combination.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/11/2026 11:54

99bottlesofkombucha · 16/11/2026 00:46

Neither. ‘Unfortunately I was doing all the parenting, housework and paid work, so unsurprisingly I was completely maxed out and the only thing within my power to cut out was him. I do wish he’d been more present in our lives and this hadn’t happened but I’d never go back to that.’

Perfect!

ShyAmberPanda · 16/11/2026 11:55

I think you can be honest without feeling the need to justify yourself or turn it into a character assasination. Something along the lines of, "I loved him and wanted things to work, but ultimately the relationship became very unequal. I was carrying the majority of the responsibility for our home, finances and childcare, and I couldn't continue like that. I want DD to grow up seeing a healthy, equal relationship, and that wasn't what she was seeing. I have no animosity towards him, but ending the relationship was the right decision for me."

You don't owe anyone a detailed breakdown of everything that went wrong, but equally, you shouldn't feel obliged to protect his reputation at the expense of your own. Taking the high road doesn't mean pretending everything was fine.

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 11:57

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2026 11:54

You really need to heed the posts saying not to take your dd. If his parents want a relationship with your dd, they come here.

It is likely your ex can get a foreign passport made for your dd as long as he has her birth certificate or that he has one. And it doesn’t matter if the country is signatory of The Hague convention. If he is planning to take her, it could take years to get her back.

You will need lawyers and barristers both in this country and his country to fight him. It will cost you tens upon tens of thousands, if not more. And meanwhile your dd will be getting older. And even if you win, the courts may decide she’s settled over there and refuse to return her. I have read all of this on past threads. I remember a desperate mum some years ago describing how complicated it was. Idk the outcome.

And you’re prepared to risk this, all for a cocklodger, who hasn’t bonded with your dd. Please stay in the uk and keep your dd safe.

@BusyGreySnail
This isn’t about you. My dd is 18 now. My dh is foreign. He never attempted to take dd from me. But some men will. Especially entitled men. And this one has all the hallmarks. It’s often not about wanting their child, but about possessing them, so that the mother cannot.

Op’s ex has no real ties to the uk. He doesn’t even have a place to live. That’s a dangerous combination.

I didn't say it was about me. It said it was offensive to assume, because her ex is foreign, that he is going to kidnap their child.

Would you not let your DH take your DD abroad? If not, how does your DH feel about that?

CountCountington · 16/11/2026 12:03

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 11:57

I didn't say it was about me. It said it was offensive to assume, because her ex is foreign, that he is going to kidnap their child.

Would you not let your DH take your DD abroad? If not, how does your DH feel about that?

Nobody is assuming that her ex might try to take her child because he is foreign.

People are raising the risk that he could do this, because it is a thing that sometimes happens when parents split up.

It’s more of a risk to be considered if one parent is based overseas (or could move overseas with the child) because the legal situation is much more complex, so if it happens it’s a much harder situation to resolve.

Teado · 16/11/2026 12:06

Don’t let him take her out of the country OP. Ask him to go alone - and then return to his own home, not yours.

You need to be more robust IMO. This limbo and pretending to be a family at Christmas is no good for anybody, including your ex. The three of you and the extended family need to get used to the new normal.

Snorlaxo · 16/11/2026 12:08

You are still enabling his cocklodger ways by travelling overseas etc (are you paying for all 3 tickets?) If he starts dating again then he may do what many deadbeats do and get the new gf to do the parenting instead and drop you like a hot potato. He will be able to demand this and get up to 50% contact. (I assume that you’re in the UK)

You need to do your research on his country because if it’s not a Hague Convention country then he could kidnap dd while over there and the police wouldn’t help you get her back. Have you flagged her passport at airports and ports so you’re informed if dd is travelling without you? You are splitting so have to remember that he’s no longer a friend and could stab you in the back- especially if the grandparents would happily raise dd.

If your ex wants a good relationship with his dd then he needs to start doing the graft so they are bonded.

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 12:09

CountCountington · 16/11/2026 12:03

Nobody is assuming that her ex might try to take her child because he is foreign.

People are raising the risk that he could do this, because it is a thing that sometimes happens when parents split up.

It’s more of a risk to be considered if one parent is based overseas (or could move overseas with the child) because the legal situation is much more complex, so if it happens it’s a much harder situation to resolve.

I've more or less never heard of anyone warning someone of not letting their child spend time with their ex in the UK. While maybe the legal mechanisms are easier to work out if the ex has parental responsibility they could absolutely take them. Yet on this thread basically every second reply is "he'll probably kidnap her!". I get the risks are greater if he did, but I think lots of people are defiitely concluding that he might (which, as i said, does just not come up where the father is British).

You never answered about your DH.

pinkyredrose · 16/11/2026 12:10

Why the hell is he still living with you? I'd chuck him and his stuff out today!

Jamlighter · 16/11/2026 12:11

I think you are being naive about what they can do to keep your daughter when you go. Its all very well saying legally they cant stop you leaving. They could just take your child away and not give her back then you are into international law and conventions and a shed load of money and potentially a system designed to work against you. I would not go. She is too small to go alone. If they want to see her they can come and visit you. I would also kick him out its been months. Is it tenancy, mortgage, your house? If he doesn't pay rent tell him he has 7 days to move out or hs stuff will be on the street. Also have you put in a CMS application? If you are living seprately under the same roof you can. Don't cook, feed, clean, shop or do laundry or anything else. Lock your food away. Once he starts having to do stuff himself and pay for his own food etc and maintenance he is more likely to move out