Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to tell ex-in-laws at Xmas about why I ended the relationship?

221 replies

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

OP posts:
Wordless · 16/11/2026 08:37

I too hope this thread was merely intended to put up my blood pressure, and has no basis in reality.

DaisyDooley · 16/11/2026 08:38

No way would I be going.
At the very least you will hve a miserable Christmas as they are his family and will side with him against you.
And you must know this becuse they haven’t reached out to you to see if you are ok since the ‘split”!
IF they cred about you, they would hve contacted you.
Do not put yourself and your child into a position you might find it very difficult to get out of.
And ffs, throw him out! His housing issue is not your problem to solve.

Dollymylove · 16/11/2026 08:39

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:49

Yes, ex will be there too. Sorry made it sound like we would stay with them. In fact, we will stay nearby but not with them. Its because ex wants our DD to also be close to his side of the family, and we live near mine so see them multiple times a week. Ex is still living with me and DD, he hasn't moved out yet (sigh)

If the ex wants your DC to have contact with paternal family its up to them to facilitate it, not you

PerfectPaula · 16/11/2026 08:43

I don't understand why you are going when you aren't with their son any more. If they want to see their grandchild let them come to you. But if they ask, just tell them the truth. It's not a difficult conundrum this one, is it?

Wowthatwasabigstep · 16/11/2026 08:44

You really need to raise your standards and stop settling for crumbs from this man child. He does nothing and treats you like the maid, have a review of your self worth.

I wouldn’t go for many reasons however my main reason would be the uncertainty. A lot will depend on the country your ex partner is from. Spain for example would be a lot easier to get your child back from if they were to kidnap the child. Saudi Arabia - not a chance, what is to stop them from taking your child’s passport, you can’t guard it 24 hours a day realistically.

user1492757084 · 16/11/2026 08:46

I would say that you are disappounted that living together did not work out. Say that you needed a lot more input from their son for it to be sustainable. ...
He was lazy in the home and also only worked part time. It was no way to proceed. We share a daughter who was witnessing me work, clean, cook while her fether did little. The example of woman as slave is not healthy for little girls.
Splitting up is best because he will learn to care for himself and gain independant skills.

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 08:47

Firstly, I wouldn't be doing this if you are genuinely seperated. Isn't it confusing for your DD? Does she know you are seperated? Are you staying with your ex in this "close by" place, or just you and DD?

Second, I (foreign) find the whole "he's going to kidnap your daughter" quite offensive. If DH and I broke up and he refused to let me take my kids home to see my family because he wa scared i'd kidnap them I'd honestly be so upset. I would obviously not do that - we foreigners aren't savages that, as soon as we don't get our way in a relationship, run off with the kids for them never to return. That said, you obviously feel concerned enough about it that you've talked to a lawyer. Why is that? What country are you doing to?

So, basically, I think there's a lot of bigger issues than what narrative you'll give them of your break up, but if they ask i'd just be factual.

INeedAnotherName · 16/11/2026 08:50

Which country @singlepringle23 ? Not all have signed the Hague Convention which help prevents the kidnap of children. And does he have any parental rights and named on the birth certificate?

Find out your legal rights regarding your DD as you run the risk of losing her forever. Wake the fuck up.

handybrandy · 16/11/2026 08:51

PerfectPaula · 16/11/2026 08:43

I don't understand why you are going when you aren't with their son any more. If they want to see their grandchild let them come to you. But if they ask, just tell them the truth. It's not a difficult conundrum this one, is it?

No. A weird thread

Lifestooshort71 · 16/11/2026 08:56

So, you're not actually separated? You've just accepted he's a lazy layabout and now he sleeps on the sofa (hopefully?!). No timeline for him moving out either? I can see his family may be a tad confused! He's gone from being a cocklodger (your word) to a lodger....hmmm.

OneNewEagle · 16/11/2026 08:57

Do not go. Stay at home with your DD. especially if you have your family close by.

That is your exs family you do not want to go there and deal with that. Once he moves out they can visit ex and see your DD on his days. That’s it.

Oriunda · 16/11/2026 08:59

All this talk of ‘hiding the passport’. If your daughter is a dual citizen, then depending on the country, your ex might have already applied for a passport, or can do so once you’re both in his country. Very much depends on what country.

My DH is a EU citizen; in his country, any child born to a national, regardless of where the birth took place, is automatically considered a national. That said, my signature/presence was required to get DS’ ID card and passport.

I think you’d be extremely foolish to travel. At 18 months, your daughter isn’t going to benefit from the visit. She can see her grandparents by Zoom etc and build up recognition that way.

RudePhthaloDalmadoodle · 16/11/2026 09:03

I don't think it's technically a "cocklodger" after 27+ months and a baby. Has he ever worked during this time, ever taken on any of the household responsibilities?

Anyway, if he barely even works part time lately and can't afford to pay for anything, should he not be saving his pennies rather than travelling internationally at Christmas, which is one of the most expensive times even if he has free room & board at his destination too? How is he going to afford to move out and either get a place where he can have your daughter half the time or pay CMS?

researchers3 · 16/11/2026 09:13

Crazy idea OP.

Don't go. And get him out of your home.

Pedant61 · 16/11/2026 09:15

Don't tell them anything! They really shouldn't be so rude as to ask but, if they do, keep it brief: "It's personal to us, but we're doing much better now, and we're happy to focus on our child". That's it. Nothing else. No negativity.

MotherJessAndKittens · 16/11/2026 09:16

I agree with poster who highlighted risks of going abroad to let his family have relationship with her.
I think you would be very vulnerable to them not allowing you to bring her home to UK. I would not go because of that risk and it’s happened before that children are kept in the father’s country.
I think it is a dangerous situation to put yourself and DD in.

Onlywayisrainham · 16/11/2026 09:17

Your ‘truth’ will be different from his. As time passes, you both may see a more balanced perspective. What seems really important today, may seem inconsequential as the years pass by.

No you shouldn’t share your feelings/reasons about the break up with his family.

BobbleBear · 16/11/2026 09:34

This is utter madness. 😱

Don’t go because I can guarantee you’ll have a thoroughly miserable Christmas if you do. Ex in-laws are notoriously awful to ex partners.

If he wants his family to see his daughter, they’ll have to visit because he obviously can’t take her there on his own and why on earth are you facilitating this?

Start planning your own future without him NOW. Having a relationship with his side of the family is entirely on him to facilitate. Stop being a doormat.

BackJustToSay · 16/11/2026 09:34

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 08:47

Firstly, I wouldn't be doing this if you are genuinely seperated. Isn't it confusing for your DD? Does she know you are seperated? Are you staying with your ex in this "close by" place, or just you and DD?

Second, I (foreign) find the whole "he's going to kidnap your daughter" quite offensive. If DH and I broke up and he refused to let me take my kids home to see my family because he wa scared i'd kidnap them I'd honestly be so upset. I would obviously not do that - we foreigners aren't savages that, as soon as we don't get our way in a relationship, run off with the kids for them never to return. That said, you obviously feel concerned enough about it that you've talked to a lawyer. Why is that? What country are you doing to?

So, basically, I think there's a lot of bigger issues than what narrative you'll give them of your break up, but if they ask i'd just be factual.

It's not about that @BusyGreySnail, the vast majority of people wouldn't do that of course, foreign national or British, it makes no difference. The issue is that for the small minority who would turn nasty over custody, taking the child abroad to a country where the other parent is a national internationalises the dispute and adds a whole other, far riskier dimension than if you were keeping them within UK legal jurisdiction. Sadly, it does happen, and it's life-ruining. This isn't to imply anything about non British people at all, British people also run off with kids, it's just a lot easier to remedy legally (and geographically) if you're still on UK soil.

IsawwhatIsaw · 16/11/2026 09:40

I would absolutely cancel this trip. It’s not appropriate and possibly not safe either .
Then I would take steps to remove your ex from the house. Give him a few weeks notice.

ThreadGuardDog · 16/11/2026 09:47

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:14

Yes I think I am still enabling the entitlement, ie I have "given up" asking him to pull his weight doing chores or anything else - I just got sick of asking and being infuriated when he made an excuse, it was really making it a toxic living situation especially for DD. I need to set a deadline about the moving out, that's a good idea.

Spoke with a lawyer who said that realistically he/his family wouldn't be able to block DD and I from leaving the country as he has no "proof" that she lives in his family's home country (as she doesn't), as long as I make sure I keep DD's passport safe. So figure it's "worth it" as would be nice for DD to have a relationship with both sides of her family. Of course if they do try anything then we won't go back there again

The UK is a signatory of The Hague Convention 1980. If you haven’t already, make sure the country you are visiting is also signed up to it. If not, the automatic international return mechanisms provided by the Convention don’t apply and DD’s father or his family can legally or practically prevent you from bringing your child back to the UK. You would be subject to the family and local laws of that specific country rather than UK courts or international treaty enforcement. If local laws or courts granted custody or a travel ban to the father, getting your DD back could prove very difficult and expensive.

ETA. In reality taking your DD out of the country in your present circumstances is high risk. Legally to take a child out of the UK, you need the consent of both parents. The time to consider whether this is worth the risk is before you go, and you can withdraw your consent. If you’re in any doubt about your ex’s intentions it’s not enough to remove your childs’ passport out of his possession. You need to apply to the court for a prohibited steps order to prevent him from obtaining a replacement.

Cherrysoup · 16/11/2026 09:48

Please don’t take your baby abroad. It just isn’t safe. What will you do if they refuse to allow you to take her back? Assuming your useless ex has parental responsibility because he’s on the birth certificate. And why is he still living with you?

Coconutcreamz · 16/11/2026 09:49

Topseyt123 · 16/11/2026 01:29

Why on earth are you going to spend Christmas with him and his family when you have split up? That truly beggars belief!

Tell this arsewipe to move out well before Christmas and cancel your trip.

This.
No way should you be going there for Christmas.
Get this loser out of your home asap, that should be your focus.

Horses7 · 16/11/2026 09:52

PyongyangKipperbang · 16/11/2026 02:11

Dont go. Seriously.

Cancel and send an email.

"DD and I will not be coming to stay, despite whatever your son has told you. Your son works minimal hours whilst expecting me to pay all our our housing and bills etc, doesnt do any parenting of our child (in fact he expects me to pay for outside childcare when I am at work and he isnt) and does nothing to keep our house going. He leaves it all to me, which is why I have ended our relationship. I would love to keep in touch with you for DD's sake if you choose, however I understand if you don't want to."

I like this message to your in-laws - perhaps word it even more strongly?
I’ve not read an OP post for ages that has given me so many red flags. Do not go - please.

Horses7 · 16/11/2026 09:56

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:28

What does it mean though, for the ex to facilitate this? I certainly wouldn't want DD to go with her dad to another country while I stay in the UK without her. She hasn't even really attached to her dad so wouldn't be good for her at all

Good - neither of you should go.
Have a lovely Christmas at home.
In-laws can always visit you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread