Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to tell ex-in-laws at Xmas about why I ended the relationship?

221 replies

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

OP posts:
Peachy2005 · 16/11/2026 14:02

Bonkers to travel to them and risk them freezing you out over the holidays. An 18- month old will get nothing out of it. Tell him to move out and you will consider it for next year.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2026 14:17

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:33

Thanks for the advice. The country is in the EU, its part of the Hague convention. Don't want to share the precise country for privacy reasons (ex knows I use MN).

The thing is, if it's a theoretical risk now it would always be one right? Postponing until next Christmas means if the family did decide to try to stop DD leaving the country, they could do it in a years' time, 5 years' time etc, the risk would be the same? But it seems unreasonable to then never allow DD to go to that country until she turns 16?

I've reached out to a lawyer in the ex's family's country to get advice about whether its a risk - if they say it's risky, we won't go.

Is this lawyer conversant in EU and international law? Can they cite examples, where a child has been returned in similar circumstances?

Don’t just take the word of someone, who doesn’t know their stuff.

I posted upthread about an op several years ago. The child was also in an EU country. The mum was desperate and this had been going on for many months, perhaps over a year and she was still not in a position to get her child.

You’re being woefully naive I’m afraid.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2026 14:22

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 12:09

I've more or less never heard of anyone warning someone of not letting their child spend time with their ex in the UK. While maybe the legal mechanisms are easier to work out if the ex has parental responsibility they could absolutely take them. Yet on this thread basically every second reply is "he'll probably kidnap her!". I get the risks are greater if he did, but I think lots of people are defiitely concluding that he might (which, as i said, does just not come up where the father is British).

You never answered about your DH.

You got the wrong person. Dd wouldn’t have been ok to go with dh. She couldn’t handle being away from me when little. And that only resolved at about age 7 and by then, she didn’t want to go alone with dh. There was no reason therefore for him to take her. We went to visit his family as a family, even though I’d much rather have stayed at home some of the time. And yes, I told him it wasn’t ok to take her until she went willingly. He respected that and took her alone in her teens when she was ready. Because he put his child first, as did I.

BecauseofyouIlearntnottotrust · 16/11/2026 14:27

Do you know if you are still invited for Christmas?

Inertia · 16/11/2026 14:28

You sound terribly naive.

Your ex in-laws relationship with your child is not your priority.

If you take your child to them, or allow your ex to take your child, the biggest priority would be whether or not you actually get to bring your child back.

An 18mo toddler gets no benefit from this visit. There’s nothing to stop ex’ s family from travelling to visit if they want a relationship.

Who pays? Who organises the visit? Who does the childcare?

Sounds very much like it’ll be the same shit in a different country, except you’ll feel ganged up on.

I would tell them that neither you nor your child will be going. Ex is welcome to.

Tell in-laws that you are divorcing because you were doing all of the paid work, all of the unpaid childcare and housework, and you need to prioritise caring for your daughter ahead of babying a man child.

Tell them all that you have been legally advised to not allow either parent to take DC out of the country until parenting arrangements have been finalised by the courts.

Never2late2change · 16/11/2026 14:34

NO. Don't go. Ex and family may well blame you, the only outsider in his home country. You'll face tensions or they may snatch your baby. He must move out. Then you'll establish a new routine and THEN you'll see how he co parents responsibly. And after that, you'll arrange access to his family. You're trying to be reasonable and adult, but a cock lodger ain't and probably his family ain't either.

AllyOP · 16/11/2026 14:36

I trust your view on the situation OP, and that she’s not at risk of abduction.

You're at high risk of a very shit Christmas though?! Wouldn’t it be nicer to spend it at home being cosy with your daughter, instead of with people who will be speaking another language and thinking badly of you?

FedAndWatered · 16/11/2026 14:43

Having been in this situation with a CL, it doesn’t matter what happened or what you bent over backwards to accommodate.

Henceforth, your role is to be The Official Bitch from Hell. And imagine this family, getting accustomed to this new situation, possibly with drink in them, and imagine them seeing Golden Boy readjust to his new financial reality. This is going to be a big fucking disaster. Save yourself money. You’re going to need your money, since it is a young child and lots of expenses are coming your way. If his family wish to set up a relationship, they can get a plane, send birthday cards and Christmas cards and do video messages etc.

Soon there will be a big backlash against you when Golden Boy lands to earth with a bump. You want your own friends and family around at this point, rather than be vulnerable away from home. Might I also suggest that leaving a relationship can be dangerous, especially when cocklodgers who have been financially abusive realise they have nothing to lose.

Make alternative plans. Cancel at the last minute with an “illness” if you need to. Just make sure you don’t go and put yourself in a potentially dangerous position.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 16/11/2026 14:43

I also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up

Too bad. Of course they will think that, they are his family not yours. Does it really matter? Do not go to tidy up the narrative and make yourself look good in their eyes. It wont work.

You are taking a risk by going at all. Maybe your DH is still coparenting nicely with you until you and DD get to his parents' country, then he will stay put and he and his family will that DD stays with them and you will be able to do nothing about it. They may not even have that intention at the moment but things can change. Just suppose he wants to stay longer, you don't, and it escalates from there. Don't expose yourself or DD.

And he is not your "ex" until he has moved out at the very least.

GrantMyWishes · 16/11/2026 14:46

Quite honestly OP, I don't care what a lawyer from his country says, or what anyone else says, you would be MAD to take your child there. It would only need for you to go to the toilet, or for a shower, and they could quickly whip your child out of the house, into a car, and off anywhere in Europe, and you might NEVER find her! Think of other children who have disappeared while in foreign countries, Ben Needham for example, if you don't know the story, Google it, but he was basically playing outside, disappeared, and was never seen again, that was in 1991. Of course he may be dead, as they don't know who took him, but if he can disappear so completely, what's to stop the same happening to your child? The fact that you don't even speak their language makes it even worse, as they could actually plan something like this right in front of you. Or what if one of them grabbed you, bundled you into a vehicle, and took you away long enough for them to take your child away, or locked you in a room with plans to do the same thing? These things DO happen, and I think you are being EXTREMELY naive to think otherwise.

PLEASE DO NOT TAKE THIS RISK!

You would never forgive yourself if anything happened, and at 18months, it's unlikely your child would even remember the trip, so I really can't see the point. Get rid of this useless cocklodger, and deal with him purely through the Courts.

Another reason I think you would be mad to go, is the fact that they used to contact you, but haven't spoken to you in 3 months, since they heard the relationship had broken down. If that's the case, what on earth makes you think it's going to be comfortable to spend time with them if you go there? Have you discussed any of this with your own parents, or anyone else in real life?

PurpleThistle7 · 16/11/2026 14:46

This sounds like a terrible plan all the way through. At best you'll be uncomfortable and confused as they jabber away in another language (which is really rude if they all speak your language too). At worst you'll lose your child (are they dual citizens? That can be quite complicated). There's actually no good outcome here - you need to let the dust settle and rebuild relationships as an ex-partner, not a weird co-habitating not-couple arguing without a proper custody arrangement.

There's absolutely no reason for you to take responsibility for maintaining a relationship with people who are not trying to maintain a relationship.

You are clearly a very positive thinker, but you need to be a lot more realistic here. Visiting ex-inlaws is something you can explore after you've actually split up properly and created a new co-parenting relationship, not something to do amidst this mess.

FedAndWatered · 16/11/2026 14:48

You might still be in shock, OP.

Nonetheless, it’s hard work with a young child and being a single mum. This is a time to hunker down with your own tribe, be it family or friends. Don’t make it harder by going to stay with people who will side with their son, no matter what has occurred.

You will be treated like sh1t by his family and you deserve a nice and pleasant holiday after all this crap you have been through.

latetothefisting · 16/11/2026 14:52

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:14

Yes I think I am still enabling the entitlement, ie I have "given up" asking him to pull his weight doing chores or anything else - I just got sick of asking and being infuriated when he made an excuse, it was really making it a toxic living situation especially for DD. I need to set a deadline about the moving out, that's a good idea.

Spoke with a lawyer who said that realistically he/his family wouldn't be able to block DD and I from leaving the country as he has no "proof" that she lives in his family's home country (as she doesn't), as long as I make sure I keep DD's passport safe. So figure it's "worth it" as would be nice for DD to have a relationship with both sides of her family. Of course if they do try anything then we won't go back there again

Seems both unnecessarily risky and just a bit pointless to me.

Why spend the money and effort going to a different country with people who clearly dont want you there? Sounds like a crap christmas for you.

The fact they havent contacted you doesnt suggest they are particularly bothered about a relationship with dd and even if they are, she's 18months, she won't remember them next time if she only sees them once a year.

I think you're mad to be travelling to see them. If they are that bothered about building a relationship with her they can make the effort to ring and contact you, and come to visit while she is still young. Once she is a bit older and you and her father have properly separated by all means go and visit, and once she is older again she can go with just him if she is happy, but this is just muddying what sounds like already dirty waters!

There seems to be absolutely no benefit and a lot of negatives to going for both you and dd.

Seagulldancing · 16/11/2026 14:57

Are you paying for this trip? Either go as a holiday and DC can spend the odd afternoon with exs family, or just cancel the whole thing.
If you are done, be done, what you are suggesting is confusing.

Cardhey · 16/11/2026 15:00

You seriously need to think through this as the potential consequences of doing this could be awful, and actually you’ve got no reason to do this now. This is the first Christmas since you’ve broken up, so seriously, like somebody else said, get a grip and don’t do this because it’s just too risky and if something goes wrong, it’s seriously gonna go wrong

Cardhey · 16/11/2026 15:01

A toddler’s never gonna have an amazing relationship with family overseas at that age, so going as Christmas is not gonna make an IOTA of difference to them

7yo7yo · 16/11/2026 15:03

My advice would be not to go.

Therescathairinmybath · 16/11/2026 15:03

I know someone who wasn’t allowed to bring her child home from a European country in similar circumstances. Why take that risk?

Why do you want to make so much effort for a family who no longer wish to have regular contact with you? Concentrate on separating yourself from this man rather than caring so much about his family and what they think.

fuchsteufelswild · 16/11/2026 15:15

Why not go later when relations are hopefully more amicable? Your toddler wouldn't benefit from going now anyway.

Most parents who had this happen to them were shocked and surprised or they wouldn't have taken their kids abroad.

Notasbigasithink · 16/11/2026 15:22

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

In all seriousness OP, I would knock this Christmas on the head and not risk leaving this country. At 18mths she won't remember anything so who exactly are you doing this for?
By all means if they want to see thwir granddaughter, they can visit here, under your supervision until you have fully split with your ex.
He sounds as though he is still cocklodging with you. After 3mths he's still in your house with no end in sight?
Tell him he has to be completely moved out by 31st Dec. His living arrangements and employment status is of absolutely no concern of yours thereafter.
Just make sure he's not planning to go for sole custody of your child so he doesn't have to work and you end up paying him! The longer he's sponging off you, the more likely he will have grounds to prove this is your arrangement and the established routine for your baby.

FedAndWatered · 16/11/2026 15:28

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:42

So that DD can build a relationship with her ex's side of the family too and know that side of her heritage/culture, learn the language, etc. I would also like to see her cousins again and keep the family ties as much as possible. I don't want to split the family apart more than necessary just because her dad was a rubbish partner to me

Edited: that being said, if the lawyers say its too risky to go then that will trump the reasons outlined above

Edited

I bent over backwards trying to set up a relationship with my ex CL’s family. They have never appreciated this and they are still not pleasant. There is no point at this stage. If they are going to make it happen, they will make it happen.

FedAndWatered · 16/11/2026 15:30

And this is a serious risk - that he would say to a court that he is the parent who looks after the child and you would be the one living in the bedsit down the road and paying for him to live with your child.

I would suggest changing the locks on him.

godmum56 · 16/11/2026 15:39

seahorsessky · 16/11/2026 13:28

Think about how hurt and upset they'll be. No doubt there'll be comments, generally blaming the mother, not father, for "enabling" him, but sometimes the best parents have the worst kids and vice versa. Some amazing people had awful parents. They will be really worried about your child-and remember she is half them (and half your parents) so cutting them off would be spiteful, and children from broken families suffer even worse when they don't have grandparents. I have a friend who said she wouldn't be here now if she hadn't had her gran's support when her parents broke up.
So be kind to them, and maybe ask their advice/opinion on how to move forward. You don't mention culture, but for many parents, the worst thing they can imagine in the world is their child's marriage breaking down, having watched them promise to support each other forever. Not everyone has to agree with this, but it is a fact.

their hurt and upset means NOTHING ZERO NADA compared to the safety of a child. If they want to see the child then they can travel to the UK.

SavBlancTonight · 16/11/2026 16:06

Obviously, you must decide on the risk for yourself. Based on what you've said, I don't think there's a risk of him trying to keep the child in his country. He's not an active or involved parent and he only would do something like tha tto get at you... but he's lazy, so it's too much effort. I've seen controlling cocklodgers who absolutely WOULD do this but I've also seen many who absolutely won't because they don't actually want anything to do with the effort of a child.

In your case, I still think you shouldn't go - why the fuck should you be doing all the work here. He needs to move out. And then his family can come visit and if yo have a good relationship with them, then erhaps they might invite YOU to stay in due course andyou can decide if you want to do that or not.