Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to tell ex-in-laws at Xmas about why I ended the relationship?

221 replies

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 00:41

I ended the relationship with my DD's dad because he was a cocklodger. Ridiculous levels of entitlement, leaving me to full time work, most of babycare (and I pay for the rest while I work) and all the housework while he barely works part time or lifts a finger.

His family lives abroad and we are staying with them for Xmas (and planning for other seasonal holidays). He has painted himself as a victim, and am sure they think I've treated him terribly by ending the relationship.

What should I say to them at Xmas when they ask about the break up? I don't want to be petty, but also don't want them to think that I'm some monster and he's a poor victim, in case that becomes the narrative when DD grows up (she's 18m now). I haven't heard from his family since the break up 3 months ago, although we used to get on well.

AIBU: don't say much, just say we work better as coparents, and take the "high road".
AINBU: tell them being with him was like having a second child, he is lazy and selfish, and I didn't want to set such a bad example of a romantic relationship to our DD? (Ie the truth)

Or something else?

OP posts:
undergroundandoverground · 16/11/2026 12:16

Instead of worrying about this I'd worry about getting him to leave, and the legal implications of his home country, visits there, custody etc.

Do you WANT to go there this Xmas?

Personally I'd say you feel its too soon after the split and maybe you can shelve the idea for next Xmas (and hide her passport).

MrsSlocombesCat · 16/11/2026 12:23

Every day there is at least one post that makes no sense at all. Today it's this one.

Sunshineandgrapefruit · 16/11/2026 12:28

Don't go. You have split up. They will always take his side. Draw a line.

bumblingbovine49 · 16/11/2026 12:29

Londonwelshie · 16/11/2026 01:53

Did you get legal advice from a lawyer in your ex’s home country? As legal advice from the UK (assuming you live here) is meaningless in practice.

Theres a huge difference between what the law says and how it works in practice. It’s important you consider the worst case scenarios- e.g. if your ex takes your DD’s passport and tries to keep her there, you will have to fight to bring your daughter back via an unfamiliar and potentially unfavourable legal system. In most cases it will take many months, if not years, for a case to be heard and resolution reached. If you are unable to get a long term VISA for the duration of the legal process, you will have to leave your daughter in the home country with your ex or his family, whilst you live in the UK. Your daughter is very young to be separated from her primary carer, and the whole situation would be distressing for the both of you.

I therefore would recommend that you only take your daughter on the trip if you trust with absolute certainty that your ex and his family would never put you in that situation. Given he’s your ex, I don’t think you can rely on his assurances or stated intentions for this trip. I wouldn’t take your daughter there if I were you- the family can come to visit her instead.

Please do ensure that you have all the appropriate paperwork in place. Just having your DD's passport is not enough in some countries. Many countries will stop you at the border and ask for proof that your child's father is ok with them leaving the country. This is more likely if your children have a surname common in the country you are visiting but they can ask anyway. They will see your passort and the chldrenns' passports and if they think they might be citizens of the country you are visiting (albeit ones with a UK passport) they will ask where the children's father is and whther you have permission to travlel with them. If you don't have this, they can stop you leaving the country. I am not saying this always happens but it definitely can and does happen

CountCountington · 16/11/2026 12:31

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 12:09

I've more or less never heard of anyone warning someone of not letting their child spend time with their ex in the UK. While maybe the legal mechanisms are easier to work out if the ex has parental responsibility they could absolutely take them. Yet on this thread basically every second reply is "he'll probably kidnap her!". I get the risks are greater if he did, but I think lots of people are defiitely concluding that he might (which, as i said, does just not come up where the father is British).

You never answered about your DH.

I haven’t mentioned anything on this thread about whether or not I have a husband, you are confusing me with somebody else.

You obviously feel strongly that people are prejudging this “foreign” ex. I’m just going to point out that the OP has only said that her ex’s family lives overseas - I can’t see anything where she has specified that they are from that overseas country or that her ex is not British.

Honestly I’m not sure what point you’re really making here. The risk of ex or his family trying to take the daughter is a valid concern and the OP should be aware of it, regardless of whether you feel offended on behalf of the ex who are you assuming is foreign!

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:33

Thanks for the advice. The country is in the EU, its part of the Hague convention. Don't want to share the precise country for privacy reasons (ex knows I use MN).

The thing is, if it's a theoretical risk now it would always be one right? Postponing until next Christmas means if the family did decide to try to stop DD leaving the country, they could do it in a years' time, 5 years' time etc, the risk would be the same? But it seems unreasonable to then never allow DD to go to that country until she turns 16?

I've reached out to a lawyer in the ex's family's country to get advice about whether its a risk - if they say it's risky, we won't go.

OP posts:
Cardhey · 16/11/2026 12:36

Why are you going?

Shedmistress · 16/11/2026 12:39

Op you don't have to EVER go.

Periperi2025 · 16/11/2026 12:41

I put YABU, because I don't think you should specificaly set out to tell them, but if your ex says anything that isn't true or your ILs do, by all means correct them.

My exMIL has never really acknowledged anything to me and I haven't said anything, but she's been fine with me. I'm not really sure telling her "he was already turning into his Dad who lives as a virtual recluse, barely makes conversation, and never acts on his own intitaitve, before he was even 40, and I didn't want to end up living like you do where the only way to stay sane is to spend every waking moment busy and/or outside the house with other people".

If you MIL can see the problem, she will already have empathy for you, if she can't and is part of the problem she will see her precious son as always right and having been wronged by you and no matter what you tell her it will make no difference.

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:42

Cardhey · 16/11/2026 12:36

Why are you going?

Edited

So that DD can build a relationship with her ex's side of the family too and know that side of her heritage/culture, learn the language, etc. I would also like to see her cousins again and keep the family ties as much as possible. I don't want to split the family apart more than necessary just because her dad was a rubbish partner to me

Edited: that being said, if the lawyers say its too risky to go then that will trump the reasons outlined above

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 16/11/2026 12:45

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:28

What does it mean though, for the ex to facilitate this? I certainly wouldn't want DD to go with her dad to another country while I stay in the UK without her. She hasn't even really attached to her dad so wouldn't be good for her at all

Going with them makes absolute sense if you feel she should visit them. Staying in their home is beyond uncomfortable, entirely unnecessary. I wouldn’t be agreeing to any of it. Presumably they are also able to travel, if they are that interested in a relationship, they would come to you. Or at least phoned at some point in 3 months.

ThreadGuardDog · 16/11/2026 12:47

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:33

Thanks for the advice. The country is in the EU, its part of the Hague convention. Don't want to share the precise country for privacy reasons (ex knows I use MN).

The thing is, if it's a theoretical risk now it would always be one right? Postponing until next Christmas means if the family did decide to try to stop DD leaving the country, they could do it in a years' time, 5 years' time etc, the risk would be the same? But it seems unreasonable to then never allow DD to go to that country until she turns 16?

I've reached out to a lawyer in the ex's family's country to get advice about whether its a risk - if they say it's risky, we won't go.

Then at the very least keep DD’s passport under your control at all times and get a prohibited steps order so that he can’t just go and order a replacement.

FairKoala · 16/11/2026 12:52

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 01:28

What does it mean though, for the ex to facilitate this? I certainly wouldn't want DD to go with her dad to another country while I stay in the UK without her. She hasn't even really attached to her dad so wouldn't be good for her at all

They come to the uk for a visit

No way would I be going to a foreign country with your ex to visit his family.

Red Flags all over this one.

Also why if you have split up months ago is he still living with you

FairKoala · 16/11/2026 12:53

And you are going on holiday
with him to spend Christmas with his family

Has he actually told them you and he are not together

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 13:02

FairKoala · 16/11/2026 12:53

And you are going on holiday
with him to spend Christmas with his family

Has he actually told them you and he are not together

Yes apparently he has told them we are not together, and I think thats true because I haven't heard from them since he says he told them, although he continues to speak with them when I'm not around/in the other room (in his native language so I don't understand what's being said). Don't know if the reason I haven't heard from them is because they think I'm being horrible and he's the victim (thats my guess), or they feel awkward and don't know what to say (plausible) or something else. Doesn't really matter I guess, except maybe regarding potential bad intentions" from their side (I would be very very shocked and surprised if they tried to keep DD in their country, but people can always surprise you).

OP posts:
Timeforanothernamechange3 · 16/11/2026 13:05

"He wasn't pulling his weight."

godmum56 · 16/11/2026 13:07

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 12:42

So that DD can build a relationship with her ex's side of the family too and know that side of her heritage/culture, learn the language, etc. I would also like to see her cousins again and keep the family ties as much as possible. I don't want to split the family apart more than necessary just because her dad was a rubbish partner to me

Edited: that being said, if the lawyers say its too risky to go then that will trump the reasons outlined above

Edited

I think that nice as that would be, you need to get stuff a whole lot clearer and your child should be older before you do it. Honestly you do sound a bit naive.

CountCountington · 16/11/2026 13:19

Honestly when your dd is older she will get more out of the visit, be more able to learn the language etc, plus if they did try to take her she would be able to communicate with people or explain what had happened. Taking a 13 year old to see them would be a world away from taking a toddler.

seahorsessky · 16/11/2026 13:28

Think about how hurt and upset they'll be. No doubt there'll be comments, generally blaming the mother, not father, for "enabling" him, but sometimes the best parents have the worst kids and vice versa. Some amazing people had awful parents. They will be really worried about your child-and remember she is half them (and half your parents) so cutting them off would be spiteful, and children from broken families suffer even worse when they don't have grandparents. I have a friend who said she wouldn't be here now if she hadn't had her gran's support when her parents broke up.
So be kind to them, and maybe ask their advice/opinion on how to move forward. You don't mention culture, but for many parents, the worst thing they can imagine in the world is their child's marriage breaking down, having watched them promise to support each other forever. Not everyone has to agree with this, but it is a fact.

FatMrsHoot · 16/11/2026 13:29

No way in hell would I be taking a toddler abroad for Christmas 3 months after ending my marriage.

OP you're being wildly naïve. She's not going to remember any of this at her age, and you're going to have a stressful Christmas.

Millytante · 16/11/2026 13:34

singlepringle23 · 16/11/2026 13:02

Yes apparently he has told them we are not together, and I think thats true because I haven't heard from them since he says he told them, although he continues to speak with them when I'm not around/in the other room (in his native language so I don't understand what's being said). Don't know if the reason I haven't heard from them is because they think I'm being horrible and he's the victim (thats my guess), or they feel awkward and don't know what to say (plausible) or something else. Doesn't really matter I guess, except maybe regarding potential bad intentions" from their side (I would be very very shocked and surprised if they tried to keep DD in their country, but people can always surprise you).

I’m astounded at your air of ‘Que sera, sera’ in all this; at the general passivity. In your shoes I would be very much on the ball at this time, in order that very firm foundations are made for the future. (Mixed metaphors, apologies!)

Get that man out of your house and flipping well separate already.
If you don’t get a shift on you will have sunk back into old ways, he’ll be more firmly ensconced, and nothing will have changed except perhaps a determination on the part of his family to shore up their access to your child.

Act now in your own interests and that of the child, before the opportunity to effect real change has evaporated.

edit: It goes without saying that this proposed trip is an absurd and even risky notion. Cancel all arrangements pronto. It’s a completely crazy idea.

Coconutcreamz · 16/11/2026 13:38

FatMrsHoot · 16/11/2026 13:29

No way in hell would I be taking a toddler abroad for Christmas 3 months after ending my marriage.

OP you're being wildly naïve. She's not going to remember any of this at her age, and you're going to have a stressful Christmas.

Agree.
Some women cannot be told and have to learn things the hard way.
I cannot believe a mother would put her and her child at such unnecessary risk for a child that will not remember.
He doesn't care about his child or providing for them.
Sending one of those clear messages above, to his family is the wisest thing to do.
Let them visit the uk if they are so keen.

Bluefox2 · 16/11/2026 13:47

Your off your trolly op
This isn't your responsibility
Let them make the effort and travel to you
And your still in the same house , spending Christmas together at his family abroad..not giving separated vibes to me ..how confusing all round

AshCullen1894 · 16/11/2026 13:50

How many hoops are you planning to jump through for this man and his random cousins?? You sound incredibly naive.

Wickedwhiskers · 16/11/2026 13:53

Given your living arrangements haven't changed and you are all going to be going on holiday then I'd say he hasn't told them you've split permanently.

And you talk about your lawyers advice which sounds a bit too vague. I would certainly NOT be taking her abroad. If they want to see their grandchild they can come here.