Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries with MIL and SIL

167 replies

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 22:06

I’ve had a baby for first time last year and previously had no issues with my in laws but relationship has changed since becoming a mother as my boundaries are repeatedly disrespected.

The first sign was that they visited my place for the first time a week before I was due to give birth (my partner had moved in a month before) - I didn’t want any visitors at the point and it was almost as though they wanted to try and accidentally on purpose be at the birth.
I had a traumatic birth and emergency c-section and really didn’t want one. I didn’t want any visitors until I was ready but they kept pushing to come after a few days even though my baby was in hospital with jaundice after a few days. They wouldn’t take no for an answer and thought their needs trumped mine (texting ‘I am his grandmother I have a right to see him’ to partner), which left a bitter taste in my mouth and suggested they didn’t have mine or my baby’s best interests at heart if can’t respect my boundaries at most vulnerable time of our lives.
Since then several other things have happened including:

  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;
  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),
  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;
  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),
  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,
  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),
  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),
  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)
  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,
  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

They also expect us to drive up at least once a month, to the other side of the country despite having a baby and very busy with work and childcare and no money. They don’t visit here, and expect us to pay for petrol and also want us to stay there despite having a three bed home with FIL, MIL and SIL in one house and only a spare box rom where we won’t fit. They offer SIL’s bigger room where we have stayed before when baby was very small, but we can’t now he’s bigger (and don’t really want to anywhere as we were made to get a hotel before I had my son due to space, so don’t feel welcome now).
Think I would like them more if boundaries were communicated more firmly and quickly by partner but I’ve had to do most of it as he’s not been able to. That creates some friction between me and them, but I think the reason he can’t is because of them being enmeshed and a generally unhealthy dynamic (where the only job he ever has was at his Dad’s company, his best friend is cousin and lived at home until 44 years old with SIL and MIL and FIL). I know MIL cried when he previously moved out at 30 and suggests to me she is manipulative and doesn’t want him living his own life. It seems like helicopter parenting where they won’t let their children do anything for themselves - and I don’t want that for my son, or my partner.

I’m very independent and moved out at 18, lived in 3 continents and not willing to have my life dictated by people who clearly have no regard for me.
At the same time, they mean well (I think) and I’m hyper independent and like the idea of having a close knit family - I just am too aware of toxic patterns due to my own childhood to overlook them when I see them, and will protect my son from anything I see as being harmful in any way. AIBU?

The reason I ask is because we were originally meant to move closer to them last year so they could help with childcare, but don’t want to now due to consistent boundaries overstepped regarding my son. I would be isolated there and risk their big family basically take over all decisions in our lives.
I hope to get past this and move there eventually but need some advice on how to, as not sure they are open to discussing these issues and partner is defensive when bring up the topic and accusing me of not liking his family. The truth is, I like them but also want them to respect my boundaries - sadly the longer they don’t, the more likely I will start to dislike them - so I want to nip this in the bud.

OP posts:
everyonedeservesbetter · Yesterday 23:16

My personal take on this, is that you don’t want them involved with your dc at all and are finding every reason/excuse in the book to justify this.

And because of this, I do not understand your decision to move closer for help with childcare.

These totally contradict each other. So maybe I’ve got the wrong end of the stick.

FoodoftheDog · Yesterday 23:20

My only advice is to not move any closer. The rest you’ll have to start addressing as it comes up. I have ILs with the worst boundaries imaginable and thankfully we are well past the worst of it now.

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:27

everyonedeservesbetter · Yesterday 23:16

My personal take on this, is that you don’t want them involved with your dc at all and are finding every reason/excuse in the book to justify this.

And because of this, I do not understand your decision to move closer for help with childcare.

These totally contradict each other. So maybe I’ve got the wrong end of the stick.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I’ll reflect on that.
To clarify, before we had the baby we had planned to move to where they live. As a results of boundaries crossed since I gave birth, I’ve put the move on hold.
I’d like to find a way forward and move nearer them eventually, but not until these issues have been acknowledged and resolved. I want advice so we can rebuild trust and I can feel safe with my son around them.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:30

FoodoftheDog · Yesterday 23:20

My only advice is to not move any closer. The rest you’ll have to start addressing as it comes up. I have ILs with the worst boundaries imaginable and thankfully we are well past the worst of it now.

Edited

Thank you! It’s reassuring to hear it gets better. I guess the first year with the first child is bound to be the hardest as you’re post partum and still understanding each others’ boundaries (especially as my partner and I have only been together a few years so I don’t know his family that well yet).

OP posts:
BibbityBoppityTwo · Yesterday 23:34

everyonedeservesbetter · Yesterday 23:16

My personal take on this, is that you don’t want them involved with your dc at all and are finding every reason/excuse in the book to justify this.

And because of this, I do not understand your decision to move closer for help with childcare.

These totally contradict each other. So maybe I’ve got the wrong end of the stick.

I agree with this. I think some things you mention are fair enough and ultimately require you saying no. But many of them involve you being a bit uptight. I don’t think, for example, you can get upset with your SIL being involved in care if she lives with your MIL who is caring for your child.

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:42

BibbityBoppityTwo · Yesterday 23:34

I agree with this. I think some things you mention are fair enough and ultimately require you saying no. But many of them involve you being a bit uptight. I don’t think, for example, you can get upset with your SIL being involved in care if she lives with your MIL who is caring for your child.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. It was specifically finding out my 4 month old son had stayed in her bed overnight without our consent. It was first night away from us, first baby and prefer to be asked if the person who is meant to be caring for my child is delegating to someone else. It matters to me as I wouldn’t have given my SIL permission to look after my baby as she doesn’t have children and doesn’t have experience looking after a baby. It’s also about respect and earning trust to me, but I acknowledge I can be uptight and very protective of my baby.

OP posts:
RedSheep26 · Today 02:36

They sound extremely pushy and I would really struggle with this. I would not be travelling up every month and the plan to move would be on indefinite hiatus! You have a small baby, they are grown adults and can do the travelling (and stay in a hotel). When you go there you’re on their turf and you can see they don’t respect your rules for your baby so that’s not viable.

However your problem is your partner. From what you’ve said he doesn’t see any issue with the behaviour and actually has a go at you when you try to raise it. So it doesn’t seem like he’d back you up if you said “hey, it’s taking a lot out of me to do this travel with a young baby, can you ask your parents to visit us instead?”.

You need to push back though because this man and his family are walking all over you. You’re the mum, you get to use the pram you bought! The day I was forced by my partner to use a (worse) pram because SIL bought it would be the day I would properly lose my shit. I wouldn’t be giving my baby crappy cheap toys. If MIL and SIL want a baby they can have their own.

IMHO2 · Today 06:02

I think this is a mixture of lack of boundaries and letting you take the lead from your MIL and SIL, but also some of the things you list I don’t really see an issue with personally and think you might need to chill a bit and think where you can compromise too.

Holdinguphalfthesky · Today 06:20

Cosleeping done wrong can actually lead to baby death so that’s absolutely not you being “uptight” at all.

I know it’s unhelpful to say wtf about your OH, living at home until 44, but really that was my response. They sound weirdly enmeshed together. How old is the sister? How old are the parents? What’s your OH like as a partner, does he pull his weight?

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:36

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:42

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. It was specifically finding out my 4 month old son had stayed in her bed overnight without our consent. It was first night away from us, first baby and prefer to be asked if the person who is meant to be caring for my child is delegating to someone else. It matters to me as I wouldn’t have given my SIL permission to look after my baby as she doesn’t have children and doesn’t have experience looking after a baby. It’s also about respect and earning trust to me, but I acknowledge I can be uptight and very protective of my baby.

Edited

I'm puzzled about why your baby was staying overnight with your MIL if she is overbearing and determined to ignore your boundaries. Four months is very young to be staying overnight without you there. Is your partner pushing for letting his mum have your baby overnight? Do you feel unable to say no?

SpainToday · Today 06:42

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:36

I'm puzzled about why your baby was staying overnight with your MIL if she is overbearing and determined to ignore your boundaries. Four months is very young to be staying overnight without you there. Is your partner pushing for letting his mum have your baby overnight? Do you feel unable to say no?

I wondered about this too

Pobblewob · Today 06:47

This whole thing is a mess of things that are unreasonable (photos online, kissing and passing to ill people), and things that make you sound hard work (toy/clothes, tickling, changing place and to some extent MIL wanting to meet grandchild). I can't decide on the sleepover with SIL, did the baby sleep in her bed? That is dangerous.

It would seem that you are both somewhat unreasonable.

TheRealWhacker · Today 06:47

The announcing birth, kissing and refusing to take pictures down are not ok, but the rest is just ridiculous on your part. I mean your SIL not being “authorised” to look after your baby?

The childcare situation has got disaster written all over it with your determination to enforce these “boundaries” so I’d make other plans as it’s clearly not going to work. Just remember you will be a MIL one day and try to lighten up a bit.

Itsnottheendoftheworldthough · Today 06:50

It’s nice you have a village. One that cares about your child and wants to see them. Let me tell you from the opposite side of that… no one is coming. No one cares. No one offers any help or support. No one wants to hold your child or kiss them. You don’t need boundaries because there isn’t anyone to cross them.

cuddlebear · Today 07:28

I don’t understand why you are travelling to see these people so often? Are you scared of saying no?

Is DH the problem?

Definitely don’t move closer!! I would be pulling back and seeing them less frequently and sticking to your boundaries within reason when you do see them.

The more they pissed me off, the less they would be seeing me.

rememberingthem · Today 07:37

They need firm boundaries and you need to stop being so controlling.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:41

RedSheep26 · Today 02:36

They sound extremely pushy and I would really struggle with this. I would not be travelling up every month and the plan to move would be on indefinite hiatus! You have a small baby, they are grown adults and can do the travelling (and stay in a hotel). When you go there you’re on their turf and you can see they don’t respect your rules for your baby so that’s not viable.

However your problem is your partner. From what you’ve said he doesn’t see any issue with the behaviour and actually has a go at you when you try to raise it. So it doesn’t seem like he’d back you up if you said “hey, it’s taking a lot out of me to do this travel with a young baby, can you ask your parents to visit us instead?”.

You need to push back though because this man and his family are walking all over you. You’re the mum, you get to use the pram you bought! The day I was forced by my partner to use a (worse) pram because SIL bought it would be the day I would properly lose my shit. I wouldn’t be giving my baby crappy cheap toys. If MIL and SIL want a baby they can have their own.

Agree on travelling, have tried to push back but his parents are hold and FIL can’t travel. I’ve stopped paying for petrol, and go less but they always seem to make up a reason we have to go.

I did push back on pram and MIL made partner bring it back to SIL - but the fact it even happened is frustrating, and all this makes me look like the bad guy and undermines the possibility of any normal relationship we might have in the future (as it always has to be me to manage everything, which is draining). I’ve also asked for a plastic free home, and communicated to them that only want one or two gifts for Christmas and wooden Montessori toys (they asked what my son wanted for Christmas) to avoid the situation last year since we have a small home and don’t want to overwhelm baby.

Agree partner is mostly the issue, he eventually sticks up for my boundaries but takes a lot of arguing and energy to get there but it’s draining. I was hoping it would improve as he unlearns some of the toxic patterns from childhood where feelings and boundaries are treated as personal attack rather than respected.

OP posts:
cuddlebear · Today 07:44

Read your own post back. They come up with a reason you have to go.

No. You don’t have to go. DH is obviously free to visit them as often as he likes, but they don’t get to order you about.

Find your backbone and say no.

Soreenmaltloaf23 · Today 07:47

Don't ever move nearer. You won't have your own lives. Stop going every month. Say it's too expensive and stretch it to 6 weeks or more. Have an honest conversation with your DH about the relationships and agree a plan together.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:47

Holdinguphalfthesky · Today 06:20

Cosleeping done wrong can actually lead to baby death so that’s absolutely not you being “uptight” at all.

I know it’s unhelpful to say wtf about your OH, living at home until 44, but really that was my response. They sound weirdly enmeshed together. How old is the sister? How old are the parents? What’s your OH like as a partner, does he pull his weight?

Thank you. FIL is 80s, MIL 70s, SIL 40s.
Partner is great generally and does most of childcare at home as I work full time and he’s full time caring for son for now.
Agree it’s a weird set up and hadn’t realised the extent of it until all this happened.
I acknowledged it’s likely a form of enmeshment based on not respecting their own or other people’s boundaries.

OP posts:
PollyBell · Today 07:47

They sound insane but you sound over the top controlling you are not the first to have a baby and you won't be the last

Maybe they would be less insane if you realised it is his baby too and you are not an army sergeant

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:52

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:36

I'm puzzled about why your baby was staying overnight with your MIL if she is overbearing and determined to ignore your boundaries. Four months is very young to be staying overnight without you there. Is your partner pushing for letting his mum have your baby overnight? Do you feel unable to say no?

At that point we had a good relationship so I didn’t question it as the plan was for MIL to be involved with childcare from 9 months and wanted baby used to her (although they were pushy in retrospect). I would definitely never let that happen now. I don’t even like my son to be there without me now, and that’s why I don’t just stay at home when my partner wants to visit with son.
All this really became apparent after Christmas when baby was 5 months.

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · Today 07:54

I wouldn’t want anyone co-sleeping with a young baby. Do they know the guidance?

How come your partner didn’t live with you before you got pregnant?

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:56

cuddlebear · Today 07:28

I don’t understand why you are travelling to see these people so often? Are you scared of saying no?

Is DH the problem?

Definitely don’t move closer!! I would be pulling back and seeing them less frequently and sticking to your boundaries within reason when you do see them.

The more they pissed me off, the less they would be seeing me.

If definitely want to go less, we go more than we do to my own family.
My partner gets pressured by his family and guilt tripped and manipulated into it. He has no boundaries.
I don’t like my son to be there without me now, so have to go. I’ve stopped paying for petrol though and will try to go less.

OP posts:
Pobblewob · Today 07:57

The stuff about the toys makes me think you have some part to play in having ridiculous expectations though.

How often do you see them and how far away is it?