Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries with MIL and SIL

170 replies

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 22:06

I’ve had a baby for first time last year and previously had no issues with my in laws but relationship has changed since becoming a mother as my boundaries are repeatedly disrespected.

The first sign was that they visited my place for the first time a week before I was due to give birth (my partner had moved in a month before) - I didn’t want any visitors at the point and it was almost as though they wanted to try and accidentally on purpose be at the birth.
I had a traumatic birth and emergency c-section and really didn’t want one. I didn’t want any visitors until I was ready but they kept pushing to come after a few days even though my baby was in hospital with jaundice after a few days. They wouldn’t take no for an answer and thought their needs trumped mine (texting ‘I am his grandmother I have a right to see him’ to partner), which left a bitter taste in my mouth and suggested they didn’t have mine or my baby’s best interests at heart if can’t respect my boundaries at most vulnerable time of our lives.
Since then several other things have happened including:

  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;
  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),
  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;
  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),
  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,
  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),
  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),
  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)
  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,
  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

They also expect us to drive up at least once a month, to the other side of the country despite having a baby and very busy with work and childcare and no money. They don’t visit here, and expect us to pay for petrol and also want us to stay there despite having a three bed home with FIL, MIL and SIL in one house and only a spare box rom where we won’t fit. They offer SIL’s bigger room where we have stayed before when baby was very small, but we can’t now he’s bigger (and don’t really want to anywhere as we were made to get a hotel before I had my son due to space, so don’t feel welcome now).
Think I would like them more if boundaries were communicated more firmly and quickly by partner but I’ve had to do most of it as he’s not been able to. That creates some friction between me and them, but I think the reason he can’t is because of them being enmeshed and a generally unhealthy dynamic (where the only job he ever has was at his Dad’s company, his best friend is cousin and lived at home until 44 years old with SIL and MIL and FIL). I know MIL cried when he previously moved out at 30 and suggests to me she is manipulative and doesn’t want him living his own life. It seems like helicopter parenting where they won’t let their children do anything for themselves - and I don’t want that for my son, or my partner.

I’m very independent and moved out at 18, lived in 3 continents and not willing to have my life dictated by people who clearly have no regard for me.
At the same time, they mean well (I think) and I’m hyper independent and like the idea of having a close knit family - I just am too aware of toxic patterns due to my own childhood to overlook them when I see them, and will protect my son from anything I see as being harmful in any way. AIBU?

The reason I ask is because we were originally meant to move closer to them last year so they could help with childcare, but don’t want to now due to consistent boundaries overstepped regarding my son. I would be isolated there and risk their big family basically take over all decisions in our lives.
I hope to get past this and move there eventually but need some advice on how to, as not sure they are open to discussing these issues and partner is defensive when bring up the topic and accusing me of not liking his family. The truth is, I like them but also want them to respect my boundaries - sadly the longer they don’t, the more likely I will start to dislike them - so I want to nip this in the bud.

OP posts:
TheignT · Today 13:55

Differentforgirls · Today 13:46

I could never have left my boys at that age overnight. Tbh, neither of them would have stood for it either 😁

Nor me. Mine were breastfeeding on demand at that age so it wouldn't have been possible even if I wanted to.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:55

Differentforgirls · Today 13:54

And how will you tell?

Because he won’t just be advocating for his mother or sister, he’ll be taking his own view

OP posts:
TheignT · Today 13:57

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:54

I know but I’m uncomfortable my son going unsupervised now after all this

He isn't unsupervised, he's with his father.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:58

TheignT · Today 13:55

Nor me. Mine were breastfeeding on demand at that age so it wouldn't have been possible even if I wanted to.

Yes it was a mistake on my part and have learned from it. If I hadn’t have done it I wouldn’t have learned what they are like though. Any coldness on my side is because they abused my trust when son and I were so vulnerable

OP posts:
TheignT · Today 13:58

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:55

Because he won’t just be advocating for his mother or sister, he’ll be taking his own view

He might agree with them. His views might not always be the same as yours.

Pobblewob · Today 13:59

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:55

Because he won’t just be advocating for his mother or sister, he’ll be taking his own view

So he's not allowed to agree with his family because you think that's not his own opinion?

Controlling AF.

TheignT · Today 14:00

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:58

Yes it was a mistake on my part and have learned from it. If I hadn’t have done it I wouldn’t have learned what they are like though. Any coldness on my side is because they abused my trust when son and I were so vulnerable

Well you decided to leave your vulnerable baby with them. You need to own your own part in that. Is part of your upset because you feel guilty about that.

Barney16 · Today 14:03

I think in some matters you are reasonable, in others unreasonable. Probably your in-laws are ecstatic there's a baby in their family. They haven't had any practice at being GP so they are going to make mistakes. I get the co sleeping but other things on your list are silly. They sound hard work, but so do you. The visiting every month is obviously a real trial. Let your husband go with baby every other month. Or meet half way for a day out?

chirrupybird · Today 14:04

If your son is the only GC he is sure to be the apple of everyone's eye. We were in the same position my DH was an only child and his mother's sister's didn't have children at all, so when we visited we had to go to all the family to show the baby and everyone cooing over her. It was a bit annoying but I understood that to all of them she was really precious. It all came from good hearts. Years later all of them have died, but they had a little joy from our bundle of joy.

seahorsessky · Today 14:08

everyonedeservesbetter · Yesterday 23:16

My personal take on this, is that you don’t want them involved with your dc at all and are finding every reason/excuse in the book to justify this.

And because of this, I do not understand your decision to move closer for help with childcare.

These totally contradict each other. So maybe I’ve got the wrong end of the stick.

Exactly! Lots of us had terrible times and still welcomed family immediately, because we care about our kids and want them to have a good relationship with grandparents. You have strangers visiting and right next to you on postnatal wards, why not family? I also wanted my husband to be supported by his family, and for them to enjoy seeing the baby on that precious first day. It's not all about me just because I am the mum!

PartingGift · Today 14:11

Honestly? You sound a little bit ungrateful for the free childcare. Baffled at leaving your baby overnight when he was so little.

You don’t get to dictate what people choose to buy your child.

Don’t leave your child alone with family members you don’t trust and you won’t have these issues.

FoodoftheDog · Today 14:22

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:20

Agreed - I only mention the registry and toys as common patterns of not considering our preferences and going overboard on gifts in a manner that seemingly is to buy affection and is overbearing in the scale of things bought for baby (and not enough space in our house to keep it, or money to buy duplicates - see my last reply).

it’s not a big thing at all, and a recent thing which has come up as a result of me being hyper sensitive to their actions after overstepping important boundaries and giving us stuff with toxins and chemicals which we don’t want in our home.

I take the point that best to drop and focus on key safety issues. Thanks.

Yeah I agree with you on this one. You need to pick some of these battles for your own sake as much as anyone.

Acertwirl · Today 14:30

JLou08 · Today 13:30

I really think you're going to damage your DS and your DH. You come across as very rigid and controlling and terrified of your small family unit getting close (or enmeshed as you see it) to wider family. You already have your DH bending to what you want, your trying to isolate him and your DS from his family telling him they are toxic and enmeshed.
I think your therapist failed you. Did they explore your attachment style with you? Did they explore how you treat others and form and maintain relationships? Or was it all just providing you with validation with no challenge to your thought process or relationship skills?

Are you the parent of an adult son by any chance? You seem very keen on OP believing that she is toxic, controlling and should just roll over and let her in laws do whatever they please even though she has observed unhealthy family dynamics AND experienced them overstepping (at best) and endangering her child (at worst).

If she doesn’t want them around the baby without her, that’s fine and relatively normal. If she doesn’t want them having the baby overnight, that’s fine and normal (especially when it came to light that they were co sleeping). If she doesn’t want to live near them, that’s fine and normal. Her DH doesn’t have to agree, but he has to at least support her decisions if he wants his marriage to last. It’s pretty basic.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Today 14:30

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:20

Agreed - I only mention the registry and toys as common patterns of not considering our preferences and going overboard on gifts in a manner that seemingly is to buy affection and is overbearing in the scale of things bought for baby (and not enough space in our house to keep it, or money to buy duplicates - see my last reply).

it’s not a big thing at all, and a recent thing which has come up as a result of me being hyper sensitive to their actions after overstepping important boundaries and giving us stuff with toxins and chemicals which we don’t want in our home.

I take the point that best to drop and focus on key safety issues. Thanks.

For the gifts, can you ask for money into a ISA or premium bonds in your child's name instead of a gift? Saving for the future/uni/car/house deposit type thing.

My Dad set up premium bonds for both my DC when they were born and every Christmas or birthday or Easter he would put money there instead of buying stuff for the sake of it. As they got older they loved winning and reinvesting, even now (dad has passed) they still win and thank grandad for setting it up.

AllyOP · Today 14:31

(I haven’t RTFT, just OP’s updates)

Your partner is the main carer which puts you in very dangerous territory if you split! Focus all energy on him getting a full-time, local job and your son into childcare.

For the visits, push them out to every five, then six weeks. Insist on a hotel close to something you’re desperate to see. Grit your teeth, bin the crap, get SIL “best auntie” crap, see them for special occasions but not necessarily on the day.

Thank your lucky stars you didn’t move!

JLou08 · Today 14:45

Acertwirl · Today 14:30

Are you the parent of an adult son by any chance? You seem very keen on OP believing that she is toxic, controlling and should just roll over and let her in laws do whatever they please even though she has observed unhealthy family dynamics AND experienced them overstepping (at best) and endangering her child (at worst).

If she doesn’t want them around the baby without her, that’s fine and relatively normal. If she doesn’t want them having the baby overnight, that’s fine and normal (especially when it came to light that they were co sleeping). If she doesn’t want to live near them, that’s fine and normal. Her DH doesn’t have to agree, but he has to at least support her decisions if he wants his marriage to last. It’s pretty basic.

No, I'm not. I am someone who grew up with amazing relationships with my extended family that helped shape who I am and build my resilience. I also have a husband who doesn't try and get in the way of family relationships and visa versa.
If someone posted here from the POV of the partner more people would reapond as I have.
My husband is causing arguments with me until I agree to what he calls his boundaries with my family, we were a very close family and they have been really supportive and generous but he says we're enmeshed and he wants our child to be autonomous.
He got angry that my sister in her 40s looked after our baby when the baby was staying with my mum overnight, sister lives there so it's not like mum shipped the baby off to another house. My husband says my mum abused his trust, I don't agree but he is adamant that's not my own opinion, if I agree with my family he argues with me and says I need to form my own opinion but it seems that he sees my opinion as agreeing with what he wants.
My husband thinks my mum was trying to be there for the birth and this was breeching boundaries, my mum visited a week before the birth, she likes to see us all and was really happy to be having a grandchild. My husband doesn't like anything my family buy, he is getting at me to enforce that my family only buy wooden toys from a gift registry and stop buying clothes for the baby. It feels like a dig at my family and like they can do nothing right.
100% every comment would be saying it's coercive control and he is trying to isolate her from family.

Acertwirl · Today 14:57

JLou08 · Today 14:45

No, I'm not. I am someone who grew up with amazing relationships with my extended family that helped shape who I am and build my resilience. I also have a husband who doesn't try and get in the way of family relationships and visa versa.
If someone posted here from the POV of the partner more people would reapond as I have.
My husband is causing arguments with me until I agree to what he calls his boundaries with my family, we were a very close family and they have been really supportive and generous but he says we're enmeshed and he wants our child to be autonomous.
He got angry that my sister in her 40s looked after our baby when the baby was staying with my mum overnight, sister lives there so it's not like mum shipped the baby off to another house. My husband says my mum abused his trust, I don't agree but he is adamant that's not my own opinion, if I agree with my family he argues with me and says I need to form my own opinion but it seems that he sees my opinion as agreeing with what he wants.
My husband thinks my mum was trying to be there for the birth and this was breeching boundaries, my mum visited a week before the birth, she likes to see us all and was really happy to be having a grandchild. My husband doesn't like anything my family buy, he is getting at me to enforce that my family only buy wooden toys from a gift registry and stop buying clothes for the baby. It feels like a dig at my family and like they can do nothing right.
100% every comment would be saying it's coercive control and he is trying to isolate her from family.

If I agreed to someone having my 4 month old child overnight (which I wouldn’t 😂) and that person was a mother themselves, and then I found out that actually, my 4 month old had been looked after by someone else in their house, and had co slept with them, I’d be fucking furious. I see you didn’t refer to that in your reverse.

I think children benefit hugely from relationships with their extended families and as parents we should absolutely support and embrace that, but there are occasions where we need to say “that’s not acceptable” without terms like coercive control being thrown around.

A lot of the things in OPs comments are minor annoyances and I said myself that I think she is being hyper sensitive to it and confirmation bias is at play, but that doesn’t mean that she doesn’t have good reason to set boundaries with her in laws.

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · Today 15:02

An aunt co-sleeping with a baby is stupidly dangerous.

Don’t move closer. You’ll hate it.

MyLittleNest · Today 15:02

I saw this as someone who has been in your position: the situation will only continue and get worse if you do not make changes. It is one thing to be an excited grandparent, but that is not what is happening here.

You probably cannot change MIL or SIL or make them respect boundaries or your parenting decisions. They have already demonstrated that repeatedly.

Instead, I would focus on what you can do, primarily. Do not move closer. If anything, distance is best. Stop the drives once a month. A hard talk with your DH is needed. If he is unwilling to say no to mommy and daddy, then he can go alone and you can go as a family less often. I would not let him just take the baby given the situation you are describing.

Your DH needs to remember that he has his own family now. It doesn't mean cutting off his parents, but it does mean compromise, and they are asking for too much given the circumstances. You are an adult and so is your DH. You have your own family unit. They can't "tell" you what to do or "make" you do anything. The guilt tripping just underscores how incredibly selfish they are.

You are a mother now. You have to be more assertive. You will visit when it fits your schedule. You will not be allowing anymore overnight babysitting given that they broke your trust.

I would absolutely continue to tell SIL to stop posting public photos of your child on social media. If she can't respect that, then I would not share any more photos with her or allow her to take your child's photo or be alone with him without you present. (Not sure you can trust DH to stand up for his child or you to his sister?)

In general, they all seem to think this is some doll that can be shown off or passed around.

But it's your child. You are the adult in your child's life. His advocate. Time to start setting firm boundaries and (this part is on you) stick to them despite their reactions. So they might get upset! They haven't cared if they upset you...

CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:06

Pobblewob · Today 13:59

So he's not allowed to agree with his family because you think that's not his own opinion?

Controlling AF.

Of course he’s allowed to agree with his family. The issue is when them assert their decisions on him and us without either of us having a say or chance to discuss between ourselves. That is what I would call controlling. Interesting that you see it as the opposite.

OP posts:
momtoboys · Today 15:09

Not every infraction is a hill to die on. Your life is going to be very difficult if you can't let things go.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:16

JLou08 · Today 14:45

No, I'm not. I am someone who grew up with amazing relationships with my extended family that helped shape who I am and build my resilience. I also have a husband who doesn't try and get in the way of family relationships and visa versa.
If someone posted here from the POV of the partner more people would reapond as I have.
My husband is causing arguments with me until I agree to what he calls his boundaries with my family, we were a very close family and they have been really supportive and generous but he says we're enmeshed and he wants our child to be autonomous.
He got angry that my sister in her 40s looked after our baby when the baby was staying with my mum overnight, sister lives there so it's not like mum shipped the baby off to another house. My husband says my mum abused his trust, I don't agree but he is adamant that's not my own opinion, if I agree with my family he argues with me and says I need to form my own opinion but it seems that he sees my opinion as agreeing with what he wants.
My husband thinks my mum was trying to be there for the birth and this was breeching boundaries, my mum visited a week before the birth, she likes to see us all and was really happy to be having a grandchild. My husband doesn't like anything my family buy, he is getting at me to enforce that my family only buy wooden toys from a gift registry and stop buying clothes for the baby. It feels like a dig at my family and like they can do nothing right.
100% every comment would be saying it's coercive control and he is trying to isolate her from family.

It seems like you are intent on purposely misunderstand the situation to suit your own narrative.
it’s interesting that such a post can have such wildly different interpretations and shows that we are all different and entitled to our own opinions. But I should be allowed to make my own decisions in my life and you should be on yours. But I am no longer seeking your opinion as you’ve breached a certain level of respect. Take care

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:18

momtoboys · Today 15:09

Not every infraction is a hill to die on. Your life is going to be very difficult if you can't let things go.

Yes I want to focus on the things that matter, but the patterns paint a picture that there’s underlying issues that I can’t overlook easily. It will have to be discussed and hashed out openly when I’ve got the mental energy to do so

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:22

AllyOP · Today 14:31

(I haven’t RTFT, just OP’s updates)

Your partner is the main carer which puts you in very dangerous territory if you split! Focus all energy on him getting a full-time, local job and your son into childcare.

For the visits, push them out to every five, then six weeks. Insist on a hotel close to something you’re desperate to see. Grit your teeth, bin the crap, get SIL “best auntie” crap, see them for special occasions but not necessarily on the day.

Thank your lucky stars you didn’t move!

Exactly this - thanks for understanding why this matter is so serious and getting to the crux of the issues. My main focus is getting my son into nursery and partner into work, but he keeps delaying it. It’s why we don’t have money to waste on things we don’t need, petrol money to burn, and why I don’t have the emotional or physical energy to deal with this all right now as had to go back to work after 6 months to support my family whilst still breastfeeding. I need people who support me in my life, not make it more difficult during this time (especially as recently had a close family bereavement, hence the therapy).

OP posts:
Coconutcreamz · Today 15:28

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:52

About the same distance. I’ve become more nitpicking now boundaries have been overstepped, yes, and want to get away from that.
i’d like things to be more amicable.
For the decisions, I’ve addressed this in the original post and replies (for example, his job, friends and home have all been chosen by parents up until we got together)

Honestly OP, what was his appeal?

He's a complete Mummys boy, at 44.

I think he is just too old to change.

Don't move near them.
Move to where you will have people supporting you.

They will likely gang up on you and you WILL be outnumbered.

Also, should you try to move away from where his family are he could then use the courts to keep you in that area until your child was 18.

Be very wary of such people.
He clearly hasn't a mind of his own.

Imagine if they encouraged him to go for 50/50 custody and his sister said she would help him with childcare?
These things happen and you would be so stuck.

Educate yourself before you do anything.
The courts are very supportive of the most awful of men having access.

Swipe left for the next trending thread