Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries with MIL and SIL

170 replies

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 22:06

I’ve had a baby for first time last year and previously had no issues with my in laws but relationship has changed since becoming a mother as my boundaries are repeatedly disrespected.

The first sign was that they visited my place for the first time a week before I was due to give birth (my partner had moved in a month before) - I didn’t want any visitors at the point and it was almost as though they wanted to try and accidentally on purpose be at the birth.
I had a traumatic birth and emergency c-section and really didn’t want one. I didn’t want any visitors until I was ready but they kept pushing to come after a few days even though my baby was in hospital with jaundice after a few days. They wouldn’t take no for an answer and thought their needs trumped mine (texting ‘I am his grandmother I have a right to see him’ to partner), which left a bitter taste in my mouth and suggested they didn’t have mine or my baby’s best interests at heart if can’t respect my boundaries at most vulnerable time of our lives.
Since then several other things have happened including:

  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;
  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),
  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;
  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),
  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,
  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),
  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),
  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)
  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,
  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

They also expect us to drive up at least once a month, to the other side of the country despite having a baby and very busy with work and childcare and no money. They don’t visit here, and expect us to pay for petrol and also want us to stay there despite having a three bed home with FIL, MIL and SIL in one house and only a spare box rom where we won’t fit. They offer SIL’s bigger room where we have stayed before when baby was very small, but we can’t now he’s bigger (and don’t really want to anywhere as we were made to get a hotel before I had my son due to space, so don’t feel welcome now).
Think I would like them more if boundaries were communicated more firmly and quickly by partner but I’ve had to do most of it as he’s not been able to. That creates some friction between me and them, but I think the reason he can’t is because of them being enmeshed and a generally unhealthy dynamic (where the only job he ever has was at his Dad’s company, his best friend is cousin and lived at home until 44 years old with SIL and MIL and FIL). I know MIL cried when he previously moved out at 30 and suggests to me she is manipulative and doesn’t want him living his own life. It seems like helicopter parenting where they won’t let their children do anything for themselves - and I don’t want that for my son, or my partner.

I’m very independent and moved out at 18, lived in 3 continents and not willing to have my life dictated by people who clearly have no regard for me.
At the same time, they mean well (I think) and I’m hyper independent and like the idea of having a close knit family - I just am too aware of toxic patterns due to my own childhood to overlook them when I see them, and will protect my son from anything I see as being harmful in any way. AIBU?

The reason I ask is because we were originally meant to move closer to them last year so they could help with childcare, but don’t want to now due to consistent boundaries overstepped regarding my son. I would be isolated there and risk their big family basically take over all decisions in our lives.
I hope to get past this and move there eventually but need some advice on how to, as not sure they are open to discussing these issues and partner is defensive when bring up the topic and accusing me of not liking his family. The truth is, I like them but also want them to respect my boundaries - sadly the longer they don’t, the more likely I will start to dislike them - so I want to nip this in the bud.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:57

sittingonabeach · Today 07:54

I wouldn’t want anyone co-sleeping with a young baby. Do they know the guidance?

How come your partner didn’t live with you before you got pregnant?

His work was on the other side of the country where his parents are

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:58

Pobblewob · Today 07:57

The stuff about the toys makes me think you have some part to play in having ridiculous expectations though.

How often do you see them and how far away is it?

About once a month. About 2 hour drive each way.

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · Today 07:59

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:57

His work was on the other side of the country where his parents are

So was the plan for him to go back to that work?

sittingonabeach · Today 08:01

When you say the other side of the country it sounds like miles away but 2 hours isn’t that far.

Letsbe · Today 08:01

It must be very hard. It is nice your baby has so many people to love and care for them. I guess your sister and law may never have a child to love so maybr thats why she is very pushy.

I think a reset is in order where you try and decide what you are comfortable with. Definitely pause the move reduce the visits but when you do try and see it as love not deliberately difficult behaviour.

GreenFrameDot · Today 08:10

You have a DP problem- your MIL/SIL have consistently overstepped since before birth and he should be the brick wall between you and them, protecting your family unit.

If you’ve clearly set out the boundaries around your DC he should be backing you up.

Your MIL and SIL sound deranged, but I’ve never understood why some people can’t respect other’s choices (even if they personally disagree with the boundaries, they should follow them in hopes of having a good relationship in the future).

Don’t move closer, change your childcare plans to something you are comfortable with, this will only get worse if you let it continue to happen. Quite honestly, with a start like this, I would say you’re better off as a single parent away from their unhealthy dynamic.

howshouldibehave · Today 08:13

For someone so independent, why did you choose someone who was so enmeshed with their mum, to have children with!?

I think you and they are two very different types of people, so they probably think you are OTT, as you do about them, but you have chosen this man so presume you want it to work. I don’t get why you’d let your baby stay overnight with them at 4 months (I’m very laid back and mine didn’t stay without me for ages!) with people there were issues with (your post mentions them overstepping boundaries before the baby was born). You’re fine with that, but then complain that SIL-who lives there-was involved!?

I think you moving closer for childcare is a bad idea.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:20

Itsnottheendoftheworldthough · Today 06:50

It’s nice you have a village. One that cares about your child and wants to see them. Let me tell you from the opposite side of that… no one is coming. No one cares. No one offers any help or support. No one wants to hold your child or kiss them. You don’t need boundaries because there isn’t anyone to cross them.

I appreciate this. I really wanted that the be the case and had planned to uproot my whole life for it to be possible. Unfortunately it’s just causing more stress and problems than support and not something I need post partum.
Its also been a tough year due to bereavement for me, so anything that doesn’t help my son or I - and causes more problems, I’ve got very little patience for.

OP posts:
Pobblewob · Today 08:20

CycleBreaker68 · Today 07:58

About once a month. About 2 hour drive each way.

That's not unreasonable of them either.

You're clearly very different people.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:22

sittingonabeach · Today 07:59

So was the plan for him to go back to that work?

Yep - one of the main reasons I offered to move. Now he’s looking for work where we live

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:26

Letsbe · Today 08:01

It must be very hard. It is nice your baby has so many people to love and care for them. I guess your sister and law may never have a child to love so maybr thats why she is very pushy.

I think a reset is in order where you try and decide what you are comfortable with. Definitely pause the move reduce the visits but when you do try and see it as love not deliberately difficult behaviour.

Thank you, will do.
Yes I don’t think SIL will have baby, so that’s part of reason she puts so much emphasis on my son - makes me feel uneasy the way she almost thinks of him and wants to treat him as her son. She has my son as her phone wallpaper and wrote such emotive posts online about him, and in his birthday card (which he can’t read) that MIL cried. It just feels all too much and unhealthy to try and use my son as a substitute as she doesn’t have a family. I’m sure if she had a child things wouldn’t be this way.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:29

howshouldibehave · Today 08:13

For someone so independent, why did you choose someone who was so enmeshed with their mum, to have children with!?

I think you and they are two very different types of people, so they probably think you are OTT, as you do about them, but you have chosen this man so presume you want it to work. I don’t get why you’d let your baby stay overnight with them at 4 months (I’m very laid back and mine didn’t stay without me for ages!) with people there were issues with (your post mentions them overstepping boundaries before the baby was born). You’re fine with that, but then complain that SIL-who lives there-was involved!?

I think you moving closer for childcare is a bad idea.

I liked the idea of having a close knit family as mine was different. It was idealistic and now I see the reality, I don’t like it. We both have work to do on ourselves and hopefully this will make us grow, or we will have to separate.

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · Today 08:29

I don't know really - they sound challenging, and some of the things they've done have 100% crossed a line and I wouldn't put up with. But also you sound very rigid yourself, and some of your "rules"/ gripes strike me as quite silly. I mean of course, if your baby is at your MIL's house where your SIL lives your SIL will spend time with the baby. It's a ridiculous notion that someone living in the same house has to be directly "authorised" by you to spend time with the baby while he's there. Same with the whole "she has bought things that are NOT on the registry" - people gift because it's nice to gift. Gifting isn't you placing orders with them.

If you want them to be involved - which is soudns like your DH does - you need to focus on reasonable boundaries. Hold those (and let your DH manage them, they are his family), and in return don't sweat the small stuff, If you can have a good relationship with your ILs, which keeps your baby safe and happy, this will only benefit your child.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:31

Pobblewob · Today 08:20

That's not unreasonable of them either.

You're clearly very different people.

Yes, I think I respect the different but not sure they do. They’d prefer my partner to marry a local girl and not someone independent like me.

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · Today 08:32

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:26

Thank you, will do.
Yes I don’t think SIL will have baby, so that’s part of reason she puts so much emphasis on my son - makes me feel uneasy the way she almost thinks of him and wants to treat him as her son. She has my son as her phone wallpaper and wrote such emotive posts online about him, and in his birthday card (which he can’t read) that MIL cried. It just feels all too much and unhealthy to try and use my son as a substitute as she doesn’t have a family. I’m sure if she had a child things wouldn’t be this way.

this is quite mean. Unless your SIL has form/ mental illness chances are she's just super excited to be an aunt and isn't trying to steal your son. I find it so sad when people accuse other of loving their relatives too much - your son will only benefit from being loved by lots of adults, and your SIL won't actually steal your son.

Honestly the more I read your posts, it seems like you really look down on them and their way of being.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:34

BusyGreySnail · Today 08:29

I don't know really - they sound challenging, and some of the things they've done have 100% crossed a line and I wouldn't put up with. But also you sound very rigid yourself, and some of your "rules"/ gripes strike me as quite silly. I mean of course, if your baby is at your MIL's house where your SIL lives your SIL will spend time with the baby. It's a ridiculous notion that someone living in the same house has to be directly "authorised" by you to spend time with the baby while he's there. Same with the whole "she has bought things that are NOT on the registry" - people gift because it's nice to gift. Gifting isn't you placing orders with them.

If you want them to be involved - which is soudns like your DH does - you need to focus on reasonable boundaries. Hold those (and let your DH manage them, they are his family), and in return don't sweat the small stuff, If you can have a good relationship with your ILs, which keeps your baby safe and happy, this will only benefit your child.

It was more sleeping in her bed, seemingly overnight, on first trip away at 4 months…but also coupled with all the other stuff it adds up and pings a picture of lack of respect for boundaries.
The toy stuff is more recent and me worrying about Christmas - so I’ve communicated it. It’s just a symptom of all this and shows I’m more likely to get annoyed by small things until this is resolved and respect and trust is rebuilt

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · Today 08:37

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:34

It was more sleeping in her bed, seemingly overnight, on first trip away at 4 months…but also coupled with all the other stuff it adds up and pings a picture of lack of respect for boundaries.
The toy stuff is more recent and me worrying about Christmas - so I’ve communicated it. It’s just a symptom of all this and shows I’m more likely to get annoyed by small things until this is resolved and respect and trust is rebuilt

That's a bit different, I'd be very cross if someone coslept with my baby - but also it's exactly what I mean. You are annoyed with them so getting cross about everything they do. That makes you sound difficult and mean. Rather, focus on the things that are actually an issue and let the more minor stuff go. You are far more likely to have luck with that - with them and with your husband - than picking at every little thing they do which really doesn't matter at all (e.g. phone screen saver).

FoodoftheDog · Today 08:40

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:30

Thank you! It’s reassuring to hear it gets better. I guess the first year with the first child is bound to be the hardest as you’re post partum and still understanding each others’ boundaries (especially as my partner and I have only been together a few years so I don’t know his family that well yet).

My ILs never changed over the years, we just held them way at arms length because the boundary crossing was extreme.

People who trample boundaries rarely change in the way you suggest would need to happen. DH and I changed and our children got older which meant they had boundaries too so it got easier.

I think it is you that needs to change. Stick to your guns on the big stuff and don’t pick too many hills to battle on. We just stopped trying to fix the issue and instead stepped back as changed our expectations.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:41

BusyGreySnail · Today 08:32

this is quite mean. Unless your SIL has form/ mental illness chances are she's just super excited to be an aunt and isn't trying to steal your son. I find it so sad when people accuse other of loving their relatives too much - your son will only benefit from being loved by lots of adults, and your SIL won't actually steal your son.

Honestly the more I read your posts, it seems like you really look down on them and their way of being.

I admit that all this may have left a sour taste in my mouth and that’s why I want to resolve this and nip it in the bud as don’t want it to ruin our relationship and cause animosity.
Maybe that comment is unfair, I just wonder if it’s genuine love if wouldn’t be like this if she had a child (& don’t want my son used as some sort of substitute / be exposed to anything that may harm him as a result like the enmeshment or helicopter parenting)

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:43

BusyGreySnail · Today 08:37

That's a bit different, I'd be very cross if someone coslept with my baby - but also it's exactly what I mean. You are annoyed with them so getting cross about everything they do. That makes you sound difficult and mean. Rather, focus on the things that are actually an issue and let the more minor stuff go. You are far more likely to have luck with that - with them and with your husband - than picking at every little thing they do which really doesn't matter at all (e.g. phone screen saver).

Yes that’s why I want to find a way forward now -as I know the longer it goes on, the worse it will get. I don’t want that atmosphere around my son.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · Today 08:46

Honestly OP I’m saying this kindly - get a grip!

Acertwirl · Today 08:47

I think you have confirmation bias. You have already decided that they are wronguns and now subconsciously look for things that they are doing to constantly confirm it. You’ve become hyper sensitive to it.

Btw, this isn’t particularly unusual after having your first baby. You are establishing yourself as a new family and that can change dynamics in relationships with the extended family. Sometimes people respond poorly to this and seek to try and re establish the previous status quo.

Obviously, don’t move closer and stop visiting so often. They’ll have to make the journey to you sometimes or use face time.

My DH is also somewhat enmeshed with his family and my advice is to be gentle but firm when discussing it with him. He has probably spent his whole life accommodating his parents needs and feeling responsible for their reaction to things. He needs to become more comfortable disappointing them when the things they want don’t work for him. Does he recognise that there are some unhealthy relationships dynamics at play?

My MIL will deploy manipulative guilt tactics from time to time when we don’t do something she wants from us. I keep it short but sweet, something like “I appreciate it isn’t what you want, but that’s what we’ve decided and there’s no debate”.

Good luck!

Soontobe60 · Today 08:48

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:42

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. It was specifically finding out my 4 month old son had stayed in her bed overnight without our consent. It was first night away from us, first baby and prefer to be asked if the person who is meant to be caring for my child is delegating to someone else. It matters to me as I wouldn’t have given my SIL permission to look after my baby as she doesn’t have children and doesn’t have experience looking after a baby. It’s also about respect and earning trust to me, but I acknowledge I can be uptight and very protective of my baby.

Edited

You do realise that when you brought your baby home from hospital, you’d never had a child and been responsible for looking after one?

BigBadPotato · Today 08:52

Some of these points in isolation sound OTT on your part but as a whole, fucking yikes. MIL and SIL sound awful, overbearing and completely dismissive of you as a parent. The other obvious issue though is your partner, he isn’t on your side and doesn’t seem to see any issue with his family’s behaviour. To trot out a tired but often true mumsnet classic, you’ve a partner problem!
Obviously moving closer is a terrible idea as is having them do any kind of childcare. The fact you were, or are?, considering this at all, combined with the fact you let them take baby not just once but multiple times for sleepovers at just 4 months old (seriously?!) when you’ve got such misgivings, makes me think you need to worry a bit less about boundaries re tickling a small child and a bit more about your own boundaries as a parent. Stand up for yourself and don’t allow things to just happen around you and your child if you’re uncomfortable. Now’s the time to step up a bit.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:54

Soontobe60 · Today 08:48

You do realise that when you brought your baby home from hospital, you’d never had a child and been responsible for looking after one?

Yes, but he’s my baby and am carried him for 9 months and responsible for him and breastfeed him/has help from midwives. I wouldn’t have felt comfortable looking after someone else’s baby before I became a mum, and haven’t looked after my own nephew on my own (and definitely wouldn’t without express consent). Perhaps it’s a generational thing or different expectations.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread