Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries with MIL and SIL

170 replies

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 22:06

I’ve had a baby for first time last year and previously had no issues with my in laws but relationship has changed since becoming a mother as my boundaries are repeatedly disrespected.

The first sign was that they visited my place for the first time a week before I was due to give birth (my partner had moved in a month before) - I didn’t want any visitors at the point and it was almost as though they wanted to try and accidentally on purpose be at the birth.
I had a traumatic birth and emergency c-section and really didn’t want one. I didn’t want any visitors until I was ready but they kept pushing to come after a few days even though my baby was in hospital with jaundice after a few days. They wouldn’t take no for an answer and thought their needs trumped mine (texting ‘I am his grandmother I have a right to see him’ to partner), which left a bitter taste in my mouth and suggested they didn’t have mine or my baby’s best interests at heart if can’t respect my boundaries at most vulnerable time of our lives.
Since then several other things have happened including:

  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;
  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),
  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;
  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),
  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,
  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),
  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),
  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)
  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,
  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

They also expect us to drive up at least once a month, to the other side of the country despite having a baby and very busy with work and childcare and no money. They don’t visit here, and expect us to pay for petrol and also want us to stay there despite having a three bed home with FIL, MIL and SIL in one house and only a spare box rom where we won’t fit. They offer SIL’s bigger room where we have stayed before when baby was very small, but we can’t now he’s bigger (and don’t really want to anywhere as we were made to get a hotel before I had my son due to space, so don’t feel welcome now).
Think I would like them more if boundaries were communicated more firmly and quickly by partner but I’ve had to do most of it as he’s not been able to. That creates some friction between me and them, but I think the reason he can’t is because of them being enmeshed and a generally unhealthy dynamic (where the only job he ever has was at his Dad’s company, his best friend is cousin and lived at home until 44 years old with SIL and MIL and FIL). I know MIL cried when he previously moved out at 30 and suggests to me she is manipulative and doesn’t want him living his own life. It seems like helicopter parenting where they won’t let their children do anything for themselves - and I don’t want that for my son, or my partner.

I’m very independent and moved out at 18, lived in 3 continents and not willing to have my life dictated by people who clearly have no regard for me.
At the same time, they mean well (I think) and I’m hyper independent and like the idea of having a close knit family - I just am too aware of toxic patterns due to my own childhood to overlook them when I see them, and will protect my son from anything I see as being harmful in any way. AIBU?

The reason I ask is because we were originally meant to move closer to them last year so they could help with childcare, but don’t want to now due to consistent boundaries overstepped regarding my son. I would be isolated there and risk their big family basically take over all decisions in our lives.
I hope to get past this and move there eventually but need some advice on how to, as not sure they are open to discussing these issues and partner is defensive when bring up the topic and accusing me of not liking his family. The truth is, I like them but also want them to respect my boundaries - sadly the longer they don’t, the more likely I will start to dislike them - so I want to nip this in the bud.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:29

MyLittleNest · Today 15:02

I saw this as someone who has been in your position: the situation will only continue and get worse if you do not make changes. It is one thing to be an excited grandparent, but that is not what is happening here.

You probably cannot change MIL or SIL or make them respect boundaries or your parenting decisions. They have already demonstrated that repeatedly.

Instead, I would focus on what you can do, primarily. Do not move closer. If anything, distance is best. Stop the drives once a month. A hard talk with your DH is needed. If he is unwilling to say no to mommy and daddy, then he can go alone and you can go as a family less often. I would not let him just take the baby given the situation you are describing.

Your DH needs to remember that he has his own family now. It doesn't mean cutting off his parents, but it does mean compromise, and they are asking for too much given the circumstances. You are an adult and so is your DH. You have your own family unit. They can't "tell" you what to do or "make" you do anything. The guilt tripping just underscores how incredibly selfish they are.

You are a mother now. You have to be more assertive. You will visit when it fits your schedule. You will not be allowing anymore overnight babysitting given that they broke your trust.

I would absolutely continue to tell SIL to stop posting public photos of your child on social media. If she can't respect that, then I would not share any more photos with her or allow her to take your child's photo or be alone with him without you present. (Not sure you can trust DH to stand up for his child or you to his sister?)

In general, they all seem to think this is some doll that can be shown off or passed around.

But it's your child. You are the adult in your child's life. His advocate. Time to start setting firm boundaries and (this part is on you) stick to them despite their reactions. So they might get upset! They haven't cared if they upset you...

Thank you - this is good advice and I realise I have to do this and stop trying to please everyone. I think I’ve been made to feel guilty by my in laws and partner and that’s another reason why I’m frustrated, as that is manipulative to me. I’m constantly drained by having to assert my boundaries and have them pushed back on all the time and have them talk behind my back or have my partner lash out at me for having parenting choices which in laws don’t agree with. But is my own fault for allowing it and will be firmer now as it is kinder to everyone when expectations are set. I just wanted to try and salvage some of the nice relationship we used to have, but it isn’t worth it if it was never actually genuine.

OP posts:
Coconutcreamz · Today 15:31

So he is refusing work and wants to be childcare?
That is extremely controlling and would make me think you have been played.
Stop paying for petrol.
You need to talk to Women's aid for advice.

He wouldn't be the first man to use childcare to control a woman and keep her stuck!

Stop trying to salvage a relationship that is abusing you.

He is lashing out when he doesn't get his way.

I think you need the support of domestic abuse charities local to you.

He can visit his family by himself.
No taking the baby.
You will not be driving or paying for petrol.
Get that baby into childcare.
Stop paying anything for him.
You have gotten yourself a complete cocklodger if he isn't paying his way.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:35

Coconutcreamz · Today 15:28

Honestly OP, what was his appeal?

He's a complete Mummys boy, at 44.

I think he is just too old to change.

Don't move near them.
Move to where you will have people supporting you.

They will likely gang up on you and you WILL be outnumbered.

Also, should you try to move away from where his family are he could then use the courts to keep you in that area until your child was 18.

Be very wary of such people.
He clearly hasn't a mind of his own.

Imagine if they encouraged him to go for 50/50 custody and his sister said she would help him with childcare?
These things happen and you would be so stuck.

Educate yourself before you do anything.
The courts are very supportive of the most awful of men having access.

Thank you - yes this is what I worry about. They would easily want to take full custody if we split with in-laws and partner all living in same house raising my son. And it’s that mentality and the fact that they would be more than happy with that which makes me realise they are not good people, and don’t have my son or my best interests at heart (hell, they don’t even have my partners best interests at heart).
I chose him as I thought he could grow and liked the fact he was close with his family. I was naive to the darker side of it. I also knew he’d be a great Dad, which he largely is - and he’s willing to sacrifice his career so I can focus on mine. We just need to get him into work here and baby into nursery and both grow and establish our little family with firmer boundaries and less interference. I hope that can happen, otherwise I may have to reconsider the whole situation.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:37

Coconutcreamz · Today 15:31

So he is refusing work and wants to be childcare?
That is extremely controlling and would make me think you have been played.
Stop paying for petrol.
You need to talk to Women's aid for advice.

He wouldn't be the first man to use childcare to control a woman and keep her stuck!

Stop trying to salvage a relationship that is abusing you.

He is lashing out when he doesn't get his way.

I think you need the support of domestic abuse charities local to you.

He can visit his family by himself.
No taking the baby.
You will not be driving or paying for petrol.
Get that baby into childcare.
Stop paying anything for him.
You have gotten yourself a complete cocklodger if he isn't paying his way.

Edited

He says he is looking for work but very slowly and son is 16months now. He prefers to stay at home with son (I would have too but couldn’t afford mortgage if I did!).
So I’m not eligible for free childcare as long as he doesn’t work. Yes, good idea - I think I need some advice on this. Thank you

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Today 15:38

Oh dear. This sounds like a typical family dynamic to me. OP has married into a close knit family and is trying to assert herself in a difficult situation. Apart from the Co sleeping and unauthorised photos on facebook, which should not have happened, everyone is on a steep learning curve! The problem for grandparents (yes I am one) is when a new baby comes along you are so excited and anxious to help. You do feel that you are experienced in childcare having successfully raised your own. Unfortunately what you don’t appreciate is that years have passed and times have changed! It’s hard to step back and let the new mother make her own rules about what she considers best for her child. It’s much easier when it’s your daughter’s child as conversations are usually more frank and there’s less chance of offense being taken on either side. DIL’s sometimes don’t speak up for fear of offending and then bottle it up and, like OP ask AIBU. Much better to politely chat about things with MIL and calmly explain, try to laugh about changing times and attitudes in an open and friendly manner. Get to know and understand each other. It doesn’t have to be a battle with a bit of tolerance and acceptance from both.
Hope this helps.

TheignT · Today 15:38

Coconutcreamz · Today 15:31

So he is refusing work and wants to be childcare?
That is extremely controlling and would make me think you have been played.
Stop paying for petrol.
You need to talk to Women's aid for advice.

He wouldn't be the first man to use childcare to control a woman and keep her stuck!

Stop trying to salvage a relationship that is abusing you.

He is lashing out when he doesn't get his way.

I think you need the support of domestic abuse charities local to you.

He can visit his family by himself.
No taking the baby.
You will not be driving or paying for petrol.
Get that baby into childcare.
Stop paying anything for him.
You have gotten yourself a complete cocklodger if he isn't paying his way.

Edited

If he's the main carer he's likely to still get that if they break up isn't he, at least 50%. I think OP needs to be careful as he'll be able to take baby to visit his parents whenever he likes.

TheignT · Today 15:42

CycleBreaker68 · Today 08:34

It was more sleeping in her bed, seemingly overnight, on first trip away at 4 months…but also coupled with all the other stuff it adds up and pings a picture of lack of respect for boundaries.
The toy stuff is more recent and me worrying about Christmas - so I’ve communicated it. It’s just a symptom of all this and shows I’m more likely to get annoyed by small things until this is resolved and respect and trust is rebuilt

I'm not sure hat seemingly overnight mean. Did she cosleep all night?

CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:42

Barney16 · Today 14:03

I think in some matters you are reasonable, in others unreasonable. Probably your in-laws are ecstatic there's a baby in their family. They haven't had any practice at being GP so they are going to make mistakes. I get the co sleeping but other things on your list are silly. They sound hard work, but so do you. The visiting every month is obviously a real trial. Let your husband go with baby every other month. Or meet half way for a day out?

They can’t really leave the house much as FIL is very elderly with health issues. I’d prefer not to leave son unsupervised tbh

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 15:47

TheignT · Today 15:42

I'm not sure hat seemingly overnight mean. Did she cosleep all night?

i saw photos of him in her bed in the morning so not 100% sure - I asked my other half to speak to them about it and has hasn’t.
the cot was set up in her room so he could have slept in cot for some of the night - but either way, I wanted MIL to look after my son and didn’t agree to SIL looking after him overnight.
I also didn’t agree to the various guests coming around when we weren’t there and being told I have to pass my 4 month old baby around during flu season.

OP posts:
LynneEast · Today 15:48

There's a lot of you "authorising" and giving and denying "consent" and "permission".

Is this the first time in your life that you feel people will have to take note of you, the first time that you have been able to authorise anything other than a sandwich filling?

I think it probably is and and it's all going to your head a little bit.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:00

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Today 14:30

For the gifts, can you ask for money into a ISA or premium bonds in your child's name instead of a gift? Saving for the future/uni/car/house deposit type thing.

My Dad set up premium bonds for both my DC when they were born and every Christmas or birthday or Easter he would put money there instead of buying stuff for the sake of it. As they got older they loved winning and reinvesting, even now (dad has passed) they still win and thank grandad for setting it up.

Good idea - for Christmas I’ve requested this as an option and will set up an account for my son. Thank you

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:01

PartingGift · Today 14:11

Honestly? You sound a little bit ungrateful for the free childcare. Baffled at leaving your baby overnight when he was so little.

You don’t get to dictate what people choose to buy your child.

Don’t leave your child alone with family members you don’t trust and you won’t have these issues.

I won’t be leaving my son with them again. But I’d like to be able to and for them to regain my trust after breaking it.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:03

LynneEast · Today 15:48

There's a lot of you "authorising" and giving and denying "consent" and "permission".

Is this the first time in your life that you feel people will have to take note of you, the first time that you have been able to authorise anything other than a sandwich filling?

I think it probably is and and it's all going to your head a little bit.

Ha, no - I authorise quite a lot at work. The issue is the opposite, I’m used to people respecting me and listening to what I say, and don’t expect this type of behaviour from family.

OP posts:
Coconutcreamz · Today 16:07

He's refusing to get work.

You had to return to work as he wouldn't?

That is 100% abusive.

For crying out loud NEVER MARRY this loser.

He will then be entitled to half your house.
I am so sorry OP but I really do think you have been played.

What career has he?

You definitely need Women's aid and legal advice so that you protect yourself from him.

Any aggression from him, call the police and have him removed from your home.

I think you should be telling your family what is going on.

Has he a car, or is it yours?
If so get him off your insurance and stop going to visit his family.

He can visit them himself.

But get advice from your local Domestic abuse charity.

We are here for you.

Ponoka7 · Today 16:12

I'm amazed that no-one has picked up on you expecting a woman her 70s to look after a four month old, on top of caring for FIL. Of course SIL was going to step in. My eldest has chosen to not have children, but has minded my GC from a similar age. Not having children doesn't mean that you aren't capable. They've been pushy, you are controlling and want your child's father to fall in line. You can work this out. I get not wanting stuff, especially at this age, but later on, plastic can be scrubbed clean. If he's doing childcare, he gets a big say. He needs to also work, though.

LynneEast · Today 16:17

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:03

Ha, no - I authorise quite a lot at work. The issue is the opposite, I’m used to people respecting me and listening to what I say, and don’t expect this type of behaviour from family.

Ok but it is unusual. It tends to be people who have been taken very little notice of that behave in the way you are doing. Tone it down a bit.

You aren't the only woman to have had a baby and , as you are new, you have bugger all experience. You might be making a balls of everything. You will certainly be making a balls of some things, as we all did!

I wouldn't be lifting a bunion to help you if you came over to me with your authorising and permission. Every new mum likes things done their way but most don't use these words like a cut price Joe Stalin.

Be careful, your partner doesn't sound as if he likes these diktats being issued to his mum- who reared him-and his sister and you might wake up one day to be looking at his heels!

EDITED to say it certainly sounds as if you made a balls of choosing to have a baby with this man, so maybe you don't know it all by a country mile.

Soontobe60 · Today 16:20

CycleBreaker68 · Today 13:08

No major issue - it’s just the common theme of not thinking about what we need or want and overstepping. They buy so many toys and clothes and even bath stuff that I can hardly use any of my own as partner is offended if I don’t use them. none of them are environmentally friendly and have microplastics and toxins. I spend a lot of time researching this stuff and have preferences and fustrating for these to be overridden. It’s overwhelming and too much - they also have as much stuff at their own house including a cot, changing station, pram, high chair, loads of toys, etc.
It’s mostly that we have a small place and don’t want lots of cheap things gifted which we then have to be grateful for as they can be a tool to buy affection. Especially as it costs more to have to drive there than the gifts do themselves.
my preference is for Montessori wooden toys but have some plastic ones, just want to know where they are from and that BPA free etc. none of us have much spare money so prefer to spend money where we need it as don’t like waste.

Jeeze, are you using AI to come up with these responses????

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:24

Ponoka7 · Today 16:12

I'm amazed that no-one has picked up on you expecting a woman her 70s to look after a four month old, on top of caring for FIL. Of course SIL was going to step in. My eldest has chosen to not have children, but has minded my GC from a similar age. Not having children doesn't mean that you aren't capable. They've been pushy, you are controlling and want your child's father to fall in line. You can work this out. I get not wanting stuff, especially at this age, but later on, plastic can be scrubbed clean. If he's doing childcare, he gets a big say. He needs to also work, though.

Point is it should have been communicated - as the answer would have been no in that case.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:25

Soontobe60 · Today 16:20

Jeeze, are you using AI to come up with these responses????

No, I’m just busy as have a full on job as well as a small toddler…

OP posts:
MaryBeardsShoes · Today 16:26

You sound more and more like a total pain. You understand it’s his child too? You sound very controlling.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:33

LynneEast · Today 16:17

Ok but it is unusual. It tends to be people who have been taken very little notice of that behave in the way you are doing. Tone it down a bit.

You aren't the only woman to have had a baby and , as you are new, you have bugger all experience. You might be making a balls of everything. You will certainly be making a balls of some things, as we all did!

I wouldn't be lifting a bunion to help you if you came over to me with your authorising and permission. Every new mum likes things done their way but most don't use these words like a cut price Joe Stalin.

Be careful, your partner doesn't sound as if he likes these diktats being issued to his mum- who reared him-and his sister and you might wake up one day to be looking at his heels!

EDITED to say it certainly sounds as if you made a balls of choosing to have a baby with this man, so maybe you don't know it all by a country mile.

Edited

I think it’s you who should perhaps tone it down a bit…
it’s not unusual to set boundaries for your family and want to keep your baby safe.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:39

MaryBeardsShoes · Today 16:26

You sound more and more like a total pain. You understand it’s his child too? You sound very controlling.

The issue is that I don’t want extended family making decisions for, or controlling, our family. They have told me where to live, what job my partner should have and when, and even dictate what clothes my son wears, toys he plays with and detergent we use. It’s interesting that you think it’s okay, and that it’s controlling for me to want to make decisions for myself and my son.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:43

Coconutcreamz · Today 16:07

He's refusing to get work.

You had to return to work as he wouldn't?

That is 100% abusive.

For crying out loud NEVER MARRY this loser.

He will then be entitled to half your house.
I am so sorry OP but I really do think you have been played.

What career has he?

You definitely need Women's aid and legal advice so that you protect yourself from him.

Any aggression from him, call the police and have him removed from your home.

I think you should be telling your family what is going on.

Has he a car, or is it yours?
If so get him off your insurance and stop going to visit his family.

He can visit them himself.

But get advice from your local Domestic abuse charity.

We are here for you.

Thank you - I appreciate his. I have been keeping a log of what’s happened in case it comes to it.
He earns a lot less than me so he couldn’t cover the mortgage if he works and I didn’t (why he needed to live with family before). It is his car but I pay for petrol and insurance and tax etc. I also recently found out he’s in a lot of credit card debt which he may have used to buy the car, which I will probably have to pay off (so technically I would have paid for the car then)

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:46

DaringQuoter · Today 15:38

Oh dear. This sounds like a typical family dynamic to me. OP has married into a close knit family and is trying to assert herself in a difficult situation. Apart from the Co sleeping and unauthorised photos on facebook, which should not have happened, everyone is on a steep learning curve! The problem for grandparents (yes I am one) is when a new baby comes along you are so excited and anxious to help. You do feel that you are experienced in childcare having successfully raised your own. Unfortunately what you don’t appreciate is that years have passed and times have changed! It’s hard to step back and let the new mother make her own rules about what she considers best for her child. It’s much easier when it’s your daughter’s child as conversations are usually more frank and there’s less chance of offense being taken on either side. DIL’s sometimes don’t speak up for fear of offending and then bottle it up and, like OP ask AIBU. Much better to politely chat about things with MIL and calmly explain, try to laugh about changing times and attitudes in an open and friendly manner. Get to know and understand each other. It doesn’t have to be a battle with a bit of tolerance and acceptance from both.
Hope this helps.

Thank you, this is a helpful and well considered answer. This is what I want - I’ve noticed a dynamic in the family where they don’t discuss things and see any conflict as unhealthy and sweep things under the rug, so I would have to carry to emotional load of resolving. I will when I have the capacity.

OP posts:
Acertwirl · Today 17:15

LynneEast · Today 16:17

Ok but it is unusual. It tends to be people who have been taken very little notice of that behave in the way you are doing. Tone it down a bit.

You aren't the only woman to have had a baby and , as you are new, you have bugger all experience. You might be making a balls of everything. You will certainly be making a balls of some things, as we all did!

I wouldn't be lifting a bunion to help you if you came over to me with your authorising and permission. Every new mum likes things done their way but most don't use these words like a cut price Joe Stalin.

Be careful, your partner doesn't sound as if he likes these diktats being issued to his mum- who reared him-and his sister and you might wake up one day to be looking at his heels!

EDITED to say it certainly sounds as if you made a balls of choosing to have a baby with this man, so maybe you don't know it all by a country mile.

Edited

You remind me of my friend’s FIL. She asked everyone not to kiss the baby, he couldn’t abide being “told what to do”. Shortly after, on returning to a room, he proudly told her how he’d been kissing the baby. She thanked him for being so forthcoming about the fact that she couldn’t leave him unsupervised with the baby.

Then commenced months of him whinging about how he wasn’t being allowed to bond with the baby, she was a dictator blah blah blah. Lift your bunions or not, it’s up to you, but you get what you give so don’t go crying about it when your relationship to your grandchild is impacted by your stubborn attitude.

Swipe left for the next trending thread