Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries with MIL and SIL

170 replies

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 22:06

I’ve had a baby for first time last year and previously had no issues with my in laws but relationship has changed since becoming a mother as my boundaries are repeatedly disrespected.

The first sign was that they visited my place for the first time a week before I was due to give birth (my partner had moved in a month before) - I didn’t want any visitors at the point and it was almost as though they wanted to try and accidentally on purpose be at the birth.
I had a traumatic birth and emergency c-section and really didn’t want one. I didn’t want any visitors until I was ready but they kept pushing to come after a few days even though my baby was in hospital with jaundice after a few days. They wouldn’t take no for an answer and thought their needs trumped mine (texting ‘I am his grandmother I have a right to see him’ to partner), which left a bitter taste in my mouth and suggested they didn’t have mine or my baby’s best interests at heart if can’t respect my boundaries at most vulnerable time of our lives.
Since then several other things have happened including:

  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;
  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),
  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;
  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),
  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,
  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),
  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),
  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)
  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,
  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

They also expect us to drive up at least once a month, to the other side of the country despite having a baby and very busy with work and childcare and no money. They don’t visit here, and expect us to pay for petrol and also want us to stay there despite having a three bed home with FIL, MIL and SIL in one house and only a spare box rom where we won’t fit. They offer SIL’s bigger room where we have stayed before when baby was very small, but we can’t now he’s bigger (and don’t really want to anywhere as we were made to get a hotel before I had my son due to space, so don’t feel welcome now).
Think I would like them more if boundaries were communicated more firmly and quickly by partner but I’ve had to do most of it as he’s not been able to. That creates some friction between me and them, but I think the reason he can’t is because of them being enmeshed and a generally unhealthy dynamic (where the only job he ever has was at his Dad’s company, his best friend is cousin and lived at home until 44 years old with SIL and MIL and FIL). I know MIL cried when he previously moved out at 30 and suggests to me she is manipulative and doesn’t want him living his own life. It seems like helicopter parenting where they won’t let their children do anything for themselves - and I don’t want that for my son, or my partner.

I’m very independent and moved out at 18, lived in 3 continents and not willing to have my life dictated by people who clearly have no regard for me.
At the same time, they mean well (I think) and I’m hyper independent and like the idea of having a close knit family - I just am too aware of toxic patterns due to my own childhood to overlook them when I see them, and will protect my son from anything I see as being harmful in any way. AIBU?

The reason I ask is because we were originally meant to move closer to them last year so they could help with childcare, but don’t want to now due to consistent boundaries overstepped regarding my son. I would be isolated there and risk their big family basically take over all decisions in our lives.
I hope to get past this and move there eventually but need some advice on how to, as not sure they are open to discussing these issues and partner is defensive when bring up the topic and accusing me of not liking his family. The truth is, I like them but also want them to respect my boundaries - sadly the longer they don’t, the more likely I will start to dislike them - so I want to nip this in the bud.

OP posts:
DaringQuoter · Today 17:15

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:46

Thank you, this is a helpful and well considered answer. This is what I want - I’ve noticed a dynamic in the family where they don’t discuss things and see any conflict as unhealthy and sweep things under the rug, so I would have to carry to emotional load of resolving. I will when I have the capacity.

I do understand. Unfortunately in your case it’s going to be an uphill struggle because both your PIL’s offspring stayed at home for far longer than is customary. If you like - they never grew up but would be still be under parental influence. Mum and Dad would still ‘rule the roost’ and, I expect, never have their judgement questioned. I wonder if either DH or SIL went to university? I doubt it somehow as usually this is when people learn to think for themselves and question everything.
Mind you, my kids constantly challenged me and I became accustomed to understanding that I didn’t know everything 😂😂.
I would advise you to try and take things slowly and gently with DH. He’s got a lot of unlearning to do. Once he starts thinking for himself you can let him deal with his parents. They will require a lot of patience and tolerance from you though, if you want to make it work. Good Luck 🥰

CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:23

Ponoka7 · Today 16:12

I'm amazed that no-one has picked up on you expecting a woman her 70s to look after a four month old, on top of caring for FIL. Of course SIL was going to step in. My eldest has chosen to not have children, but has minded my GC from a similar age. Not having children doesn't mean that you aren't capable. They've been pushy, you are controlling and want your child's father to fall in line. You can work this out. I get not wanting stuff, especially at this age, but later on, plastic can be scrubbed clean. If he's doing childcare, he gets a big say. He needs to also work, though.

it doesnt mean they’re not capable but SIL has repeatedly shown me that she doesn’t respect parenting decisions and makes different ones that I don’t think are safe (such as public photos, FaceTiming colleagues with son, giving my new born screen time on her phone, having my 4 month old in her bed, etc. all without permission). So I wouldn’t have let MIL watch my son if I’d have known

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:33

TheignT · Today 13:57

He isn't unsupervised, he's with his father.

Yes but if he allows our parenting boundaries to be trampled all over than I need to be there too. There’s an unhealthy dynamic as he’s lived with parents for long that they are comfortable telling him what to do (which they can’t do to me)

OP posts:
IMHO2 · Today 17:35

CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:23

it doesnt mean they’re not capable but SIL has repeatedly shown me that she doesn’t respect parenting decisions and makes different ones that I don’t think are safe (such as public photos, FaceTiming colleagues with son, giving my new born screen time on her phone, having my 4 month old in her bed, etc. all without permission). So I wouldn’t have let MIL watch my son if I’d have known

Why is it not safe to FaceTime a colleague with your son?

CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:37

Differentforgirls · Today 13:38

Mummy boy?

Yep

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:44

chirrupybird · Today 14:04

If your son is the only GC he is sure to be the apple of everyone's eye. We were in the same position my DH was an only child and his mother's sister's didn't have children at all, so when we visited we had to go to all the family to show the baby and everyone cooing over her. It was a bit annoying but I understood that to all of them she was really precious. It all came from good hearts. Years later all of them have died, but they had a little joy from our bundle of joy.

Yes, he’s the apple of their eye - and has been molly coddled and not been held to account as a result. He’s also not had much responsibility / allowed to use initiative as had a lot of decisions made for him. That’s why there’s a lot of unlearning and learning to do (& why gets defensive when share feelings or boundaries). It’ll be a long road to build a foundation for our family built on emotional maturity, but I’d like to try for our son - we just need the space to do so.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:51

DaringQuoter · Today 17:15

I do understand. Unfortunately in your case it’s going to be an uphill struggle because both your PIL’s offspring stayed at home for far longer than is customary. If you like - they never grew up but would be still be under parental influence. Mum and Dad would still ‘rule the roost’ and, I expect, never have their judgement questioned. I wonder if either DH or SIL went to university? I doubt it somehow as usually this is when people learn to think for themselves and question everything.
Mind you, my kids constantly challenged me and I became accustomed to understanding that I didn’t know everything 😂😂.
I would advise you to try and take things slowly and gently with DH. He’s got a lot of unlearning to do. Once he starts thinking for himself you can let him deal with his parents. They will require a lot of patience and tolerance from you though, if you want to make it work. Good Luck 🥰

They didn’t go to university, and I’d done my masters by 22, so I know there are a lot of differences as people keep pointing out. I also know I may come across as a snob, but the truth is I grew up with far less on a council estate. So that’s not why I’m being proactive- & we do have a lot in common too. I genuinely want us all to be able to learn from each other and value difference, but agree it’ll be an uphill struggle and one that I didn’t quite understand when I got into this family. I also didn’t realise how challenging post partum is, and will be easier now I’ve recently stopped breastfeeding I hope.

Thank you so much, I really do appreciate the advice. I’ll take a deep breath and try to remember that everyone has my son’s best interests at heart and will try to model the patience and understanding that I want.

OP posts:
CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:52

IMHO2 · Today 17:35

Why is it not safe to FaceTime a colleague with your son?

It’s not unsafe just an example of not asking permission / showing good judgement

OP posts:
MissJeanBrodiesmother · Today 17:55

Your post is an odd mix of completely legitimate things like baby sleeping in sil bed which is not very safe and then unreasonable, precious demands about gifts being wooden or 100% cotton. I think you sound quite hard work. You need to pick your battles. You obviously also need to discuss wgat is important with your partner as he may not agree with you on some of this.

bellhawk · Today 17:56

I do think this might be a case of picking your battles so as to avoid cutting them off entirely. Have a hard boundary on social media photos of your child, and on co sleeping, but maybe reassess what's worth kicking up a fuss over for other things.

Definitely don't move closer to them and stick to what works best for you with visiting them - it's not unreasonable to only visit once every other month, or even less often than that. Your partner needs to focus on getting a job and clearing his debt before you make any other big lifestyle changes.

Philippa Perry has a substack blog and this topic comes up a lot - parenting / parent in law boundaries - you might find it useful to read through them.

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · Today 17:58

Rather shocked you let anyone take a 4month old overnight! Twice! Let alone a woman you didn't like or trust.

Some of your stuff is just pbf and some has merit. Maybe moan less about all the silly things and concentrate on the big issues.

IMHO2 · Today 18:03

MissJeanBrodiesmother · Today 17:55

Your post is an odd mix of completely legitimate things like baby sleeping in sil bed which is not very safe and then unreasonable, precious demands about gifts being wooden or 100% cotton. I think you sound quite hard work. You need to pick your battles. You obviously also need to discuss wgat is important with your partner as he may not agree with you on some of this.

Completely agree with this post. Also FaceTiming with colleague. That’s something I would have done not thinking I would need permission. However, co- sleeping if that happened and uploading photos to Facebook is not ok.

MissJeanBrodiesmother · Today 18:05

I think you talk about lot about you being the one to make decisions and after lengthy arguments your partner 'eventually agreeing'. It sounds a bit like you feel your views are more valid than his.

CycleBreaker68 · Today 18:07

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · Today 17:58

Rather shocked you let anyone take a 4month old overnight! Twice! Let alone a woman you didn't like or trust.

Some of your stuff is just pbf and some has merit. Maybe moan less about all the silly things and concentrate on the big issues.

As I mentioned, I was vulnerable post partum and too trusting before. The trust was lost after that and I’ve put in strict boundaries as a result.

OP posts:
Billy47 · Today 18:10
  • trusting MIL to look after 4 month old overnight twice and finding out she’s invited lots of people over without telling me;

She can have who she wants in her house. You cant dictate who visits. She doesnt have to tell you whos coming over. You either trust her to babysit or dont.

  • seeing photos of 4 month old in SIL’s bed despite not authorising SIL to look after baby (only MIL, but they live together),

Dont be silly of course SIL is going to spend time with the baby when it's on her home.

  • SIL announcing birth of my son on Facebook without asking;

An arsehole manoeuvre, immature but could be put down to her being overexcited.

  • SIL posting loads of public photos of my baby on Facebook without permission and leaving some public photos up even after I’d asked her to take them down (I had to ask her twice as the first time she said she wouldn’t do it again but didn’t agree to remove them and justified it),

She put photos on her Facebook. She removed them when asked. Unless you told her before posting you are not post DC online then she hasnt really done anything wrong. I dont post my kids and im clear that others can't either.

  • MIL telling me to pass my new born son around the room full of people first at Christmas (including an ill teenager) when I offered for her to hold him,

This is normal. People pass the baby around at family functions.

  • MIL repeatedly calling herself mum (to my son),

meh, I often tell my niece to come to mummy. I forget that im not talking to my own kids.

  • SIL buying sacks of presents at Christmas at Christmas and throughout the year - ignoring gift registry and getting things I don’t want for my son (I avoid too much plastic and fast fashion and prefer 100% cotton and Montessori wooden toys - & she gets the former) which partner makes us use (including a pram without consulting me - despite me buying a much better one which I chose),

She brought a gift. You say thank you. If you do t want it take it to the charity shop after.

  • mocking me asking for a private place to change our baby as they all stared and made jokes saying baby ‘was putting on a show’ when we had to change him at their house in middle of the living room (sometimes with other people there)

ignore them and change you baby in the toilet.

  • ignoring my request not to kiss baby repeatedly,

this would piss me off.

  • ignoring request not to tickle baby (SIL would do it under clothes and pat his bum when he walks - ignoring boundaries over teaching bodily autonomy).

I dont like this either. Youvd said no and explained why.

MapleLeaf190 · Today 18:10

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 23:27

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I’ll reflect on that.
To clarify, before we had the baby we had planned to move to where they live. As a results of boundaries crossed since I gave birth, I’ve put the move on hold.
I’d like to find a way forward and move nearer them eventually, but not until these issues have been acknowledged and resolved. I want advice so we can rebuild trust and I can feel safe with my son around them.

They sound annoying but nothing they have done has been “unsafe”.
You do sound a little uptight - like who cares if SIL hung out with your baby in her bed. Who cares if your MIL brought people around?
You’re going to have a hard time if you keep making small issues into such giant problems.

MapleLeaf190 · Today 18:28

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:39

The issue is that I don’t want extended family making decisions for, or controlling, our family. They have told me where to live, what job my partner should have and when, and even dictate what clothes my son wears, toys he plays with and detergent we use. It’s interesting that you think it’s okay, and that it’s controlling for me to want to make decisions for myself and my son.

How can they even “dictate” these things. If your MIL insists on buying a certain type of detergent, just say “no thanks, I use another kind” and if she buys it for you, just don’t use it.
Buying him toys and clothes isn’t “dictating” - they are gifts!!!
Keep putting your ridiculous boundaries in place and you’ll find yourself pretty lonely.

Also you don’t even know that your baby slept with SIL but keep pushing the idea that they did because that would actually be unsafe and make her look bad. Wouldn’t the most reasonable explanation be that he slept in the cot and then she brought him into bed in the morning for a cuddle?

CycleBreaker68 · Today 18:32

MapleLeaf190 · Today 18:10

They sound annoying but nothing they have done has been “unsafe”.
You do sound a little uptight - like who cares if SIL hung out with your baby in her bed. Who cares if your MIL brought people around?
You’re going to have a hard time if you keep making small issues into such giant problems.

It’s not that they are big issues or unsafe per se, it’s that they didn’t ask and haven’t communicated what they were doing. So when they do things that are big deal (& I think they have), I don’t know and can’t relax and trust them to look after my son without me there.
I also can’t trust them to respect my ‘no’ as they have shown that they’ve done things I have asked them not to.

OP posts:
Differentforgirls · Today 18:33

CycleBreaker68 · Today 17:37

Yep

I'm one. It's a bit derogatory tbh.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Today 18:33

CycleBreaker68 · Today 16:43

Thank you - I appreciate his. I have been keeping a log of what’s happened in case it comes to it.
He earns a lot less than me so he couldn’t cover the mortgage if he works and I didn’t (why he needed to live with family before). It is his car but I pay for petrol and insurance and tax etc. I also recently found out he’s in a lot of credit card debt which he may have used to buy the car, which I will probably have to pay off (so technically I would have paid for the car then)

Don't pay his debts. He can set up a payment plan if he can't afford it.

I would hesitate to pay his bills to allow him to be a SAHP. He sounds like a man child that needs to grow up quickly and take responsibility for being a partner and a parent. Otherwise you are stepping in from where his mother left off.

Does he plan to work? Is DC in childcare? He must be able to find something?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread