Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:58

DoNotComply · 12/11/2026 10:38

But the system doesn't support the ones who do want to try. I have a DD in this age group with what many people would regard as "mild" autism, she has also over the last few years suffered from OCD, anxiety, depression and PTSD from an extremely traumatic incident in school which has meant that it's been impossible for her to attend school for a number of years.

She is desperate to get qualifications, and in the future a decent job, but everything is stacked against her. It's been really difficult to get adequate mental health support, and educational support has been not just absent but feels like they're actively working against her. She managed three GCSEs last year with a combination of night classes and private tutoring, but it's a nightmare finding courses she can do and exam centres she can sit the exams in. She needs extra time in exams because of language processing difficulties due to her autism, but the new rules for that are all framed in terms of evidence from the school, and she isn't at school, so that's near impossible to sort too.

We have paid for all her medical and educational support because we can afford to, so she hasn't yet claimed any benefits, but a less well off family would absolutely need the extra money to even begin to try to plug the many gaps in the system. The government needs to give people access to proper support before you start taking away the little extra money they currently receive.

I don't think people realise how hard it is to get GCSEs if you haven't done them in year 11. There's a complete abyss until you hit adult education at 19. And my child has an EHCP so can access stuff many without couldn't!

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:59

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:58

Its definately not £3k in the part of the country where I live. and I have the evidence that its happening, its all over the facebook groups local to me advising who to go to, who is sympathetic. and whats £3k if it means you can spend the rest of your life, your whole life, not actually working and contributing.

It doesnt take long if you get PIP to make that money up does it!

And where I live, the number of people suddenly walking around on crutches weeks before their assessment is astonishing. they even call them PIP sticks and pass them around.

Pip is needs lead not diagnosis lead.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:01

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:55

Because even people without these conditions are struggling to find work now.

Which is why we need government to help/support businesses to take on young workers, not tax them out of existence and punish them for existing!

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:01

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:59

Pip is needs lead not diagnosis lead.

I know exactly how PIP works. I also know that forms where PIP has been successful are photocopied and passed round so that people can use the same wording. and yes, I do report abuses as and when I come across them because ultimately I want my taxes to go on people with disabilities who work or want to work and be independent.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 11:06

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:01

Which is why we need government to help/support businesses to take on young workers, not tax them out of existence and punish them for existing!

Yes jobs first for young people, if not then of course support will grow. The policies now aren’t helping.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 11:06

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:58

Its definately not £3k in the part of the country where I live. and I have the evidence that its happening, its all over the facebook groups local to me advising who to go to, who is sympathetic. and whats £3k if it means you can spend the rest of your life, your whole life, not actually working and contributing.

It doesnt take long if you get PIP to make that money up does it!

And where I live, the number of people suddenly walking around on crutches weeks before their assessment is astonishing. they even call them PIP sticks and pass them around.

  1. I'd expect all health professionals to be sympathetic
  2. Having a diagnosis doesn't get you pip
  3. why would anyone risk paying out thousands with no guarantee whatsoever of getting pip at the end?
  4. why would they bother paying when pip can be claimed without a diagnosis and other evidence is far easier and cheaper to collate than paying thousands for an asd/adhd assessment?

I can't speak for everyone but my (nhs) report would be useless on it's own for a pip claim as it doesn't evidence how my asd effects me in all the ways pip looks at.

Passaggressfedup · 12/11/2026 11:07

And you only have to look here to see how when someone needs reasonable adjustments at work they are resented by other team members who feel they have to do more to compensate as employers aren’t dealing with the scenario correctly
But that IS the reality of life that parents have a responsibility to help their kids adjust to.

At 16, my son was anti social, massive low self-esteem, extremely introverted, wanting to lock in his room playing video games at all hours. ie quite typical.

I told him from the start of his GCSE year that he would HAVE TO get a job after his GCSEs. Initially, I got the usual, there are no jobs, I deserve a rest, blah blah blah. He got used to accepting that it would happen. I told him he could keep all the money he earned so he started to think of the benefits. Then came the 'Im not doing any work that involves dealing with the public' so applied to stack shelves in a supermarket. The first day, he was out on the check out! He came home furious and saying he had a panic attack! He knew he had to go back.

Gradually, he adjusted. When he started college, he realise the money was quite nice and that the people he worked with were nice. Customers were not as bad as he feared so he continued. He started to enjoy it, his self esteem got better as his boss was very complementary. He likes his colleagues. He started to lose interest playing videos.

By the time he went to Uni, his confidence was up, he could speak to strangers comfortably, even make phone calls. I I was rough at first but again he pushed through and again his confidence self-esteem grew.

He is now early 20, in a very good entry job and training to become a manager. I don't recognise my shy, introverted, anxiety ridden child. I have no doubt he could have become one of those boys the policy is targeting if I hadn't taught my child to adjust to working life, slowly but firmly and instead led him to believe that everyone else should make adjustments to suit him.

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 11:07

Let me clear that I'm not saying this should happen but if PIP and UC were stopped tomorrow for everyone, it would be interesting to see how many people would suddenly find it in themselves to find employment.

Yes I'm aware 'some' areas in the UK are short on jobs. Yes I'm aware 'some' young people will genuinely never be able to work due to SEND or physical disabilities. Yes I'm aware that mental health services are shit but I believe shit parenting on most of our parts is at the root cause of this NEET issue.

We have allowed our DC's to hide themselves away on their phones and PC's because it's easier than fighting them on this. We've told them they can achieve anything in life if they just believe in themselves. We've told them the government will help them financially if they can't find the right job. We've told them it's the schools fault that they aren't reaching their potential. There is zero accountability. We've caused this through lazy parenting. I fell into this trap too and am desperately trying to undo the damage I've caused by being a gentle, supportive parent rather than a get up and get on it with it parent.

Kirbert2 · 12/11/2026 11:08

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:23

This isnt about young adults who are in work and their PIP helps them to stay in work. Its about the huge and growing number of adults who pay for a private diagnosis of some ADH whatever . they get the diagnosis they want because they are paying for it. and if one private doctor wont give it to them they go onto the next.

they do this for one reason and one reason only - so that they have enough money not to work and be comfortable doing it.

and its completely unsustainable going forward because in 15 or 20 years time maybe even sooner there wont be enough workers and tax payers to keep these now older adults with families and children sitting around at home. and by that time they will be almost unemployable.

I have lost count of the number of times every day on social media groups I read "oh its my mental health, I just spiral, I am just triggered, I get anxious" and basically this is because we are bringing up a society with absolutely no resilience. I have had jobs where I have felt physically sick on some days because of something challenging, lots of us have. but the current generations who have just been subjected to helicopter parenting, gentle parenting, not being allowed to take risks or to be bored or to understand that if you want it you earn it are just the chickens coming home to roost.

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

Eligibility for PIP (and DLA) isn't based on a diagnosis though.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 11:10

Passaggressfedup · 12/11/2026 11:07

And you only have to look here to see how when someone needs reasonable adjustments at work they are resented by other team members who feel they have to do more to compensate as employers aren’t dealing with the scenario correctly
But that IS the reality of life that parents have a responsibility to help their kids adjust to.

At 16, my son was anti social, massive low self-esteem, extremely introverted, wanting to lock in his room playing video games at all hours. ie quite typical.

I told him from the start of his GCSE year that he would HAVE TO get a job after his GCSEs. Initially, I got the usual, there are no jobs, I deserve a rest, blah blah blah. He got used to accepting that it would happen. I told him he could keep all the money he earned so he started to think of the benefits. Then came the 'Im not doing any work that involves dealing with the public' so applied to stack shelves in a supermarket. The first day, he was out on the check out! He came home furious and saying he had a panic attack! He knew he had to go back.

Gradually, he adjusted. When he started college, he realise the money was quite nice and that the people he worked with were nice. Customers were not as bad as he feared so he continued. He started to enjoy it, his self esteem got better as his boss was very complementary. He likes his colleagues. He started to lose interest playing videos.

By the time he went to Uni, his confidence was up, he could speak to strangers comfortably, even make phone calls. I I was rough at first but again he pushed through and again his confidence self-esteem grew.

He is now early 20, in a very good entry job and training to become a manager. I don't recognise my shy, introverted, anxiety ridden child. I have no doubt he could have become one of those boys the policy is targeting if I hadn't taught my child to adjust to working life, slowly but firmly and instead led him to believe that everyone else should make adjustments to suit him.

And this is where jobs being there for that age group really matters.

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 11:10

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:55

Because even people without these conditions are struggling to find work now.

This is so true.

And this all comes down to money.
The UK is a declining economy, we are not keeping up with 21st century manufacturing. Whilst we are still a relatively rich nation a lot of that is piggybacking from our glory days (off effectively making money by stealing other countries land, resources and commodities).

We do still have some robust industries but they have changed.

Instead of garment factories we now have packing warehouses. Instead of local shops we have delivery drivers.

We are the generation in the change times, which is always hard, from a strong, influential economy to a middling one.

We are reverting to families having to look after their own like many in middling economies do.

At least Labour have some MPs who will demand options before the rugs are pulled, other political parties wouldn’t bother looking for solutions just blame.

If the economics worked no Labour government would even think about cutting benefits.

Getting NEETs who can work into work first is the cheapest, easiest step. This starts to cut the benefits bill for this age group.

Vaneess · 12/11/2026 11:11

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:27

@mummymeister

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

I've a neighbour with a son like that. Apparently he's too "anxious" to work, but passed his driving test and does a lot of driving (in and out several times a day in the car), goes out regularly with friends, has a couple of expensive hobbies (not introverted hobbies like stamp collecting either!), yet can't possibly actually go out and work.

I don’t really see the problem with that, if his parents are prepared to subsidise him to be unemployed. The problem is expecting the government to pay for it. If he couldn’t afford his car or his expensive hobbies, he’d have an incentive to get a job.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:12

@Passaggressfedup and therein lies the issue. you are a responsible parent who probably works and has worked all or most of your adult life. many of the under 25s in this situation dont have a parent like you. we are expecting the state to become you and its just not going to happen. you did the right thing and your son will thank you for it as he gets older. but you are a minority. go into your local spoons now and see just how many under 25s with kids and without kids are in there. how can they afford the money and time? simple we are paying for it for them. and as long as we keep paying they will keep hanging out in spoons.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:14

Kirbert2 · 12/11/2026 11:08

Eligibility for PIP (and DLA) isn't based on a diagnosis though.

again well aware of that how the PIP forms work, how the appeals work, very familiar with this day in day out. read my other posts. forms get passed around. parents get carers allowance for a diagnosed child. its in their interests if they wont work to do this.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:18

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 11:10

This is so true.

And this all comes down to money.
The UK is a declining economy, we are not keeping up with 21st century manufacturing. Whilst we are still a relatively rich nation a lot of that is piggybacking from our glory days (off effectively making money by stealing other countries land, resources and commodities).

We do still have some robust industries but they have changed.

Instead of garment factories we now have packing warehouses. Instead of local shops we have delivery drivers.

We are the generation in the change times, which is always hard, from a strong, influential economy to a middling one.

We are reverting to families having to look after their own like many in middling economies do.

At least Labour have some MPs who will demand options before the rugs are pulled, other political parties wouldn’t bother looking for solutions just blame.

If the economics worked no Labour government would even think about cutting benefits.

Getting NEETs who can work into work first is the cheapest, easiest step. This starts to cut the benefits bill for this age group.

Labour will never cut benefits. they talk the talk, they never walk the walk because the working class (or more accurately the non working class) is their voter base.

KS had the opportunity to do this when he came into govt first off. his back benchers blocked it.

there are no jobs for young people because the ridiculous level of the minimum wage, the new taxes that have come on stream hitting employers and the vast swathes of irrelevant paperwork you need to complete to take on an apprentice. I know of so many businesses who would love to offer jobs to young people but they just cant afford to now. look at tourism and hospitality where traditionally a lot of starter and part time jobs were for young people.under the cosh and only going to get worse.

Kirbert2 · 12/11/2026 11:18

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:14

again well aware of that how the PIP forms work, how the appeals work, very familiar with this day in day out. read my other posts. forms get passed around. parents get carers allowance for a diagnosed child. its in their interests if they wont work to do this.

Parents can get carers allowance if they care for their child for at least 35 hours per week and they receive at least the middle or high rate DLA. It has nothing at all to do with if a child is diagnosed or not.

Also, do you know how much carers allowance is?

You don't sound well aware at all.

skylarkrise · 12/11/2026 11:24

creamycustards · 12/11/2026 11:07

Let me clear that I'm not saying this should happen but if PIP and UC were stopped tomorrow for everyone, it would be interesting to see how many people would suddenly find it in themselves to find employment.

Yes I'm aware 'some' areas in the UK are short on jobs. Yes I'm aware 'some' young people will genuinely never be able to work due to SEND or physical disabilities. Yes I'm aware that mental health services are shit but I believe shit parenting on most of our parts is at the root cause of this NEET issue.

We have allowed our DC's to hide themselves away on their phones and PC's because it's easier than fighting them on this. We've told them they can achieve anything in life if they just believe in themselves. We've told them the government will help them financially if they can't find the right job. We've told them it's the schools fault that they aren't reaching their potential. There is zero accountability. We've caused this through lazy parenting. I fell into this trap too and am desperately trying to undo the damage I've caused by being a gentle, supportive parent rather than a get up and get on it with it parent.

Yes definitely a lot that you can be anything

PullingOutHair123 · 12/11/2026 11:26

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:34

@PullingOutHair123

But I do question where all these entry level jobs are coming from.

The government could make it easier/cheaper for the smallest of businesses to take on apprentices and trainees.

reduce the paperwork and make it easier - sounds sensible, wonder if it will happen….

AirborneElephant · 12/11/2026 11:26

I don’t believe labour will follow through with any of this. They’re just kicking the can down the road, because they know their backbenchers will veto any real change.

I don’t think PIP and the health element of UC should be available for most mental health issues or most cases of autism or ADHD regardless of age, but I agree it’s particularly counterproductive for young people. The proportion of young people diagnosed with those conditions is over 25%. If that is the case then it needs to be treated as part of the normal spectrum of feelings and behaviour, and people need to be expected to work through it not be supported not to work.

IAmNotMyJobTitle · 12/11/2026 11:28

Passaggressfedup · 12/11/2026 11:07

And you only have to look here to see how when someone needs reasonable adjustments at work they are resented by other team members who feel they have to do more to compensate as employers aren’t dealing with the scenario correctly
But that IS the reality of life that parents have a responsibility to help their kids adjust to.

At 16, my son was anti social, massive low self-esteem, extremely introverted, wanting to lock in his room playing video games at all hours. ie quite typical.

I told him from the start of his GCSE year that he would HAVE TO get a job after his GCSEs. Initially, I got the usual, there are no jobs, I deserve a rest, blah blah blah. He got used to accepting that it would happen. I told him he could keep all the money he earned so he started to think of the benefits. Then came the 'Im not doing any work that involves dealing with the public' so applied to stack shelves in a supermarket. The first day, he was out on the check out! He came home furious and saying he had a panic attack! He knew he had to go back.

Gradually, he adjusted. When he started college, he realise the money was quite nice and that the people he worked with were nice. Customers were not as bad as he feared so he continued. He started to enjoy it, his self esteem got better as his boss was very complementary. He likes his colleagues. He started to lose interest playing videos.

By the time he went to Uni, his confidence was up, he could speak to strangers comfortably, even make phone calls. I I was rough at first but again he pushed through and again his confidence self-esteem grew.

He is now early 20, in a very good entry job and training to become a manager. I don't recognise my shy, introverted, anxiety ridden child. I have no doubt he could have become one of those boys the policy is targeting if I hadn't taught my child to adjust to working life, slowly but firmly and instead led him to believe that everyone else should make adjustments to suit him.

What a great thing! The course of his life is now so different.
But at the heart of this is a parent who knew what was best for her son and guided him in the right direction.
Unfortunately a lot of youngsters now come from successive generations of non-workers, so if the message from home is that it’s all too challenging what hope do the young people have? The challenge is breaking the cycle but how on earth that is done is a massive challenge.

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 11:30

@badbadbunnybut of that percentage of 16-25 year olds - PIP is payable from 16 not 19 - only 9% have a primary condition of anxiety or depression (DWP only records one condition but two thirds of PIP claimants have multiple conditions) although this is unlikely to be ‘mild’.

Even if the 21% with physical disabilities receive higher payments (higher than what - proposed new reduced benefits or existing PIP (which is unlikely as a young person would then receive higher PIP than a 26 year old with the same needs) - those with neurological or psychiatric conditions face the most steepest barriers to entering the workforce.

This is supposed to be reforming the system to help those who can join the workforce - which won’t be everyone - not punishing those most effected and least likely to be helped.

The OP and PP are correct to highlight the fact that delay in support from CAMHS, schools etc has led to an increase in the number of broken young people who couldn’t even cope with attending school and now suffer poor mental health, isolation and lack of qualifications. Healing these young people will not result by cutting payments to pay for support that they may not be able to access and may not be successful even if they can.

Supporting young people, including those with disabilities who are able to work, is positive and needs to be funded. But is does not need to be funded through cuts to sickness and disability. They are two separate issues.

There is only anecdotal evidence or political narrative of claimants receiving PIP who ‘should’ not be eligible because they are lying or exaggerate or the country can’t afford to support disabled people anymore and funds should be diverted to those considered more deserving.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:34

@Passaggressfedup

Sounds exactly like our son, with the same end outcome. We don't even recognise him now as a confident 24 year old living in London and working in one of the UK's biggest insurance firms, loads of friends all over the country, been on several foreign holidays with different friends/groups over the past few years. At 16 he was shy, introverted, no friends, and we were very worried about his future, whether he'd even go to Uni, and where on Earth he'd find a job. Uni was a nightmare as it was the covid lockdown year, but in some ways it helped him as no one was out partying, no face to face lectures, etc., so it kind of worked for him to be stuck in his Uni flat all day every day. The glacially slow return to normal Uni by his third year meant he could tag along when things started opening up, in person lectures started happening again, and they were all in the same boat - a kind of "leveller". We'd started doing Uni open days a year early so we'd "conditioned" him into the expectation of him going to Uni - he wasn't interested but we kind of made it happen! Same with work after Uni - we basically "bullied" him into doing a sandwich Uni course so he'd started applying for intern jobs for his "gap year" at the start of year 2 - he didn't get any offers as it was still lockdowns and many firms weren't taking on interns, but at least it got him in the "habit" of online job applications etc and the expectation of him getting a job. At the start of year 3 he started applying for graduate scheme jobs in earnest - something like 30 applications, and he got a few offers, so were encouraged him to take a job in a city not too far away from home so he could come home easily enough, which he did. He loved the work, the people, etc and the working environment fitted him perfectly. After a couple of years, he was a different person, and took the plunge to take an internal promotion to London, which is something he'd never have done previously, even sorted out his own accommodation, etc. Work has really made him the wonderful, friendly, popular lad he has become. Ten years ago, we'd have been thinking he'd be one of the ones stuck in his room all day gaming with no real "in person" friends!

IAmNotMyJobTitle · 12/11/2026 11:35

PullingOutHair123 · 12/11/2026 11:26

reduce the paperwork and make it easier - sounds sensible, wonder if it will happen….

In our area it’s now very difficult to employ under 18s in a kitchen ( think KP type jobs which many of us did as Saturday work) . This is in case they cut themselves with a knife. If a kitchen wants to employ someone of that age there’s a whole raft of paperwork and special applications that need to happen.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:37

AirborneElephant · 12/11/2026 11:26

I don’t believe labour will follow through with any of this. They’re just kicking the can down the road, because they know their backbenchers will veto any real change.

I don’t think PIP and the health element of UC should be available for most mental health issues or most cases of autism or ADHD regardless of age, but I agree it’s particularly counterproductive for young people. The proportion of young people diagnosed with those conditions is over 25%. If that is the case then it needs to be treated as part of the normal spectrum of feelings and behaviour, and people need to be expected to work through it not be supported not to work.

I agree, if it's as high as 25% then surely it becomes within the remit of being "normal" by being such a high percentage. Surely by definition, being "not normal" should be the extremes of the distribution range.

BendyAndTired · 12/11/2026 11:39

Taking financial support away from any group, and forcing them into poverty, doesn’t actually magically make them able to earn more. This is the same rhetoric that’s been applied to every proposed PIP reduction. The rallying cry of ‘help them back to work!’ ignores the reality that there are not thousands of living wage jobs waiting to be filled, and that the barriers to work for people who need support are not removed by reducing their benefits.

These types of reductions for 18-25 year olds just mean they’ll be staying in the parental home for longer because they just can’t afford to move out and be independent. Shortsighted idiocy.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwn70l1628l0o

Alan Milburn pictured wearing glasses, a blazer and black polo t-shirt.

Some under-25s should get fewer benefits, Milburn review to say

The proposed radical overhaul of the welfare system would move under-25s off the main sickness benefits.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwn70l1628l0o

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.