Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
IAmNotMyJobTitle · 12/11/2026 10:33

The thing is that most of us at some stage have suffered with some form of anxiety or mental health issues surrounding work, and these are the people the government is trying to sort out - not those with severe life limitations.
Placing people on benefits and telling them there’s no need to overcome a situation is not the answer.
Having a purpose and a reason to get up in the morning is hugely important for self esteem.
Something really does have to change to build resilience.
Also, it should never be financially better to be on benefits rather than working.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:34

@PullingOutHair123

But I do question where all these entry level jobs are coming from.

The government could make it easier/cheaper for the smallest of businesses to take on apprentices and trainees.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds
IAmNotMyJobTitle · 12/11/2026 10:34

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:34

@PullingOutHair123

But I do question where all these entry level jobs are coming from.

The government could make it easier/cheaper for the smallest of businesses to take on apprentices and trainees.

Haven’t they just done the opposite of that?

SupernaturalAddict · 12/11/2026 10:36

From what i've just seen on Sky news, PIP for young people will be replaced with an allowance that could be conditional and only for certain services and products rather than a cash amount. The health part of uc will be replaced also with another allowance equiv to the basic rate unless the yp has needs that are such they will clearly never work. They will also need to invest in support to get the yp into work. Benefits will be paid on the condition that those who can work engage with the process.

I think this is sensible. As a country we shouldn't have large amounts of yp sat at home being unproductive.

I think it's not right that we currently have a system where people who can claim for disability but don't require any formal support can keep all their benefits as that is what is deemed they need to get by, while people inc yp who require services from social care because of their disabilities are left with a minimal amount to live off with the understanding that family will meet the other costs or they go without (where they don't have chc funding in place).

I know people will give examples of how their pip is used to help them stay in employment by being able to pay for taxi's, closer parking if they drive, certain foods etc but other people have non disability circs which may mean they have to budget for similar things without having a benefit to help. While the country is in such bad financial state I think we as a society do need to have conversations about what is fair to be paid for by the state and what isn't.

I write this as a parent of a yp who will never work as they are severley disabled. (Maybe I am jaded due to the amount of abuse of the systems that are there to help people with disabilities).

Luckyingame · 12/11/2026 10:36

Zuve · 12/11/2026 07:32

Speaking my mind, really work is often the best medicine and you get to spend your wages. I have known lots of young people at work with all sorts of health issues, and they all get on better than those stuck at home.

Exactly this.

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 10:36

@Badbadbunnythat statistic refers to the total 4
million claimants not the 430,000 18-25 year olds.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:37

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:29

@PocketSand

Why has changes to PIP been suggested when PIP is not an out of work benefit?

Because the vast majority of PIP claimants are out of work. It's only around 20% who work.

Exactly!! the example of the disabled person desperate to work who uses PIP as it was intended to help them stay working and independent is not the majority. and this 20% should be getting more money and not less. Its the other 80% who get a diagnosis privately and use PIP to top up their unemployment benefits so that they can live their life more comfortably. Its a loophole and lots of lazy people are using it because its the way to get more money.

I am on a "gossip girls " forum and post after post this week is "girls I just cant manage on my benefits" to which the answer is always "get yourself on PIP go and see this or that private doctor he will diagnose you" its out there blatant as that.

and all the time the govt is paying for these people to live their best life on my money, they arent spending on increasing opportunities for apprentices or getting young people into their first jobs, or work experience. because all their money is going on Carole from up the road who spends her days gaming, meeting her mates in spoons and getting pissed at the weekends because her made up ADH whatever makes her too anxious to set an alarm and get up on time in the morning.

skylarkrise · 12/11/2026 10:38

Was the YTS such a bad thing, perhaps we need something like that again

DoNotComply · 12/11/2026 10:38

Heatedblankettime · 12/11/2026 08:33

Your young person is the type who needs support.
For others with much milder issues the current system is letting them down by enabling them to opt out of trying.

But the system doesn't support the ones who do want to try. I have a DD in this age group with what many people would regard as "mild" autism, she has also over the last few years suffered from OCD, anxiety, depression and PTSD from an extremely traumatic incident in school which has meant that it's been impossible for her to attend school for a number of years.

She is desperate to get qualifications, and in the future a decent job, but everything is stacked against her. It's been really difficult to get adequate mental health support, and educational support has been not just absent but feels like they're actively working against her. She managed three GCSEs last year with a combination of night classes and private tutoring, but it's a nightmare finding courses she can do and exam centres she can sit the exams in. She needs extra time in exams because of language processing difficulties due to her autism, but the new rules for that are all framed in terms of evidence from the school, and she isn't at school, so that's near impossible to sort too.

We have paid for all her medical and educational support because we can afford to, so she hasn't yet claimed any benefits, but a less well off family would absolutely need the extra money to even begin to try to plug the many gaps in the system. The government needs to give people access to proper support before you start taking away the little extra money they currently receive.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:39

PocketSand · 12/11/2026 10:36

@Badbadbunnythat statistic refers to the total 4
million claimants not the 430,000 18-25 year olds.

But it's still only around 25% working in the 18-25 age group which is still a minority when 75% aren't working.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:43

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:23

This isnt about young adults who are in work and their PIP helps them to stay in work. Its about the huge and growing number of adults who pay for a private diagnosis of some ADH whatever . they get the diagnosis they want because they are paying for it. and if one private doctor wont give it to them they go onto the next.

they do this for one reason and one reason only - so that they have enough money not to work and be comfortable doing it.

and its completely unsustainable going forward because in 15 or 20 years time maybe even sooner there wont be enough workers and tax payers to keep these now older adults with families and children sitting around at home. and by that time they will be almost unemployable.

I have lost count of the number of times every day on social media groups I read "oh its my mental health, I just spiral, I am just triggered, I get anxious" and basically this is because we are bringing up a society with absolutely no resilience. I have had jobs where I have felt physically sick on some days because of something challenging, lots of us have. but the current generations who have just been subjected to helicopter parenting, gentle parenting, not being allowed to take risks or to be bored or to understand that if you want it you earn it are just the chickens coming home to roost.

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

How are those 18-25 paying for multiple private assessments when they have no job?

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:43

skylarkrise · 12/11/2026 10:38

Was the YTS such a bad thing, perhaps we need something like that again

Yes, I've said many times on MN threads that we need something like the YTS scheme back again, and it's sister schemes the ETS and JTS schemes.

I know some people had bad experiences of employers just wanting free labour, but lots of people, myself included, got lifetime careers out of it. I'm now a chartered accountant after having started on the scheme as an office dogsbody and "proving myself" to be given a permanent admin role and then moved over to the accounting side of the firm as a trainee accountant. My best friend at the time got a YTS job in the local chamber of commerce as the office dogsbody, stayed and worked her way up in the organisation and eventually spent a decade or so as their chief executive running it, before she retired and now sits on various local committees.

But even if some were "abused" as free labour, it still gave them routine, and more importantly experience and usually a reference to help them get other jobs.

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 10:44

I don’t know what the review says.

But I do know we need to get young people in work regardless of whether that’s a struggle for them.

I was listening to a podcast yesterday about AI psychosis and other mental health issues. Basically being at home, on these things, without purpose. Is very likely to make you irreversibly ill - especially those already mildly ill, young, or lacking life experience.

As someone myself who had psychosis late 20s and was able to pull myself out and recover; it was uncanny to listen to. It’s exactly the kind of psychosis I had (except without the AI).

Despite being a masters graduate and chartered professional I had to get a part time minimum wage job. That’s all I could manage. Well I couldn’t really but I faked it until I made it and it got easier over time.

These kids really need to work. They might not like it. But they will like a lot less the alternative I assure you.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:44

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:43

How are those 18-25 paying for multiple private assessments when they have no job?

Parents or side "hustles" etc.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:48

TorturedParentsDepartment · 12/11/2026 10:29

I have autism (diagnosed in my 40s), and I'm fairly likely undiagnosed ADHD I've learnt to work around as best as I can... I grew up in the 80s where you had one phone in the hallway, where computers didn't really exist and tablets were something yer nanna took for her nerves.

Still autistic. Had childhood, teens and early adulthood with the most appalling mental health problems - due to the bullying from being undiagnosed and "odd" and trying to fit into a space in society that didn't really work for me at all. All my childhood established was that no amount of getting my head kicked in was going to remove my autism but it was successfully going to make me incredibly miserable.

Same, diagnosed in my 40's. My high school attendance was diabolical as I often didn't go. I basically had what is now termed emotional based school avoidance (ebsa) but apparently it didn't exist back then. Yeah right!

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:49

@Cheekycekyh

But I do know we need to get young people in work regardless of whether that’s a struggle for them.

I agree. I had "issues" as a teenager and really struggled, but wasn't given an option "not" to work, and forced myself (well taken by a parent and dropped off at the office door every day) to go to work. Actually being around adults in a real working environment was the making of me and after the first few "hard" weeks, I became a different person, more confident, more outgoing, etc., and just went from strength to strength.

Over subsequent years/decades in various employments, I've seen other youngsters taken on as trainees, mostly very shy, introverted, lacking in confidence, but it's wonderful to see them grow in ability and confidence.

The government needs to divert the money spent on them "not" working into giving the money to employers to take them on, get them into a working environment, train them the life skills they need, the confidence, etc. Otherwise we're sat on a ticking time bomb.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:50

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:43

How are those 18-25 paying for multiple private assessments when they have no job?

Cash in hand work that they all do. saving their benefits to pay for them because ultimately they know that once they get that bit of paper its quids in. even saw someone who put up a crowdfunder page to pay for their assessments!!

Yes there are young people with genuine issues that need help and support to be in work. but you are completely deluded if you dont realise that there are tens of thousands who are working the system. Their sole aim in life is for someone else to pick up their tab. you want to have a look at the shock and horror on some of these forums this morning as people are waking up to how this report will stop them in their tracks. TBH some of the comments are just hilarious - Ive got agraphobia so I cant work - how do you get your shopping and meet your mates every day in spoons then hun, see you in there every day - oh yeah I can do that just thinking about going out to work is when it kicks in!

Honestly you just couldnt make some of this shit up you really couldnt.

skylarkrise · 12/11/2026 10:50

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:43

Yes, I've said many times on MN threads that we need something like the YTS scheme back again, and it's sister schemes the ETS and JTS schemes.

I know some people had bad experiences of employers just wanting free labour, but lots of people, myself included, got lifetime careers out of it. I'm now a chartered accountant after having started on the scheme as an office dogsbody and "proving myself" to be given a permanent admin role and then moved over to the accounting side of the firm as a trainee accountant. My best friend at the time got a YTS job in the local chamber of commerce as the office dogsbody, stayed and worked her way up in the organisation and eventually spent a decade or so as their chief executive running it, before she retired and now sits on various local committees.

But even if some were "abused" as free labour, it still gave them routine, and more importantly experience and usually a reference to help them get other jobs.

Yes DH went on one and it gave him opportunities with company so was worthwhile

I suppose nowadays everyone is pushed towards university but not everyone has the ability to do a degree so need these opportunities

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:51

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:23

This isnt about young adults who are in work and their PIP helps them to stay in work. Its about the huge and growing number of adults who pay for a private diagnosis of some ADH whatever . they get the diagnosis they want because they are paying for it. and if one private doctor wont give it to them they go onto the next.

they do this for one reason and one reason only - so that they have enough money not to work and be comfortable doing it.

and its completely unsustainable going forward because in 15 or 20 years time maybe even sooner there wont be enough workers and tax payers to keep these now older adults with families and children sitting around at home. and by that time they will be almost unemployable.

I have lost count of the number of times every day on social media groups I read "oh its my mental health, I just spiral, I am just triggered, I get anxious" and basically this is because we are bringing up a society with absolutely no resilience. I have had jobs where I have felt physically sick on some days because of something challenging, lots of us have. but the current generations who have just been subjected to helicopter parenting, gentle parenting, not being allowed to take risks or to be bored or to understand that if you want it you earn it are just the chickens coming home to roost.

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

At £3k a pop, don’t be ridiculous. The government’s recent own review into autism, adhd and MH has said there is no evidence this is happening, that young people aren’t snowflakes, that autism and adhd have been under diagnosed and need is no less severe.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:53

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:51

At £3k a pop, don’t be ridiculous. The government’s recent own review into autism, adhd and MH has said there is no evidence this is happening, that young people aren’t snowflakes, that autism and adhd have been under diagnosed and need is no less severe.

Such conditions may have been under-diagnosed, but people still got jobs despite having such conditions.

There's no way we've had a genuine increase in people with such conditions - the increase is in diagnosing them.

If people could find work in the past with such conditions, why can't they now?

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:54

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:44

Parents or side "hustles" etc.

Well they must be doing well from their side hustles to fund multiple assessments costing thousands. Therefore they must be working and not NEET at all.

Has anyone reported these dodgy professionals? Let me guess, no they haven't (because no one ever reports the alleged hundreds of professionals they know of out there diagnosing asd/adhd where it doenst exist). Why is that? Wouldn't reporting them help stop all this 'fake diagnosis' to claim pip and not work stuff? Don't we all have a personal responsibility to report such fraud?

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:55

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:53

Such conditions may have been under-diagnosed, but people still got jobs despite having such conditions.

There's no way we've had a genuine increase in people with such conditions - the increase is in diagnosing them.

If people could find work in the past with such conditions, why can't they now?

Because even people without these conditions are struggling to find work now.

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 10:57

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:49

@Cheekycekyh

But I do know we need to get young people in work regardless of whether that’s a struggle for them.

I agree. I had "issues" as a teenager and really struggled, but wasn't given an option "not" to work, and forced myself (well taken by a parent and dropped off at the office door every day) to go to work. Actually being around adults in a real working environment was the making of me and after the first few "hard" weeks, I became a different person, more confident, more outgoing, etc., and just went from strength to strength.

Over subsequent years/decades in various employments, I've seen other youngsters taken on as trainees, mostly very shy, introverted, lacking in confidence, but it's wonderful to see them grow in ability and confidence.

The government needs to divert the money spent on them "not" working into giving the money to employers to take them on, get them into a working environment, train them the life skills they need, the confidence, etc. Otherwise we're sat on a ticking time bomb.

100%

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:57

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:53

Such conditions may have been under-diagnosed, but people still got jobs despite having such conditions.

There's no way we've had a genuine increase in people with such conditions - the increase is in diagnosing them.

If people could find work in the past with such conditions, why can't they now?

You clearly didn’t read the review. Women,girls and people of colour were previously shut out of the diagnosis system. We are better informed now as to how it presents hence such groups coming forward. Are these groups supposed to just not have a diagnosis?

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:58

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 10:51

At £3k a pop, don’t be ridiculous. The government’s recent own review into autism, adhd and MH has said there is no evidence this is happening, that young people aren’t snowflakes, that autism and adhd have been under diagnosed and need is no less severe.

Its definately not £3k in the part of the country where I live. and I have the evidence that its happening, its all over the facebook groups local to me advising who to go to, who is sympathetic. and whats £3k if it means you can spend the rest of your life, your whole life, not actually working and contributing.

It doesnt take long if you get PIP to make that money up does it!

And where I live, the number of people suddenly walking around on crutches weeks before their assessment is astonishing. they even call them PIP sticks and pass them around.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread