Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:44

IAmNotMyJobTitle · 12/11/2026 11:35

In our area it’s now very difficult to employ under 18s in a kitchen ( think KP type jobs which many of us did as Saturday work) . This is in case they cut themselves with a knife. If a kitchen wants to employ someone of that age there’s a whole raft of paperwork and special applications that need to happen.

We also have to realise the massive fall in small businesses, i.e. independent shops, guest houses, cafes, pubs, etc., that used to take on school children for Saturday/evening jobs, paper rounds, milk rounds, etc., which is where most of the older generations got their first taste of working life and earning money.

Wetherspoons, chain stores, chain pubs, Travelodge, etc don't take on school aged children, and as you allude, the legal/H&S restrictions on employing young people make it very difficult for the employers still wanting to take on young part timers to do so.

By the time I was 16, I'd already been working part time Friday and Saturday evenings waitressing in a local private small restaurant and working Saturdays doing room changes for a small private guest house, that became daily cleaning during school holidays, especially the summer holiday where I was working full time! They were businesses within a couple of minutes walk from my home. My (now) DH used to work as a paper boy for his local newsagent from aged around 13 which developed into working in the shop Saturday and Sunday mornings, then also to working during school holidays - again all before he was 16!

Hundreds of thousands of small private businesses like shops, guest houses and pubs have closed down over the past few decades. Milk rounds and paper rounds are now rare. Add in the legal/H&S restrictions and it's no surprise we have so many young people with no work experience, no "drive" to want to work, no workplace skills, etc.

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 11:44

Blue adult education doesn't exist anymore. Our colleges are all shut in the evenings. No GCSE's or A-levels are offered like they were twenty years ago. It's nearly impossible for young adults to claw their way back up.
Thanks austerity.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 11:46

BendyAndTired · 12/11/2026 11:39

Taking financial support away from any group, and forcing them into poverty, doesn’t actually magically make them able to earn more. This is the same rhetoric that’s been applied to every proposed PIP reduction. The rallying cry of ‘help them back to work!’ ignores the reality that there are not thousands of living wage jobs waiting to be filled, and that the barriers to work for people who need support are not removed by reducing their benefits.

These types of reductions for 18-25 year olds just mean they’ll be staying in the parental home for longer because they just can’t afford to move out and be independent. Shortsighted idiocy.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwn70l1628l0o

What nonsense! its not about forcing them into poverty. its about forcing them into the reality of life - that if you want stuff like a smartphone, a car, a computer then someone somewhere has to pay for it and that someone needs to be you - the young person who makes a concious decision not to work. if they work some hours or are on lower wages when working then there is already support there to top this up and help.

and why arent there jobs out there? because successive govts but particularly this Labour govt have made it harder and harder to give young people their first jobs or give them the work experience they need. Have you seen the sheer amount of paperwork there is for taking on an apprentice? the requirements, the rules? because I have and they are bonkers. Hitting hospitality businesses and not allowing young people under 16 to take on certain roles means the old way of getting experience - washing up at your local pub, a couple of hours in the corner shop or behind the counter in the fish and chip shop or waiting on tables in the school hols if you are in a tourism area have completely vanished.

If there is any shortsighted idiocy going on its whoever decided to raise the minimum wage and not clear out the red tape for young people to be able to start in the world of work.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:47

@BendyAndTired

ignores the reality that there are not thousands of living wage jobs waiting to be filled

Young people don't need to be paid living wage! Most are still living at home so need little more than travel/pocket money whilst they're training. Why would/should an employer pay a youngster with no workplace experience/skills the same as they'd pay someone older with more experience/more skills etc? Make it make sense. We need to make it easier for businesses to take on youngsters to train them up. We need to bring back the YTS scheme. We need to make it easier for employers to take on apprentices and for the colleges to put fewer obstacles in the way. Employers need to be helped/subsidised to take on young people to train them how to operate in the workplace.

More people working would help grow the economy and thus create more jobs, because the workers would be spending their wages, using public transport more, using shops etc close to the workplace more, probably socialising more, thus making pubs, restaurants, venues busier, rather than glumly sat in their bedrooms playing online games and spending nothing in the local economy.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 11:48

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 11:44

Blue adult education doesn't exist anymore. Our colleges are all shut in the evenings. No GCSE's or A-levels are offered like they were twenty years ago. It's nearly impossible for young adults to claw their way back up.
Thanks austerity.

There’s such a competing need for funds and taxes are high, we can’t just keep borrowing more which the next generation will pick up the bill for.

WoolHatEnthusiast · 12/11/2026 11:52

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 11:48

There’s such a competing need for funds and taxes are high, we can’t just keep borrowing more which the next generation will pick up the bill for.

This is one of those avenues that could ameliorate the youth unemployment figures in those cases when it is caused by an educational gap. It makes sense to use these buildings when they are empty to serve the whole community.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:52

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 11:44

Blue adult education doesn't exist anymore. Our colleges are all shut in the evenings. No GCSE's or A-levels are offered like they were twenty years ago. It's nearly impossible for young adults to claw their way back up.
Thanks austerity.

Yes! We lost our Poly when it converted to a Uni - at a stroke, all the adult education and workplace training it did was cancelled. It's where I studied for my accountancy qualifications on a day release/evening basis alongside full time work! We had 2 colleges in our town - they did a massive range of courses, from flower arranging, up to O and A levels, and on to diplomas etc - one closed down and the other converted to 16/18 year olds only. There's nothing at all for adults in our town now. Well now quite true, I believe that there is some provision for adults to learn basic numeracy and literacy, but certainly nothing for adults wanting to learn new skills, professional qualifications, nor even GCSE/A levels.

RaggedRocks · 12/11/2026 11:55

I think the government should just make up jobs for the young to do. It's better to have one lot digging holes and the other lot filling them in than both lots staying in bed all day doom-scrolling, gaming, and accusing the boomers of stealing their future.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:55

WoolHatEnthusiast · 12/11/2026 11:52

This is one of those avenues that could ameliorate the youth unemployment figures in those cases when it is caused by an educational gap. It makes sense to use these buildings when they are empty to serve the whole community.

I'd say we need to do the same with Unis - especially since many are struggling. Rather than concentrating only on 3 year degrees, why aren't they offering day release/evening courses for professional qualifications, etc., such as accountancy, law, HR, etc that are currently now only offered by professional private firms such as BPP via distance learning. All the lecture theatres, classrooms, etc are sat empty at weekends and evenings - just ripe for offering courses to locals.

beAsensible1 · 12/11/2026 11:57

i think 18-24 is a key window to work with the them to get them into work before they lose all confidence and get into the rhythm of never working. Getting BACK into the working world is hard enough let alone getting in when you’ve never entered.

lots of people are capable with support and if it means they need some robust pushing then robustly push. But we cannot allow an entire generation of capable young people to expire on the midden heap without even trying. It does them a disservice.

no one deserves to spend their entire adult life thinking they’re incapable when they’ve never really tried. Or that no-one around them cared enough to even push.

HPFA · 12/11/2026 12:01

CatkinToadflax · 12/11/2026 08:39

I completely agree with this, but my worry is that mine and others like him will fall through the cracks and have the support they need removed.

Unfortunately this is quite possible.

Everyone thinks themselves or their own kids are the deserving ones, the "mild cases" and the undeserving are the "I know someone who" - usually a neighbour or a distant relative or friend of a friend.

So they keep demanding a perfect system tgat can't exist.

pointythings · 12/11/2026 12:05

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 11:55

I'd say we need to do the same with Unis - especially since many are struggling. Rather than concentrating only on 3 year degrees, why aren't they offering day release/evening courses for professional qualifications, etc., such as accountancy, law, HR, etc that are currently now only offered by professional private firms such as BPP via distance learning. All the lecture theatres, classrooms, etc are sat empty at weekends and evenings - just ripe for offering courses to locals.

We used to have that. It was cut.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 12/11/2026 12:05

Camhs wouldn't help my now 18 year old when he tried to take his own life aged 12. Now he is on maximum PIP. He is currently at university getting a lot of support. He would love to work and live independently but I can't see how either could happen without a considerable amount of practical support.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 12:06

How many YPs just say that can't work vs actually can't.

RaggedRocks · 12/11/2026 12:09

Young people are babies until 5 and children until 30 now. When we were 8/9, we would be sent to the shop at the bottom of the road, including crossing a main road to get anything missing for lunch/tea.

We would have to take our 4-year-old brother because he knew we would eat the sweets that we bought with the change on the way back. We got a comic each for free each week, but additional pocket money had to be earned. We were taught early that you don't get owt for nowt. My dad would have been furious if I had gone on the dole.

The little bro was such a dawdler as well.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 12:09

WoolHatEnthusiast · 12/11/2026 11:52

This is one of those avenues that could ameliorate the youth unemployment figures in those cases when it is caused by an educational gap. It makes sense to use these buildings when they are empty to serve the whole community.

It may be helpful but voting for higher borrowing has meant so much going on debt servicing that could go to funding other things. Not just here but in a few countries that way to pay for things isn’t sustainable. It’s over £100bn a year.

So yes many things need money, but spending by borrowing or ever higher taxes may not work. IMO go for job creation. For young people in particular.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 12:11

RaggedRocks · 12/11/2026 11:55

I think the government should just make up jobs for the young to do. It's better to have one lot digging holes and the other lot filling them in than both lots staying in bed all day doom-scrolling, gaming, and accusing the boomers of stealing their future.

I think about this as well. A way and thing that if someone wants to work , they can get a job. A jobs guarantee. It gets stuff done and reduces unemployment. Instead of taxpayer funding not working, it funds working!

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 12:14

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 12:09

It may be helpful but voting for higher borrowing has meant so much going on debt servicing that could go to funding other things. Not just here but in a few countries that way to pay for things isn’t sustainable. It’s over £100bn a year.

So yes many things need money, but spending by borrowing or ever higher taxes may not work. IMO go for job creation. For young people in particular.

Yup, we need to grow the economy, not increasing our debt and debt interest payments just to pay benefits. People working spend their wages in the local economy, in shops, pubs, cafes, public transport, etc. There have been studies showing the "multiplier" effect of spending locally, as the extra spend generates more work for others, more spending locally, and it spirals thus growing the local economy.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 12:15

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 12:11

I think about this as well. A way and thing that if someone wants to work , they can get a job. A jobs guarantee. It gets stuff done and reduces unemployment. Instead of taxpayer funding not working, it funds working!

We wouldn't even have to create "non jobs" like digging holes and filling them in. There's SO MUCH that needs doing, the jobs created could actually be doing useful things.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 12:16

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 12:15

We wouldn't even have to create "non jobs" like digging holes and filling them in. There's SO MUCH that needs doing, the jobs created could actually be doing useful things.

Exactly! But there are probably some who would refuse. If they do, we can gut their benefits dry

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 12:16

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 12:09

It may be helpful but voting for higher borrowing has meant so much going on debt servicing that could go to funding other things. Not just here but in a few countries that way to pay for things isn’t sustainable. It’s over £100bn a year.

So yes many things need money, but spending by borrowing or ever higher taxes may not work. IMO go for job creation. For young people in particular.

There is no point creating the entry level jobs for young people if work doesnt pay. If they can get the same amount or only slightly less sitting at home on their devices then they will. it has to be carrot and stick. one without the other is completely pointless. all good parents know this - tidy up your room/help with the chores and then you can have...

There are whole families which havent worked for 3 or 4 generations. Kids who have no idea what is needed - getting up on time, arriving on time, being polite and engaged etc. because they have never seen it in their own families.

And what incentives are there for employers to take on these young people who have never worked and dont even have the basic skills to answer a phone or speak to a customer? you have to pay them almost as much as a 20 something with a track record of work. or spend hours and hours of your time filling in ridiculous risk assessments and paperwork to take on an apprentice.

and no I am not advocating a return to the stick em up the chimneys days but we have gone way too far the other way.

Everyone took the piss out of YTS but the kids that went on it got into work.

its time to be radical but this govt will can kick, just like they do for everything else.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 12:23

@mummymeister

There is no point creating the entry level jobs for young people if work doesnt pay. If they can get the same amount or only slightly less sitting at home on their devices then they will. it has to be carrot and stick. one without the other is completely pointless. all good parents know this - tidy up your room/help with the chores and then you can have...

They go to work and get a wage or they stay at home and get nothing. That's your carrot and stick.

WoolHatEnthusiast · 12/11/2026 12:25

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 12:09

It may be helpful but voting for higher borrowing has meant so much going on debt servicing that could go to funding other things. Not just here but in a few countries that way to pay for things isn’t sustainable. It’s over £100bn a year.

So yes many things need money, but spending by borrowing or ever higher taxes may not work. IMO go for job creation. For young people in particular.

Yes. I agree. I think we should prioritise the downstream costs that get people into employment. Personally, I think that we need to tighten up pip and dla - I definitely think people should be able to point to how it is being used to access work or fill a gap that isn't being reasonably delivered by the state.

Ilovemum · 12/11/2026 12:26

So can I ask niavely whether a certain scheme still is in place- hubby is 36, when he was 18 he had a get into work coach due to his disabilities through the job centre- ADHD, autism and epilepsy. She was fantastic and got him work experience at Sainsbury's and then he was employed by them for the next 12 years... Does that not happen anymore- as they were specifically there to help people with learning disabilities, autism, ADHD and physical needs who could work get through the door (or is that something else that was scrapped)... I think the employer got an incentive (1/2 pay paid for a while).... If it's gone can't we resurrect it.....

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 12:26

@Badbadbunny yep 100% right. but you and I absolutely know for a 100% certainty that this Labour government wont do anything even approaching this. any attempt and the backbenchers will vote it down. better to keep taking from those in work.

they havent dealt with the triple lock on pensions, they have can kicked it.

they will welcome the report and it will sit on a shelf.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread