Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
pointythings · 12/11/2026 09:11

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:41

Exactly - that pip may be enabling them to work- taking it away could be disastrous

Exactly. This is my DS. His PIP buys him transport on days when he can't wheel to the bus stop because his shoulders sublux if he tries. It buys him ready meals for those days when he is too exhausted after work to cook. It buys him extra heating to help him cope with days when the pain is so bad it's unbearable. Without the PIP, he would not be able to work.

LakieLady · 12/11/2026 09:13

Pinklightning · 12/11/2026 07:18

Well CAMHS is terrible but 18-25 year olds come under adult services. Unless of course you mean that with better CAMHS provision when younger then these 18-25 year olds wouldn’t need benefits to the extent they do?

Not speaking for the OP, obvs, but that is exactly how I feel.

Unless a child is already significantly unwell, the chances of them even being assessed by CAMHS are pretty slim in this area. Referrals are banded into one of 4 bands, only the top two bands are ever likely to get an assessment, never mind support or treatment.

I know a young adult who was referred when still in primary, at 9 or 10. It wasn't until his mother had a complete meltdown at the GP's because she was so worried about him and the GP got on to CAMHS and got his priority level raised. He finally got assessed when he was 15, and then had to wait several months for an autism assessment.

In addition to being ND, he was diagnosed with PTSD, OCD and general anxiety disorder.

He has been unable to go to school since the first year of secondary, because a child who lives nearby was bullying him psychologically (including threats to kill him, his mother and his dog). He has had virtually no secondary education, rarely leaves the house, and is, frankly, a complete nervous wreck. On a really good day, he is able to go out and walk the dog, but most of the time he just stays indoors. He used to be comfortable staying in the living room when I visited, but now just stays in his room when anyone comes to the house. His mother can only spend a couple of hours out of the house before he starts getting horrendously anxious and starts ringing her to get her to come home. He spends a good chunk of his PIP on private therapy, and pays a decent contribution towards food, rent and bills (his mother gets carer's allowance and UC).

Any cuts to his income would throw the family into really dire circumstances. Mother has already had to give up her car because it was unaffordable, which has curtailed their lives even more. And it's not their fault that getting support with his MH took years, by which time his issues were incredibly entrenched.

Winglessvulture · 12/11/2026 09:14

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/11/2026 08:24

It’s not just CAMHS, the education system actively works against kids who have different learning styles. If you do get a place in specialist provision all too often kids are basically held in school with limited learning opportunities. Without at least functional maths and English, no one is going to employ these kids and schools just don’t provide that for kids who struggle with learning.

If I had left it to school my DD would be unable to read, because the assumption was her learning disability meant she couldn’t learn. She now has a reading age commensurate with her chronological age, after years of specialist tutoring. I could afford that but many parents can’t, because parenting a child with complex needs is expensive, and the education system doesn’t fill the gaps.

Totally agree, the education system and the NHS more broadly also have a key part to play here. There needs to be a massive overhaul across the board.

Another huge part of the problem is how difficult it is for people to access support. I know from my own experience that nothing is straightforward, whether it's applying for DLA, EHCP, and even knowing what support might exist. It's exhausting for parents and carers.

Vaneess · 12/11/2026 09:22

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 07:40

I agree probably not sustainable.

But instead of just stopping payment support there should be much better schemes to help people both with their MH but also into work that they can do.

Here's a scenario.

Your business wants a part time worker for say, hospitality. Would you rather employ a uni student part time, or a 19 yo NEET who has maybe some MH issues that you might need adjusting to, and who maybe isn't anyway as 'able' as the uni student?

or

Your business wants a part time gardener for an estate. It is helpful if they have a driving license but as long as most gardeners have one you could adjust around it with a bit of effort. But because it is helpful you make it an essential requirement, it's a good filter anyway. So now anyone who is too anxious to cope with driving on main roads, or maybe has dyspraxia as well, can no longer get the job as a gardener, even if they can do 95% of the work just fine.

Repeat, repeat, repeat.

As long as support into work is limited and there aren't incentives for employers, then those who need extra adjustments will be passed over. Plus of course if you give too many job protection rights too early, employers won't be willing to take risks in case they get stuck with someone who isn't sufficiently capable.

Edit to add: So you can't blame people for being NEETs if employers / government / health services won't help them.

Edited

Obviously the employer would prefer the stable, better resourced individual in both examples.

But there’s a level of personal responsibility here. If a young person has anxiety, they can establish a routine, get exercise, eat better and see their GP for free. If a job requires driving, and you can’t drive, you find another job.

It’s not the government’s responsibility to fix everything. People have to adapt.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 09:29

CAMHS, send services and education all need more funding to help sort this issue out.

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:32

It just seems that more money is always the request.

Maybe if we took screens and social media away from a whole generation of young people, we'd be in a much better place.

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 09:33

Yanbu. CAMHS pretty much disappeared in austerity. Kids are left to struggle for years until the car crash of ending education.
There is no work experience in schools these days either, it's left to parents to sort it and most employers aren't interested.

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 09:35

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:32

It just seems that more money is always the request.

Maybe if we took screens and social media away from a whole generation of young people, we'd be in a much better place.

Mental health problems existed years before computers. But CAMHS was there to support kids and nip things in the bud.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/11/2026 09:39

Winglessvulture · 12/11/2026 09:14

Totally agree, the education system and the NHS more broadly also have a key part to play here. There needs to be a massive overhaul across the board.

Another huge part of the problem is how difficult it is for people to access support. I know from my own experience that nothing is straightforward, whether it's applying for DLA, EHCP, and even knowing what support might exist. It's exhausting for parents and carers.

Absolutely, it can be a full time job fighting the system and you still don’t get meaningful support. I’m not being funny but financial support is often the only support available.

We’ve had 8 years of working through the system to finally get the neurodevelopmental assessment that my DD should have had right from the start. She has 2 years left in education, even specialist provision has been disastrous for her, I’m not holding out too much hope that she’ll have any more meaningful support post assessment. The one thing that has been relatively straightforward has been getting financial support which helps fund tutoring support, pay for things related to her disability and fill some of the gap in my earning capacity that has been utterly undermined by her care needs. Those needs won’t end because she turns 18 and there has been very little support to help her with employability.

Now they want to reduce the financial support needed, at least in part, because of the complete lack of support for kids like mine.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/11/2026 09:43

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:32

It just seems that more money is always the request.

Maybe if we took screens and social media away from a whole generation of young people, we'd be in a much better place.

More money is the answer though. You can’t underfund mental health services, close specialist education provision, decimate support services, undermine social work services, close employment support services and then wonder why we have a whole generation of kids who can’t function.

Society will always end up footing the bill, whether that be paying for the supports needed to help people with disabilities, or paying them when they can’t work. Early intervention that would reduce the number of people reaching crisis, that they can’t come back from, but no one wants to pay for it.

Not having screens wouldn’t change the impact of significant developmental trauma, learning disability or neurodiversity. Decent therapeutic support and support tailored to her needs is simply not available, no reduction in screen time will change that.

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:46

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 09:35

Mental health problems existed years before computers. But CAMHS was there to support kids and nip things in the bud.

Poor mental health among young people did not exist in my teenage years at the scale it does now. Of course more awareness leads to more diagnosis but the advent of screens has created something that is more fundamental.

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 09:49

Vaneess · 12/11/2026 09:22

Obviously the employer would prefer the stable, better resourced individual in both examples.

But there’s a level of personal responsibility here. If a young person has anxiety, they can establish a routine, get exercise, eat better and see their GP for free. If a job requires driving, and you can’t drive, you find another job.

It’s not the government’s responsibility to fix everything. People have to adapt.

Yes there is personal responsibility. But Obviously the employer would prefer the stable, better resourced individual in both examples is really quite a barrier.

Nevermissabeat · 12/11/2026 09:50

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:46

Poor mental health among young people did not exist in my teenage years at the scale it does now. Of course more awareness leads to more diagnosis but the advent of screens has created something that is more fundamental.

Yes it did. Self harm, severe depression etc were common in the 80's. You either luckily missed it or ignored friends who were going under and not in school.

TigerRag · 12/11/2026 09:51

Heatedblankettime · 12/11/2026 07:42

At any stage I would say.
We've become a country where any mild adversity means we think we should get a huge pile of benefit handouts and it's embarrassing

I've lost count of the amount of "I've just been diagnosed with (usually adults diagnosed with autism or ADHD) what can I claim?" But some parents are just as bad. I've seen parents try to claim DLA because their child has myopia which isn't even a disability

TrappedByThisDesk · 12/11/2026 09:59

LakieLady · 12/11/2026 09:13

Not speaking for the OP, obvs, but that is exactly how I feel.

Unless a child is already significantly unwell, the chances of them even being assessed by CAMHS are pretty slim in this area. Referrals are banded into one of 4 bands, only the top two bands are ever likely to get an assessment, never mind support or treatment.

I know a young adult who was referred when still in primary, at 9 or 10. It wasn't until his mother had a complete meltdown at the GP's because she was so worried about him and the GP got on to CAMHS and got his priority level raised. He finally got assessed when he was 15, and then had to wait several months for an autism assessment.

In addition to being ND, he was diagnosed with PTSD, OCD and general anxiety disorder.

He has been unable to go to school since the first year of secondary, because a child who lives nearby was bullying him psychologically (including threats to kill him, his mother and his dog). He has had virtually no secondary education, rarely leaves the house, and is, frankly, a complete nervous wreck. On a really good day, he is able to go out and walk the dog, but most of the time he just stays indoors. He used to be comfortable staying in the living room when I visited, but now just stays in his room when anyone comes to the house. His mother can only spend a couple of hours out of the house before he starts getting horrendously anxious and starts ringing her to get her to come home. He spends a good chunk of his PIP on private therapy, and pays a decent contribution towards food, rent and bills (his mother gets carer's allowance and UC).

Any cuts to his income would throw the family into really dire circumstances. Mother has already had to give up her car because it was unaffordable, which has curtailed their lives even more. And it's not their fault that getting support with his MH took years, by which time his issues were incredibly entrenched.

What would have happened thirty or fifty years ago?

Autism and PTSD would most likely have gone undiagnosed.
Bullying wasn't taken seriously - child would have been told to 'take no notice' or 'give as good as you get'.
Mother breaking down in GP's surgery would be give some pills to take herself.
Child would be sent into school; parent would not tolerate child refusing to attend school. Threat of punishment from parent for not going. Child might have 'bunked off' and wandered the streets, but staying home was not an option.

And most importantly, child / young adult staying in their bedroom would find it boring as hell, with no TV in there, let alone phones, internet, or any other electronics. So they would come downstairs. And eventually might leave the house more often.

Having the option of staying in a bedroom on electronic devices connected to the outside world is a huge change, and a huge part of the problem.

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 10:08

In the 80s kids were picked on for being stupid or not trying because their SpLD / ND went unnoticed. Some girls developed anorexia or bulimia and were hospitalised.
The pace of life was slower, there were more jobs for unskilled people, there wasn't the high level of pressure on GCSEs as there is now, there weren't schools giving out detentions at the drop of a hat, we didn't have a pandemic disrupting social skills and education and frightening the more vulnerable.
And yes screens. But screens aren't the cause of everything.

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:23

This isnt about young adults who are in work and their PIP helps them to stay in work. Its about the huge and growing number of adults who pay for a private diagnosis of some ADH whatever . they get the diagnosis they want because they are paying for it. and if one private doctor wont give it to them they go onto the next.

they do this for one reason and one reason only - so that they have enough money not to work and be comfortable doing it.

and its completely unsustainable going forward because in 15 or 20 years time maybe even sooner there wont be enough workers and tax payers to keep these now older adults with families and children sitting around at home. and by that time they will be almost unemployable.

I have lost count of the number of times every day on social media groups I read "oh its my mental health, I just spiral, I am just triggered, I get anxious" and basically this is because we are bringing up a society with absolutely no resilience. I have had jobs where I have felt physically sick on some days because of something challenging, lots of us have. but the current generations who have just been subjected to helicopter parenting, gentle parenting, not being allowed to take risks or to be bored or to understand that if you want it you earn it are just the chickens coming home to roost.

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

WoolHatEnthusiast · 12/11/2026 10:23

I was told by my gp that my 11 yo ds, who was struggling with anxiety and autistic burnout, that he could refer him to camhs but unless he was getting into trouble with the police or had suicidal ideation, then there wasn't much point because the service is so overstretched atm.

If that is the threshold for help then is there any wonder that we have arrived at this point? Society loses when children are left to languish in misery and become unproductive adults.

We are fortunate enough that we have been able to help ds with resources outside of the NHS, and happy to do so, but clearly that is not an option available to everyone.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:24

@Nevermissabeat

There is no work experience in schools these days either, it's left to parents to sort it and most employers aren't interested.

Employers "aren't interested" because of the mountain of paperwork required by the schools/colleges to "tick their boxes". I was approached by a local school around 20 years ago to ask if I'd take on a pupil for a work experience week, which I readily agreed to, as I'd been on one myself at school and previous employers had done it. Then came the request for the paperwork - several different risk assessments, a very long questionnaire, etc., most of it completely irrelevant. Just no!

I've had numerous clients over the years thinking of taking on an apprentice, mostly "one man bands" - the kind that the Labour Minister Emma Reynolds says "aren't working people" - who've approached our local college and likewise been scared off by the bureaucracy, paperwork, etc., and as a result not a single one has taken on an apprentice.

The government need to do something to make it easier for the smallest of businesses to take on their first worker - at the moment, it's a hurdle that's simply too big for one man bands to get over.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds
PocketSand · 12/11/2026 10:24

It seems to be deliberate that the Milburn review - that was publicised as a study of the barriers to work that 18-25 year olds encounter - is released before the Timms review of PIP to test the water. Why has changes to PIP been suggested when PIP is not an out of work benefit?

It is true that 40% of NEETS are disabled and disability increases likelihood of being NEET but removing support for that group will not improve matters. The other 60% of NEETS will not receive sickness and disability payments anyway. The argument is that benefits have to be cut to fund measures to increase chances of unemployment. Will there be measures to improve employment to the majority of non-disabled NEETs as clearly needed and if so will these be funded by cuts to the benefits of the disabled?

But this fundamentally changes the way in which disabled 18-25 year olds are supported whether or not they are NEETs. Most will live in the family home and this will reduce the income of households with disabled young people. Especially as CA at present is only paid if a young person receives PIP.

Is this an indication of what will be in the Timms review - not vouchers but limiting cash payments to those who can prove the amount of additional costs of disability resulting in decreased eligibility and reduced payment and increasing administration for claimants?

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:27

@mummymeister

There are several under 25s in my family. 2 of them work less than 20 hours a week because they just cant cope with working any more hours yet they can cope with playing on their devices, watching tv and going out getting pissed with their mates. and we are paying for this, we tax payers. when asked about jobs they just say they dont want to start at the bottom, they wont go out the door unless its for a job where they are paid 30k plus and have nil qualifications. it has to stop, we have to stop enabling this. and when we do, even more money can go to those with a disability who are desperate to stay in work and make their own way. I want to give them double what they get now and take everything away from the lazy arses who see benefits as their way to an easy life.

I've a neighbour with a son like that. Apparently he's too "anxious" to work, but passed his driving test and does a lot of driving (in and out several times a day in the car), goes out regularly with friends, has a couple of expensive hobbies (not introverted hobbies like stamp collecting either!), yet can't possibly actually go out and work.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 10:28

I agree with the previous point that even young people without send are struggling to get work, so what chance do those with send have?

Who's going to employ someone who needs a bunch of RAs when they can employ someone who doesn't and will be much easier and possibly cheaper to have as an employee?

Look at the local jobs and see how many there are, then see how many of those are signed up to the disability confident scheme. As an example, I've just done this via the jobcentre and the jobs went from 468 to 42. That's before we then have to filter out ones that wouldn't be accessible due to their particular send needs. They won't manage full time work so that cuts it to 11, 6 require quals they don't have, 1 requires a driving licence, 2 are support worker jobs (they need support themselves!) and two are cleaning jobs which they won't manage due to physical disability. I appreciate there are other sites to look at, the job centre are the only ones who show the disability confident employers and even so its the same experience trying to find something suitable.

much like education, people with send/disabilities often can't manage certain environments which immediately cuts down the amount of jobs accessible to them.

it's also really annoying people just assume those who are NEET are sat around gaming all day. My young person is currently NEET after completing a supported internship. There was no job available at the end but they have been volunteering instead. The same place recently advertised a job which she's gone for. She knows she won't get it as there's customer facing elements and she can't do that due to communication needs (it might be something she could manage in the future with patience and support, but will the employer want to bother with providing that, or just employ someone that can do the whole job from the off?). She's applying anyway to get an interview (disability confident scheme so guaranteed interview) so she can get interview experience. She WANTS to work, but finding suitable employment will be extremely difficult.

And do people think we want our kids living a life off benefits with zero security? I want to know mine can support themselves because benefits can be taken away at the drop of a hat and I do agree working and playing a part in society is beneficial for a lot of peoples MH (not necessarily everyone though).

TorturedParentsDepartment · 12/11/2026 10:29

JimBobsWife · 12/11/2026 09:32

It just seems that more money is always the request.

Maybe if we took screens and social media away from a whole generation of young people, we'd be in a much better place.

I have autism (diagnosed in my 40s), and I'm fairly likely undiagnosed ADHD I've learnt to work around as best as I can... I grew up in the 80s where you had one phone in the hallway, where computers didn't really exist and tablets were something yer nanna took for her nerves.

Still autistic. Had childhood, teens and early adulthood with the most appalling mental health problems - due to the bullying from being undiagnosed and "odd" and trying to fit into a space in society that didn't really work for me at all. All my childhood established was that no amount of getting my head kicked in was going to remove my autism but it was successfully going to make me incredibly miserable.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 10:29

@PocketSand

Why has changes to PIP been suggested when PIP is not an out of work benefit?

Because the vast majority of PIP claimants are out of work. It's only around 20% who work.

PullingOutHair123 · 12/11/2026 10:31

I agree with a previous poster who said diagnosis is great for adding extra support where needed, but rubbish when being used as an excuse to not do (or even try) anything. It's those people that (as a country) we should be getting back out into the world and working - however that looks.

But I do question where all these entry level jobs are coming from.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.