Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 10:10

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:05

Well don’t refer to all disabled people as they, needs differ.

They is the pronoun when we don't know if people are he or she.

BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 10:13

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:07

I would imagine a fair few in research are ND and “office politics” isn’t a requisite of any job. With reasonable adjustments, time and progress who knows what any autistic student can achieve.

Academia is awash with office politics.
Research jobs are highly competitive.
Communication has always been a key element of research jobs.

Apotofrealcoffee · 15/11/2026 10:16

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 09:21

You can’t say all autistic people won’t use their degree. Uni can lead to qualifications in special interest, jobs less face to face, more technical…As I said uni can be the difference between working and not working for autistic people.

I mean did I say that? Or even alluded to it?

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:24

BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 10:13

Academia is awash with office politics.
Research jobs are highly competitive.
Communication has always been a key element of research jobs.

Skills can be built on over time, reasonable adjustments can be made and jobs vary. There are many successful academics with poor people skills. The fact is it’s better to persue special interest and getting qualifications in that field and to aim high rather than telling disabled people they have no chance of achieving because of their disability.

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:31

pointythings · 15/11/2026 09:12

There are a lot of people on this thread who think of everything purely in financial terms. That's a choice. When you call them on it, they start shouting about how 'we can't afford it'. Well, we could - but society would have to change a lot, and for the better. The problem we have is that too many people are addicted to unfettered capitalism. And in that world, the human doesn't matter.

Ultimately this boils down to allocation of resources. Money is just a modern manifestation of this but resource is always finite and should be used wisely where there is scarcity. Public finances are very stretched at the moment and we have to think long and hard about what we spend money on.

The 'human' matters but we have 70 million of them in this country, each with their own aspirations and dreams. The state can't afford to fund everything, especially when the majority of people are net beneficiaries of the welfare state and some people have very high support needs that run into the hundreds of thousands each year. This means the minority that are funding everything are carrying an enormous burden and I think they have every right to question why we are funding degrees for people that have no realistic prospect of repaying that investment in tax receipts and student loan repayments. Is this really a priority over cancer treatment or defending our country? Do we just accrue more and more debt and higher interest repayments each year so that everyone can pursue their special interest when the statistics suggest that it's very unlikely they will get a well paid job?

BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 10:33

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:24

Skills can be built on over time, reasonable adjustments can be made and jobs vary. There are many successful academics with poor people skills. The fact is it’s better to persue special interest and getting qualifications in that field and to aim high rather than telling disabled people they have no chance of achieving because of their disability.

I did not say they have no chance. All fields of work are awash with older people with autism and ADHD, including mine.
I was questioning the idea that someone whose autism is so severe that they can't follow an instruction like go to the kitchen and fetch me a glass of water, can get a job in research

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:34

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:31

Ultimately this boils down to allocation of resources. Money is just a modern manifestation of this but resource is always finite and should be used wisely where there is scarcity. Public finances are very stretched at the moment and we have to think long and hard about what we spend money on.

The 'human' matters but we have 70 million of them in this country, each with their own aspirations and dreams. The state can't afford to fund everything, especially when the majority of people are net beneficiaries of the welfare state and some people have very high support needs that run into the hundreds of thousands each year. This means the minority that are funding everything are carrying an enormous burden and I think they have every right to question why we are funding degrees for people that have no realistic prospect of repaying that investment in tax receipts and student loan repayments. Is this really a priority over cancer treatment or defending our country? Do we just accrue more and more debt and higher interest repayments each year so that everyone can pursue their special interest when the statistics suggest that it's very unlikely they will get a well paid job?

So only degrees that lead to a certainty of loans being paid off should be allowed.

Very few universities will continue to run in that case.

EasternStandard · 15/11/2026 10:35

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:31

Ultimately this boils down to allocation of resources. Money is just a modern manifestation of this but resource is always finite and should be used wisely where there is scarcity. Public finances are very stretched at the moment and we have to think long and hard about what we spend money on.

The 'human' matters but we have 70 million of them in this country, each with their own aspirations and dreams. The state can't afford to fund everything, especially when the majority of people are net beneficiaries of the welfare state and some people have very high support needs that run into the hundreds of thousands each year. This means the minority that are funding everything are carrying an enormous burden and I think they have every right to question why we are funding degrees for people that have no realistic prospect of repaying that investment in tax receipts and student loan repayments. Is this really a priority over cancer treatment or defending our country? Do we just accrue more and more debt and higher interest repayments each year so that everyone can pursue their special interest when the statistics suggest that it's very unlikely they will get a well paid job?

I don’t really find the you just care about money angle works. We’re £3trn in debt. If anything voters are totally oblivious to how much public funding that takes up each year in servicing so they demand more.

Over £100bn per year could go to other things. But because there’s the how can you not care etc angle various countries including us have been pushing it higher.

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:36

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:24

Skills can be built on over time, reasonable adjustments can be made and jobs vary. There are many successful academics with poor people skills. The fact is it’s better to persue special interest and getting qualifications in that field and to aim high rather than telling disabled people they have no chance of achieving because of their disability.

We need to be realistic. Some people shouldn't attend university because they don't have the academic ability. Some people shouldn't attend university because they don't have the passion for a subject and will not last the distance. Some shouldn't go to university because their chance of getting a well paid job after they have completed their degree is minimal and it's a poor investment.

If you had to fund degrees completely yourself, like you do with other forms of training such as pilot training, then I think this would bring the issue into sharp focus. Only those with a passion, aptitude and great career prospect would pursue the extra education and it would lead to a much more efficient system.

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:36

BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 10:33

I did not say they have no chance. All fields of work are awash with older people with autism and ADHD, including mine.
I was questioning the idea that someone whose autism is so severe that they can't follow an instruction like go to the kitchen and fetch me a glass of water, can get a job in research

And I said there are a variety of roles, it’s a journey and who knows what can be achieved with work on skills and reasonable adjustments.

Writing autistic children and adults off because of their disability does not help anybody and is hugely ableist.

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 10:37

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 09:36

Many students in receipt of DSA at uni have study assistants.

When you're working a job people usually have to do their own job/tasks and don't get assistants to do it.

Rustybike · 15/11/2026 10:38

Wherever you stand in this debate, next week
is shaping up to be an ‘interesting’ week for Burnham….

On Alan Milburn's proposals, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden agrees there needs to be “legislative underpinning" to put opportunity for young people at the heart of the system.

Asked if some people will lose benefits because of the proposed cuts, he says: “There will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today."

In the interview, Kuenssberg also asks if people with ADHD or anxiety will lose benefits under the new proposals. McFadden replies that people "are not guaranteed to continue with what they have right now".

"Benefits are not guaranteed for life." McFadden says, adding: "We need a complete reset of the system in terms of what it offers young people."

Asked if Labour backbenchers will accept cuts to some young people’s benefits, McFadden replies: “Look, my job is to put forward my case for this...I think we really need to reset the system.”
“We don’t just owe young people an income, we owe them a future,” the cabinet minister says.

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:40

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:34

So only degrees that lead to a certainty of loans being paid off should be allowed.

Very few universities will continue to run in that case.

There is no such thing as certainty but yes, I believe that we need to allocate state funding to those degrees that offer the best probability of return through tax receipts or loan repayments OR those that are required for key roles in society.

Why should we fund someone's special interest when it will be enormously expensive and leave them with minimal job prospects? Why is this a better use of money than funding health care or other aspects of education?

There is only a finite pot of money.

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:41

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:36

We need to be realistic. Some people shouldn't attend university because they don't have the academic ability. Some people shouldn't attend university because they don't have the passion for a subject and will not last the distance. Some shouldn't go to university because their chance of getting a well paid job after they have completed their degree is minimal and it's a poor investment.

If you had to fund degrees completely yourself, like you do with other forms of training such as pilot training, then I think this would bring the issue into sharp focus. Only those with a passion, aptitude and great career prospect would pursue the extra education and it would lead to a much more efficient system.

Do tell us how you’re going to work out with certainty and without discrimination who has a passion, will last the distance and get a well paid job.

Also tell us how unis will run with next to no degree courses and how we’re going to fill jobs that aren’t well paid but rely on degrees and or a high level of knowledge in a field.

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:41

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:40

There is no such thing as certainty but yes, I believe that we need to allocate state funding to those degrees that offer the best probability of return through tax receipts or loan repayments OR those that are required for key roles in society.

Why should we fund someone's special interest when it will be enormously expensive and leave them with minimal job prospects? Why is this a better use of money than funding health care or other aspects of education?

There is only a finite pot of money.

Ooo sounds peachy. Which degrees are allowed and who are allowed to attend them if qualifying qualifications aren’t enough?

BluebellBeth · 15/11/2026 10:42

Pretty sure the news has also indicated today it's unlikely they will cut anything because they will invest in helping young people get jobs first so the welfare bill reduces naturally. Which is exactly how it should be.

Rustybike · 15/11/2026 10:42

EasternStandard · 15/11/2026 10:35

I don’t really find the you just care about money angle works. We’re £3trn in debt. If anything voters are totally oblivious to how much public funding that takes up each year in servicing so they demand more.

Over £100bn per year could go to other things. But because there’s the how can you not care etc angle various countries including us have been pushing it higher.

Yes, and the ‘broadest shoulders’ schtick will no longer wash. One fiscal assault after another on the taxpayer, coupled with the hostile rhetoric, mean many people have had enough.

Burnham is about to be properly tested.

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 10:42

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:34

So only degrees that lead to a certainty of loans being paid off should be allowed.

Very few universities will continue to run in that case.

Maybe university and the higher education system is over bloated in the UK and needs mass trimming

BluebellBeth · 15/11/2026 10:43

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 10:37

When you're working a job people usually have to do their own job/tasks and don't get assistants to do it.

Take it you've never heard of access to work then?

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:43

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 10:42

Maybe university and the higher education system is over bloated in the UK and needs mass trimming

Ok so which degrees are allowed and who are allowed to attend them if qualifying qualifications aren’t enough?

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:51

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:41

Do tell us how you’re going to work out with certainty and without discrimination who has a passion, will last the distance and get a well paid job.

Also tell us how unis will run with next to no degree courses and how we’re going to fill jobs that aren’t well paid but rely on degrees and or a high level of knowledge in a field.

Some universities should close. I think there is an emerging consensus that we have too many universities churning out graduates with degrees that don't align with what the job market wants. Look at current graduate employment rates and how many graduates feel their degrees were bad investment. We are doing a disservice to our young people letting them join these courses that are such poor value for money.

The application process should be able to discern who has the attributes needed and who are the best candidates in the same way that graduate roles are filled in the real world.

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:52

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:51

Some universities should close. I think there is an emerging consensus that we have too many universities churning out graduates with degrees that don't align with what the job market wants. Look at current graduate employment rates and how many graduates feel their degrees were bad investment. We are doing a disservice to our young people letting them join these courses that are such poor value for money.

The application process should be able to discern who has the attributes needed and who are the best candidates in the same way that graduate roles are filled in the real world.

It already does.

As I said which degrees are going to be allowed and which applicants if qualifying qualifications aren’t enough?

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:53

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:41

Ooo sounds peachy. Which degrees are allowed and who are allowed to attend them if qualifying qualifications aren’t enough?

Edited

Some degrees have appalling employment rates. The data is there for everyone to see. We need to keep only those degrees with good employment prospects.

The same process should be used for university applicants as we use for filling graduate job roles. Look for academic achievement but also beyond that. This is the way that we are likely to produce graduates that best fit what the job market actually wants.

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:58

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 10:53

Some degrees have appalling employment rates. The data is there for everyone to see. We need to keep only those degrees with good employment prospects.

The same process should be used for university applicants as we use for filling graduate job roles. Look for academic achievement but also beyond that. This is the way that we are likely to produce graduates that best fit what the job market actually wants.

No I haven’t seen it. I’m asking which degrees are you saying should be culled?

So going by your logic no nurses ( who are really struggling to get jobs) then or teachers of none stem subjects….Where is the knowledge of none AI proof jobs going to come from?

All graduates are struggling to get jobs soooo do we cut all the courses with low graduate employability which is the majority at the moment.

Even law isn’t a shoe in now thanks to AI.

Itchthescratch · 15/11/2026 11:06

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 10:58

No I haven’t seen it. I’m asking which degrees are you saying should be culled?

So going by your logic no nurses ( who are really struggling to get jobs) then or teachers of none stem subjects….Where is the knowledge of none AI proof jobs going to come from?

All graduates are struggling to get jobs soooo do we cut all the courses with low graduate employability which is the majority at the moment.

Even law isn’t a shoe in now thanks to AI.

It's not rocket science and I think you're being disingenuous feigning ignorance. How many anthropologists or theologians do we need? Earning and employment stats suggest not as many as we are currently churning out.

Nursing, like teaching, is a scandal but if we can't sort out the sectors so that graduates can be employed then we should be accepting less on courses. To do otherwise is cruel!

Maths, computer science, performing arts etc all have high unemployment. Graduates from some universities have a much lower median income after 5 years of completing their degrees than the non graduate population.

If graduate job demand is generally down then we need to be producing less graduates and looking at what our young people can do to gain meaningful employment without being saddled with debt and wasting years of their lives.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread